7 Ups And 4 Downs From WWE Clash At The Castle

WWE's first UK PLE in 30 years is eventful affair with good action, turns and debuts.

Roman Reigns Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WWE’s first premium live event (or PPV) in the United Kingdom in 30 years came with high expectations. SummerSlam 1992 was a huge deal, and it’s only grown in lore over time.

Throw in that this was a stadium show in front of 62,000 fans and you have an edict to deliver.

The result was an energetic, high-octane show that had the live fans engaged from the opening bell with solid-to-excellent in-ring action, a couple surprises, and some memorable moments to make this a meaningful show (rather than just filler).

However, Clash at the Castle was not without its concerns. The six-woman tag had a high bar set, and it’s debatable whether it cleared it. Matt Riddle spent his summer getting his head stomped in and then his personal life’s dirty laundry aired, only to get beaten and humiliated further.

And then there’s Drew McIntyre, who came into the match with the weight of the UK on him, and he closed out the night title-less and signing karaoke. No way a DraftKings gambler could have predicted that one.

Still, Sheamus and Gunther tore the house down. And Dominik Mysterio finally made up his mind about his loyalties to his father Rey. And really, enjoyable wrestling, a couple cool debuts and a hell turn is about all you can ask for on a WWE show. Thumbs up overall.

Let’s get to it…


Downs...

4. Clunky And Uneven

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

We’ll give the six-woman tag its due for getting the result correct, but the match itself could have and should have been so much more.

Multiple times throughout the bout, wrestlers looked to be out of position or even lost, with several awkward spots evident. Rarely did the match flow smoothly, even with six ridiculously talented women who all have certified bangers in their repertoire.

The finish in particular looked baffling, with Bianca Belair facing a 3-on-1 attack that took a while to get to the climax of Dakota Kai, Bayley and Iyo Sky hitting their finishers in succession to put the Raw Women’s Champion down.

Right result, and not a terrible match, but really, this should have been a fair bit better.


3. Judgment Day Loses, Laughs About It

WWE Clash At The Castle Rey Dominik Mysterio Edge
WWE.com

One of the toughest groups to rally around these days has to be Judgment Day, a faction that wants to be taken seriously, but then has moments like Saturday at Clash at the Castle.

Finn Balor and Damian Priest were battling Rey Mysterio and Edge in a tag bout that saw Dominik Mysterio repeatedly get involved, cheating on multiple occasions to help his father’s team win. The result was Judgment Day eating another loss.

Afterward, Dominik turned on Rey and Edge, and Finn, Priest and Rhea Ripley (who had laid Dominik out for interfering) just sat there and laughed about it. Sure, what else could you do? But this comes after weeks of Judgment Day trying unsuccessfully to recruit Dominik, and then he cost you a match on a huge stage, and all you can do is laugh?

Maybe if Dominik had turned mid-match, or if Judgment Day had won, this would have worked better for everyone involved. But this felt like the trio just laughed off what should have been a serious loss for them.


2. McIntyre Gets 'Luger'-ed

Tyson Fury Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Speaking of laughing off losses…

Drew McIntyre fought with the weight of the entire United Kingdom on his shoulders in the main event of the first PPV/PLE on “island” in 30 years. He came up short when Roman Reigns enlisted yet another family member to bail him out.

His reaction afterward? McIntyre joined Tyson Fury to sing karaoke-style to “send the fans home happy.” He did vow to win the title, but then immediately turned to celebrate with the fans and sing, brushing aside this devastating loss that should have at the very least pissed him off. Threatening to rip Solo Sikoa’s head off and pry the titles out of Roman’s hands would have sounded a lot better than badly sung Oasis.

It vaguely harkened back to Lex Luger defeating Yokozuna in their WWF Championship match at SummerSlam 1993 via countout and celebrating as if he had won the title, when in fact he didn’t. He looked like a geek, and then he proceeded to lose his title match at WrestleMania X and was ratcheted down the card.

