7 Most Notorious Randy Savage Urban Legends

Did he and Hogan really make up before his death?

For years, pro wrestling fans around the world wanted to see 'Macho Man' Randy Savage inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame. The legendary grappler was someone many argued was a huge omission from the annual ceremony. One of the best-remembered stars from his generation, Savage was also a sterling in-ring performer. In 2015, people finally got their wish, with Hulk Hogan posthumously inducting Savage into the WWE Hall Of Fame. An interesting choice, because there had long been rumours of a love/hate relationship between both men. In fact, proposed issues between the pair have been a talking point in the wrestling industry since the 1980's, and there have been many (often wildly different) stories about their arguments and friendship. Issues with Hulk Hogan aren't the only question marks hanging over the life and career of Randy Savage. The man had a storied, lengthy tenure in the wrestling business, so it's only natural that he left some mystery behind. Savage wasn't one for doing many media interviews once he stepped away from the ring, either, so there's been a lot of debate over the validity of any urban legends. This article aims to explore some of the most notable urban legends from the career of Savage, examining whether or not there's any credence to them.

7. He Hated WWF System After 1987 Incident With His Father

Story: In 1987, Randy Savage was riding high as the 'Macho Man'. Given that he was one of the bigger stars on the roster, Savage felt that he had some sway behind the scenes. Officials had mentioned to him that they were running a Battle Royal on an upcoming house show, one which would feature top names from years gone by. After discussing this fact with Angelo Poffo, Savage was excited when he learned his father would be interested in working the bout. Randy would be on the same show, and he dearly wanted to give Angelo one last big hurrah with his buddies in the ring. Broaching the subject with WWE officials, Savage was angered by their negative response. Poffo didn't work the Battle Royal, and Randy held a grudge against the company from that day on. Why People Believe It: This is something that's been mentioned by several sources. Randy's brother, Lanny Poffo, has made mention of it on numerous occasions. The idea of heat between Randy Savage and the WWF had also been reported in many different articles and books, including the exceptionally well-researched Titan Sinking. Should We Believe It: Yes, there's a good chance that this one has some truth to it. Randy was fiercely loyal to his father, so he was likely upset that the WWF wouldn't even allow this simple little gesture towards his family. There would be no reason to exclude Angelo, because the match was happening on a non-televised live event anyway. Randy likely just took it as a slight against his father and his family.

6. He Drunkenly Called Vince McMahon Over WWF Tenure

Story: Late-1994 marked a significant shift in the career of Randy Savage. Since 1992, Vince McMahon had expressed an interest in making Savage more of an ambassador for the WWF, rather than a full-time member of the wrestling crew. This didn't sit well with the wrestler himself, who still believed he had a lot to offer the company as an in-ring performer. Things came to a head when Savage's contract with the WWF ran out in late-October. Unable to come to terms on a new deal, he elected to sign with rivals World Championship Wrestling. One evening, he phoned Vince whilst under the influence of alcohol and basically verbally tore into him. Savage wasn't happy with how he had been presented, used more often as an announcer rather than a wrestler. This is one rumour often tagged along with others as to why McMahon had such disregard for Savage after he left the promotion. Why People Believe It: It's fairly easy to imagine that someone as proud as Randy Savage had issues with effectively being put out to pasture by the WWF. If WCW were offering Savage the chance to work as an actual wrestler (for big money), the man would have been afforded some peace of mind that tearing into McMahon wouldn't affect his immediate career prospects. Should We Believe It: It's tough to say whether this is true or not. If it is, McMahon didn't sell the supposed call on television. During a November episode of Monday Night Raw, he wished Savage all the very best in the future and remarked that he was one of the best performers the WWF had ever witnessed. It's hard to picture him doing that if he had received such a phone call.

5. He Would Keep Elizabeth Under Lock And Key

Story: Aware of leering eyes behind the curtain, Randy Savage tried his best to keep Miss Elizabeth away from other wrestlers. Taking things one step further, Savage would instruct Elizabeth not to leave his private locker room during his matches. In other words, his wife and lover was a prisoner, constantly under instruction from Randy not to socialise with anyone else in the company. Taking things to an even more extreme level, Elizabeth wasn't really allowed out when back home. This didn't sit well with many friends of the couple, who felt Savage was more than a little controlling over her. The woman was clearly beautiful, but Randy's domineering personality served to wreck their relationship, more than keep Elizabeth by his side. Why People Believe It: This is a common legend, one backed up by many others who were around the couple in the WWF. Everyone from Hulk Hogan to 'Mean' Gene Okerlund has stated that Savage did indeed keep Elizabeth under lock and key. Hogan even once told that Elizabeth came to his own family home, asking to stay with them to get away from Savage's intense scrutiny. Should We Believe It: There's at least some truth to this, but it's obviously all conjecture. Who can say for what sure happened in their own home, but it's difficult to imagine that everybody who has commented on Elizabeth being shut away at WWF events can be fabricating the story.

4. Savage Wasn't Supposed To Win WWE Title At WrestleMania IV

Story: At WrestleMania IV, 'Macho Man' Randy Savage captured the WWF Heavyweight Title for the very first time. An interminable 14-man tournament had been held. but was capped off with a memorable coronation of Savage to end the show. Fans hadn't really reacted to many of the bouts in the tournament, but they sure went nuts when Randy defeated Ted DiBiase to bag the gold. As it turns out, this wasn't always the plan. The first draft for 'Mania called for DiBiase to leave with his hand raised as champion. From there, the 'Million Dollar Man' would engage in a feud against Hulk Hogan. For his part, Savage was supposed to face The Honky Tonk Man for the WWF Intercontinental Title. Those plans were shelved when Honky refused to lose to Randy. Why People Believe It: It would have made sense for DiBiase to win the belt and face Hogan at a later date. Earlier in 1988, Andre The Giant had seemingly won the title from Hogan only so he could hand it to Ted. The subsequent tournament was a result of the WWF Title being vacated by management. Should We Believe It: There's a decent chance DiBiase was initially considered for the top prize, but nobody can have any arguments against the idea that Randy Savage would make a fine champion. As for Honky Tonk Man refusing to lose to Savage, that's a little harder to swallow. At SummerSlam later that year, Honky lost to The Ultimate Warrior in just over 30 seconds. Why would he agree to that, yet balk at the idea of putting Savage over?

