7 Ups And 10 Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Dec 7)

Does a stacked opening make for good television? Yes and no.

After bottoming out in the ratings (again) two week ago, WWE saw viewership climb last week and looked to capitalize on that increase by trying to hook viewers through a packed opening half-hour. The question that the ratings might bear out is whether that overstuffed opening will translate into sustained viewership or a bubble that quickly burst before 9 p.m. It€™s fair to say that Raw hadn€™t opened with a 16-man match in anyone€™s casual memory, but a main event confrontation between the current world champ and top challenger on the go-home Raw is something we€™ve probably seen 10 times in the past year. Monday, the WWE World Heavyweight Champion took a pinfall loss to his #1 contender, Roman Reigns, in a tag match, which is WWE€™s favorite way to raise the question of whether the champ€™s title is in jeopardy. Let€™s face it: Sheamus is not setting the world on fire as champ. In fact, he€™s going to be viewed as little more than a placeholder unless he starts Brogue Kicking opponents and pinning them cleanly. But his challenger hasn€™t fared much better. Reigns isn€™t the guy fans are clamoring for to take the Celtic Warrior down, though you get the feeling fans would accept him a lot more simply because it€™s obvious WWE believes Roman is a top guy. Meanwhile, there€™s a PPV on Sunday and a card needed to get filled out, which WWE tried to do to varying degrees of success. But hey, it€™s the last PPV of the year and it€™s right before the holidays, so you can€™t fault them for not being prepared, right? So what climbed the ladder of success and what got put through a table? Let€™s get to it€

DOWNS€

10. Two Plodding Beasts

What can be said about the developing rivalry between Rusev and Ryback? How about €œno?€ For the second consecutive week, the Big Guy and the Bulgarian Brute squared off on Raw, only for the match to end inconclusively. Both times a possible Lana injury resulted in a count-out, this time with both men being outside the ring and Lana faking her injury to lure Ryback into a Rusev attack. It€™s a feud that doesn€™t appear to have any coherent reason to exist other than, €œHere are two big men who aren€™t doing anything else.€ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXlJ7nizDMc And while that can work sometimes, this pairing isn€™t inspiring anything other than a bathroom break. Even a Ryback plancha and missile dropkick can€™t save this €œfeud.€ Unless something is going to captivate fans soon, this one could use a decisive match to put a cap on this rivalry.

9. Joined In Progress

Raw is three hours long, plus an overrun. Keep that in mind as you realize that the Jack Swagger versus Stardust contest was joined mid-match, with no announcement (outside of Stardust€™s promo earlier) and no ring introductions. Raw came back from commercial and within 30 seconds, Swagger had the Patriot Lock on Stardust threatening a tap-out. Look, not every match can get 10 minutes on Raw, that much is clear. And sometimes WWE needs to cut out one introduction, having the first competitor enter the ring during a commercial. But to see the intros and first few moments of the match start during a break is just ludicrous. There€™s no reason for it when Raw is three-plus hours in length. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lphUxcO-4ug It would be interesting to see if this was the plan all along, or if something ran a bit long, forcing them to bring Swagger and Stardust both out during the break. Oh, was it mentioned that Swagger is supposed to be challenging for the United States Championship at TLC?

8. Accuracy Matters

Did anyone else feel like Sheamus was lost out there during his opening promo? He looked almost nervous and whiffed on a couple points during his remarks. First, the Celtic Warrior pointed to his €œSheamus 5:15€ shirt and remarked that it only took him 5:15 to beat Roman Reigns for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. That€™s not only wrong, it makes Sheamus look worse than the truth does. Reigns was champ for 5:15 €“ from the end of his title match against Dean Ambrose to the end of the 34-second match in which he lost the title to Sheamus. Second, Sheamus said his victory and Roman€™s brief reign had to be some kind of €œworld record€ for a title victory. Whether he€™s talking about his win or Reigns€™ time holding the title, both are wrong. Most Money in the Bank briefcase cash-in has been quicker than that. Randy Orton beat Daniel Bryan at SummerSlam 2013 in 8 seconds. Bryan beat Big Show at TLC 2011 in 7 seconds. Hell, Sheamus beat Bryan at WrestleMania XXVII in 18 seconds! Again, it€™s not some great sin against the wrestling gods, but it didn€™t help that Sheamus sounded off out there and then muffed those points.

