7 Classic Wrestling Storylines WWE Should Recycle

Compelling storylines from wrestling's past.

Harley Race
WWE.com

Much has been made among the wrestling community about WWE Creative's struggles to construct a coherent storyline. Angles start and get dropped, are changed or ignored before they pay off, or, in many cases, the story makes little sense. The performers we're supposed to cheer act like jerks (Seth Rollins, John Cena), and those we're supposed to boo deserve our sympathy or are most entertaining (Chris Jericho, Rusev).

In many cases, rivalries aren't given time to develop or demonstrate logic behind why the wrestlers are fighting to begin with.

The good news is, a stroll through the WWE Network or YouTube provides plenty of examples of good wrestling storytelling ripe for recycling. Here are seven cases where classic wrestling angles from years past easily could be remade with modern performers.

7. Ric Flair Vs. Ricky Steamboat - “Step Aside, Kid.”

When most people think of the Ric Flair-Ricky Steamboat rivalry, they think of the 1989 series of five-star classics for the NWA World Title. But in truth, the seeds were planted for that angle years before, when Ricky Steamboat was new to the business and Flair was not yet in his prime in the Mid-Atlantic Territory.

In 1977, while Steamboat was making a name for himself on Mid-Atlantic TV, Flair began interrupting Steamboat's interviews, telling him, "step aside, kid," so the Nature Boy could flaunt his NWA TV Title. He arrogantly proclaimed the audience had tuned in to see him, not the newcomer.

Eventually, Steamboat had enough and knocked Flair out during an interview segment. An incensed Flair agreed to a TV Title match, which Steamboat won, sparking a feud that would literally last decades. Flair's heel persona came across perfectly, and he put over Steamboat as a force to be reckoned with. It was a textbook case of how to get a new talent over without sacrificing an established star.

If there's one thing with which WWE has struggled of late, it's making new stars. This is a perfect template for how to do it. The heel role would perfectly suit the Miz, whose irritating movie star gimmick is equal parts annoying and entertaining. If WWE chose to give someone like Apollo Crews some wins or bring up Tye Dillinger or Roderick Strong from NXT, this angle could work just as well as it did with Steamboat.


6. Freebirds Vs. Von Erichs – "Pin Him."

The World Class Championship Wrestling territory wasn't built solely around the rivalry between the Fabulous Freebirds and the Von Erichs - but it almost was.

The Freebirds were loud, brash, and crude, while the Von Erichs were clean-cut, good looking, and respectful heartthrobs. The story practically wrote itself, and WCCW went back to it so many times it almost became self-parody.

During World Class' big Christmas show of 1982, Michael "P.S." Hayes was assigned as a guest referee for the NWA World Title cage match between Ric Flair and Kerry Von Erich. Hayes got involved in the match, knocking Flair down and suggesting Von Erich make the cover to win the title. When Kerry refused, a frustrated Hayes started to walk out of the cage. When Von Erich stopped him to try to reason with him, Flair hit Kerry with a knee to the back (jump to the 28:50 mark of the video), knocking Hayes to the floor. Freebird enforcer Terry 'Bam Bam' Gordy then slammed the cage door in Von Erich's head.

It's long since been time to turn AJ Styles babyface again, so a similar angle would be an ideal way to bring Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson to SmackDown and have them resume their quest to #beatupjohncena.

Since Styles has shown babyface tendencies by beating Cena clean at SummerSlam and shaking his hand recently on SmackDown, a slow face turn could come to pass by having Gallows & Anderson help Styles by laying Cena out during a WWE Title match and offering Styles the pin. When Styles refuses, his former friends could turn on The Phenomenal One for his lack of gratitude, costing him the championship and setting Styles up as the top full-time babyface on SmackDown.


