6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Collision: Holiday Bash (Dec 23 - Results & Review)

AEW in-ring standards are high, but Collision featured one of the company's best matches EVER.

Bryan Danielson Eddie Kingston
AEW

The Blue League final of AEW's Continental Classic is set.

Eddie Kingston will wrestle Bryan Danielson to find out who advances to Worlds End. Elsewhere in the Gold League, a three-way between Jon Moxley, Jay White and Swerve Strickland will settle the other side of the tournament brackets. Overall, Tony Khan can be very chuffed with the Classic - it's been producing cracking matches weekly since the beginning.

The summary line offered on socials to accompany this piece says it best. If you love pro wrestling, then you'll adore this week's episode of Collision. There was one memorable in-ring promo moment, but management used most of the two TV hours to play to the strengths of AEW's roster as a whole.

Only one bout could be considered a slight struggle, and even that's arguable. Naturally, this is just one dude's opinions, so you'll likely have your own thoughts about where company booking is heading before the next pay-per-view. Everyone will surely agree on one thing though: Dynamite on Wednesday should be another excellent show.

Here's all the good and bad from Saturday night's serving!


Downs...

3. Poor Timing, As Usual!

Claudio Castagnoli Bryan Danielson AEW Picture-In-Picture Ad Break
AEW

Hopefully, one of Tony Khan's new year resolutions is to sort out show formatting.

What was this all about? AEW cut to a picture-in-picture ad break right as Claudio Castagnoli walloped Bryan Danielson with a huge uppercut outside the ring. That was a pivotal moment in the match too, because it showed that Claudio (who was desperate to win) would attack Bryan's face/injured eye to get the job done.

Tony Schiavone had already thrown to commercials, so the commentary team fell silent for a few seconds. That led to an odd visual of Castagnoli steam-rolling his way in on Bryan and connecting right as the screen went double feature and muted the match audio. It was pretty amateur hour and just shouldn't be happening.

You absolutely cannot have major moments in an important match being ignored that way. It's frustrating for fans. Yes, commercial revenue is important to AEW too, but come on - it isn't much to ask that any pic-in-pic stuff steers clear of potentially wrecking the matches people tuned in to see.


2. Not Much To Shout About

Julia Hart Thunder Rosa
AEW

Here's the "slight struggle" that's definitely arguable.

This writer was a little disappointed by Julia Hart and Skye Blue vs. Abadon and the returning Thunder Rosa. Throughout, their tag match was way lower on energy than one expected going in. You've got to worry for Abadon challenging Julia at Worlds End too, because that could end up playing before some silence.

It was certainly downplayed and cast as a backdrop to Rosa's comeback here. Whilst it's great to have Thunder back in-ring on TV, it's fair to say this wasn't her best work. In fact, the ongoing story involving Abadon and Skye's turn to the dark side alongside Hart could've done without Rosa's involvement.

The live crowd popped for Thunder pinning Skye, but it does raise a question for Tony Khan: Is Blue gonna become cannon fodder so Julia doesn't have to eat pins in matches like this? If so, then that's a bit of a waste of someone who should be looking towards 2024 as a breakout year.


1. Ship Has Probably Sailed

Keith Lee AEW
AEW

Here we go again, people.

It'll be pretty difficult for All Elite to get fans hyped for Keith Lee vs. Swerve Strickland after so much time has passed. This is a match that should've happened on pay-per-view a long, long time ago, so it's brave to try reignite the flames heading into 2024. AEW fancies giving it a go anyway, apparently.

Keith cut a promo following his win over Brian Cage (more on that in the 'Ups'). He referenced Swerve's prior cinder block attack that took him out around a year ago, and vowed revenge. There was nothing wrong with the speech, but...Strickland has kinda moved on since then. He has bigger things to think about.

Being brutally honest, Lee feels a little too rearview mirror for Swerve at the moment. Fingers crossed everyone finds a way to make this work, but the ship has sailed on the rivalry. It could've happened in 2022, and probs should've. Instead, there's a chance AEW will try it on at Revolution 2024.

Hmm.


Ups...

6. Big Boys Who Shift

Keith Lee Brian Cage
AEW

The upside to Keith Lee is that he has a point to prove. His AEW run hasn't hit the heights anyone expected when he left WWE and signed on the dotted line, but he's defo capable inside the ring when given the time to showcase his intoxicating blend between power moves and astonishing agility.

Lee vs. Brian Cage on Collision worked out well.

It was clear to see from the first lockup that Cage and Keith fancied working a banger match that wouldn't look out of place next to some of the higher-profile bouts on the episode. Their scrap didn't quite reach 'Match Of The Night' territory, but it was never less than watchable. Some of the spots were actually really impressive.

The way bigger lads like Lee and Cage move around the ring is incredible to witness. It must be a proper thrill for fans with ringside seats to see workers with this bulk/muscle up close and flying about the place. Their match offered something different on Collision, and that's why it scores an 'Up'.


