6 Ups & 3 Downs From NXT Great American Bash 2023

New champs crowned, a classic title match, a debut gone awry...this had it all!

Carmelo Hayes
WWE

Call it formulaic, but it looks like NXT has rediscovered the recipe it used to great success in the 2010s with its TakeOver specials, putting on another good PLE Sunday night with the Great American Bash.

As with much of WWE programming these days, the TV shows might be roller coasters of highs and lows, but the actual events built up typically deliver on the night. Even the developmental brand has a level of talent that is capable of producing at least passable matches, and most of the time can give fans highly entertaining action.

Sunday was no different with Carmelo Hayes and Ilja Dragunov putting on a clinic to close the Bash. Fans got a much-welcomed title switch, a surprising finish to the women’s title submission bout, and a pretty decent plunder brawl.

But all was not great. The hyped debut of Olympic gold medalist Gable Steveson fell flat, with fans turning on the former collegiate champion and openly cheering Baron Corbin. The match itself, the finish and aftermath did little to dispel the jeers, digging an early hole for the rookie.

Overall though, the Bash was a success and shows that there are positives in WWE’s developmental brand. It doesn’t mean all is well, but let’s celebrate the successes and enjoy the show that was put on.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

3. Mafia Motions

Tony D'Angelo
WWE

There was reason to celebrate Tony D’Angelo and Stacks taking the NXT Tag Team Championship from Gallus after six months on top, but the match itself was nothing to write home about.

Oh sure, they executed their spots well, but it didn’t feel like the conclusion to a blood feud where the heels sent one of the challengers to prison for a month. The story was there, but the soul was missing from the match itself.

A well-executed match is definitely something fans should be expecting on an NXT PLE at this point, but when you don’t feel anything – not for the moves themselves nor the wrestlers performing them – that’s not great. Maybe that’s an unfair criticism, but a title change in a PLE-opening match should trigger emotion during the match, not just after the 3 count.


2. Need Developmental For Announcers

Booker T Commentary
WWE.com

Remember how NXT was originally a developmental territory for everyone, not just the wrestlers but the referees, crew and even the announcers? They tried out different combinations of play-by-play men and analysists over the first several years, breaking in several current mainstays.

But the current duo of Vic Joseph and Booker T might be beyond help as a pairing. They’re perversely entertaining – if you enjoy trainwrecks. Booker not knowing the rules of a mixed tag match was bad enough, but having a submission match where the announcers don’t call the actual submission holds by their names (Fujiwara armbar, Mexican surfboard, bow and arrow, body vice) was unforgivable.

WWE doesn’t like calling moves that aren’t signature spots, but it was ridiculous watching Thea Hail and Tiffany Stratton run through a bunch of submission holds and Vic and Booker spent more time squabbling with each other than putting over the severity of the moves. It would have given gravity to the match while educating casual fans a bit more.

Try picturing Excalibur giving a rundown of the pain inflicted by each hold and you can already see the difference. Instead, someone must think Booker babbling incoherently and Vic losing his mind while yelling is what the fans really want.


1. A Bad Kurt Angle Knockoff

Gable Steveson
WWE

The problem with being compared to Kurt Angle is that you have an almost impossible task of living up to one of the best ever. But when you’re also the closest parallel to Angle – a fellow Olympic gold medalist and collegiate champion – the comparisons and scrutiny will be even more intense.

Gable Steveson had a mountain to climb heading into his debut match Sunday against Baron Corbin, and while he likely executed the game plan laid out for him well, it didn’t feel like fans were watching something special. Instead, they watched a highly skilled athlete trained at the Performance Center work a match with a highly skilled veteran, something that they see every week on NXT. Only, this one came out in a singlet carrying a gold medal and tried to cinch in an ankle lock.

The fans were not having this and rallied behind Corbin, clearly not feeling Steveson. They really weren’t having it when the match ended in a double count-out, drawing deserved “bulls***” chants.

The moral of the story: This match needed to go perfectly for Steveson to succeed, and they didn’t even book a finish. If you can’t book a finish in a guy’s heavily watched debut match, don’t book the match.


Ups…

6. Gallus Gets Fitted With Concrete Shoes

Tony D'Angelo
WWE

Finally!

Gallus’ near-six-month reign of terror as NXT Tag Team Champions finally came to a close Sunday night when The Family toppled them to open the Great American Bash.

Since February, Gallus has inexplicably ruled the tag division, proving to be the cure for insomnia. It’s not that they’re bad in the ring – it’s just that they’re boring. You can hear it – or more accurately, not hear it – during their matches. Sunday’s tag title match provided more of that, as the fired-up fans went silent during periods when Gallus were in control, then ramped up when Tony D’Angelo and Stacks took over.

