7 Best Obsessive Wrestling Storylines

Obsession. Desire. Depression.

Shawn Michaels The Undertaker
WWE.com

The Cambridge dictionary defines obsessive as, "thinking about something or someone, or doing something, too much or all the time". That meaning is heavily present in the tropes of pro wrestling storylines, because it allows creative to depict a person so preoccupied with another that it consumes their every waking moment.

This obsession can come in many forms, most of them ideal for heels who can't live with the thought of babyfaces doing well.

Maybe they want to stop another worker from winning championships, or they're trying to muscle in on a relationship to become the object of someone's desire. Alternatively, it can simply be one wrestler attempting to oust another from the picture by way of mind games, or the reason for a good ol' heel/babyface turn.

Not every obsessive storyline is creepy, but there is a thread of the disturbing about the idea of one person becoming so absorbed in undermining or destroying another that they will go to extraordinary lengths. Also, it's interesting that two examples on this list feature babyfaces, not heels, who became obsessed with those they were feuding with...


7. Bray Wyatt Will Tolerate Anyone But Roman Reigns

bray wyatt roman reigns interview
WWE.com

"Anyone but you, Roman".

After attacking Roman Reigns during the 2015 Money In The Bank match, Bray Wyatt revealed that he couldn't bear to watch Reigns succeed. In other words, he was hooked on the thought of having dominion over Roman's career, and he wasn't going to stand idly by as the ex-Shield man became WWE Champ.

This, arguably (and possibly aside from that brief WWE Title reign in 2017) was the last time Wyatt's character was worth a toss on TV. His usually cryptic, winding and mysterious promos gave way to a much more straightforward approach. Bray, whatever his reasons, wanted to stop Reigns from succeeding.

The feud led to a seriously underrated caged classic at Hell In A Cell, and it also allowed Wyatt to introduce Braun Strowman as his new charge. By being so transfixed on Reigns, the madman exposed that he wasn't necessarily driven by championships - just the power of stopping one man from winning them.


6. Kurt Angle Muscles In On Stephanie McMahon

Triple H Stephanie McMahon Kurt Angle 2000
WWE.com

What do you get when you take three unlikeable heels and throw them into a love triangle situation? The answer: Stephanie McMahon's heart is torn between 'Cerebral' bad-ass Triple H and dorky Olympian Kurt Angle, and 2000 has one of its absolute best summer story threads.

Kurt, much to Triple H's chagrin, managed to turn Stephanie's head despite blatantly hoping for more than being friend-zoned. He repeatedly tried to undermine 'The Game', appeal to Steph's gentle side and show that he was there for her when her sledgehammer-wielding man was too busy chasing titles.

The beauty of Angle's obsession was the fact that McMahon couldn't see Kurt's true intentions until it was too late.

Angle and Triple H were also dynamite in-ring together. Their matches at SummerSlam (a Triple Threat co-starring The Rock) Unforgiven and the 2001 Royal Rumble were awesome, and the ongoing soap-opera-style melodrama let Kurt show his acting chops.


5. Goldust Is Infatuated By Razor Ramon

Goldust Razor Ramon
WWE Network

The WWF had never had a character like Goldust before the Hollywood-loving weirdo popped up on television in late-1995. His dramatic entrances, androgynous appearance and sexual vibes were a far cry from hokey cartoonish jokes like Mantaur or a babyface Doink The Clown; Goldust shared their exaggerated feel, but he was far more provocative.

Just ask Scott Hall.

In years since, Hall has admitted that he (as Razor Ramon) was pretty uncomfortable with the thought of children looking on as he was borderline stalked and groped by this oddball clad in gold. Goldust got a 'Razor' tattoo, blew kisses at his new infatuation and played mind games aplenty with someone he described as a real man.

The wonderful thing about this angle is that it made people feel confused and uneasy. Was Goldust after Ramon personally, or did he want to rattle him enough to steal away the Intercontinental Title?

Everything about the tale was ahead of its time.