5. Hulk Hogan V. Paul Orndorff – Disputed Finish

One of the best Hulk Hogan feuds from the '80s was his long program with 'Mr. Wonderful' Paul Orndorff, which lasted from 1985 until Hogan's rivalry with Andre The Giant in 1987. The two spent much of 1985 and '86 feuding with Bobby 'The Brain' Heenan's family in tag matches. However, Orndorff grew impatient when he was unable to reach Hogan while he was outnumbered by King Kong Bundy and Big John Studd.

In July 1986, Hogan and Orndorff joined forces for one final showdown with Studd and Bundy. Orndorff, determined to do all the work himself, took a beating before Hogan tagged in, but later accidentally knocked Orndorff from the ring apron. Orndorff entered the ring despite being knocked out by his partner and cleaned house, then shockingly turning on Hogan with a clothesline and piledriver (jump to 8:35), sowing the seeds for Orndorff himself joining Heenan's family.

The feud culminated with a steel cage match in January 1987 on Saturday Night's Main Event in January 1987. Hogan and Orndorff both left the cage simultaneously, with one referee declaring each man the winner, in a finish that required instant replay to be resolved.

While the only thing WWE does worse than book babyfaces is book heels, a similar angle could be a way to finally turn Roman Reigns heel. Now that he has joined forces with former Shield mate Seth Rollins, the two could engage in a feud with a team such as Gallows & Anderson, Sheamus and Cesaro, or Chris Jericho and Kevin Owens. While Rollins is preoccupied with his impending feud with Triple H, Reigns could become frustrated with him and destroy him after a loss, allowing him to return to the the silent killer that once was over with fans of The Shield.


4. Shawn Michaels Vs. Razor Ramon – Who’s The Real Champion?

With WWE focused on breaking new ground in the women's division, one match type that has yet to be explored is a ladder match. Despite the women's rosters on both Raw and SmackDown being thin, deeper storytelling is the best way to keep the division interesting.

In 1993, Shawn Michaels was suspended for using steroids during a time when the company was facing an unseemly trial for steroid distribution - a charge he denies to this day. On screen, he was ordered to give up the Intercontinental title (ostensibly for defending it too few times), but he refused to surrender the belt.

Razor Ramon was declared the new champion, but Michaels returned with his title, claiming to be the "real" champion. The program culminated in the influential ladder match at Wrestlemania X.

The rivalry was great because it was about who was the better performer, so the motivation was to be champion, which added prestige to the title. While WWE has worked very hard to label Charlotte vs. Sasha Banks as the greatest women's rivalry, the reality is that the Bayley vs. Sasha rivalry in NXT was the best in recent years, especially with Banks in the heel role. Instead of hot-shotting the women's title back and forth as has been the custom of late, having two women do something that hasn't been done in WWE would add to the lure of the Raw Women's Championship.

WWE could play off of Banks' real-life injury issues by having her take the women's title yet again from Charlotte, then be forced to drop it due to a kayfabe injury. After Bayley wins it, Banks, now a defiant heel, could refuse to return the belt, leading to a ladder match to determine the "real" champion.


3. Barry Windham Vs. Lex Luger - “I Told You He Wouldn’t Be There.”

One of the best slow-build angles of the '80s was Barry Windham's heel turn en route to replacing Lex Luger as a member of the Four Horsemen. In late 1987, Luger began to question the leadership of the group and its manager, J.J. Dillon. This got him ejected from the group, and Luger vowed to learn from his mistakes.

As Luger left the group, Ric Flair announced that he and Dillon had an eye on Windham as a possible replacement for Luger. Windham and Luger joined forces, beating Tully Blanchard and Arn Anderson for the NWA World Tag Team titles in April 1988.

During his promos, Dillon told Windham that Luger could not be relied upon, and that eventually Luger wouldn't be there when Windham needed him. Shortly after Windham and Luger won the belts, a rematch was held, during which Luger was incapacitated outside the ring, Windham took a beating, getting to his corner to make a tag several times to find Luger not there and hearing Dillon repeatedly yell, "I told you he wouldn't be there!" (around the 7:30 mark in the video.)