3. He Was Supposed To Return To The WWF In 1997

Story: By 1997, the WWF were interested in pushing back at WCW and attempting to reclaim the top spot in North American wrestling. Part of the plan was to bring back Randy Savage, and there were also rumours of a potential jump for Hulk Hogan at the time. This is something which must have given Eric Bischoff a few sleepless nights, fretting about any potential deals. It's unclear what spot Savage would have held in the WWF of 1997. Questions must have remained over Vince McMahon's interest in pushing him to the top, but this was a heavily circulated story around the wrestling world at the time. Later in 1999, the same story would pop up. Both times, Savage elected to stay with WCW, but 1999 would mark his last appearance for either company. Why People Believe It: Vince McMahon has often conducted business with people he has bitterly fallen out with in the past. When there's money to be made, McMahon is interested. Therefore, it's plausible that he could have considered Randy Savage coming back to the WWF. After all, The Ultimate Warrior had made a short-lived return in 1996, and he had left on extremely bad terms in 1992 (and would again in 96). Should We Believe It: Given the fact that Vince McMahon was frosty when the name of Randy Savage was even brought up in production meetings, it's hard to foresee him green-lighting, let alone pursuing, any deal. Savage had a critically-acclaimed feud opposite Diamond Dallas Page in 1997 and was making top money as a member of the nWo, so there's a good chance he was happy in WCW.

2. He Made Up With Hulk Hogan Before His Death

Story: There's long been rumours of a love/hate relationship between Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan. For some, both men only saw eye to eye when they were making money together. When they weren't, friction levels would skyrocket. As far back as the 1980's, Savage felt that Hogan was poking his nose in where it didn't belong with regards to his relationship with Elizabeth. It seems as though there was an eternal battle between both guys. Savage, as the slightly smaller man, wanted to prove that he was every bit as big a star as Hulk. A few months before Savage sadly passed away in 2011, he and Hogan apparently bumped into one another at a doctor's office. During the meeting, they buried a longstanding hatchet, something which proved more poignant after Randy tragically died of cardiac arrest at the wheel of his car a short time later. Why People Believe It: Lanny Poffo and Hogan have spoken about this. According to Hogan, the meeting at the doctor's got rid of any longstanding heat and Hogan had planned to reconnect with Randy further, telling WWE.com that:
We talked on the phone a couple of times. I invited him over to have a barbeque, and really got back on track, which was cool. Later, I was with Lanny, his brother, at an independent wrestling show. He told me their mom wasn't doing so well with Angelo passing away. So we had planned on having a barbeque at her house €” because I got along well with Randy's mom €” and try to cheer her up. So, Lanny and I called Randy from the arena. Three days later, he had the heart attack. It was crazy.
Should We Believe It: It's admittedly doubtful that things happened so amicably, but Savage seemed to change as a man once he left the pro-wrestling world behind. Perhaps he thought it was time to let bygones be bygones and really wanted to mend fences with his former friend. Hogan certainly seemed like he wanted to as the instigator and it's doubtful that Lanny/WWE would allow him to posthumously induct Randy into the Hall of Fame, had Randy died with the two on bad terms.

1. Savage Had An Affair With A Young Stephanie McMahon

Story: As one of the biggest stars in the whole of the WWF, Randy Savage was often permitted to stay at the McMahon family home. A trusted member of the roster, he was almost like a son to Vince McMahon. It wasn't uncommon for Vince to play father figure to his wrestlers, and he was reportedly very close to Savage. At first, it seemed that McMahon was willing to accept that Randy had decided to depart the WWF and sign for WCW. His spiel on Raw, during which he wished Savage all the best, proves this. Later, McMahon would refuse to bring the wrestler's name up. This massive change confused many, but there have long been rumours that Vince's hatred was born out of him finding out about a romantic relationship between Savage and his daughter Stephanie. Why People Believe It: This is one of the most infamous urban legends in all of pro wrestling. Vince's sudden shift in attitude towards Randy Savage does seem a little weird. After all, why would he suddenly become angry at the man for something (a move to WCW) which he had seemingly already accepted? Then there was a video that did the rounds online in the early 2000s with an in-character Savage cutting a promo and threatening Triple H that he would take his girl, mentioning Stephanie by name. This only added fuel to the fire. Should We Believe It: Without concrete proof, it seems this one will never be solved. It's unlikely that either Vince McMahon or Stephanie is going to come out and address any rumours at this point. Lanny Poffo has said that he believes a romantic relationship did happen, but the answers can only really come from Stephanie or Randy himself. Obviously, due to Savage's death, that's not going to happen. Stephanie certainly isn't going to come out and confirm or deny, so this one looks set to live on in IWC infamy. What other Randy Savage urban legends do you know? What do you make of the ones listed here? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!
Also, be sure to check out our brand new eBook €˜100 Worst Wrestling Moments Of 2015 €“ How Pro Wrestling Lost Over 25% Of Its Audience In 12 Months€˜, written by WhatCulture.com author Andrew Soucek (writer of the weekly Worst Wrestling Moments Of The Week column!) by clicking the picture below. Priced only £2.99

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.