7 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Quake By The Lake (10 Aug)
CM Punk returns, Jon Moxley batters Chris Jericho, Darby Allin drops Brody King's coffin.
Quake by the Lake was a hot mess in great ways and bad.
A wild, unruly maelstrom of a show, AEW's latest Dynamite special was pure chaos from start to finish. The energy was through the roof at times. Buoyed by a vocal Minneapolis crowd, Tony Khan's promotion delivered two fast-moving hours of television that lagged only for a few fleeting moments that did little to hinder the ride's incredible, boisterous buzz.
Khan's pre-show Twitter teases suggested a big angle was to go down last night. He delivered a full-on CM Punk comeback just over two months after the AEW World Champion was shelved through injury, potentially setting the All Out main event in the process.
This came following the headlining title fight between interim kingpin Jon Moxley and Chris Jericho, for which the challenger reprised his 'Lionheart' person, crawling out of the Hart Dungeon one last time. Elsewhere, Brody King and Darby Allin settled their bloody beef in a coffin match, Jade Cargill put the TBS Championship up against Madison Rayne, and Rush and Andrade El Idolo finally got their tornado tag with the Lucha Brothers.
A frankly mental show. Where to begin?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
4. Luchasaurus' Unnecessary Squash
Last night's Christian Cage vs. Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy developments felt insubstantial, doing little, if anything, to advance the story.
Luchasaurus destroyed the far-too-good-for-this-role Anthony Henry in a quick, decisive, and impactful squash. Watching on from backstage, Cage, turtleneck and all, said that he would come out and slap Jungle Boy up but the people of Minneapolis didn't deserve to see it. When Jungle Boy ran to the back to jump cage, security stepped in until Luchasaurus beat them up. Pat Buck ate a headbutt.
AEW's attempts at delaying the gratification of Jungle Boy finally getting his hands on Christian continue, though this was more of a reminder of the feud's existence than a development. We've seen plenty of this already.
3. Backstage Melodrama
Fundamentally, this was a good idea.
The Young Bucks need a third man for the Trios Tournament. 'Hangman' Adam Page saved them last week and Matt Jackson had been trying to leap the mental hurdle of trying to reach out to their former stablemate before that anyway. This is one of the most detail-rich long-running stories that AEW has ever told on, many, many levels, and the Bucks swallowing their pride, apologising for how they'd treated Page over the years, and extending their olive branch was always happening.
Page's way of saying "no" was what it needed to be, too. The Dark Order were there for him in his attempts at becoming World Champion, so he was going to be there for them in the tournament. Sorry, Bucks.
All of this sets up Kenny Omega's return. He'll be the Bucks' third man in the tournament leading to a potential finals clash with the Dark Order, which will play heavily on incredibly complex character dynamics. The storytelling is fantastic, genuinely.
But the execution? Not so good.
After last week's Undisputed Elite breakup landed with around half the heft it should have, this backstage segment featured a wrestler who isn't comfortable delivering lengthy exposition doing just that. Matt Jackson is not a backstage actor. He's part of a phenomenal modern wrestling storyline and has been pivotal to that, but this segment opposed the idea of hiding weaknesses and highlighting strengths. Shaky in his delivery and seemingly nervous beyond his character, this performance, unfortunately, made for an amateurish segment.
Most wrestlers can't act. But if Elite-brand melodrama is coming back, the segments must be of a higher calibre.
2. Ricky Starks... Runs Away?
Booking Ricky Starks vs. Aaron Solo was a fun nod to the former partners' past. Their shared history as Extra Talent-ed came into play through a backstage segment last week, with The Factory accosting Starks, trying to recruit him. This led to last night's match being booked.
And it was good. Starks was over as a babyface, commanding chants as he fought Solo's scouting and his Factory stablemates' skullduggery, eventually scoring the pinfall through an excellent finish. Solo had done enough homework to dodge the first spear but Ricky came right back, hit the ropes again, and blasted him.
The post-match, unfortunately, portrayed neither Starks nor new feud partner Powerhouse Hobbs in a flattering light.
Ricky literally ran away from The Factory, AEW's designated undercard enhancement stable. He was able to neutralise Nick Comoroto and Solo by throwing them into each other, then slipped away from QT Marshall and Anthony Ogogo, dashing up the bleachers. Meanwhile, a flustered Hobbs pulled a television off the wall backstage.
