7 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (Oct 10)

Huge returns, average wrestling punctuate 'season premiere' of flagship show.

Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

As far as looking at Monday night’s episode of WWE Raw, the program was a success. Surprise returns continued at a breakneck pace, titles changed hands, the biggest name in the company made a rare appearance, and an iconic faction held a reunion, all on the show’s “season premiere.”

But on the flip side, WWE loaded the show up with a lot of smoke and mirrors to captivate fans. Once you got past the shocking returns of Brock Lesnar and Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows, Seth Rollins winning the United States Championship, D-Generation X’s 25th anniversary and the full Bloodline making an appearance, what was left?

The wrestling was surprisingly average. There were a couple of nice non-wrestling segments too, but there were some real stinkers in here. The concern you’ve got to have as a fan is that while you might have enjoyed Monday night tremendously, Triple H can’t bring back wrestlers in perpetuity to pop ratings and rely on that to carry the day.

The good news is that Raw’s writing has been stronger for months now. It’s only the past couple of weeks that it’s flagged a bit. Assuming they can right the ship quickly, this won’t be noticeable. But if it continues once the surprises melt away, you’re going to have problems.

For now, though, enjoy this season premiere of Raw and everything it offered. It’s perfectly fine to lose yourself in the smoke and mirrors.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

5. Nostalgia Act At Best

D-Generation X
WWE.com

After all the hype surrounding D-Generation X’s big 25th-anniversary celebration, there were no retrospectives, no talking head segments, no interviews, no angles, and no interesting tidbits.

When it all came down to it, four members of one of the most influential acts of the Attitude Era rode a jeep (not a tank) into the arena, danced down to ringside, threw out green glow sticks, and delivered all their catchphrases while briefly thanking fans for supporting them.

And that was it.

Don’t get it wrong, there was nothing bad about the segment or inherently wrong with it. But this was just pure nostalgia and a low-grade version of nostalgia at best. We’ve heard all of them deliver the same routine countless times, and if that was sprinkled in with some genuine celebration or insight, it would have been fantastic.

But delivering the bare minimum of catchphrases isn’t going to warrant an “up” here, especially not when watching on TV. Live and in person? Sure, that’s an easy “up.”


4. Not Miz’s Balls And The Cake!

The Miz birthday
WWE.com

After hyping Miz’s birthday celebration, you’d think there’d be something decent to it. But you’d be wrong.

Raise your hand if you were shocked that Dexter Lumis (well, his head) was inside one of the presents. Now go sit in the corner.

This was an extremely predictable, paint-by-numbers segment, right down to Maryse getting awkwardly knocked into the cake and having it smeared all over her hair, face and dress. The only deviation from the norm was Lumis grabbing a serving knife and puncturing the two giant yoga balls with Miz’s face on them, deflating his metaphorical massive balls.

Otherwise, this was tremendously terrible and further evidence that this storyline is a steaming turd.


3. Omos: Jobber Killer, Crowd Killer

Omos killing some schmuck
WWE.com

Here we are, 18 months after Omos’ main roster in-ring debut, and he’s still battling jobbers in handicap matches that play out to absolute silence from fans.

Really, that’s the entire point here. Omos beat two jobbers in a match on Raw Monday night, the third time he’s done that in the past two months. Since losing his feud against Bobby Lashley this spring, he’s had nothing resembling a sustained rivalry and has not really been involved in anything of substance other than the Money in the Bank ladder match.

The worst part is that Omos’ matches play out in eerie silence, with fans not really reacting to much of anything, even when the announcers sell it as if he’s wreaking havoc on his opponents. It’s hard to imagine anyone tuning in to see an Omos squash, which has got to be approaching “bathroom break” status for the live fans.

It’s disappointing to say this, because he’s been forced to develop almost entirely on TV rather than on NXT house shows. But his match Monday night was just another in a series of forgettable, directionless squashes.


2. Not Exactly A Blow-Away Blowoff Match

Johnny Gargano Austin Theory
WWE.com

Ever since returning to WWE in August, Johnny Gargano has been hounded by his former protégé Austin Theory, who has maintained nonstop that the student has exceeded the teacher.

The two went back and forth for weeks tormenting the other, and interfering in each other’s matches, and it finally came to a head Monday night on Raw’s season premiere.

But when the bell rang… it was just a match. Don’t get it wrong, the match itself was fine, with both men looking fairly crisp en route to Gargano nailing One Final Beat to put Theory down. However, this wasn’t the culmination of a feud between former stablemates, or at least it didn’t feel like one. It felt like two guys just trying to move up the ladder.

Sure, Theory swiped Johnny’s Gargano Escape submission hold, but it barely registered with fans. After Johnny Wrestling put Austin away, there was no feeling that he had defeated an arch-rival or gained some cathartic win. It was just another day at the office.

Let’s hope then that this is it for this feud because nothing here indicated a need or desire to run it back. And let’s hope better things are on the horizon for both men.


1. Miz Match Makes No Sense

Dexter Lumis
WWE.com

A “sport” where you can whip someone into the ropes and they keep running back and forth in perpetuity requires you to suspend disbelief a bit, but what we got backstage with Miz and D-Generation X after Miz’s birthday celebration was upended was just beyond the pale.

Miz and Maryse sputtered and raved about being tormented by Dexter Lumis, so Road Dogg decided the best solution was to make a match with the stipulation that if Miz wins, Lumis is “gone forever,” and if Dexter wins, he keeps Miz’s birthday gifts… and gets a WWE contract.

So let’s break that down: Lumis doesn’t work for WWE, has been showing up in arenas and backstage attacking contracted talent, stalking Miz, kidnapping him and invading his home, and the solution is to make a match with the condition that if he loses, Lumis – who hasn’t agreed to the match yet – will agree to stay away from WWE and Miz forever.

