7 Ups & 2 Downs From ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022

Claudio Castagnoli wins; ROH showcases tag-team wrestling; Tony Khan has a decision to make.

William Regal Claudio Castagnoli Wheeler Yuta ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Tony Khan has a decision to make on Ring Of Honor.

Yes, Death Before Dishonor 2022 was a fantastic wrestling pay-per-view (the 'Ups' count makes that clear) and the brand has been brought back to life with a bang. However, it remains to be seen whether or not ROH can survive on scraps fed via segments on regular AEW programming like Dynamite and Rampage.

The promotion may need its own TV show sooner rather than later, especially if Khan wants to make this an ongoing concern. For now though, Tony can pour himself a nice cold drink, sit back in his chair and declare Dishonor a rip-roaring success that was stuffed full of excellent matches.

New champions were crowned, everybody worked incredibly hard and fans inside the Tsongas Center were definitely thrilled to see Honor alive and kicking again. A few tweaks here or there, including dropping at least one bout from the card, would've made it a near-perfect show.

Of course, few wrestling events are completely flawless, and Death Before Dishonor was no different. Some key moments fell a little flat, but there was enough elsewhere to ensure that everybody went home happy.

Here's all the good and bad from a memorable night.


Downs...

2. They Couldn’t Overcome Sh*t Build

Mercedes Martinez Serena Deeb ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

First, only two downers.

AEW's on/off tag-team partner storyline between Mercedes Martinez and Serena Deeb knackered the pair's build towards this ROH Women's Title match. Both went for an epic feel, and they definitely worked hard, but things fell a tad flat when it mattered most.

Honestly, you'll see better than this elsewhere. Length doesn't automatically = greatness (more on that later). Some fans might not agree with that analysis, which is fine, and it's cool if you enjoyed this one - however, the main meat of the bout did little for this guy.

The middle section, which is always crucial, was rather boring in parts. Fans also struggled to stay invested throughout, and they seemed happier that the match was over rather than truly leaping out of their seats for the finish. Again, Martinez and Deeb worked hard, but this was defo one of the weaker outings on show.


1. A Match That Could’ve Been Cut

Dalton Castle The Boys ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Right, confession time: The guy writing this piece isn't exactly sweet on the idea of Six-Man Tag Titles generally. They just seem like an unnecessary addition to most promotions that have them outside of Japan, and ROH is no exception. "Unnecessary addition" could sum this particular match up too.

It was clear 'let-me-up' fare.

Whilst there was nothing wrong with The Righteous vs. Dalton Castle and The Boys, this was Death Before Dishonor's popcorn match. In other words, it came out looking like something that should've been on the pre-show rather than a featured act on pay-per-view.

90% of the thing was skippable; the live crowd kinda snoozed through it until Dutch's dive spot, and then went back to sleep after that moment. Watch it for Dalton's flashy entrance, then fast forward through until the finish.

Khan could've cut this one easily.


Ups...

7. Brothers Deliver

Rush Dragon Lee ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

F*cking hell, this was a statement from Rush and Dragon Lee.

They kicked off their brotherly battle with some chain wrestling and a healthy amount of respect, but things broke down once Rush started to show more aggression. Lee met him halfway by lawn-darting his bro through a table at ringside, and then things got even better from there.

Fans were hooked by the time Rush hit a belly-to-belly off the ring apron that legitimately looked like it knocked Dragon out cold. Perhaps the only criticism, and it's a mild one, is that both could've sold some of the bigger bumps a little longer. That's a general gripe with modern wrasslin' more than anything though.

There's no way Tony Khan watched this and wasn't impressed by what he was seeing. AEW's roster is obviously stacked, but Lee deserves a look in soon. Rush didn't do his own chances of succeeding alongside Andrade El Idolo any harm either.


6. That Pre-Bell Violence

Jay Lethal Samoa Joe ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Credit goes to Jay Lethal and Samoa Joe for finding a way to heap sympathy on the Samoan. That's hardly easy, because it's a challenge to convince fans that Joe is genuinely in peril or might not be able to fight his way back. Having the reigning ROH TV Champ brawl from underneath here was smart.

Lethal wrapped a steel chair around Joe's arm and rammed him into the steel post before the bell had even sounded. That, once both men were inside the ring, forced the referee to eject Satnam Singh from ringside so the actual match was strictly one-on-one.

Again, clever.

Who knows where Joe goes with the TV Title in the future, but having him hold one of the undercard belts adds instant credibility to Ring Of Honor. Also, that belt shot near fall tricked everybody in attendance, and was one of the night's most convincing false finishes.


