7 Match Star Ratings For WWE Survivor Series 2020
WWE waved goodbye to the Undertaker at Survivor Series, which itself needs to Rest In Peace.
Survivor Series was the dumbest WWE pay-per-view of 2020.
Since Extreme Rules 2020 wore the tagline 'The Horror Show' amid a viral outbreak, and was based on which wrestler would first extract an eyeball, that is saying something. Let's also not forget Money In The Bank, a show on which the wrestlers were invited to 'Climb The Corporate Ladder!' in parallel with WWE firing multiple corporate staffers despite generating record profits, which the layoffs would not have remotely affected.
What next?
WWE Planes, Trains & Automobiles: a madcap show based on the quickest route out of Saudi Arabia?!
Imagine Celtic and Rangers transferring almost literally every player to one another weeks before the Old Firm. That impossible scenario would somewhat negate the toxic fascination ahead of the Old Firm. WWE is in narrative control of their derby, and they effectively do this for some f*cking reason. Because they're dumb? Because they think you're dumb? It is excruciating and exhausting, in any event.
It was bad enough, a few years back, when the 'Shake-Up' was held in April, because no attempt was ever made to make brand loyalty a thing. It is somehow even dumber now. The Draft takes place one month before the big derby. The Street Profits represented SmackDown last night. Looking back at their WWE run, it is the brand they should be least loyal to.
The whole thing is a f*cking farce and it needs to stop.
As for the match quality, not that it mattered much...
7. KICKOFF: 18-Man Inter-Brand Battle Royal
Kalisto and Rey Mysterio highlighted the customary stand-there-and-look-busy flesh wall with a bang-tidy sequence. That was quite good. Dolph Ziggler wore a cap backwards, '90s style. The New Generation isn't going to shag you, mate.
Shinsuke Nakamura seemed confused about which brand he was representing. He wore a red and blue outfit. He is as confused as everybody else.
Ricochet half-killed Cedric Alexander in a crazed and awesome elimination by suplexing him on the apron, for which he will be rewarded with a nine-minute Main Event match. Elias, in contrast, bumped like a felled tree at the slightest threat of a Jeff Hardy kick. Chad Gable unleashed his best-in-the-world-calibre suplex trifecta before Dominik Mysterio eliminated him. The Miz then eliminated him to win as the crafty veteran. The crafty veteran who took years and years to become as competent as Dominik was on day one.
Those were the highlights. This was mostly a sluggish bore.
The nicest possible thing one can write about this match is that a Money In The Bank briefcase holder won, and wasn't utterly buried, like so many prospective World Heavyweight Champions have been before him.
That's good!
The Money In The Bank briefcase holder is The Miz, who failed to evolve into a true headliner a decade ago.
That's bad.
Star Rating: ★★½
6. Men's Traditional 5-On-5 Elimination Match
What is the 'Greater Good' now? It used to be that we were to accept Seth Rollins as the saviour of RAW.
Is the Greater Good now "not letting Murphy get his hole'? That's a face move, surely. He's in his 30s.
Whatever it is now, Seth Rollins sacrificed himself for it and intentionally eliminated himself from the match.
Elements of this were entertaining, but the big hoss stare-downs diminished even if Otis entered his best performance in ages. The agenting was loose and excessive. It was the worst of a match type that has yielded some excellent iterations since it was introduced in 2016. Team SmackDown were over-enthusiastic and were swiftly eliminated to little dramatic effect despite taking the piss with their tandem moves, which the referee didn't attempt to curtail. He didn't have to.
The RAW team won out because they were cannier at working together. What a wholesome story.
There are three heels on Team RAW, depending on what the f*ck Braun Strowman is.
The barely competitive layout was structured to further babyface Jey Uso - who has just turned heel (!) and has twice lost to Roman Reigns, if that's the ultimate destination - but his last stand was rushed, and he barely sealed the envelope on the superkick party he threw. The sequence was a bit loose.
Keith Lee picked up the win for Team RAW. He got more over in defeat last year.
That's the main roster for you.
Star Rating: ★★¾
5. The Street Profits Vs. The New Day
Holy sh*t did these guys actually get it.
An awesome match that was actually germane to the context of brand superiority, it was worked like human beings, and not barely sentient t-shirts, were involved in it.
Instead of adhering to the established dynamic, the New Day owned their veteran storyline superiority and realised it with a heelish performance. There was a flexing competitive theme to this match that belonged on the Survivor Series stage. This was the ideal Survivor Series match. Where even the best matches work in spite of the gimmick, or don't really need it, this banger cultivated the tone tremendously.
Kofi Kingston was great value reducing Montez Ford to a gimmick on the apron, and the story of the match maximised what Ford excels at in all too rare accentuate-the-positives booking masterclass. He out-jumped Kofi - Kofi! - in a blistering pissing contest of a sequence. Ford pissed the farthest when he delivered Trouble In Paradise to Kofi in a well-earned power absorption spot.
The match built magnificently to the hot tag - Xavier Woods entered such an accomplished connective performance - and if it had one flaw, it's that Ford and Angelo Dawkins really need to refine or outright retire an element of their double team comeback. That twirl into the corner strike thing just looks plain odd and barely effective.
Still, this was great - precisely the sort of breakout match that instils hope that such lessons will be learned by an act on the rise.
