6 Ups And 9 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Oct 5th)

Can Brock stop the ratings freefall? Only if he's in every segment.

With ratings in a freefall and no simple solution to stop the bleeding, WWE did the only thing it thought it could do Monday: Give yourself a shot in the arm in the form of Brock Lesnar and try to replenish the ratings. Lesnar, fresh off a dominating performance at Madison Square Garden on Saturday, is the one legit, mainstream star on the active roster (unless the Rock or €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin suddenly start getting the itch), so WWE added a date to his calendar and brought him in. Unfortunately for WWE, an awesome opening segment really was the high point of the show, which meant fans had to sit through another two hours and 40-plus minutes of Raw. Perhaps they need to have him come out every other segment and just demolish whatever geeks are in the ring at the time. It can€™t be any worse than what€™s going on right now, and really, would that damage King Barrett€™s standing any worse than the writers already have done? The other big storyline Monday night was Corporate Kane teaming with Seth Rollins against the Dudley Boyz, getting carted off and then returning as Demon Kane to obliterate the world champ. While Kane€™s dual personality gimmick was fun and fresh, they are now playing it a little too silly, with the suit-wearing Kane nursing a busted ankle, but the Big Red Monster impervious to pain. It also doesn€™t help that the announcers are questioning whether Kane is playing mind games or really has schizophrenia. So what F5€™d the opposition and what got chokeslammed to hell? Let€™s get to it€


Downs...

9. Going Through The Motions

Did anyone else feel like the latest incarnation of the mini-Shield versus the Wyatt Family was more of the same, just at half-speed? Randy Orton is no slouch, but the six-man tag match felt like it was just plodding along to the obvious conclusion: Roman Reigns pins Luke Harper, the one member of the Wyatt Family who can safely lose right now. Part of the issue is that Braun Strowman only brings his power moves to the match and not much else €“ and everyone else has to account for his shortcomings. These guys also have had the same match before, so it gets a little bland after we€™ve seen it a bunch of times. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=stgiEHR4hqE That doesn€™t mean that the men in the match aren€™t talented, but we€™ve seen Reigns and Bray battling for months now in a feud that feels more and more like a placeholder than an epic struggle. Believe that.

8. As The Steph Turns

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNFI9PNcvNU For those keeping score, Stephanie McMahon ostensibly played a face tonight, despite being labeled a heel boss for the past two-plus years. It was yet another occasion for Stephanie to soak in cheers while emasculating the heels for a change. Stephanie started out by putting Seth Rollins in his place, mocking his plight as he was left without a tag team partner when Brock Lesnar beat up Big Show. She then came out and sucked up to the Boston crowd by saying the New England Patriots were going to win the Super Bowl (she€™s supposedly big Pats fan). Then Steph put New Day down (the team she and Triple H were dancing with in the ring just a couple weeks ago). Villains don€™t have to be pure evil 24/7. We all know that. But when a person who so clearly is supposed to be the chief bad guy starts playing to the crowd and belittling her own charges, then she€™s crossed a line. Vince McMahon never would€™ve pulled that stunt in the Attitude Era. Or at least if he did play to the crowd, it would be so obviously disingenuous that he would be booed even more.

7. Hyperbole Much?

We all know that announcers have to occasionally make something that was awful seem awesome, something boring seem hilarious, and something that was OK seem outstanding. It€™s understandable, but sometimes the announcers cross the boundaries of acceptability. JBL tried to convince fans that Saturday€™s Madison Square Garden match between Brock Lesnar and Big Show was €œa titanic battle,€ comparing it to Ali/Frazier. He then talked about how Brock took Show to Suplex City, €œsomething we never thought we€™d see€€ except for that time at Royal Rumble 2014 that he destroyed Show, or the 2003 episode of Smackdown where Lesnar superplexed Show to implode the ring (which they showed on Saturday€™s show). We get that you have to sell something as epic, but trying to convince us that a four-minute match that consisted of 30 seconds of Show on offense and the rest being pummeled was €œa titanic battle€ is just insulting.

6. Third Time€™s A Charm?

A large part of booking professional wrestling correctly is knowing when to pull the trigger on something, and when to pull the plug. You want to strike when things are their hottest to cash in on fan interest in the product. If you wait too long, then the reaction and interest can be greatly diminished. That is exactly what we€™re seeing with the Dudley Boyz and New Day feud. The Dudleys returned to great fanfare, getting a huge reaction when they showed up on the scene. They immediately set their sights on the WWE Tag Team Championships. While New Day is extremely hot right now, a three-week hotshot of the titles to one of WWE€™s biggest tag teams of all time wouldn€™t be terrible. But instead, we€™ve seen two DQ finishes, setting up a third match at Hell in a Cell that is much less-anticipated than their Saturday bout at Madison Square Garden €“ which was the right time to pull the trigger if WWE was going to switch the titles. One has to hope that we get a definitive finish at HIAC finally.

