7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (28 Feb - Results & Review)

CM Punk chimes in on Cody Rhodes taking The Rock's offer and John Cena no shows WWE SmackDown.

Cody Rhodes WWE Champion
WWE.com

Well, at least WWE didn't take a century to get to the point between The Rock and Cody Rhodes this week. The same couldn't be said for last week's rambling promo between both men. Now for the bad news: It's still unclear whether or not this story is going to satisfy fans heading into WrestleMania 41, or if it'll even have an impact on the main event across either night in Las Vegas.

Time is rapidly running out on that front, but creative will want to put Elimination Chamber in the rearview mirror before painting some of the bigger storytelling strokes on the 'Mania canvas. Friday's episode of SmackDown was all about delivering three things. One, more mental mulling over Rocky's offer from Cody. Two, establishing an official challenger for Shinsuke Nakamura's United States Title. Three, getting you real excited about both Chamber bouts in Toronto.

Success varied there, and WWE even exposed the truth about John Cena's retirement run. He's as part time as part time gets. This was probably always going to happen, but the loudest words should go unsaid unless it's someone like Logan Paul needling 'Super Cena' just because he can.

One glance at the 'Ups' and 'Downs' counts shows that there's still a lot to like about SmackDown despite the pesky third hour that's been added in 2025 and is all over the WWE news. Hopefully, they can do away with that soon and go back to the zippier two hour format. That worked for Fridays better than becoming Raw-lite ever will.

Here's all the good and bad on the final stop before everyone gets locked in those Chamber pods.


Downs...

4. Keep Braun & Carmelo Away From One Another

Braun Strowman Carmelo Hayes Eddie Guerrero Chair Spot
WWE.com

Right, it's become crystal clear that nothing good comes of these guys squaring off. Braun Strowman and Carmelo Hayes had another short match that ended via DQ when the ref bought Melo doing the old Eddie Guerrero steel chair trick. Being fair, that got a rise out of the live crowd, but there wasn't much time to let things digest before WWE motored onto the next segment.

In a regrettable bit of booking, both Tama Tonga and even Solo Sikoa kinda looked like losers after running in and getting smashed by Braun. That's particularly worrying for Sikoa, because he's gone from being presented as a potential equal beside Roman Reigns on Raw's Netflix debut to this sort of fare. Fingers crossed that doesn't mean Triple H has lost interest in pushing the guy or developing his character.

He was a focal point on SmackDown for most of 2024, after all.

Being honest, Braun vs. Melo had nothing to shout about. It was the lame duck of the three one-on-ones pre-Triple Threat in the United States Title chat. Both LA Knight vs. Santos Eacobar and Jacob Fatu vs. Andrade proved vastly superior to Strowman vs. Hayes, but that isn't really on the workers themselves - they weren't given much to work with from the off.

WWE should avoid booking a rematch between these lads. Some combos just have zero chemistry, and this is one of them. Carmelo can't start tagging with The Miz as 'Melo Don't Miz' soon enough. That'll take some of the singles heat off his shoulders and give him some relevancy on the SmackDown roster for the rest of the year.


3. Erm…The Draft/Transfer Window?

CM Punk
WWE.com

So, what was the point in hyping up the Transfer Window if so many wrestlers are appearing on rival brands during WrestleMania season anyway? The timing couldn't have been worse, but this is something WWE does this constantly and it’s irritating. If the brand separation thing doesn’t matter and is a creative nuisance, then scrap it instead of playing pretend every once in a while.

Even Michael Cole showed up on SmackDown, for crying out loud.

He was one of the names included in the Window gimmick. Granted, Cole working an in-ring interview spot with Cody Rhodes on SmackDown isn't the most egregious thing in the world, but it is avoidable. Fellow Raw stars like CM Punk, Sami Zayn, Seth Rollins, Logan Paul and Bayley also showed up to work on Smackers like that had been the plan all along.

Again, what was the value of the Draft and/or Transfer Window then? This should be remembered the next time WWE bangs on about ironclad rosters or seismic brand leaps. Apparently, they just don't matter, but you should totally care about them when the company says you should. That's weak. Either book it properly or don't bother next time, 'cause it's a slap in the face to fans who invest.