HOW DOES ANY OF THAT MAKE ANY SENSE?

Spoiler: It doesn’t.


Ups…

7. All Angle, All The Time

Sami Zayn Jey Uso
WWE.com

On paper, Matt Riddle versus Sami Zayn should have been a tremendous bout that featured high-flying and aerial spots galore. And once the bell rang, we got something completely different.

The match was not about what happened in the ring, but what played out on the apron and on the floor, with Jey Uso’s conflict with Sami continuing to play out and stir up trouble in the Bloodline. Riddle defeating Zayn is the right call for a couple of different reasons, but this allowed him to keep his momentum from Extreme Rule while leaving Zayn presumably to face consequences on Friday.

So put aside your star rating for this one and just enjoy.


6. ‘Hit Me’

Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

Who could have predicted that Dominik Mysterio’s perfect role was to cash in on his punchable face by leaning into it with a heel turn on his father?

But that’s exactly what has worked perfectly for Dom since joining Judgment Day and repeatedly tormenting Rey Mysterio. The younger Mysterio has gotten nuclear heat just by demanding that his dad hit him.

Monday, Rey won his match against Chad Gable, but then went face-to-face with Dominik, who slapped him and clotheslined him. Rey, however, wouldn’t hit his son… but Dom happily took another swing, and then delivered a 619 to leave Rey sobbing.

On paper, this shouldn’t work as well as it does, but it miraculously has. Here’s hoping it can continue.


5. Bayley Left Reeling

Damage CTRL
WWE.com

When Bianca Belair defeated Bayley in their ladder match to retain her Raw Women’s Championship at Extreme Rules, you had to wonder how Bayley would recover from this loss, because the title win was probably baked in for Damage CTRL, but in the storyline and in reality.

Instead, the group leader was forced to regroup after her loss Saturday. On Monday, she sat stone-faced during a backstage interview before he match against Candice Le Rae. Despite injuring LeRae and keeping after the knee injury, Bayley faltered, with Candice countering a Rose Plant with a cradle for the shock win.

Damage CTRL would rush the ring and lay out LeRae and Belair, who tried to save Candice. The result is that Bayley is still lacking confidence after losing two straight matches and being on the defensive, but her group is bailing her out and keeping challengers at bay. It’s not the strongest story, but having Bayley question herself is fine for a plot point, especially before we get to November and WarGames.

In the past, Bayley losing two straight like these would be a huge negative and red flag, but we’re going to exhibit some faith in WWE for a bit to see what comes next.


4. New Champ Goads Ex-Champ Into Losing Prospect

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

The minute the announcers started talking about cancelling Bobby Lashley’s planned title defense against Seth Rollins while waiting for medical help due to his injury, you knew something was going down.

Sure enough, Rollins came out and taunted a conflicted and injured Lashley into wrestling him, succeeding in getting the title match he wanted with a wounded opponent. The age-old “heel taunts a wounded babyface” angle works for a reason, and this was one of them. It’s very easy to take a shot at Lashley for foolishly accepting the challenge, but you’ve got to give it up to Rollins for getting what he wanted.

From that perspective, this was a victory for Rollins just being a jerk and coaxing a match he had no right to receive.


3. AJ Gets Some Backup

AJ Styles Karl Anderson Luke Gallows
WWE.com

For the past few weeks, Finn Balor has tried to recruit his old running buddy AJ Styles to join Judgment Day, noting that the Phenomenal One is alone and needs backup.

This message has been delivered with some tough love, but Balor insisted that he was showing mercy in not finishing the job. Monday, he started to deliver an ultimatum, but Styles came out to say he had seen the light and agreed with Finn that he needed friends, family even. And he wanted someone who had his back in Japan and WWE was the kind of help he needed.

But when Finn hugged AJ to welcome him to The Judgment Day, Styles noted that he wasn’t talking about Balor… and out came Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows, marking their first appearance in WWE since WrestleMania 36, when they backed up AJ against The Undertaker in the Boneyard Match.

Just like then, the Good Brothers backed up Styles as a brawl broke out, with Judgment Day fleeing the scene. A feud between Judgment Day and the reunited OC could be fun, especially given the history between the wrestlers. Throw in Rey Mysterio possibly sticking his masked head into things and you could have something there.


2. Brock Returns, Targets Lashley

Brock Lesnar Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

With a Saudi Arabia premium live event on the horizon, it shouldn’t have been a surprise that Brock Lesnar made his return to WWE for the first time since SummerSlam on Raw Monday night.

The Beast came out before Bobby Lashley’s United States Championship defense to a thunderous ovation, slapping hands with fans and looking like we could get a respect showdown between the two behemoths.

Instead, Lesnar hoisted Bobby up on his shoulders and delivered an F-5. He then hit a German suplex and another F-5 before locking in a Kimura, just to really crank it in on the champ. This of course paves the way for Brock and a now-title-less Lashley to collide at Crown Jewel next month.

But first, the All Mighty called Brock out to meet him at Raw next week, so let’s see what happens there to set the table.


1. Sami Owns Opening Segment

Sami Zayn The Usos
WWE.com

Sami Zayn has found his groove in a way that wrestlers so rarely do, connecting with the audience at every turn.

Zayn found himself as the center of attention during the Bloodline’s show-opening segment, interrupting Roman Reigns to take responsibility for (and possibly saving) Jey Uso for his disrespect. It’s impossible to do Sami’s promo credit, so let’s just say that he had the crowd eating out of the palm of his hand.

Even an interruption from Matt Riddle and what normally would be a completely insipid and moronic conversation revolving around the word “yeet” proved to be entertaining thanks to Zayn’s antics and how everyone else played off it.

The man has the Midas Touch, and that’s really good news for anyone in his orbit.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.