5. The Right Decision

Wheeler Yuta William Regal ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Being frank, Daniel Garcia couldn't really win the ROH Pure Title without AEW then killing off the strap on Dynamite or Rampage. The JAS member made it clear that he planned to trash the thing if he was able to prize it from Wheeler Yuta on Saturday night.

It's a good thing that Yuta retained, because the belt suits William Regal's Blackpool Combat Club better and gives Wheeler some credibility. On that, Regal made it clear via guest commentary that he didn't want to see the Club's youngest member use any rope breaks during his title defence - what a fun sub-story this was.

Speaking of which, having Josh Woods (the man Wheeler beat for the Pure Title) as one of the judges added yet more intrigue to the bout. The entire package, from Regal on comms to Woods keeping an eye on things, was sensationally presented.

Check out that submission trade-off and reversal-fest at the 13-minute mark for some of the best wrestling you'll see all year.


4. Daniel Garcia Says ‘F*ck You, ROH!’

Wheeler Yuta Daniel Garcia ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Then, post-match, Garcia flipped Yuta off.

He didn't stop there either. The Jericho Appreciation Society hard nut stuck a middle finger up at the ROH logo on the big screens when he was walking back down the aisle, and he held the double bird up long enough that cameras couldn't fail to catch his show of disrespect.

This was stunning character work from someone who truly gets it. Something this simple did more to sell Dan's gimmick than anything All Elite has done recently; if that sounds harsh, then consider that Garcia has been a bit-part player in recent brawls between Chris Jericho and Eddie Kingston.

AEW could keep this running into the next ROH pay-per-view. Imagine the uproar if Jericho himself brought the gang to a show and held it hostage, or trashed ideas like the Pure Championship. JAS would have a blast if they disparaged serious pro wrestling and flaunted sports entertainment.


3. A Predictably Magic Slow-Burner

FTR The Briscoes ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Nobody who bought Death Before Dishonor on pay-per-view went in thinking the '2 Out Of 3 Falls' match between FTR and The Briscoes would be anything other than special. The good news? It lived up to the hype, but only if you were willing to properly sit down, turn off your phone and invest.

Being fair, it took some attention span to stomach a 43-minute bout after such a lengthy card. Tag-team wrestling, when it's done the FTR way, is absolutely mesmerising though. Both sides started with a slower pace that gradually built towards a bump-filled crescendo of tables, blood and brawling.

Kudos to Ian Riccaboni and Caprice Coleman (who were superb all night) for putting over the importance of that first fall too. The fact it was The Briscoes who scored it gave the announcers cause to wonder aloud if Cash Wheeler and Dax Harwood had met their match.

This was the right main event.


2. Opening With The Big One

ROH World Title Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Meanwhile, the ROH World Title showdown opened the main card.

OK, few could've predicted that this would happen, and it was honestly kinda cool. Sure, some traditionalists will sigh a heavy sigh and remark that the World Championship should always go on last, but...what a striking way to kick off the actual pay-per-view this was.

Khan turned typical PPV formatting on its head and added a little bit of unpredictability to the ROH product with one masterstroke of his pen. On commentary, Riccaboni explained that Jonathan Gresham vs. Claudio Castagnoli was opening Death Before Dishonor because of a backstage coin toss earlier in the day.

Fair enough - it was nice to have that context.

Fans didn't think Claudio's music would hit first after the hype-filled 'we're live now' intro. The Swiss star's entrance electrified people and helped make ROH's comeback supercard feel like it was going to be newsworthy straight away.


1. Claudio Castagnoli = World Champion

Claudio Castagnoli ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022
ROH

Then, Castagnoli won the big one.

Man, it feels good to type this: Claudio Castagnoli is ROH World Champion, and he should be for a very long time. This was another solid call after Gresham's 224-day reign. AEW boss Khan had to start this new ROH era off with something notable, and Claudio clutching the brand's biggest prize was the ideal way to go about that.

Yes, Jonathan carried the belt with distinction during ROH's downtime (and did so across multiple promotions), but Castagnoli is the big star that the title needs right now. It was so, so, so sweet to see William Regal looking on like a proud father afterwards too.

Moments like this one vindicate the former Cesaro's decision to leave WWE behind in February. Now, the next challenge will be ensuring that Castagnoli uses his title win as a springboard to even more greatness on AEW's main shows.

What did you think of ROH Death Before Dishonor 2022? For more wrestling, check out 3 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE SmackDown (July 22) and 5 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Rampage (July 22)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.