7. Is This Going Somewhere?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcInDJhTFM0 OK, this makes sense in some weird sense. WWE knows that Stardust is a reliable hand who can deliver a kooky, fun promo. And the company clearly wants to keep Titus O€™Neil visible whether the Prime Time Players are performing on television or not. So why not pair them up in backstage vignettes? But this is what, the third or fourth time Titus has descended on Stardust€™s star room (Really? We couldn€™t call it the cosmic lair or constellation corner?) to interrupt the former Cody Rhodes€™ rantings. O€™Neil once again engaged Stardust in a conversation, only to €œget one up€ on him verbally. So where is all of this going? A match between the two? Over what, O€™Neil violating the sanctity of Stardust€™s lair? Or is this just WWE putting smiles on faces and it€™s going absolutely nowhere? Well, according to Titus on commentary, he wants Stardust to go back to being Cody€ because he€™s the son of a Hall of Famer. Don€™t ask how poking fun at him is supposed to accomplish that, you€™ll hurt your head.

6. Timing Is Everything

Let€™s see, four four-man teams engage in a massive elimination match€ it must be Survivor Series time, right? Sadly, WWE mistimed its opening segment by one pre-PPV go-home Raw. Had the writers done something like this last month, it would have been a cool Survivor Series preview with the Wyatt Family, Team ECW, Roman Reigns€™ family and the League of Nations squaring off. Instead, it was the go-home Raw before Tables, Ladders & Chairs. And while it€™s not a terrible sin, it just felt like this was a weird reversal, with three of these teams forming in the weeks after Survivor Series instead of before. But hey, we got two electrifying Survivor Series elimination matches at the PPV, right? Right?

5. Demote Byron Saxton

This could almost be a weekly item, but it bears reminding this week that Byron Saxton is not ready for prime time. He€™s trying really hard, and God knows that many would fail in his position, but he€™s just not cut out for live television at this time. One glaringly awful exchange came before the Dolph Ziggler versus Kevin Owens match when Tyler Breeze made his way out. Saxton seemed confused or surprised that Breeze was heading their way, only for Michael Cole to point out that Prince Pretty€™s VIP lounge was set up €œtwo feet away€ from Byron. Saxton then went into banal conversation mode, commenting on the cheese and grapes they had and discussing sneaking over to take a selfie with Breeze. Maybe he€™s there to hit the high-pitched €œUnity!€ when mimicking Team BAD€™s promo, because he sure isn€™t there to add insight and depth to the commentary team. The sad thing is that Tom Phillips and Corey Graves are much better. Renee Young also could do a much better job and deserves a shot before keeping Saxton out there.

4. A Cena Sighting!... Sort Of

This item has gotten a pass for a while, but the unspoken absence of John Cena really needs to be noted this week after two direct references to the former United States champ without a single musing about his whereabouts for the past six weeks. Cena hasn€™t been seen since losing the U.S. title at Hell in a Cell in October. Since then, there have been a couple passing mentions, but nothing in recent weeks. However, on Monday Michael Cole noted that Cena was scheduled to be a guest on the Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon on Tuesday. So he hasn€™t come back for a U.S. title rematch or to entertain the fans he professes to love so much, but he€™s well enough to appear on a talk show? And there€™s nary a concern about where he€™s been the past month-plus? Later, Zeb Colter mentioned how he knew that Cena was ripe for the pickings when he brought Alberto Del Rio in at HIAC to challenge Cena for the United States Championship. But again, there was no reference beyond that.

3. Return Of The Bathroom Break Match

Even at its lowest point, the Divas Revolution had accomplished one thing: It had turned women€™s wrestling matches from bathroom break bouts into competent matches worth watching. That says nothing about poor angles and booking, though. And on Monday, we saw the very definition of a bathroom match emerge, as Naomi and Sasha Banks squared off against Brie Bella and Alicia Fox. Banks possibly is the best female wrestler out there right now, and she was reduced to a pedestrian pace of a match, with Brie Bella inexplicably acting like a face and getting booed throughout the match. Once again, Team BAD had to resort to their numbers game helping them win, because we have to protect Alicia Fox. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HrqMjqWYsCE Hopefully this will not be another 3-4 weeks of Team BAD and the remnants of Team Bella squaring off in a variety of inconclusive matches. Fans might stop simply sitting on their hands and actively take a position against the match.

