7 Best Ways WWE Can Utilise Rumoured Returning Stars
It's one thing to bring them back, it's another to know how to properly use them.
The latest WWE brand extension comes at a time when the company is desperately pushing a New Era, which is all the more ironic given the fact that high-ranking officials behind the scenes are reaching out to stars of a bygone era to help bolster star power for Raw and SmackDown.
Not only is it an admission from the proud, typically chest-thumping promotion that they have failed to create bona fidestars that can consistently draw ratings, it is also recognition of the positive effect those stars from the past had on the company.
Jeff Hardy, Rey Mysterio and Bill Goldberg are just a few of the names being tossed back and forth, their name value alone almost guaranteed to generate interest among longtime fans and casual audiences alike.
It is one thing to coerce those stars to strap on their boots, pull on a brand new pair of tights and take to the squared circle in which they have earned their fortunes and legacies, it is another to know how to best utilise them.
With July 19 rapidly approaching, and rumours heating up that the WWE Universe could see any of these superstars back on their screens sooner than later, enjoy this look at the best ways to use them for desired results.
7. Stevie Richards
One of the most underrated elements of WWE circa 2000 was Stevie Richards' work as the uptight censor Steven Richards, head of The Right to Censor, a faction of midcard stars who struck out against the inappropriate violence and sex that permeated the company's programming.
Richards was loud, obnoxious even, but he spoke with great conviction and was never anything but believable.
Even when he moved on from that gimmick, becoming the kooky boyfriend of Victoria and a staple of the hardcore division, Richards was always a great hand between the ropes.
It should be no surprise that WWE would be interested in bringing him back into the fold as it embarks on its second brand extension. While Richards is smart enough to adjust his style and still be an effective in-ring performer at this point in his career, he would better be served working in the company's Performance Center, where he can both train competitors in the ring and coach them in their development as on-screen characters.
A star for WWE, ECW, WCW and TNA at different points throughout his career, Richards has a wealth of experience to draw from. Vince McMahon's promotion has a wealth of young stars who could benefit from his expertise.
6. MVP
Like Richards, MVP is a talented wrestler whose charisma helped earn him "breakout star" status in 2006 with the SmackDown brand. He rose to prominence as the United States champion, holding the title for over a year and developing into a heel straight out of the gridiron.
No matter how many times he mixed it up with top stars like Batista, The Undertaker, Rey Mysterio and Edge, the biggest free agent ever signed by general manager Theodore Long never broke through the glass ceiling and became the headliner so many expected him to.
Instead, he settled for midcard mediocrity before departing WWE in 2010. He floated around other promotions, including TNA. A superstar whose ability to talk is as valuable as his in-ring work, he would sure up the midcard of any brand he appears on. As far as a main event run goes, that appears unlikely at this stage.
While his character is strong enough, nothing that he accomplished outside of WWE suggests he is a marquee star. A solid hand at this point in his career and one who can lend his name recognition to either Raw or SmackDown, MVP still has value, just not as much as he probably thinks.
5. Carlito
Carlito should have been a monumental star for World Wrestling Entertainment.
Debuting in late 2004, the second-generation competitor defeated John freaking Cena in his debut match to win the United States Championship. Almost immediately, though, it became apparent that his in-ring skills were did not quite match up to his undeniable charisma. He was cocky, arrogant and brash but, more importantly, he was a step behind Kurt Angle, Eddie Guerrero and the rest of the SmackDown brand.
After moving to Raw, the question was no longer whether or not he had the makings of a star; he had shown as much in matches with Shelton Benjamin, Johnny Nitro, Ric Flair and the aforementioned Cena. No, the questions centred on Carlito's passion to be the best.
In 2007, Flair even cut a truth-based promo on Carlito during a live episode of Raw in which he questioned his heart. While he would rebound and eventually form a very entertaining tag team with brother Primo, he had descended down the ranks far too quickly to ever be considered the credible main event attraction so many once thought he may be.
After his release in 2010, Carlito returned to Puerto Rico, where he has had considerable success working for, and with, his father Carlos Colon.
The best way for WWE to utilise him at this point in his career is a solid midcarder with name recognition. He has natural charisma, as witnessed at the Hall of Fame in 2014, where he stole the show with a few digs at management and WWE Creative while inducting his dad.
Letting him host his Carlito's Cabana talk show while working with the likes of Neville, Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens and Cesaro would best suit him. Is he a headliner? No, but he can be a solid addition to a roster full of extraordinary wrestlers, of which there were few when he was last inside a Vince McMahon-owned ring.
4. Jeff Hardy
There is no way Jeff Hardy can return to WWE as anything but a main event attraction.