McIntyre brushing off a significant loss – even one that came via cheating – two minutes later makes it look less like a real fight and more of a scripted defeat, and that’s never a good feeling.


1. Riddle Humiliated, Then Humbled

WWE Clash At The Castle Seth Rollins Matt Riddle
WWE.com

We’re not saying the slighted and maligned babyface should always win a feud, but Matt Riddle losing his match against Seth Rollins at Clash at the Castle after being beaten down physically and verbally in the lead-up was deflating.

The match itself was good, but didn’t feel like a blood feud between two men who hated each other. (See Sheamus versus Gunther for a good example of how to hit each other when you hate someone.) Sure, they started with a brawl, but it soon settled into a normal, solid match between two really good wrestlers.

Riddle fired up a few times and looked really good, but then he decided to grab a steel chair – like a moron – and missed, then walked right into a stomp, immediately followed by a diving stomp for the Rollins win.

This came just days after Seth brought Matt’s real-life divorce into the feud, only for the villain to get no comeuppance in a blowoff match.


Ups...

7. Liv Morgan Survives

Liv Morgan Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

While you could very easily question the buildup and the decision to have Liv Morgan retain her SmackDown Women’s Championship, you’ve got to credit them for at least telling a decent story of an underdog champion.

Morgan went into the match at less than 100% with an injured arm, facing a submission expert in Shayna Baszler. The Queen of Spades targeted that arm, but Morgan managed to survive, even locking in an armbar of her own at one point. (The announcers noted that Morgan had trained with Matt Riddle in the lead-up to the match to improve her submission game.)

Liv absorbed more punishment, but she caught a break and nailed a Codebreaker, followed immediately by an Oblivion for the win. She basically hung in there until she found an opening and eked out a victory, which is in line with her character these days as she knows she’s punching above her weight class and is constantly having to prove herself.

However, WWE should do a better job of setting the table for these matches. When fans are actively jeering her (as they were on SmackDown in the weeks prior), that’s a bad sign. They should be rallying to the babyface underdog.


6. Hats Off To The Fans

WWE Clash At The Castle Drew McIntyre Karrion Kross Scarlett
WWE.com

For 30 years, United Kingdom fans have wanted a WWF/E PPV/PLE. They’ve gotten UK-only events, but not since SummerSlam 1992 was a main PPV or PLE held in the UK.

Clash at the Castle ended that drought, and fans responded strongly to the show. The crowd of 62,000+ was into the action from the kickoff show six-man tag through the main event. Their reactions to Gunther/Sheamus and Drew McIntyre/Roman Reigns in particular (along with serenading Bayley) were particular moments that added to the matches and made them feel even bigger.

After hearing the reactions and energy throughout the night, you’ve got to imagine this only solidifies the notion of holding PLEs more regularly abroad, be it in the UK or European mainland. It shouldn’t take 30 years for the next UK PLE to take place.


5. Profits, Madcap Kick Things Off Nicely

madcap moss
WWE.com

When you’ve got a stadium show with 60,000+ in attendance, sometimes you just need a high-energy party match to get the fans fired up.

Enter the Street Profits, Madcap Moss, Alpha Academy and AUSTIN Theory (yes, he got his first name back). The six-man tag on the kickoff show was born out of a couple ongoing rivalries and was more of a mid-card grudge match than something resolving a feud. However, it crammed a ton of action in a short package.

Moss got to show off his freakish speed and strength, hitting Otis with a fallaway slam at one point. Montez Ford did his usual aerial display, hitting a diving blockbuster/electric chair combo to the floor onto a pile.

The Profits picked up the win for their team, but the real story was the fans getting more into things as the match wore on, setting the table for the PLE proper.


4. Dom Finally Boots His Old Man

WWE Clash At The Castle Rey Dominik Mysterio Edge
WWE.com

After countless rumors and hints, Dominik Mysterio finally turned on his father at Clash at the Castle Saturday, laying out Rey Mysterio and Edge after their victory against Judgment Day.