'Absolute' can't believably take on four men, particularly when one of those men, Ogogo, demands a degree of protection. Nonetheless, although he saved his hide, having Ricky flee a group of wrestlers that only ever wins on YouTube was a terrible look following his red-hot face turn. Hobbs, meanwhile, looks toothless. The situation demanded another Powerhouse beatdown, rather than the big man standing around helplessly.
1. TBS Title Fight Underwhelms
Pairing Jade Cargill vs. Madison Raynes was a good idea. Rayne's primary AEW function will be to coach the women's division. Jade exudes incredible star qualities but is still putting it together between the ropes, so she stands to benefit from working with the TNA veteran, who faced Leila Grey in her first AEW match last week.
Their match was hindered by clumsy execution, though. This was often on Rayne's end. One particularly awkward moment came with an attempted flipping neckbreaker from Madison, who either mistimed or dive or had to execute it on an out-of-place Cargill. This drew the dreaded "didn't get all of it" from the commentators and was far from the only clunky exchange in a bout that ultimately underwhelmed.
It's a shame, because the layout generated doubt in the outcome and some of Rayne's counters to Jade's biggest bombs were well worked. Nonetheless, Jade won and moved on to Athena, who ran the TBS Champion off after the bell, having disguised herself as a Baddie.
Ups...
7. Big Match Build
It's not rocket science, having your two main event wrestlers cut fantastic promos to hype their match later in the evening, but Jon Moxley and Chris Jericho both delivered down the lens.
Moxley, with trademark intensity, promised to test the last survivor of the Hart Dungeon, saying that if Jericho's spirit didn't break, his body would. This hammered him pulling 'Lionheart' out of his challenger home as the key story beat. Immediately afterwards, Jericho said he was going to put Mox through the kind of pain Stu Hart made him experience in the Dungeon, adding that what he was going to do to the Interim World Champion wouldn't be fixable.
Quick, simple, and effective, these two last-minute promos added to the excitement of the match ahead.
6. Miro Will Destroy You
Miro's direction became clearer at Quake by the Lake, with the former TNT Champion seemingly shunning the House of Black after weeks of teasing.
The Bulgarian claimed he had found Malakai Black's darkness empty. Julia Hart walked in, telling Miro to embrace the "gift." Miro does embrace it, but plans on owning it, using it against the House, and destroying them, setting his new course.
This storyline should now come to life after largely being restricted to Miro's short weekly promos. Miro, Sting, and Darby Allin vs. House of Black would be the most obvious direction, potentially for All Out, with the Malakai/Sting factor represented elsewhere on Dynamite. Beyond that are a number of off-shooting singles bouts, all of which sound appealing.
Particularly Miro vs. Brody King.
5. Odds Evened
FTR's adverted Dynamite comeback manifested in the tag team belt collectors aligning with old Pinnacle buddy Wardlow, assisting the TNT Champion in his ongoing rivalry with Jay Lethal, Sonjay Dutt, and Satnam Singh.
Battle of the Belts III saw Wardlow laid out by the opposing trio's numerical advantage, culminating in the colossal Singh chokeslamming him through a table. He needed an equaliser. So, when Lethal and co. gathered in the ring, calling Wardlow out, he was backed up by FTR. Dax and Cash's music hit after the TNT Champion had promised to whoop the heels' asses there and then, with the faces running the villains off.
FTR have always shown respect for Wardlow, even when the big man was feuding with MJF. This split allegiance prompted them to move away from The Pinnacle in the first place. No tandem could have been more fitting to support Wardlow, who finally has the communication needed to deal with Lethal, Dutt, and Singh.
4. Rush & Andrade Triumph In Absurd Spotfest
An insane, out-of-control spotfest befitting Dynamite's chaotic overall feel, Andrade El Idolo and Rush vs. the Lucha Brothers was joyous.
A runaway train that often threatened to careen off the tracks, but never quite did that, this was a pure adrenaline rush. Spots layered on spots layered on spots was the name of the game. It perhaps wasn't the most intricate Lucha Brothers popcorn-grabber AEW has ever seen, but Andrade and Rush brought a different level of hard-hitting intensity, starching the hard-flipping duo with every shot in a bout that settled into a frantic rhythm from the first bell.