5. Hurry Up! There Are Breast Cancer Survivors!

Can€™t you just envision hearing Vince McMahon sitting in the Gorilla position telling that to Neville and Sheamus as they walked out to the ring? It sure seemed like they were rushed, as what could have been a fun bruising-bully-versus-undersized-warrior gave way immediately to a distraction finish that then wasn€™t follow up on. WWE seemed to remember to King Barrett has returned to the roster last week, having him join commentary €“ at least temporarily. Seconds into the match, Barrett jumped up from the announce desk to get Neville€™s attention after his countryman had jumped Sheamus. The Celtic Warrior wasted no time in hitting the Brogue Kick for the pin. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GoIkvZRnApY What made this worse was that there was no follow-up with Barrett talking to Neville (he claimed he was out to cheer him on). Had there been some follow-up to advance the storyline beyond a Neville loss, it would have been something. But alas, we got nothing.

4. We€™re In Pink Hell

On the surface, it seems like an OK gesture: Pay tribute to the ongoing fight against breast cancer during Breast Cancer Awareness Month by partnering with a major organization supposedly devoted to ending breast cancer. Wash WWE in pink, trot out breast cancer survivors during Raw and pat yourself on the back. It just smacks of self-congratulatory smugness to trumpet your efforts like this, having an obvious screeching halt with John Cena and Roman Reigns out there talking up the effort while the roster stands on the stage. (Side note: Why isn€™t someone like Titus O€™Neil, who has an actual personal story about losing immediate family to breast cancer, up there talking rather than Reigns, who added absolutely nothing?) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bmFt13L5u_U Worse yet, Susan G. Komen isn€™t the be-all, end-all for breast cancer, even though they would like to have everyone believe that. Komen has faced some controversies in recent years, but some survivors have pointed out the hypocrisy and willful ignorance of the organization. Komen is far from the final authority on breast cancer, but WWE is all too willing to line right up with them.

3. An Indecent Proposal

In some ways, thank God that WWE is seemingly turning the page on the Dolph Ziggler/Rusev feud, having the Bulgarian Brute now feud with someone else. Sadly, it looks like he will be feuding with his valet and her marriage proposal. Yep, Summer Rae got down on a knee and asked Rusev to marry her. (It is 2015, after all.) To his credit, Rusev (who deserves much better than a soap opera storyline like this) played it off well, accepting her offer, but only after he wins championship gold again. It was a great way for him to blow Summer off and turn the focus back on himself. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zcg1ktnXxqc The storyline itself has €œtrainwreck€ written all over it, but it could be a €œso bad it€™s good€ type of affair. One note: Rusev talked about winning championship gold, then did not answer an open challenge for the United States Championship in the next segment. Talk about lack of consistency.

2. What Really Has Changed?

WWE can hashtag the Divas Revolution every day six ways to Sunday, but as long as the women are still cutting catty promos like Team Bella and Team BAD did on Raw, then the revolution really is just lip service. Naomi jumped on Nikki, alleging her sexual promiscuity, while the Bellas tried to instill petty jealousy between Naomi and Sasha Banks. The women traded barbs until the match started€ and that didn€™t really improve things much. It was yet another six-woman match with no real stakes and the usual subpar performance from the Bellas €“ watching them stumble through basic moves to cut the ring in half was painful. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXnMdEphD9U Women€™s wrestling took off in NXT because the women wanted to be the best, and that meant beating other women and winning the championship. In WWE, it€™s who can insult who and who can take credit for starting the Divas Revolution. They could have accomplished the same goal Monday by having Team BAD come out and challenge any member of Team Bella since it€™s Sasha€™s hometown and then have her beat Alicia Fox. It€™s just a mess right now, and longer matches do not necessarily equal better results.

1. World€™s Jobbiest World Champion

In case you missed the memo, Seth Rollins is the most gullible, idiotic man to hold the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. The company is doing everything in its power to make sure we get the point. Despite being the world champion, Rollins has lost nearly two-thirds of his televised matches this year. Now, he€™s getting demolished by a guy who has a worse won-loss record than him, Kane. Oh, but he put his mask back on, so he€™s invulnerable. Monday, Rollins looked like every bad Bond villain we€™ve seen, standing over a fallen Kane and taunting him (after leaving the ring and deciding to re-enter it to confront the Demon). Naturally, Kane sat up, goozled Rollins and chokeslammed him through a table. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDDWLZcfOuk The worst part is that Rollins absolutely could make this roll work if he won his matches, even if he used the ropes for leverage or pulled the tights. Ric Flair is a legend known as the €œDirtiest Player in the Game€ for a reason. Why would you book your world champion to be as weak and foolish as Rollins is? He delivers in all his matches, which is probably what keeps him afloat in fans€™ eyes.

Ups...

6. Hometown Heroes Win

It bears noting that WWE broke from an unspoken €œtradition€ of having wrestlers lose in their hometowns Monday night, with two wrestlers getting their hands raised. Both John Cena and Sasha Banks claim the Boston area as their hometown, with Banks billed from the city and Cena from a short drive up the road in West Newberry. Banks picked up the submission victory in Team BAD€™s six-woman match against Team Bella, while Cena pinned Big E to retain the U.S. Championship. We€™ve seen multiple times throughout the years that whenever WWE plays up that they are in someone€™s hometown, that wrestler either loses or is humiliated in some fashion. Booker T seemingly never won in Houston. Paige lost to Alicia Fox last year in London after cutting a promo about how great it was to be home. William Regal seemed to lose in England more often than he won. While there are no statistics at the fingertips, it seems like WWE superstars are more likely to lose when on their home turf, so Cena and Banks€™ victories were certainly notable.