5. A Fun-Enough Sprint

The Acclaimed Billy Gunn Top Flight Action Andretti
AEW

Anyone who reads the Rampage reports regularly knows this writer occasionally goes borderline Jim Cornette when it comes to spotfest-style matches with moves for the sake of moves. Sometimes, he even finds his voice getting a little too high pitched and ranty, so has to calm down.

Only kidding.

Some AEW trios matches can be guilty of trying to be too hectic and cram too much in, but The Acclaimed and Billy Gunn vs. Top Flight and Action Andretti offered just the right amount of speed. Things never got out of control, and that minimised the danger of injury. Safety is important, y'know! There's a difference between calculated high risk and sloppy recklessness.

Kevin Kelly revealed that this was the 10th successful Trios Title defence for the champs. Interestingly, Max Caster hooked Andretti's tights to effectively cheat the high-flying babyface team out of the belts. Is an Acclaimed heel turn incoming? That'd be curious to see, but risky considering their enduring popularity.


4. The Patriarch & His Matriarch

Christian Cage Nick Shayna Wayne
AEW

Time to confess something: Eyes rolled in this household when Shayna Wayne poked her nose into the much-anticipated Adam Copeland vs. Christian Cage match a while back. That initially seemed like an unnecessary distraction, but it fits neatly into the broader story. Retrospectively, that eye rolling was unfair.

Besides, Shayna did really well with her part of the promo on this week's Collision. It could've been shakier than a sh*tting dog, but she smashed it and fans responded in kind by raining down boos. Then, Cage accepted the 'No DQ' match vs. Copeland for Worlds End next week.

Job done.

Christian plays his character so well that 'Ups' are almost guaranteed when he's around. It's still kinda funky that Edge is challenging for the TNT Title after moving to AEW, but that goes to show how much Cage has done to elevate the belt.


3. Daniel Garcia Isn’t Pointless!

Daniel Garcia Brody King
AEW

Tony Khan almost certainly realised early on in the Continental Classic that some matches would be harder to sell than others. That's especially true for those with less stakes than Collision's opener between Claudio and Bryan, for example. Somewhat remarkably, Daniel Garcia and Brody King succeeded in spite of that challenge.

The match was a lengthy squash, for the most part, but it did let Garcia show some spirit by rallying back for the surprise win. Collision's live crowd wanted that bad (one lady opposite the hard cam was particularly into Danny), and AEW didn't disappoint them. It was a story within a story.

Garcia had no chance of advancing in the tourney, but people wanted him to win anyway so he didn't finish pointless. The segment served three purposes: Daniel got some fire, Brody was eliminated from the CC, and their match paved the way for FTR to challenge House Of Black at Worlds End.

Slick TV all-round.


2. Eddie Kingston Stays Alive

Eddie Kingston
AEW

Scrappy babyface Eddie Kingston started the Continental Classic by putting both his ROH World and New Japan Strong Titles up for grabs as part of the new Triple Crown. Then, Eddie went on to lose his first two matches to have a disastrous 0-2 record. That didn't stop him from advancing to the Blue League finals.

That, fellow fans, is how you use the straightforward tourney format to tell a story.

Kingston worked another fun match for the CC vs. Andrade El Idolo. Together, they closed Collision with a bang. Was it as technical as the opener? No. Did Kingston and Andrade hurl one another around like Lee and Cage before them? Nah. However, they produced a hard-hitting and dramatic finale to the round robin.

The Continental Classic has been hitting it since day one, so it's nice to see the first stage of the tournament end on such a high. Credit must also go to El Idolo for making Eddie look like someone who might be rough around the edges but can never be ruled out.

Great match.


1. That Must-See Opener

Claudio Castagnoli Bryan Danielson AEW Collision
AEW

It paled in comparison to the must-see match of the night though.

Bryan Danielson vs. Claudio Castagnoli was just a stellar pro wrestling showcase from two true masters of their craft. Jim Ross posted about it on social media afterwards, and rightly gushed with praise for what these guys can do. The amazing thing is that you sense they could've taken things up a notch or two if the occasion had needed it.

Nigel McGuinness set the scene on commentary by wondering if Claudio would go all in on his BCC teammate and attack his injured eye. The bout's early knockings were respectful, but then Castagnoli realised he had to win to stay alive in the tournament. So, he went after Bryan's weakness.

That, in turn, fired Danielson up. It was all seriously high quality stuff from start to finish. Claudio, in particular, showed urgency as the time limit ticked down to the final few minutes, and the announcers reminded fans that a draw wouldn't do any good to the Swiss wrestling machine.

That draw meant both guys earned a point apiece; Bryan advances on 10, and Claudio is eliminated on 7 points.

Go out of your way to see this one. That's said a lot about top notch AEW TV bouts (which have been even more abundant during the Classic), but this might be one of the best All Elite matches ever.

What did you think of this week's AEW Collision? For more like this, check out 8 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Dec 22 - Results & Review) and 3 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Dec 22 - Results & Review)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.