Dom has long been viewed as the underwhelming son riding Rey’s coattails, desperately in need of getting out from his father’s shadow. For months, Judgment Day has been trying to recruit Dominik, to no avail. But when Rey chose Edge as his tag partner for the Clash tag match, you could see the younger Mysterio finally growing tired of being set aside.

During the match, Dominik bailed out his dad and Edge several times, cheating to help them win. Afterward, however, Rey and Edge celebrated together while Dom stood off to the side, his contributions ignored. Dominik finally lost it, kicking Edge low and clotheslining Rey, walking out to thundering boos.

The turn came ridiculously late and even came late in the match itself – why not just have Dominik help Judgment Day out in defeating his dad and Edge? – but it happened, and the crowd received it well, so there’s that.


3. Damage Control Picks Up Important Win

WWE Clash At The Castle Bayley Dakota Kai IYO SKY Damage Control Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Clunky match aside, the newly named Damage Control desperately needed to win the six-woman tag match at Clash at the Castle. And they did.

Bayley’s faction debuted five weeks ago at SummerSlam, shocking the wrestling world. Since they, they’ve made a pretty solid showing on Raw, save for Dakota Kai & Iyo Sky losing a match for the vacant WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship earlier in the week. That loss though necessitated Damage Control picking up the win here, lest they look like a group in disarray.

And what’s more, the group managed to isolate Raw Women’s Champion Bianca Belair and put her down with a trio of finishers, the first time Belair had been pinned in more than 300 days. That alone was noteworthy, and it really solidified that Damage Control was a unit and not to be taken lightly.

Now, let’s see what comes next for this group. You’ve got to imagine Bayley targets Bianca after pinning her Saturday.


2. McIntyre, Reigns Deliver Suspense In Main Event

Roman Reigns Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

Setting aside what happened post-match and the trope of Roman Reigns relying on the Bloodline to bail him out, he and Drew McIntyre had a tremendous title match at Clash at the Castle.

Oftentimes, Michael Cole proclaims that a match has a “big-fight feel” and it sounds like hyperbole, but this time, it absolutely was true. Both men played into it, with Roman backing off early on and then trading offense with McIntyre. Drew refused to stay down, kicking out of numerous pinfall attempts at 1.

The match went from standard mode to bomb-throwing midway through, with both men going for their knockout blows repeatedly, and countering each other several times. Reigns even hit a Rock Bottom at one point.

Both men kicked out of each other’s finishers, which really fired up the fans, right up to the point where Solo Sikoa made his debut and pulled the referee out on what was most likely a 3 count for McIntyre. That, followed up immediately by a spear and pin for Reigns, deflated the crowd something fierce.

But overall, this was a highly entertaining match.


1. Hard-Hitting Beyond Advertised

Sheamus Walter
WWE.com

Everyone knew going in that Sheamus versus Gunther for the Intercontinental Championship was going to be a stiff, brutal slugfest between two of the hardest hitters on the roster.

What we got was an incredible display of sheer brutality between two beasts that completely captured fans’ hearts, with Sheamus playing the de facto babyface role. Gunther turned the Celtic Warrior’s chest into raw hamburger as he continuously chopped and slapped away, only for Sheamus to fire up and come back with forearms and his repeated 10 Beats of the Bodhran.

Sheamus pulled out a Celtic Cross for a super-hot near-fall, but Gunther put him away with a powerbomb and a lariat to successfully defend the IC title. Afterward, Sheamus got a well-deserved standing ovation from an audience that was practically willing him on throughout the match.

The match also was notable for the return of Giovanni Vinci, who rejoined his Imperium mates before the contest. Presumably, this re-establishes that stable to further feud with the Brawling Brutes, which could make for some fun television this fall.

Interestingly, it was the first time the Intercontinental Championship was defended at a PPV/PLE in more than 500 days, with the last match coming at WrestleMania 37.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.