5. An Old-Fashioned Squash

Sorry to say to all the Lucha Dragons fans out there, but this is exactly how they should be used if they aren€™t getting a push as a tag team: the occasional singles match punching bag for a bigger star. In this case, Kevin Owens tangled with Sin Cara, defeating him with little effort. Owens is the Intercontinental Champion (which used to count for something) and theoretically could be in the main event scene right now if he had been allowed to stay as hot as he was when he debuted. A big part of his gimmick is that he walks away from fights when they don€™t suit him. The subtle difference between that and being a typical chickens*** heel is being able to beat people up at will. Owens got that character over in NXT, destroying Sami Zayn and others but walking away from battles when they didn€™t suit him. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRGXSq0pPKU Getting a quick and easy win over Sin Cara and then wandering off when Ryback raced down was exactly the sort of thing Owens needed. Now, if there€™s justice, he€™ll actually beat the Big Guy convincingly in their rematch rather than raking the eyes again. One can dare to dream.

4. Hard Sell For Wednesday

The only redeeming factor of the poorly executed six-woman tag match was listening to the announcers really putting over the 30-minute Iron Woman match between Bayley and Sasha Banks for the NXT Women€™s Champion at NXT TakeOver: Respect on Wednesday. JBL pointed out how an Iron Man match can be a career-defining moment, and he really gave high praise when he talked about how the women stole the show at TakeOver: Brooklyn and deserved to main event Wednesday€™s show. That kind of sell made the match feel like it really is an important match and is something any real wrestling fan shouldn€™t miss. The obvious problem with this is that if WWE can figure out how to make an NXT Women€™s Championship match feel important, why can€™t they do the same thing with the Divas Championship? Aside from when Charlotte challenged Nikki Bella on the day she tied AJ Lee for the longest title reign, has there been a title match that felt like it was a really big deal?

3. New Day Stands Tall

If you had said three months ago (or even three weeks ago) that New Day would close out an episode of Raw standing over the fallen bodies of John Cena, Dolph Ziggler and the Dudley Boyz, most people would€™ve thought you were crazy. The popular trio is riding quite the wave, but they€™ve been more of a comedy act than a serious threat €“ until Monday night. For the second week in a row, New Day answered Cena€™s U.S. Championship open challenge, this time decimating Dolph Ziggler in the process. Big E fought the match and though he dominated throughout, he ultimately lost. But in the aftermath, New Day would manage to fend off Cena, an intervening Ziggler and the Dudleys. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCYrQ350q1E The result was the WWE World Tag Team Champions walking out as the dominant force for the night. It was a strange visual, but it served as a reminder to fans that despite being goofy and probably the funniest part of Raw, New Day is talented and dangerous.

2. Finally, Something Fresh

It€™s funny to think of two guys who have been on WWE€™s roster for nearly a decade together as a fresh matchup, but that€™s exactly what we€™re looking at with Dolph Ziggler and John Cena, who presumably began a program together after an errant Ziggler superkick put Cena down Monday night. Ziggler and Cena had a memorable feud in late 2012 into January 2013 over Ziggler€™s Money in the Bank briefcase (punctuated by AJ Lee turning on Cena to cost him a ladder match for the briefcase). But they haven€™t faced off against each other in one-on-one competition in more than two-and-a-half years. Since then, Ziggler has become a massive fan favorite (though an underachieving one), while Cena has reinvented himself as a workrate fiend. A feud between the two over Cena€™s United States Championship could be interesting, especially if WWE doesn€™t go the route of turning Ziggler heel, and especially if WWE doesn€™t tie in the Total Divas storyline of Ziggler hitting on Cena€™s girlfriend (and Dolph€™s ex) Nikki Bella. If that happens, then this storyline will occupy the #1 €œdown€ spot for the foreseeable future. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_AGP4u8XGI But as a straight feud between two popular stars who have forged alliances in the past and can go in the ring, this could be really good. At the very least, it gets Ziggler away from his dead-end feud with Rusev.

1. 20 Minutes Well Spent

Normally, a 20-minute opening promo is both dreaded and dreadful. Fans could be lost for the rest of the night as the air gets let out of the balloon. But opening Monday with Brock Lesnar and Paul Heyman seemed to have the exact opposite effect, pumping up the Boston crowd. Sure, the recap packages dragged things down a bit, but Heyman is masterful at rallying fans to his cause, calling out the Undertaker (€œHell in a Cell is your match? My ass!€) and delivering his take on their HIAC match later this month (€œOne of you won€™t walk out€ that€™s not a prediction, that€™s a spoiler.€). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNwJ3PsHQXw Throw in Big Show wandering down to get annihilated yet again and you have an awesome segment that just makes Brock look even more like a killer €“ if that€™s possible €“ and put fans in the right frame of mind.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.