4. Chris Jericho Wants To Expose Shawn Michaels As A Fraud

Chris Jericho Shawn Michaels 2008 Jeritron 3000
WWE.com

Chris Jericho wasn't obsessed with a title when he targeted Shawn Michaels in 2008. No, Y2J was simply disgusted that his childhood hero could be so selfish and no good to feign injury during a match he was refereeing. At Backlash against Batista, that's exactly what the crafty HBK did to nab the win.

Jericho, feeling ashamed to be a Michaels cheerleader, was outraged that he'd been hoodwinked, and he wanted answers.

This facilitated one hell of a heel turn for the Canadian and planted a seed for 2008's standout feud. After grilling Shawn on his pretence, Jericho blasted his teen icon through the Jeri-Tron on The Highlight Reel and launched a one-man campaign to unmask the fraud behind Michaels' legend.

In 2008, that was all Jericho cared about. Consequently, his obsession became HBK's too; even when Shawn was written to "retire" at SummerSlam, he was drawn back in after Jericho socked his wife. What a story, one so good that Y2J's kayfabe obsession became every wrestling fan's new passion.


3. Mickie James Wants To Be Trish Stratus

Mickie James Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Ignore the controversial use of implied cunnilingus at WrestleMania 22 (now there's a sentence), because the Trish Stratus vs. Mickie James rivalry had way, way more than that to offer. It was a quite startling introduction for Mickie, and a unique use of Trish's beauty that didn't rely on some red-blooded dude getting all misty-eyed.

They didn't have a look-in anyway, 'cause James was more in love with the ex-glamour-model-turned-pro-wrestler than anyone else.

It was the little touches that made Mickie's fixation with Trish soar. The way she'd look at Stratus during promos with a serial killer stare, the super-creepy shrine she kept to her hero that turned fan-girling into James' own religious cult, and her need to tell Stratus how pretty she was at every turn. Everything worked.

Then, when Mickie did turn on Trish and reveal she wanted to destroy her if she couldn't have her, WWE had one of their most strange yet fascinating female storylines ever. Go back and watch, and you'll find that this wasn't the typical Diva fare.


2. Shawn Michaels Must Beat The Undertaker

Elimination Chamber 2010
WWE.com

If anyone can name better back-to-back WrestleMania matches than the ones worked by Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker at XXV and XXVI, then yours truly will be shocked. Both bouts were a stunning example of how credibility with fans, storytelling and in-ring nous can combine to create pro wrestling excellence.

After the original's exhibition presentation, WWE knew they needed something more for the follow-up.

Enter Shawn Michaels' crazed need to topple 'Taker's WrestleMania winning streak before hanging up his tights. The promos HBK cut in the lead up to XXVI, and the way he'd beg for another chance to beat one of his greatest foes, was spellbinding stuff. When 'The Deadman' said no, Michaels decided to kill his World Title reign inside the Elimination Chamber.

Two things that stood out in the story more than anything were Shawn's disinterest in the title itself and his willingness to help old rival Chris Jericho bag the gold if it meant sending a message to 'Taker. This, this was how to end a career. It remains a multi-layered drama that'd put most feature films to shame.


1. Sting Stalks The nWo

Sting - WCW - Crow
WWE.com

On the subject of feature films, it was 'The Crow' that opened new doors for Sting in 1996-1997 and turned him from bleach-blonde good guy into monochrome vigilante.

Eric Bischoff (and WCW as a whole) do not get enough credit for refusing to hot-shot Sting's new character into a quick money-grabbing pay-per-view match against Hollywood Hogan and his nWo cronies quickly. Instead, the company held off on Sting's attack on the focal point of the group but made his purpose abundantly clear.

He, jilted by suggestions from friends that he'd turn on WCW and join the nWo, was there to nobly defend the promotion that had made him against its biggest threat. To prepare for war, Sting watched from the rafters, only occasionally striking from the shadows before pointing a black baseball bat at Hogan.

The dominance of the New World Order and it's iron-like grip on WCW's product turned the babyface of the 90s into a bleak, emotionless guardian who was both haunted and driven by the need to spurn Hogan's crew. It was masterful storytelling, and one of the best angles WCW ever produced.

What other obsessive wrestling storylines can you think of? Let us know down in the comments section below!


In this post: 
Mickie James
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.