7 Ups And 3 Downs From NXT TakeOver Brooklyn III

NXT once again throws gauntlet of incredible matches, shocking moments at WWE's feet.

roh nxt
WWE.com

After a couple middling TakeOver specials that were solid but unspectacular, NXT delivered a must-see program Saturday night with its third showing in Brooklyn.

The five-match card featured three title bouts and two grudge matches, but it’s what happened outside the bells that really made this a noteworthy show (beyond the solid wrestling). A trio of aggressors made sure to introduce themselves to new champions, laying them out and announcing their presence. It set up future storylines, future matchups and gave fans a reason to tune in on Wednesdays other than to see the new champs.

The action inside the ring was solid at worst and excellent at best. All the wrestlers went 100 kph, and the hot crowd certainly helped amplify that. It’s hard to pick which match was the best of the night, though the opening between Andrade “Cien” Almas and Johnny Gargano was hard to top, and the NXT Women’s Championship match riveted fans and had some of the hottest near-falls you’ll see.

SummerSlam might have a four-hour PPV schedule – twice as long as TakeOver – but they’re going to have to work twice as hard to top TakeOver Brooklyn III in terms of quality and entertainment value. That’s not to say that it can’t be done, but the bar has been set rather high.

With that said, let’s see what rose and what fell. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

3. Code Avoid

As a general rule, unless there is a major act or a major tie-in, live musical acts during a wrestling PPV are a no-no. And Code Orange opening NXT TakeOver is no exception.

While it’s better than a mid-show performance, the metal band opening the PPV was an instant deflation. This writer is admittedly not up on all the hot musical acts, but Code Orange should have at least sounded somewhat familiar, lest it generate a “WTF?” reaction and a muting of the TV.

When the band played Aleister Black’s entrance theme, that was a perfectly good use of the group, much like Living Colour playing out CM Punk at WrestleMania XXIX or Motorhead playing out Triple H on multiple occasions.

But kicking off a PPV with a group that a casual fan has to perform a Google search to identify? Not the best idea.


2. What Does Itami Do Now?

Itami Black
WWE.com

Since returning to action after WrestleMania, Hideo Itami has undergone a transformation from a no-nonsense babyface to a sulking heel who demands that fans show him respect.

And while this change is definitely an improvement in character – in that he now has one – Itami’s record has been checkered at best and disappointing at worst. Itami lost his NXT Championship match against Bobby Roode at TakeOver Chicago and has spent most of the summer battling Oney Lorcan and Kassius Ohno, losing matches to both.

On Saturday, Hideo lost to the undefeated Aleister Black after a really good, hard-hitting, bloody match. While Itami lost to a surprise Black Mass kick, it still was another loss in a big match for the Japanese superstar, leaving him without any big wins since returning.

We’re not witnessing a full-on losing streak (which WWE typically loves), but they’ve got a potentially great top heel in an angry, remorseless Itami. Will they pay it off? Until we get some indications that they will, this gets a cautious “down.”


1. Failing To Pull The Trigger

Asuka Women's
WWE.com

Legit question: Who is going to take the NXT Women’s Championship off of Asuka?

It’s understandable that WWE wants to build the Empress of Tomorrow’s record-setting title reign up – she’s now at 504+ days, more than two months longer than CM Punk’s vaunted title reign in 2011-13. But at this point, she’s now run through the entire NXT women’s division, including several women who have since been called up to the main roster.

Saturday was the right time to elevate a new star. It was the right time to “make” Ember Moon and have her end Asuka’s reign and establish herself as a top competitor. Sure, her match with Asuka was really good, but it was a huge mistake to have her come up short again.

Unless WWE has a tremendous prospect in the pipeline who they want to knock off Asuka (Kairi Sane?), this was a wasted opportunity.


Ups...

7. The Numbers Game Defeats AOP

authors of pain nxt
WWE.com

For the past year, the Authors of Pain have been built up as a nearly impossible team to beat. So it was only fitting that it took more than a tag team to defeat them on Saturday night.

AOP tangled with Sanity (Alexander Wolfe and Eric Young) for the NXT Tag Team Championships, but it wasn’t just the duo they faced. Killian Dain and Nikki Cross found a way to factor into the match, saving Young (Cross) and taking Akam out of the match (Cross and Dain). That paved the way for Wolfe and Young to overcome Rezar and win the tag titles.

In that manner, it allowed AOP to look strong but also get the titles off of them after holding the straps since January.


