6 Ups And 5 Downs From WWE Crown Jewel 2023

A title change, a shock return, another typical Bloodline main event. Good enough overall.

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Logan Paul
WWE.com

WWE’s Saudi Arabia shows have evolved over time from glorified house shows, to WrestleMania-level spectacles, to meaningful PLEs where major storyline developments take place.

Saturday’s Crown Jewel provided fans with a title change, a surprise return, an attempted career-defining moment, a stellar world title match and another world title match that could have been lifted move-for-move from any PLE main event from the past three years.

Fans who love Roman Reigns and think the Bloodline saga is the greatest thing ever will not even blink at his latest title defense against LA Knight. It was the same thing they’ve seen and loved for three-plus years. But if you’re longing for even the slightest change to the formula, you were left groaning at the TV.

Logan Paul shocked the world with a little help, while Drew McIntyre couldn’t get the job done on his own. Sami Zayn had a great night against the Judgment Day, while Damian Priest had a horrible evening. The women’s title matches produced mixed results, but overall everyone looked good in their roles.

Lastly, a word about Miz TV: It’s not getting either an Up or a Down here. On its face, the segment was dire, with Miz dropping Grayson Waller in the first battle of reality TV stars-turned-WWE superstars. However, if this first salvo ends with Waller finally vanquishing Miz and taking his place as the new-and-improved loudmouth host in WWE, then this would get a pass.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

5. Liar Liar

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WWE loves to ignore its own history whenever it’s convenient, but just because it’s their own, that doesn’t mean they should get a pass.

During the World Heavyweight Championship match, Michael Cole talked about Drew McIntyre’s pandemic-era world title reign and noted that his first title defense came at Money in the Bank against Seth Rollins.

Except… that’s not true.

McIntyre defended his WWE Championship moments after he defeated Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 36, when the Big Show came out to immediately challenge him. The Scottish Warrior managed to topple Show in a few minutes to hold onto the newly won title.

That match – which was actually McIntyre’s first title defense – was shown on Raw the following night.

It’s not like WWE can’t write or talk around that bit by saying “his first post-WrestleMania title defense,” but instead they just lie because it’s easier and then hope they don’t get called out.


4. A Series Of Moves

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Rhea Ripley Nia Jax
WWE.com

There are going to be plenty of people who were entertained by the Women’s World Championship five-way match, but it can’t be classified as anything more than a spotfest to give five women opportunities to shine.

Rhea Ripley successfully defended her title with an impressive finish, hitting an avalanche Riptide with Zoey Stark onto Raquel Rodriguez and Shayna Baszler, effectively neutralizing the entire field in one fell swoop (Nia Jax already had been taken out).

Most of the match was your typical WWE multi-person match, with several of the wrestlers rolling out of the ring for extended periods as different groupings battled inside, with others jumping in to break up pinfall attempts or to hit counters.

There wasn’t anything wrong with the match, but if you were looking for a cohesive, intricate story being told, you were disappointed. The four women didn’t even do a beatdown of Nia Jax as payback for her attacking all of them since her return, which one would have thought was the low-hanging fruit for this match.

Ripley again looked impressive overall, but her title reign has been saved by her Judgment Day segments, not by her in-ring opportunities.


3. A Snoozefest Of A Career-Defining Match

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Solo Sikoa John Cena
WWE.com

Fans evidently were meant to receive Solo Sikoa versus John Cena as an end of an era match for one star and a career-making moment for the other. But that’s not how it came across at Crown Jewel.

Wrestled at half-speed, Solo versus Cena was a pretty basic match with the former 16-time world champion staying very limited in his movements, save for a diving crossbody. Cena targeted Sikoa’s right arm and hand to try to render the Samoan Spike useless. Instead, Solo simply attempted the Spike no fewer than five times unsuccessfully, each time comically winding up and whiffing or getting blocked.

When he finally connected, Solo elected to not go for a pin and repeatedly spiked Cena nearly a dozen times before pinning the Greatest of All Time. After all the buildup of Cena wanting – and needing – his first singles victory in five years, losing like that certainly was a statement… though it was diminished when you realize that Austin Theory defeated Cena six months prior at WrestleMania 39.