Sure, everyone understands that 'Mania season hits different, but at least then have the smarts to book the Transfer Window during a different portion of the year. Why is that so difficult a concept for WWE to grasp?! Their approach is 'Worst Of WCW' levels of stupid, and it needs to stop.


2. CM Punk Said The Word

Logan Paul
WWE.com

Punk called Logan Paul "boring", which kinda summed up the revolving door promo segment heading into the men’s Chamber match. Drew McIntyre, Damian Priest, Seth Rollins, Punk and Paul all put forward their claims to winning. Fair enough, but nobody really said anything of any value and the segment ended with Punk chasing Logan away. That was it.

Meanwhile, Priest and Rollins stood around awkwardly inside the ring and didn't seem sure what to do with themselves. Perhaps the only redeeming quality here was Paul coming out to John Cena’s music and tricking the fans, but that wasn’t enough to save the segment. It is worth mentioning though, because it exposed the untouchable Cena’s retirement tour as the part time gig it is but wasn’t framed as.

Oops.

That'll surely come back up in promos post-Chamber if Cena and Logan are locking horns at 'Mania. If not, then it was a fun insert that almost (aaaaaalmooooost) saved this segment from the trash heap. Sadly, it wasn't nearly enough. Yes, there were some giggles to be had when McIntyre was poking fun at everyone and Punk was trolling everybody in sight (including those who weren't there like Cena), but you've seen this promo train one million times before.

There are only so many times wrestlers can look surprised that they've been interrupted when it happens every other week. Go home episodes before PLEs need something a little more inspiring than this sort of thing. The women's Chamber match build showed the way later. At least it ended with some intrigue.


1. Cody’s Chamber Segment Better Be Big

Cody Rhodes The Rock
WWE.com

One thing's for sure: WWE must have something monumental in store for Elimination Chamber. If not, then it'll be extra confusing that they've let The Rock and Cody Rhodes chew up so much time on TV in recent weeks. Thankfully, Rock got to the point quicker on Friday's episode, but his involvement in the WrestleMania picture is still a bit hazy.

After all, Cody Rhodes is current WWE Champion, has money and status, is about to headline 'Mania for the third year running etc etc. What can The Rock offer him to justify Rhodes being so conflicted about things? Again, as said previously, every story deserves time to shake out, but something feels off about this as things stand. Hopefully, there’s a huge bombshell at Chamber to make things worthwhile.

It'd be understandable if some fans viewed the whole exercise as a drawn out excuse for Rock to come back and force his way into 'Mania plans even when it doesn't make a lick of sense. His “I love you” stuff is hollow after last year’s shenanigans too. He literally beat the hell out of Cody heading into WrestleMania 40, and then he tried to stop him from becoming WWE Champion on night two.

Currently, their plot isn't rewarding those who gobbled up everything WWE had to offer during the road to 'Mania 40, and that's a shame. Rock going overboard with the Dusty material does suggest he's toying with Cody's emotions before something bigger happens though.

Get those fingers and toes crossed.


Ups...

7. No Problems With Any Of This

Trish Stratus Tiffany Stratton Chelsea Green Piper Niven
WWE.com

Getting to work with another featured champ is a positive step for Chelsea Green. Her interminable feud with Michin needs to end, then this is the kind of opponents she needs on a more regular basis. Chelsea's match vs. Tiffany Stratton ended via DQ when Nia Jax and Candice LeRae got involved, but that’s fine - it was simple build for the Elimination Chamber tag involving Trish Stratus, but it also managed to shine Green up a little too.

Nobody should have any arguments with that kind of booking.

Green showed up well on the mic opposite Trish and Tiffy, then she was allowed to look competitive with one of the top female champs before the Nia and Candice stuff took over. It likely bodes well for Chelsea that she wasn't fed to Stratton in a glorified job match. Hopefully her last blow off match vs. Michin satisfies then she can move up the ladder a little.

Green vs. Stratton in a protracted series of champ vs. champ matches actually sounds like it'd work out well post-WrestleMania. That's assuming, of course, that Triple H doesn't get swept up in Charlotte Flair fever like his father in law constantly did. There can't be too many WWE fans who want to see Flair replace Tiffany as Women's Champion.

All in all, this built towards a match on the next PLE and helped give Chelsea a leg up in the division. That should be celebrated by those praying her Women's United States Title run is a game changing moment for her career. Green just needs a reign-defining feud and she'll be fine.