Star Rating: ★★★★
4. Bobby Lashley Vs. Sami Zayn
What do you do?
Do you just say "F*ck it," further damage the prestige of the midcard championships, and arbitrarily switch them around for the sake of a better dynamic? Is it worth doing that for a single match that goes under eight minutes?
WWE has done this before, for the World Title no less, but at least in 2017 and 2018 those matches were exponentially better and or fresher than those originally scheduled.
Do you - and hold onto your d*ck, because this new wavelength of thought might shake you up - meticulously plan the show months in advance to arrive at a match that isn't impossible to make good and, at the same time, does not affect the creative on the respective brands?
Or do you realise that the respective midcard titles are each held by heels, and accept that Bobby Lashley Vs. Sami Zayn is probably going to be a bit warped and a bit sh*t?
WWE realised that the respective midcard titles are each held by heels, and accepted that Bobby Lashley Vs. Sami Zayn was probably going to be a bit warped and a bit sh*t.
Zayn cowered, stalled, and attempted to draw a disqualification from the Hurt Business. He looked like a geek. This was the worst possible version of a Bobby Lashley Vs. Sami Zayn match, which would have ruled, had Zayn played the frantic, spirited underdog babyface. He didn't. But the match, which stood no chance, had to happen because both men held a midcard title in November.
What do you do?
What you do is you bury the the damn pay-per-view six feet under the Performance Center, and see it off with a hologram of William Regal.
Star Rating: ★
3. Asuka Vs. Sasha Banks
Isn't the very appeal of Survivor Series in the presentation of brand new matches you'd never see on the other 364 days of the year?
It is, after all, the one night of the year on which the stars of RAW and SmackDown engage in direct competition.
Asuka and Sasha Banks engaged in direct competition several times over the summer. The matches were great, but there were so many of them, and so many of them were f*cked by obnoxious finishes, that it was very difficult to invest in or get hyped for this fifth match of 2020. WWE contriving to normalise a fantastic match with fantastic workers is very WWE.
This wasn't fantastic, but it was very good. The tremendous chemistry of the frantic technical struggle felt relatively loose in the opening half. By their standards, it was a bit overcomplicated too. Not a great deal registered as moments of true dramatic peril because the pacing was all a bit muddled.
Far tighter and immersive by the closing stretch, the match peaked brilliantly towards a politicised and thus deflating finish. WWE didn't want to beat either woman. The flash pin, sold as a lapse in concentration more than anything else, felt like a get-out.
It's the pay-per-view that needs to get out.
F*ck Survivor Series.
Star Rating: ★★★½
2. Women's Traditional 5-On-5 Elimination Match
An uneven match that, to its credit, tried to play with the subplots that the genre enables, it wasn't great and it rested on a visual gag to its overall detriment.
The omni-f*cked mechanics that plague WWE undid what was, in theory, good or at least progressive. The big-star-gets-eliminated-first trope isn't a bad story to tell, but it's not as if Peyton Royce is getting the big push on the back of it. WWE's general directionless apathy meant it lacked any gravity. It will mean nothing, so it meant little.
There's an arbitrary quality to how Shayna Baszler is booked in these tag scenarios - the theoretical submission killer will passively eat chains of offence or even visual pins - that underscores how thoughtless and random so much of WWE's output is. When WWE "protected" her with a DQ finish, it didn't much resonate as a cue to continue taking her seriously because they don't.
Some might argue that this is blanket jaded thinking that should not overwhelm the analysis of a match in isolation. But it all matters, and if you pay attention, you are invariably punished. The match wasn't worked particularly well enough to allow you to switch off and get swept up. It was hard, for example, to bemoan the state of tag team wrestling in WWE when the New Day and the Street Profits stole the show.
An unfocused and forgettable match, the quality and excitement heightened considerably when Bianca Belair realised her athletic doyen persona wonderfully in the closing stretch. She looked awesome.
And then she was counted out to enable the sight gag that was Lana, passenger, standing victorious having done nothing.
Good.
Good babyface characteristic.
You know, AEW gets sh*t for its treatment of women, but WWE would never dream of booking a finish like this in a men's match.
Star Rating: ★★¼
1. Roman Reigns Vs. Drew McIntyre
It would be churlish to say this was worthless, or not "good".
It was a good match. Both Roman Reigns and Drew McIntyre worked really hard and hit each other harder. And when that finish arrived, they exploded into one another with conviction and, somehow, amid a ThunderDome atmosphere that gets sh*ttier by the week, a not inconsiderable electricity.
But Jesus Christ did it take an eternity to get there.
At times, this was a parody of a Big WWE Match. It was slow. It was slow because that way, you know to take it seriously. You know it to be epic, if the wrestlers laboriously exchange holds and skulk around the ring giving each other the cagey side-eye. You know them to be very powerful, when they writhe around in agony during the middle phase.
The finish saw Michael Hayes run through his list of main event tropes in a transparent bid to get it over as a WWE main event. Finishers were kicked out of. Twice. The barricade was broken. And so too - of course - was the announce table. This was a grunting, portentous and drab match that had zero personality of its own. Between content and pacing and set-pieces, it was indistinguishable to every modern WWE main event.
A very well-worked - but wholly uninspiring - show-closer. And if that reads as harsh, you need to ask yourself why this company hasn't grown in years and years and years.
It might be because this in-house style has long become a cliché.
Star Rating: ★★★