2. Blowing Rhyno€™s Return

In the days leading up to Raw, it became obvious that the Dudley Boyz and Tommy Dreamer were going to get some extreme backup. When Bubba Ray Dudley tweeted as much, the speculation went into overdrive about who would fill that fourth slot as Team ECW battled the Wyatt Family. While Spike Dudley made sense from a storyline perspective and Rob Van Dam would have popped the crowd the most, WWE went with an ECW veteran it already has under contract: Rhyno. That€™s not to say it was a letdown by any stretch, but WWE turned around and tanked it in the worst way possible. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nkmF63p1aOg Instead of having Rhyno€™s return have any impact whatsoever, they immediately had it segue directly into a 16-man, Fatal Four-way elimination match. The Man Beast€™s first appearance on Raw in a decade was a cool moment, but it was brushed aside in less than a minute. Sure, he might not be a game-changer for the roster, but it could have been a fun moment on its own, not part of an orgy of activity.

1. Rushing A Massive Match

WWE did something completely different from the norm Monday night, opening with a segment that built quickly to a boiling point, with 16 wrestlers in the ring/at ringside when Raw cut to commercial. Instead of a standoff or an impasse, we returned to a massive, 16-man Fatal Four-way elimination match in progress. No explanations, no match-making, just a quick comment from the announcers. If ever there was a time that was perfectly appropriate for the Authority to come out and make a match, this was it. Stephanie McMahon should have come out and announced the match, thus providing a logical reason for it and briefly explain the rules. It made perfect sense. And she could have made it the main event €“ or even to top the 9 p.m. or 10 p.m. hours €“ rather than putting it on right away, giving fans something to look forward to later in the program. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kjjl0B2hemY Yes, WWE is trying to hook viewers right away with a strong effort, and that€™s commendable, but how do you follow that match, especially when nothing else was announced for Raw beyond that bout?

UPS€

7. A Star In The Making?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvd8kIVSdaE Say what you will about the Miz, but he gets a reaction out of fans. He is perfectly serviceable in a role riling up a crowd or providing a figure for someone to play off of. He provided the perfect foil for Damien Sandow (though that didn€™t really work out too well for him in the long run), and now he€™s being paired up in backstage segments with Neville. One of the biggest criticisms that can be levied against the British high-flyer is that he seems to lack personality on WWE television, and in WWE, a lack of personality is a huge problem. The good news is that Miz is quite adept at getting others out of their shell a little and play off of him, so hopefully the coming weeks will see Neville grow as a performer outside the ring. The other good thing is that Miz is capable in the ring, so this shouldn€™t drag on forever solely as a backstage skit, as some other €œfeuds€ have been in the past. Look for Neville to tire of Miz€™s antics soon and it lead to a match.

6. New Day, New Friends

There surely will be those who think that Team BAD and New Day being partnered together is a desperate sign, but it certainly is an interesting grouping with potential. New Day is exactly the kind of act that thrives when they play off someone else and can bring out more of the female trio€™s personalities, and Team BAD could use having its profile boosted. Consider how rare it is for multiple men and women to partner together. When was the last time that happened? Typically, you€™ll see one woman join a man or men, but multiples of each is very rare in today€™s era. New Day is capable of making nearly every situation entertaining, while Team BAD falls a little short in this connecting with fans. In that regard, this pairing could work pretty well. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlysMbuFAgU Of course, requiring that Michael Cole explain how the teams already are joined at the collective hips via social media is just painful.

5. A Sneaky Good Match

This was ready to be listed as a negative, but Dolph Ziggler and Kevin Owens worked to get the fans (and columnists) into their match by the end. When Tyler Breeze came out before the bout and took a seat in his VIP lounge, it seemed like it would only be a matter of minutes before he would interfere to cost Ziggler the match, thus setting up their rubber match for TLC and allowing Owens to win without hurting Dolph too much. As such, the opening minutes of the match €“ punctuated by KO chinlocks and headlocks €“ felt like a slow march to a DQ finish. Instead, the match built slowly until a quiet crowd got louder as the action picked up and the near-falls started in abundance. Owens threw Ziggler around like a ragdoll (most impressively a release German suplex that launched Dolph halfway across the ring), while Dolph fought back with a DDT on the floor and getting the better of dueling superkicks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tpdHf_tF5o The best part is that Owens won clean with a Pop-Up Powerbomb that came as both men were spent and were just teeing off on each other. Sure, Ziggler lost, but if you€™re going to go down, a lengthy, hard-hitting match against the Intercontinental Champion isn€™t the worst way.