6. Announcers Bring The Goods

NXT 400 Mauro Ranallo Percy Watson Nigel McGuinness
WWE.com

Not to knock Tom Phillips, but if you watched previous TakeOver specials and then watched Saturday night’s event, you had to notice a difference.

Mauro Ranallo is a fantastic play-by-play announcer, and when paired with someone who isn’t yelling and competing with him (JBL) and instead is a knowledgeable and competent color commentator (Nigel McGuinness), you’ve got the makings of something pleasing to the ears. They made each match feel special, dropped some knowledge on fans (like the fact that STO actually stands for “Space Tornado Ogawa”) and helped build the drama around the near-falls.

Oh, and Percy Watson was there too.


5. New Tag Challengers Step Up

o Reilly Fish
WWE.com

It was a little strange that former Ring of Honor tag champs Bobby Fish and Kyle O’Reilly debuted in NXT in separate singles matches against Aleister Black – with both men losing.

But it didn’t take long for the duo to reconnect in NXT and make a statement, which came just moments after Sanity knocked off the Authors of Pain for the NXT Tag Team Championships. Fish and O’Reilly attacked both teams, decimating them and clearly indicating they were here for the tag titles. It added an air of unpredictability to the TakeOver special and shocked the fans in attendance.

Just like that, a tag division that looked weak with the loss of DIY now looks to be heating up with reDRagon joining the Street Profits as new teams in the mix.


4. A White Hot Opener

andrade gargano
WWE.com

What do you think the message from gorilla was to Johnny Gargano and Andrade “Cien” Almas? Tear the house down? Set the bar super-high?

Whatever it was, Almas and Gargano traded matwork, high-impact offense, several high-flying moves and a few near-falls to whip fans into a frenzy. Both men escaped each other’s finishers and both looked to have the match well in hand at various points. The X-factor was Almas’ manager, Zelina Vega, who distracted Gargano in a very unique way.

Vega threw a DIY T-shirt into the ring at Gargano, causing him to pause for just a second, and that allows Almas to take over and grab the win with his hammerlock DDT. Considering everything Gargano and former partner Tommaso Ciampa have been through, it was a clever way to pull his attention away from the match. Points for that as well.


3. Women Nearly Steal The Show

asuka ember moon
WWE.com

While the ending of the NXT Women’s Championship match was a disappointment and a letdown, the match itself up to that point was everything you could ask for from Asuka and Ember Moon.

The two women had fans buying every near-fall, especially after Moon hit her Eclipse finisher, and then escaped a rollup with tights and hit a superkick. There was a great little moment after Asuka kicked out of the Eclipse and Ember mouthed, “I hate you” while staring her opponent down. The match itself laid on the gas pedal the whole time, barely slowing down except for submission holds.

The match served as a reminder of how talented both women are and the level of quality wrestling WWE can offer if it lets its performers do their thing. Sure, crowning a new champ would have made this a bigger deal, but we can all appreciate a really good match.


2. McIntyre Climbs The Mountain

drew mcintyre
WWE.com

When Drew McIntyre was released from WWE in 2014, he was little more than a joke and a cautionary tale: a former Intercontinental and tag team champion loaded with potential who had jobbed to El Torito.

McIntyre left WWE and toured the world, became a champion everywhere he went, and then returned to the company earlier this year in NXT, looking like and being treated like a big deal. He defeated all comers, became #1 contender for the NXT Championship, and on Saturday, a man who lost to a little person in a three-minute comedy match defeated Bobby Roode for the NXT title.

The match itself was a solid one, if somewhat overshadowed by some of the action earlier in the night, but overall a nice main event.

It remains to be seen if McIntyre can recapture some of his early potential on the main roster, but his TakeOver title win has to be a big redemption for him.


1. Landscape-Altering Ending

Adam Cole Debut NXT Brooklyn III
WWE.com

We’ve seen two of the three NXT titles change hands at a TakeOver event, but Saturday’s PPV was unique in one major way.

The event ended with new NXT Champion Drew McIntyre being laid out by the debuting Adam Cole and new NXT superstars Bobby Fish and Kyle O’Reilly. The duo had already made their presence felt earlier in the night by attacking the new tag champs Sanity, but now all three men – all Ring of Honor alums – jumped McIntyre and left him laid out, standing tall to close the show.

It’s the kind of ending that actually makes you want to tune in on Wednesdays to see how things shake out with two new champs and new challengers/rabble-rousers already ready to take them on. Will the ROH trio form a faction to try to capture NXT gold ala the Four Horsemen or Evolution? It’s an intriguing scenario.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.