Regardless, one would think that hitting your finisher on a wrestler more than 10 times would warrant a stretcher job or at least needing help getting to your feet. But Cena instead was back up in moments rubbing his throat like he had a bad case of strep and walked to the back under his own power. That even undercut the announcers’ speculation about whether Cena’s career was potentially over.

Disappointing execution of what seemed like a good plan on paper.


2. Vision 2030? More Like 1730

WWE Crown Jewel 2023
WWE.com

When WWE first announced its partnership with Saudi Arabia, they went all-in as a willing partner in the sportswashing effort for the repressive kingdom, airing vignettes touting how “progressive” the country was because they now let women drive and attend school.

Then the murder of an American-based journalist forced that outward praise into the shadows, as WWE didn’t even mention they were in Saudi Arabia, going to great pains to cover up the relationship, while still cashing each $50 million check for every paid show.

Fast-forward to 2023, where time has healed all wounds, according to WWE, as they once again praised Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 plan, an economic reform plan to make the kingdom a destination.

But this all comes less than two months after a Saudi court handed down a death sentence for a man because he made critical social media posts about the Saudi government.

WWE, the company that drapes itself in the American flag and talks a good game about freedom, has no problem staying in bed with a nation that literally murders its citizens for speaking out against it, presumably because their checks don’t bounce. It’s an absolute embarrassment that should be called out at every opportunity as a reminder of how disgusting it truly is.


1. Another Cookie-Cutter Bloodline Main Event

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 LA Knight Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Is anyone else beyond tired of the same, played-out title defense from Roman Reigns? There’s got to be a limit for how much the average fan will put up with when it comes to the repeated paint-by-numbers approach to the Tribal Chief’s interference-laden championship matches.

LA Knight was the latest babyface challenger inserted into the equation that featured Roman’s trademark control in slow-motion, as he hit a move, played to the crowd for 30 seconds, and then repeated five or six times. Reigns ate a bunch of offense and appeared to be in jeopardy, but the Bloodline made sure to get involved again to continue his 1,160-day title run.

This time, it was Jimmy Uso putting Roman’s foot on the ropes after a BFT, which led to Knight attacking Jimmy on the floor, opening the door for Reigns to spear the Megastar through the barricade and then casually roll LA back into the ring and spear him again for the victory.

And everyone points to the ceiling. The end. Give a call when it’s WrestleMania 40 and there’s a chance someone will be able to finish the story.


UPS…

6. Sami Gets The Duke

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Sami Zayn JD McDonagh
WWE.com

By the end of this weekend, no one is going to remember intimate details of the Crown Jewel kickoff show match between Sami Zayn and JD McDonagh. But that wasn’t the point of the bout, as everyone saw later.

Zayn’s stated purpose as a solo act is to bring down the Judgment Day, no matter how long it takes. He vowed to end the purple-clad group, so why not start with the guy who’s been a hanger-on to the stable for the past several months?

It goes without saying that Zayn and McDonagh are probably incapable of having a bad match, though there was a near-disaster on an attempted monkey flip early on where JD went crashing into the ropes awkwardly. Thankfully, he recovered and they strung together a pretty basic opener that warmed the fans up and let Sami get his first pelt.

As an added bonus, Zayn put McDonagh away with the Blue Thunder Bomb, a rarity these days, but a smart move to try to establish it as a potential killshot. Perfectly fine wrestling and a perfectly acceptable kickoff show match that established Sami’s modus operandi for later in the show.


5. Iyo Wins With A Little Help

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Kairi Sane IYO SKY
WWE.com

Iyo Sky defending her WWE Women’s Championship against Bianca Belair with a little help wasn’t much of a surprise. What was a shock was that it wasn’t (just) Damage CTRL that saved Iyo.

Kairi Sane made her return to WWE after a three-year absence, taking out Belair on the floor after Bayley’s attempted interference proved insufficient. Sky quickly capitalized and nailed her Over-the-Moonsault to pick up the win, and she and Kairi celebrated before demolishing Bianca with an InSane Elbow.