Ostensibly a blank canvas for tough dudes to do cool things, at no moment did it feel like the wrestlers even considered slowing things down. Instead, this was about escalating the pops with every sequence. Bombs were dropped with near-concussive impact, as expected by the participants in this Tornado format.
AEW played with the mask removal trope with the finish. While recent months have seen Rush and Andrade snatch the Lucha Brothers' masks several times, here, Penta willingly sacrificed his to save a pinfall. Rush and Andrade tying him with the ropes left him with no choice. His face exposed, he leapt onto Rush as he covered Fenix following a sitout piledriver, sending the match into its next big peak.
Rush killed Fenix with the Bull's Horns soon after, allowing Andrade to pin Rey to huge heat from the Minneapolis crowd.
3. Blood, Guts & Coffins
Brody King and Darby Allin's coffin match came with the same brutal, bellicose energy as their first AEW encounter and added pro wrestling theatrics to the mix, as it should have.
The opening half was as violent as expected. King was busted open almost immediately, his skin pierced by the tacks on Allin's skateboard. The crimson streaming down his black and white corpse paint made for an incredible visual that lasted the duration of the match, making the House of Black's powerhouse look even more terrifying in his role as the horror movie monster.
King's caveman offense once again looked great against Darby, who bumped like crazy. His chops hit as hard as anything else in the match. For all its smoke and mirrors, Big Bad Brody's big bad assault was one of the bout's most compelling components.
The remainder of the match was pure theatre. The House got involved after cutting the lights, beating Darby down. When Malakai Black opened the coffin, out popped Sting, sporting a black ring around his eye from Malakai's mist. Darby had his pathway back into it - and capitalised by hanging Brody from the apron by his own chain, mirroring the incredible battle royal elimination. Unconscious, the monster toppled down into the casket, the lid shutting on impact.
That's how you kill a monster.
And that's how you deliver a great sequel to a great first match that takes established foundations and builds something new.
2. Hearts On Fire
The ceiling was high for Jon Moxley vs. Chris Jericho, as the 2022 wrestler of the year faced a resurgent veteran whose body might not be as willing as it once was, but is in fantastic, revitalising form himself, having reinvented his career once more.
It hit that ceiling. This was an Interim AEW World Title match fitting the billing, with Moxley tapping his Revolution 2020 opponent out via Bulldog Choke after a long, bloody battle.
Jericho's reprised 'Lionheart' persona meant White Zombie, black and yellow trunks, and diving deep into his bag of tricks with a handful of llave submission holds that Mox didn't know how to deal with. When this gameplan started slipping, Jericho took the more textbook approach of destroying Moxley's knee on the ring post and keeping his target locked on it thereafter. This made Mox particularly susceptible to the Walls of Jericho and Liontamer, both of which came into play.
This was a giving performance from the challenger, too. Moxley got a Judas Effect kickout. A countered Codebreaker from the top rope (made extra impactful for the simple fact that Mox never goes to the top rope, showing his desperation) drew a 2.999-count. The veteran tapped, too, rather than passing out. He more than earned his pay - and justified his position in the match - with a performance on par with his showing opposite Eddie Kingston at Revolution.
Moxley vs. Jericho II was better than the first. Unhindered by the eyeball storyline, it was a gritty struggle of a hard-as-nails babyface gutting it out against a hypocritical opponent more than willing to take shortcuts despite name-dropping Stu Hart.
1. A Monster Pop For A Monster Return
Minneapolis' pop for CM Punk's AEW return hit like a triple espresso first thing in the morning.
It was electric. The kind of angle that puts your heart through your ribcage and your arm hair on end, showing, again, that the most straightforward ideas are often the best ideas in this sport.
The Jericho Appreciation Society had a clear numerical advantage in their post-match beatdown of Moxley, whose help comprised of Blackpool Combat Club, Ortiz, and Eddie Kingston. This set the stage for an equalizer. 'Cult of Personality' hit, the audience members lost their minds, and CM Punk blasted back for the first time in over two months, putting JAS members down on the ramp, clearing the ring of any stragglers, and going nose-to-nose with Mox.
Who raised a middle finger in his face.
Punk added an extra level of detail by hobbling around the ring, selling his recent foot injury. That AEW didn't mess around by waiting to set the tone was appreciated, too. This unification match was inevitable and both men are beloved - but a respectful few weeks heading into a neat, tidy pay-per-view match wouldn't fit their characters.
Defiance does.