6. BFT Out Of Nowhere

LA Knight Santos Escobar
WWE.com

There was a cool finish to LA Knight vs. Santos Escobar that's worth talking about.

Knight hit a BFT on Santos in mid-air like he was doing his best Randy Orton impersonation. On commentary, Wade Barrett even said that it was "a BFT out of nowhere". Randy's legal team shall be in touch, Mr. Barrett. Seriously though, the finishing bump looked awesome, and it gave Knight's finisher some extra added oomph it otherwise lacks when he hits it normally; BFT isn't one of the best wrestling moves ever, but it worked here.

This singles match might’ve been less exciting without the United States Title thing hanging over it too. It's clear both are capable of better overall, but they entered a workmanlike effort that got the job done and never dipped below watchable. However, Escobar needs something to do character-wise soon. He's been drifting horribly since splitting from Rey Mysterio and the LWO, and that was a lifetime ago.

It's fair to say that Knight vs. Santos was the second best of the three "qualifiers" (if you can even call them that) WWE peppered throughout SmackDown. Another match soared to higher heights than this one could reach. Well, apart from Escobar when he went for something off the top but got caught by the aforementioned BFT goodness.

Knight is the kind of babyface who doesn't need to do much talking every week. Just stick him in matches with purpose like this one and let fans roar his catchphrases as he conducts the orchestra. That US Title will be back around his waist soon enough, it seems.


5. A Fun Enough Six Woman Sprint

Alexa Bliss Roxanne Perez
WWE.com

Unlike the fellas during their Elimination Chamber segment, it's safe to say Roxanne Perez, Raquel Rodriguez and Liv Morgan vs. Bayley, Bianca Belair and Naomi didn’t waste any time. There were a few nice moments sprinkled through a fun sprint: Bianca and Naomi targeted Liv and Raquel over the Jade Cargill stuff, then Perez pinned Bayley with her finish. Post-match, Alexa Bliss hit Roxanne with a Wyatt-esque finish to remind everyone that she's involved on Saturday too.

This wasn't anything that'll convince those sitting on the fence to watch Chamber, but it was a decent little match and better than the guys droning on earlier. Of interest, Bianca quickly echoed suggestions from Bayley during a backstage promo that Morgan and Rodriguez attacked Jade, and Naomi stayed quiet on the subject. WWE has done a really good job of keeping things mysterious regarding this 'whodunit' business.

It's entirely plausible that either Belair or Naomi could turn heel and be outed as the aggressor soon. They're certainly going all in on attacking so-called perpetrators one minute, then dancing around in cute matching outfits the next. Hey, maybe both of them conspired to take Cargill out, then this Liv and Raquel stuff ruined their plans to enjoy a lengthy reign with the Women's Tag straps.

You don't need to go out of your way to watch this six-woman tag from SmackDown, or anything, but stick it on if you're in the mood for something rapid fire that has a few sub-plots hiding beneath the surface. That's always fun.


4. A Tag-Team Tornado

The Street Profits Motor City Machine Guns
WWE.com

Do SmackDown's tag-team division eat and drink at separate catering, or something?! It's like somebody has been feeding these boys up on protein and caffeine, because they've been feisty lately. You've got to love how chaotic and unpredictable the tag ranks have become on Fridays. Nobody is content to just go through the motions and have dull matches or segments.

They're bringing it.

DIY ran in on The Street Profits before their match vs. Los Garza could begin, then Pretty Deadly and Motor City Machine Guns got involved too. A mass brawl ensued as Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett put it over as big and important on comms. Joining in on the hubbub, fans chanted, “LET THEM FIGHT! LET THEM FIGHT! LET THEM FIGHT!” over and over again. It's promising that audiences seem so up for some sort of multi-team scrap heading into WrestleMania.

Deadly, DIY, MCMGs, Garza and The Profits are about to throw down in Vegas, people. Their five-way bout could be a sleeper hit on the 'Mania undercards if it's given enough time on night one or night two. Ideally, someone like PD or Los Garza can win the belts and get their flowers after being overlooked for so long.

The Profits have a mean edge to them that was totally absent even when teaming with Bobby Lashley before his jump from WWE to AEW. Next step: Change up their entrance track to something less joyful. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins deserve the chance to get over as smash-mouth, no nonsense heels.