You could argue that Gallus did their job as heel champions, but it was more of a relief to see their title reign end than anything else. At least D’Angelo and Stacks will be far more entertaining as tag champs and hopefully will breathe some life into the titles and the division.


5. Just A Good, Fun Mess

Meta Four
WWE

Mixed tag matches can be a mixed bag: they can be entertaining, or they could feel like a disjointed disaster.

Thankfully, the eight-person mixed tag pitting Meta-Four against Nathan Frazer, Dragon Lee, Yulisa Leon and Valentina Feroz was the former: a quick-paced blitz of nonstop action from the opening bell. All eight superstars flew around the ring, getting a chance to shine. Leon and Feroz in particular looked good in their first Premium Live Event, hitting a few nice top-rope moves and showing some fire.

The strategy behind the match couldn’t have been by accident: By keeping their collective foot on the pedal, it masked various mistakes. Jakara Jackson looked out of place, but there never was enough time for those botches to sink in because they were off to the next flurry of moves.

This match won’t win any awards, nor was it something you’ll go and rewatch a bunch, but it was fun and fired up the crowd, which is what you need for a kickoff match.


4. Perez, Davenport Ramp Up The Violence

Roxanne Perez
WWE

Plunder brawls always carry the risk of just being a series of weapons shots to fill the time and to mask a lack of talent or ability.

But Roxanne Perez and Blair Davenport had a really nice Weapons Wild match Sunday night, with Perez coming out on top after hitting Pop Rox onto a pile of chairs. The match was also aided in an unusual way: Roxanne’s sister at ringside.

Family sitting ringside can be a crapshoot, but Perez’s sister was perfect in her role, sobbing when Roxanne was being attacked and then cheering through the tears when she made her comeback and splashed Blair through the table in front of her.

If this match’s goal was to show that the “happy to be here” Perez is gone and replaced with a more aggressive, serious wrestler, this worked nicely.


3. Throwing In The Towel

Tiffany Stratton
WWE

Had it not been for the double count-out finish in the earlier match, the NXT Women’s Championship title bout conclusion wouldn’t have looked bad at all.

In reality, Andre Chase throwing in the towel after Thea Hail was locked in a Boston Crab for a painfully long period of time was probably the right call. Hail’s Scrappy Doo persona was not going to allow for her to actually submit, so the babyface mentor/teacher was left to look out for her long-term health.

It didn’t help that Tiffany Stratton’s Boston Crab was horrendously applied. You’d think a Performance Center would have trained her to apply that move properly for a submission match where it was the finish, but that can be forgiven, as NXT tried something different with two of its youngest talents, and it worked decently.

Also, the finish opens the door to real division between Duke Hudson and Chase, with Duke not looking pleased that Andre quit for Thea. That possible thread could be interesting to watch in the coming weeks.


2. A Predictable Ending

Mustafa Ali Dominik Mysterio
WWE

The Honky Tonk Man’s Intercontinental Championship “defenses” were predictable, as he ran away, got disqualified, or relied on outside interference and cheating to hold onto his title.

So, it shouldn’t have been shocking that Dominik Mysterio defended his NXT North American Championship Sunday by relying on Rhea Ripley once again to bail him out and to capitalize on other wrestlers’ hard work. Dom-Dom retained his title in a Triple Threat when Mustafa Ali hit a 450 splash on Wes Lee, but Ripley pulled him out, allowing Mysterio to nail the frog splash for the pin. That was classic Dom, but also within the confines and rules of the match.

The match itself was pretty good, though it noticeably slowed down whenever Mysterio was involved. Still, they managed to have a nice little bout, while Rhea stole the show with her ringside antics, freaking out multiple times and taunting – and then attacking – Lee.

Who knows how long this Dominik experiment will last? Regardless, it’s pretty hot stuff right now, and maybe, just maybe, Mysterio will pick something up while battling guys like Ali and Lee.


1. Melo Gets His Classic

Carmelo Hayes Ilja Dragunov
WWE

Carmelo Hayes has been a strong, reliable superstar in NXT, but he’s also been the epitome of the 3.75-star performer, having very good matches, but not quite breaking through to the classic that you would think he already has under his belt.

That changed at the Great American Bash, when Melo defeated Ilja Dragunov in a tremendous NXT Championship match to retain his title. The two went to war, starting slowly and exchanging holds before ramping up the aggression into a full frenzy of chops, elbows, kicks and strikes.

Both men countered each other’s signatures and laid everything in snug before Hayes capitalized on a Torpedo Moscow that struck Trick Williams – and the NXT title – knocking Ilja loopy. A quick Nothin’ But Net later, and Melo picked up the win.

Great match, giving Hayes the kind of showing he needed as champion. And for Dragunov, he certainly deserves a look at the main roster after this run in NXT. Throwing him in there with the likes of Sheamus, Gunther (again), and a host of others could be a lot of fun.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.