7 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (1 Sep)
CM Punk gets physical, FTR and Santana & Ortiz settle their beef, Anna Jay returns, and more.
AEW's three-show run in Chicago, Illinois kicked off with last night's episode of Dynamite, which was more in line with what fans have come to expect from the Wednesday night flagship than the previous misfiring episode.
The problems didn't vanish completely. This was a good All Out go-home show rather than a great one, featuring a handful of harmful tropes and heat angles that didn't land the way AEW had intended. A shame, as the ingredients were there for a night worthy of the pay-per-view's hype, but this wasn't the pulsating, energetic adrenaline factory the best episodes of Dynamite tend to be.
While CM Punk didn't wrestle last night, he ended up getting physical for the first time on wrestling television in over seven years, dirtying his hands (and knee) ahead of his All Out clash with Darby Allin. Punk's hometown crowd witnessed this and a number of other big angles, including Chris Jericho and MJF's final verbal flurries before their Final Fight at the pay-per-view.
Match-wise, an eight-man tag pitting The Elite against Jurassic Express and the Lucha Brothers took top billing on a card featuring such grudge-settlers as FTR vs. Santana and Ortiz, Powerhouse Hobbs vs. Brian Cage, and more.
Let's light the fuse.
Downs...
3. The Giant, Felled
Billy Gunn turning heel on Paul Wight could have been cut and pasted from a 1998 episode of Raw. It was a big misread on AEW's behalf, because who is really watching this show to watch two ageing WWE veterans working heat angles for a QT Marshall feud?
Are we getting Paul Wight vs. heel Billy Gunn on television now?
A segment that started with QT and some of his Nightmare Factory trainees offering Wight a fight saw the former Big Show march down, throw hands, and find support in Gunn Club, who stood by him at first. Billy attacking Wight with a chair inspired shock in Marshall, who hit the ring to pick the bones after the Gunns were done.
It's a bad look for AEW to book this kind of angle with these specific participants on their main television show. Such content plays straight into the hands of the bad faith actors waiting to jump on this promotion's every decision and in this rare case, the criticism is warranted.
2. An Overlong Rivalry
Extended far beyond its natural point is Orange Cassidy and Best Friends vs. Hardy Family Office, which has been trundling along to minimal returns for weeks now. At least All Out's 10-man tag should mean the end of a rivalry that has already been squeezed dry.
Cassidy and Jack Evans worked an awkward match on Dynamite. Lacking in fluidity while the heel was in control, it came to life through Orange's comebacks but rarely for a prolonged period, as Freshly Squeezed fought back from Matt Hardy jumping him before the bell, resulting in Bryce sending away.
A supplemental Up, at least, for the decision to end this during the picture-in-picture break. This was overdue. AEW needed to establish that important things can happen during these spells to stop the viewers' attention from drifting, which was accomplished here. A precedent has now been set.
1. Heat Turns Cold
Overlong and overcooked, the big heat angle that closed Dynamite didn't hit the desired level.
On the positive side, this was an effective way of establishing that nobody is getting inside the steel cage when The Young Bucks face The Lucha Brothers this weekend. A horde of babyfaces, from Marko Stunt to Frank Kazarian, tried to get in the structure after it descended upon The Elite and Christian Cage. When they were repelled, AEW told you that All Out will avoid the tiresome trope of wrestlers flooding into a match that's supposedly custom-built to keep them away - which often happens in that other promotion.
But the angle was too long, too tongue-in-cheek, and leaned too heavily on Kenny Omega's attempts at drawing meta heat to work.
Omega wasn't entirely convincing while directing traffic here. He was on the microphone, calling the shots for the duration, commentating his squad as they beat Christian down in what was likely designed to conjure building-shaking jeers in Chicago. It didn't, though. At least on television, the reactions were muted and mumbled, not roared. There was a clear gulf between the idea and the execution - and it came off poorly and to the detriment of this well-built storyline.
Ups...
7. Interview Economy
AEW's myriad 60-second backstage interviews don't usually make it into the Ups and Downs column, as we'd end up with a 20-entry article every week, but Britt Baker deserves extra props for cramming so many things into her window of opportunity last night.
Here's what she covered:-
1. Rebel and Jamie Hayter's participation in the Casino Battle Royale.
2. Negging Rebel by suggesting she doesn't have a chance of winning.
3. Insisting that Hayter would never turn on her, foreshadowing just that later down the line. Much later, most likely.
4. Teasing Adam Cole by saying a big-name free agent had signed a contract.
5. Revealing that "free agent" to be herself, breaking the news that she had inked a new deal.
6. Booking Kris Statlander vs. Rebel and Hayter for Rampage.
The handicap match is the only concern here, as there's no ideal outcome ahead of All Out (Hayter won't take the pin, but why put an L on her record so early on). Regardless, this was economical and well-delivered.
6. Return Of The Queenslayer
That the opening stages of Tay Conti vs. Penelope Ford were met with near-silence is a failure on the company's behalf. AEW, unfortunately, haven't invested enough time into getting these people (and the rest of the division) over as personalities. Britt Baker is the notable exception, as her crowd responses prove, but we see it every week now. What the scene needs more than anything else are well-defined characters with clear hooks developed through storylines, promos, and angles.
Conti and Ford overcame this in a similar way to Kris Statlander and Nyla Rose a few weeks ago. Like last night's combatants, Rose and Statlander stirred a quiet audience to life through good, well-plotted work, and that was the case here too.