3. Run An Encore On Fatu & Andrade!

Jacob Fatu Andrade
WWE.com

It was a storyline call, but Jacob Fatu replacing Solo Sikoa in the one-night United States Title contendership sprint at Solo’s request was the right move. Solo still needs some work after failing in his bid to become the only 'Tribal Chief' around these parts, and it's obvious that WWE fans are more into Fatu's style anyway. Suddenly, something magical roared into view.

Jacob replaced Sikoa as Andrade's opponent, and the pair had a tidy match that really needs to get a sequel someday. Honestly, run this back whenever Fatu has a title around his waist and give them 15-20 minutes. That's the best use of Andrade - he hit some seriously sweet moves (including a killer moonsault) to the outside. Then, Fatu took control and ended him to advance to the Triple Threat.

LA Knight vs. Santos Escobar was good for the most part, but nothing was touching Jacob vs. 'El Idolo' in-ring on this week's SmackDown. If Triple H ever rewards wrestlers who have the best and hardest-hitting match of the night after shows, then both these boys will get a tasty little bonus in their bank accounts. They went hell for leather from the opening bell.

The match wasn't a spotfest though. They paced themselves and let the biggest moments breathe before Fatu's rage-filled animal act pushed the pair towards a finish everybody in the arena wanted. It's going to get tougher and tougher to keep Jacob heel if he keeps up this kind of performance.

Fatu is a WWE mega-star in the making.


2. LA Knight Was Always Winning, But…

LA Knight
WWE.com

…WWE's agents did a neat job sowing seeds of doubt with Jacob Fatu’s involvement as a late Solo sub and how good Carmelo Hayes looked during the main event Triple Threat. That's all anyone can reasonably ask for when it's fairly clear who's about to become number one contender. LA Knight had been chasing down Shinsuke Nakamura before Friday's episode of SmackDown, after all.

Sadly, Shinsuke announced via X that a man he considered an older brother (Osamu Nishimura) had passed away before WWE's latest TV made air. Pivoting away from a planned Shin vs. Knight bout, the company gave Nakamura time off to grieve and GM Nick Aldis announced a one-night mini-tournament of sorts to thrash out who'd challenge for the United States Title next. That gave them some breathing room, and it was the right thing to do.

Some things are more important than pro wrestling.

Back to the Triple Threat. Fatu hit his moonsault finish (it'd still be good if WWE came up with something for him, 'cause it's the same finisher Tiffany Stratton uses), then Knight pulled him out of the ring and stole the pinfall. Sure, Knight was probably always winning this one night affair to crown a new number one contender for the United States Title, but we had some fun along the way and Nakamura got time to reflect and mourn.

Fans there live for SmackDown seemed to enjoy following along with the quasi-qualifiers and they popped when LA nabbed Fatu's thunder. That was risky due to Jacob's popularity, but it worked out well.


1. Simple But Effective Build

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Yes, it's a bit annoying that WWE squash their own brand separation so frequently, but even that couldn't stop Sami Zayn's segment with Kevin Owens from stealing the top spot in this week's 'Ups & Downs'. A melancholy Sami came out to address what's coming next in his "Unsanctioned" match with Kev at Elimination Chamber, then he called KO to the ring for a heart to heart.

Screw that, said Owens.

He remarked that he was in Toronto as requested, but not for SmackDown. Instead, KO was at the Rogers Centre ahead of the Chamber show instead. Take a bow, sir. That was peak heel trolling, and it made perfect sense rather than putting Zayn and Owens in the same ring on TV before they brawl. The pair couldn't exactly have a tense conversation in person without coming to blows, and WWE fancied avoiding that.

This was as good as fans were gonna get if they were looking for one final nudge towards Chamber. To their credit, both friends-turned-enemies-turned-friends-turned-enemies were intense without getting too over the top. They also, very much like The Rock finally did near the end of the show, got straight to the point rather than going back and forth on duelling mics for 20 minutes.

There was a sweet moment of realism when Kevin nearly choked as he said, "See you tomorrow". Sami didn't reply. He couldn't. He's so overcome with a toxic mix of rage and regret for a beating that hasn't even happened yet to say much of anything when confronted by Owens. Roll on the "Unsanctioned" war.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 50 Fascinating Facts About WWE in The 1980s and WWE Elimination Chamber 2025: 7 Things That Must Happen!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.