When he is "on", there are few stars more captivating and beloved in the world of professional wrestling. He has a way of forcing the audience to invest emotionally in everything he does. Hardy has spent two-plus decades of his life putting his body on the line in the name of entertainment and fans have rewarded him with an energy and vocal support that few superstars ever achieve.
The last time the WWE Universe laid eyes on Hardy, he was losing a "Loser Leaves WWE" match to CM Punk in August 2009. Since then, he has become the cornerstone of TNA Wrestling, its biggest attraction and the one star keeping that company in the national conscious.
At a time when John Cena, Brock Lesnar, Undertaker and Triple H are counted on by WWE to help boost buyrates in and around WrestleMania season, Hardy could shoulder some of the responsibility. Unlike The Game and The Phenom, though, Hardy has proven time and time again in TNA that he still has gas left in the tank.
While he may not be the performer he once was, he is still immensely talented and understands crowd psychology.
Best of all, beating him means something. Even as the face of TNA during its descent into mediocrity (to put it nicely) his star is inarguable, lending itself to putting over young talent. As a former world champion in a New Era, Hardy can prepare the next generation for a decade of stardom, just as industry icons did for him so long ago.
3. Rey Mysterio
There is nothing for Rey Mysterio to achieve in WWE.
The masked luchador elevated himself to Hall of Fame glory based on the resume he compiled in Vince McMahon's promotion, where he captured the world heavyweight title on two separate occasions and battled Kurt Angle, Undertaker, CM Punk, Chris Jericho and the late Eddie Guerrero in some of the best matches of the new Millennium.
So why would Rey come back to the company that he left amid such contentiousness in 2014? Simple: one great last run.
Mysterio was essentially jobbed out on his way out of WWE. He wallowed in mediocrity while teaming with Sin Cara and dropping one-sided matches to Roman Reigns. He was a shell of his former self, a wrestler seemingly passed on by a new generation of stars.
As fans have seen through his work in Mexico, the independent scene and Lucha Underground, Mysterio can still go. Maybe not on a nightly basis, which was the case when he was under WWE contract but as a superstar reserved from television, he can be used to attract viewers while providing an extraordinary in-ring product alongside the likes of Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, Kevin Owens and the aforementioned Reigns.
There were questions about Mysterio's usefulness when he signed with WWE in 2002. Was he still a star after a disastrous close to his WCW career. The company made him one, putting him over through a series of video packages. Repeating that booking method would allow WWE to get another year or two out of the all-time great while providing name recognition at the top of Raw or SmackDown.
2. Goldberg
Goldberg has not wrestled a match on television in 12 years, yet he remains one of the most sought after stars in the industry, thanks to the incredible aura that still follows him after his star-making turn in WCW.
Even a disappointing WWE run in which he was repeatedly undermined by Triple H and management behind the scenes, the name "Goldberg" continues to elicit great excitement and intrigue from fans chomping at the bit for one more run from the Monday Night Wars icon.
The recent revelation that Goldberg will be the star of WWE '17 has spurred rumors of a comeback. With the company desperate for star power as it embarks on another brand extension, a return to the industry that made him a household name through the late 1990s would make sense.
The only acceptable offer for Goldberg would be as a special attraction, a performer who can pop up on Raw and SmackDown, draw a rating and set up a high-profile wrestling match before repeating the cycle a few months later.
Overexposing his star did neither the performer nor the company any good last time and led to diminished results. Learning from the past, using Goldberg in a role similar to that of Brock Lesnar and reaping the rewards would best suit the sports-entertainment empire.
1. John Morrison
After leaving WWE in 2011 to explore wrestling beyond Vince McMahon's traveling circus, John Morrison found tremendous success as one of the founding fathers of Lucha Underground. A recognisable face whom management could believably put in main events, he rewarded their faith with performances that resembled the show-stealing ones that he had delivered just prior to his departure from WWE.
Since then, he has been one of the top stars for the critically-acclaimed product.
It is understandable, after watching his work with the California-based promotion, that Vince McMahon, Triple H and Company would want to reach out to Morrison (known in LU as Johnny Mundo) to gauge his interest in returning to the company in which he rose to prominence.
It remains to be seen if Morrison accepts the offer or if he even can thanks to a Lucha Underground contract that can best be described as oppressive. If he does make his way back to WWE, though, he must be the main event level star that he was never given the opportunity to during his original run.
Morrison no longer has anything to prove to management. He has spent the last five years stealing shows in the independents, Mexico and LU. He has evolved his game and is as good a wrestler as any of the free agents on this list. With stars for the top of Raw and SmackDown desperately needed, he makes as much sense as anyone.
It is his time to shine. Now it depends on whether or not he wants to and if WWE management can legally make it happen.