4. Roman! Roman! Roman!

No, your ears weren€™t deceiving you, that was the Charleston faithful chanting for Roman Reigns at the end of Raw. Somehow, some way, Roman manages to elicit a strong positive reaction when he€™s in the midst of a wild brawl. That€™s happened a couple times now where Reigns has gotten the live audience behind him, which might be a sign that he€™s turning a corner. Or it€™s just the fans trolling the TV viewers. Regardless, a mediocre chant for Reigns doesn€™t mean that he€™s suddenly the answer to John Cena or that he€™s going to change the business like his cousin the Rock did. But if we€™re looking for any positive possible, this has to count for something. It means that fans want to buy into Roman at some level, though it€™s not at the Vince McMahon-inspired superhero level. Reigns got over with the Shield for their hard-nosed brawling, and that€™s when Roman tends to get the biggest reaction nowadays. (Remember his wild brawl with Bray Wyatt to close Raw a couple months ago?) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fPbXRTiLs8 It€™s just worth noting that Reigns got a nice reaction from the live crowd, but it€™s also worth tossing out that WWE logic would indicate that since Roman pinned Sheamus in the opener and got the upper hand at the end of Raw, he€™s losing at TLC.

3. MexAmerica Has Surrendered

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNNPCZ5PTco It€™s official, MexAmerica is no more. We got a hint last week that Alberto Del Rio€™s fictional country that he and Zeb Colter populated was disintegrating around them when the merged flag representing the unrecognized nation didn€™t appear on Zeb€™s scooter. But the first nail in the coffin came during the opening segment of Raw when Sheamus introduced the members of the League of Nations. After introducing Rusev as hailing from Bulgaria, he declared that Del Rio was from Mexico. Not MexAmerica, Mexico. Maybe that€™s because Del Rio has renounced his MexAmerican citizenship. Maybe it€™s because he€™s reaffirmed his pride in Mexico. Or maybe it€™s because that entire storyline was stupid and needed to be buried and forgotten once and for all. But just to drive the point home, Del Rio and Colter formally broke up later in the show, finally ending this failed experiment. Viva la Mexico, adios MexAmerica!

2. Less Talking, More Action

For all the criticism levied in previous items about the opening of Raw, one big positive that needs to be highlighted is that WWE broke from the (recent history) norm Monday night, having the show open with a brief promo but then quickly escalate into chaos. Sure Sheamus€™ promo was rambling and error-riddled. And Rhyno€™s fun return got lost in the jumble. And the huge 16-man match was rushed forward without a proper setup. But it was different. And for that, we have to give WWE credit. They tried something different for a change. While we can poke holes through everything they did, it shouldn€™t disqualify them from continuing to try something new. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hFplIPx5TPc Monday€™s opening segment(s) was high-energy and action-packed. That€™s a pretty big departure from the 20-minute talkfests that have dominated the opening of Raw for the past several years. And that along merits a thumbs up.

1. Was That A Double Turn?

Last week, WWE teased a Charlotte turn in the vein of her famous father, Ric Flair, who was known as the €œDirtiest player in the game€ when she faked an injury to beat her friend Becky Lynch. Monday, Charlotte blew right past shades of gray and went full-on heel, from her all-black outfit, to lecturing Miz on how to introduce the Nature Boy, to saying they were on €œRolex time.€ At the same time, Paige€™s past transgressions €“ including mocking Charlotte€™s deceased brother €“ were forgotten as she became the heroine. And you know what? All of that gets a pass €“ and a thumbs up. That might sound crazy €“ approving of a ridiculous double turn with little logic €“ but let€™s face it, Charlotte as a face wasn€™t working, and the crowds enjoy cheering Paige even when she€™s acting like a heel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y95Yoyxl5mE The dynamics weren€™t working, so rather than let things die a slow death, WWE opted to rapidly change course. Whether it was artfully done or even if it ultimately was the right thing to do, it was good to see WWE recognize the problem and do something about it to try to save the angle and the characters. Now, let€™s see if it works.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.