The match itself was fine, but the interesting note here is that Bayley did not look like she realized Sane was going to run in, which raises the question of whether the two Japanese stars are going to form an alliance outside of Damage CTRL (and have others join them), or if Kairi will join the group. Bayley has fumbled about in trying to help Iyo at times, so it’s possible the Genius of the Sky takes her leave of the group.

While the story of a stable having instability is way overdone in WWE, Damage CTRL is a group that might actually benefit from a shakeup of sorts.


4. Zayn Thwarts Priest

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Damian Priest Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Following on Sami Zayn’s vow to bring down the Judgment Day, his night wasn’t over after toppling JD McDonagh on Saturday.

At the conclusion of the World Heavyweight Championship match, Damian Priest ran down to ringside to cash in his Money in the Bank briefcase on a wounded Seth Rollins. Suddenly, a hooded Zayn attacked Priest, snatched the case and fled with it, denying Damian the cash-in and almost guaranteed title win.

Briefcase theft is rarely the kind of thing that works, but in this situation, it actually does given Sami’s quest, which Michael Cole helpfully pointed out on commentary. Doing this provided the logical move of Damian Priest wanting to use his MITB contract and a plausible way in which he was denied, all leaving Rollins as the luckiest champion in the company who is hanging onto his title by a thread.

The theft also completed a pretty good night for Zayn, knocking off one pseudo-Judgment Day member and thwarting another.


3. Cody Stays The Course

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Cody Rhodes Damian Priest
WWE.com

Ever since Cody Rhodes declared that he was getting back on track to finish the story – and win the WWE Championship his father never could capture – everything he did needed to be in service of that goal.

Putting Judgment Day behind him is part of that process, and Rhodes took a step in that direction Saturday by defeating Damian Priest. Señor Money in the Bank got plenty of offense and hung right there with the American Nightmare, but Cody being on a mission was not going to be denied.

Jey Uso provided a huge assist in chasing off the rest of Judgment Day, and with it being a fair fight, Rhodes took Priest down with a flurry of signature spots. Damian came close, but Cody needed to stand tall at Crown Jewel, and he did.


2. Biting On A Title Switch

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Drew McIntyre Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The best kind of wrestling matches can have a pretty simple, logical conclusion but still get fans to fall for a false finish or two that subverts expectations.

Drew McIntyre came a hair’s width away from capturing the World Heavyweight Championship on Saturday night, including avoiding a Phoenix Splash and nailing a Claymore for what felt like a surefire victory – especially after he had kicked out of Seth Rollins’ Stomp. But both men’s near-bulletproof finishers proved to misfire a bit, and the match continued.

Rollins got the victory with a Pedigree/Stomp combo, escaping a highly entertaining match with his championship intact. It’s also heartening that Seth’s back issues have carried over from the Shinsuke Nakamura feud and now presents a target for every challenger, leaving Rollins’ reign to feel like it’s on borrowed time.

For McIntyre, he tried to win the honorable way and fell short, so now the focus likely will turn to how Drew regroups and whether he starts to give in to shortcuts to reach his goal. The Scottish Warrior’s slow heel turn has been extremely well-handled and one of the most entertaining parts of Raw, and this likely will kick off the next phase of that story.


1. Logan Paul Is America

WWE Crown Jewel 2023 Logan Paul
WWE.com

There is no denying Logan Paul’s pure, raw talent in the ring. Just a handful of matches into his WWE career, he’s shown an aptitude that many who have been wrestling for years haven’t grasped. Throw in his social media presence and natural charisma and he’s got all the raw tools.

So, it wasn’t a shock to see Paul defeat Rey Mysterio to capture the United States Championship. Paul winning the title gives him a trophy to parade around at all his non-WWE engagements, and it puts a target on his back for a litany of superstars to come after him. Logan using the brass knuckles also worked in that he hung with Rey for the entire match, but he couldn’t overcome the Hall of Famer’s experience. The knucks were the difference-maker, and he only needed that to get over the top.

Mysterio didn’t need the championship any longer, and the way in which he lost lends more sympathy to the luchador.

And then there’s the question of Santos Escobar, who stopped one of Logan’s buddies from retrieving the knucks, but then placed them on the apron to allow Paul to grab and use them. Was that just a dumb mistake, or was it intentional? That’s an issue that can be explored going forward.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.