When Luger finally made it back to the corner, Windham tagged him, threw him into the ring, then hit his Lariat finisher on his partner, allowing Anderson and Blanchard to regain the titles and officially join the Horsemen

The angle was brilliant because it teased the eventual conclusion in a subtle manner, so that afterward, Dillon could tell everyone that everything had gone as the Horsemen planned. This could work well with DIY, who have teased a split before. Should the team lose the NXT Tag Team Titles to the Authors of Pain, AOP manager Paul Ellering could tell Tommaso Ciampa that partner Johnny Gargano was the weak link and the reason the team lost.


2. Harley Race Vs. Ric Flair – The Bounty

This angle actually was redone once, in 2003 when Triple H took out a $100,000 bounty on WWE World Heavyweight Champion Goldberg, which Evolution member Batista cashed in, injuring Goldberg's ankle. However, since Goldberg never really missed any time, we'll look back to the original bounty angle, featuring NWA World Champion Harley Race and Ric Flair in 1983.

The two had feuded off and on for years, and when Race became tired of Flair pursuing him for the title, he cut a famous promo in July 1983 where he offered $25,000 to anyone who could run Flair out of the business. 'Cowboy' Bob Orton and Dick Slater collected, seemingly injuring Flair's neck permanently. Flair claimed he was retiring, but he later returned to Mid-Atlantic in shocking fashion, attacking the pair with a baseball bat, which he called "the only partner I'll ever need."

This led to Flair and Race's cage match at the first Starrcade, where Race passed the torch to Flair as the dominant heel of the '80s. It painted Race as a ruthless villain, and allowed Flair to come back from a career-threatening injury.

The angle could be done again with Triple H, perhaps out of frustration with being unable to put Seth Rollins away. On SmackDown, The Miz, the only sniveling heel currently fitting of the Race role in WWE, could put out a hit on Dean Ambrose through his obsession to reclaim the Intercontinental title, leading to a no-holds barred match at WrestleMania. To make it work, however, the babyface in the angle would have to be kayfabe injured and miss a few weeks, something WWE often seems loathe to do.


1. Jerry Lawler Vs. Nick Bockwinkel - $500 A Punch

One of the greatest old-school heels in history, Nick Bockwinkel was a great talker as well as a great wrestling heel, working as an arrogant, big-talking villain in the vein of Buddy Rogers long before Ric Flair came along. One of Bockwinkel's best rivalries was with Jerry 'The King' Lawler in Memphis, which the two would often revisit.

In 1984, Bockwinkel and Lawler battled for the AWA World Title in Memphis, a match Lawler won by disqualification when Bockwinkel accidentally punched the referee. After the match, Bockwinkel cut a promo in which he claimed Lawler couldn't really do anything but brawl, and in a pure wrestling match, he would be no match for the champion.

Bockwinkel went on to offer Lawler a rematch for the title, but only if Lawler agreed to pay $500 for every punch he threw, assuming that the fines would keep 'the King' from throwing his legendary right hand. Lawler agreed to the match, but in his promo accepting the stipulation, he said that while $500 per punch was a lot of money, Lawler estimated that 20 punches would be enough to finish Bockwinkel off, and the $10,000 would be a good investment if it brought him the World Title.

WWE often does angles where a certain wrestler's finisher is banned but the move always comes into play anyway. The fine both puts over how devastating a certain move is without insulting the fans, who know it's going to be used anyway. The only WWE wrestler with a move similar to Lawler's punches would be Cesaro, whose European uppercut is both impressive and stiff in its delivery. Cesaro could challenge Kevin Owens for the Universal Championship, but Owens could claim that he'll only take the match if Cesaro agrees to pay $5,000 per uppercut.


In this post: 
harley race
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm a lifelong writer and former newspaper journalist, a full-on Star Wars and wrestling nerd, and a fan of superheroes. I'm also a husband and a dad, and my fondest wish is to instill good values into my children, and to convince them that Han shot first.