The match had a handful of clunky moments but still nowhere near enough to sully it, with Conti fired up after Ford and The Bunny laid her out on Rampage. She worked Ford's knee, making a late-match gutbuster ineffective, and helped draw "this is awesome!" chants from a previously disinterested Chicago. That's a sign of quality work - and an objective Up.
A supplemental Up, too, for Anna Jay's comeback. The 23-year-old cleared the ring to save Conti when Bunny and Ford swarmed after the bell. It's good to see her back after seven months on the shelf, with a tag match now likely between the two sides.
5. Roughouse Powerhouse
"Beef" was the keyword as Powerhouse Hobbs faced Brian Cage - in both senses. The two are feuding as part of Team Taz's wider rivalry with the former FTW World Champion and yes, they are both gigantic human beings. This meant their bout was a pec-slapping good time worked at a different pace to everything else on the card.
This was a game of contrasts. Hobbs is capable of spectacular offense, regularly throwing opponents around like empty tracksuits, but played a slower game here. The Powerhouse wore Cage down to prevent him from utilising his sprightlier, more athletic moveset. This negated Brian's agility and speed advantages and made for a more compelling story. Styles make fights, and this worked as a clash.
Town Business put Cage away for Hobbs after interference from Hook and Ricky Starks, who smacked Brian with the belt while Rick Knox was distracted. Irritating, given AEW's recent over-reliance on such finishes, but it at least fits the story as a near-direct repeated of how Team Taz screwed Cage out of the group in the first place.
4. Santana & Ortiz Settle The Score
FTR vs. Santana and Ortiz II was much improved on their first outing. This is largely down to the simple fact that Cash Wheeler didn't slice his arm open this time around, of course, but the bout had more intensity and cohesion from the first bell too.
Cash and Dax hit the ring in Midnight Express tribute attire as a nod to the dearly departed Bobby Eaton. they gave up the notion of tying up and working for parity early on, with the bout devolving into a brawl after a few minutes - which you knew was going to happen from the moment the Inner Circle men came out in Dead Presidents face paint. This opened things up for Proud and Powerful to take flight with dives, springboards, and sentons, before settling down for FTR's control segment.
The match cooled off significantly during this portion but riled back up for the finish. With Harwood isolated outside, the injured Wheeler was left to the wolves, eating the pin after a combination suplex.
Wheeler sold and protected his injured arm well from bell to bell, doing everything he could to prevent further damage. FTR were clever, too, in going for revenge on Santana and Ortiz, trying to destroy their limbs at various points. Both of these could end up feeding into the feud continuing beyond last night.
3. Go To Sleep
CM Punk finally got physical in AEW, delivering his first GTS on American wrestling television in over seven years to put Jeff Parker down while Sting hit a Scorpion Death Drop across the ring.
This was the biggest talking point coming out of a hot segment that began with another Punk victory lap promo. 2point0 and Daniel Garcia jumped him early, beating him down until Sting and Darby Allin made the save, with violence soon following.
Sting broke Darby and Punk's nose-to-nose after the bell. Happy to finally share a room with the returnee, he confirmed that he won't be ringside at All Out, content to let the wrestlers wrestle and stay out of the way. Here's hoping he locks 2point0 and Garcia in their locker rooms.
A simple angle executed well for a hot crowd, this broke up Punk's promo loop, gave the match some extra spice, and made perfect sense given Punk's existing beef with the invading heels.
2. Final Shots For The Final Fight
MJF and Chris Jericho were both magnificent in their pre-All Out promos, teed up by Tony Schiavone and Jim Ross respectively.
Jericho took Ross' setup and ran with it, cutting the kind of riled-up diatribe we've come to expect from him in this babyface run. He plays the ageing gunslinger's role well, putting over that while he's aware this could be the beginning of the end of his time in the ring, he doesn't want to stop. His ego won't let him step away forever. He's Chris Jericho, MJF doesn't have the balls to get rid of him, and JR, willing tears from his eyes to get the angle over, deserves special credit here too.
MJF, somehow, was on a different level. This was one of the best promos of his AEW career thus far not only for the excellent delivery, but the content as well. Comparing Jericho to Ali (who thought he was the GOAT one or two times too many, turning his "brains into scrambled eggs"), he attacked the Inner Circle leader's fragile ego while dispensing with shtick, leaving his catchphrase at home instead of closing on another killer line. When Jericho's career goes dark, the same yearning of the spotlight that brought him to the dance will be the reason his music dies.
Tremendous, A+ stuff from all involved, and an exercise in how to sell a pay-per-view match. The Final Fight now has the heft to live up to its mighty billing.
1. Fireworks In The Main Event
Jurassic Express and Lucha Brothers vs. The Elite wasn't at the upper end of AEW's eyeball-popping multi-man tags, but that's no put-down. These matches have a very, very high floor and an even higher ceiling. They hit hard and fast, layering pops on top of pops with cloudbursts of offense, whirling limbs, and flying bodies because if nothing else, AEW's house style and roster are perfectly calibrated to deliver in this domain.
But yes, the match was great.
Intricate and laced with action, it was a clash of fast-moving paces that refused to waver in pace from the moment Rey Fenix and Nick Jackson tagged in early on. Luchasaurus was more grounded and the Good Brothers more straightforward in their approach, but the primary focus was on giving Fenix, Jungle Boy, and co. a canvas to pump adrenaline all over, though even the beefiest man in the match found room for a late-bout moonsault press.
A questionable decision to have Fenix eat the pin here. Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy aren't involved in featured pay-per-view matches, competing instead on the Buy In, and could have easily absorbed the L. Nonetheless, this is only a minor complaint towards a bout that largely delivered on its promise.