8 Awesome WCW Ideas That Didn't Last

If it ain't Crockett, don't break it.

Goldberg Sting
WWE.com

If WCW is remembered for anything these days, it's a horrendous series of preposterously bad creative decisions that managed to transform what was briefly North America's most popular wrestling promotion into a saleable asset within the space of three years. Indeed, such was the precision of the Atalanta promotion's ineptitude that's hard to believe it wasn't an intentional self-destruct, as some part of some elaborate insurance or pension scheme.

Except it wasn't. WCW creative was a kaleidoscope of chaos with scant disregard for concepts such a logical coherency, long-term outcome and whether or not anyone would really want to see Judy Bagwell as a tag team champion. There were many reasons for this - most of them designed around protecting the interests of an elite cartel, or Vince Russo - but ultimately this lack of clarity helped usher along the company's demise.

That's not to say WCW had any good ideas. In fact, they had one bloody great one - a well which they went back to so many times it became foul. Aside the nWo however - and before that became the promotion's only hat-hook - there were a few corkers. Unfortunately, many of them never had a chance to outstay their welcome like Hogan's crew.

8. Spin The Wheel, Make The Deal

Vader Spin The Wheel
WWE.com

Imagine a Mad Max version of Wheel of Fortune, in which instead of winning fabulous cash prizes or a trip to Italy, you're forced into a barbaric, depraved deathmatch (John Leslie could still host). That was basically the idea behind WCW's Halloween Havoc '92 gimmick, 'Spin the Wheel, Make the Deal', in which Sting and Jake Roberts spun, well, a big wheel, contesting whatever match the needle landed on.

In theory, this was a rad idea, selling the pay-per-view on the strength of the unknown quantity, as opposed to say, promoting tired stipulations for no reason besides the calendar demanding it. Unfortunately, WCW being WCW didn't think to rig this 'unknown quantity', resulting in the worst possible main event: a coal miner's glove match.

What's a coal miner's glove match? Good question. Effectively, it was your standard 'thing-on-a-pole' affair, that thing being, erm, a coal miner's glove. Just a big ol' glove. This sucked in practice - though WCW did at least give the novel wheel concept another spin the next year before binning it off.


7. Running The Gauntlet

WCW Power Hour
WWE Network

This idea seems less appealing having lived through WWE's brief obsession with gauntlets over the past two years, each of diminishing returns. That said, WCW's late '80s spin on the match type was one that could be repeated in the long term without ever growing particularly stale.

With the advent of a Saturday afternoon show called Power Hour in 1989, WCW introduced a new feature called 'Running the Gauntlet'. It wasn't quite as simple as it first sounds: rather than face a series of concatenated matches, a wrestler would instead be challenged to win three bouts across all of TBS' weekend wrestling shows. Succeed, and they'd bag a cool $15,000. Fail, and they'd probably get their face smashed in by Sid Vicious.

Only two men - the tough as nails Steiner brothers - managed to pass the gauntlet, before the star-making concept was prematurely abandoned in 1990.


6. Ted DiBiase Financing The NWO

Ted DiBiase nwo
WWE

The excited fervour of Scott Hall dumping Steve Doll and The Mauler out of a Nitro ring in May 1995 gave way to complete bedlam just under two months later, when Hulk Hogan revealed himself as the interlopers' third man.

Cool though the whole 'New World Order' concept was, it was not fully baked. What exactly was their objective, for example? And what was in it for them? Money? Power?

At least one of those questions was answered by the reveal of former WWE tycoon Ted 'Million Dollar Man' DiBiase as the cell's benefactor. With the finances sorted, the nWo were at liberty to recruit defectors from within, as part of their as yet hazy goal to take over WCW.

It was somewhat ambiguous whether this actually made sense. As the intricacies of the story itself was concerned, DiBiase's millions helped explain how three otherwise jobless megastars could afford to mount an ideological offensive without going hungry, brother. On the other hand, intrigue in the nWo persisted so long as fans bought that this was a legitimate invading force, and being backed by the obviously fake millions of 'The Million Dollar Man' exposed the work.

Having insider Eric Bischoff take the role made that much more sense in maintaining the illusion. It also rendered 'Trillionaire Ted' entirely irrelevant.


5. The NBC TV Deal

NBC logo
NBC

In the summer of 1998, WCW were on top of the world.

Yes, anyone with a keen eye for the business could see the cracks starting to widen in the creative process, fissures which would eventually lead to the complete crumble of the entire company. But in the moment, the Turner group was killing it in the ratings, the leading light in a pro wrestling boom that had brought the industry back to Golden Era levels of relevance.

It was during that last time of plenty than national network NBC had any involvement in wrestling. In 1998, they once more wanted a slice of that pie - and in the same Hulk Hogan flavour as previously. So they approached the family-friendly WCW with an offer, with a view to filling the scheduling hole left by the ongoing NBA lockout. Three Las Vegas specials were agreed for 1999: the first opposite WWE's St. Valentine's Day Massacre, another, audaciously, going up against WrestleMania XV, and a final show ringing the year out on New Year's Eve.

The WCW Heavyweight Championship was shifted to Hulk Hogan as efficiently as possible - all it took was a single infamous fingerpoke - as Bischoff began booking around the Valentine's Day special. It was then his paymasters got involved. Eric's boss Harvey Schiller, echoing the sentiments of Turner higher ups, told him the board were uncomfortable with NBC profiting from Turner's property. Failing to see the bigger picture, a potentially lucrative and aggrandising idea went up in smoke. When the NBA returned to NBC, the deal was done for.


4. Raven: Spoiled Rich Kid

Raven's mother
WWE Network

Maybe not quite 'awesome', but certainly 'interesting'.

Throughout much of his time in ECW and WCW, Scott 'Raven' Levy was the grungy beacon for the disaffected youth, the embodiment of emo before 'emo' was a thing, all cut-offs, gnarly soul patch and band shirts. His moody ringside slouching and gang of outcasts was a far cry from the gimmick he'd been typecast as earlier in his career: that of the spoiled rich kid. Middle-class problems?

As it turned out: yes. Post the dissolution of The Flock, Raven went into an emotional on-screen tailspin, regularly walking out on matches and cutting morose promos. Things culminated with a nasty assault on apparent friend Chris Kanyon, only for it to be interrupted by none other than Raven's mother. She implored her son to knock the wrestling on the head for a bit, and return to the protective bosom of his extraordinarily privileged family home.

Turned out all this time Raven was playing up his emotions for financial sympathy. It was a neat way of joining the dots across Levy's career, and resulted in some legitimately hilarious vignettes - family friend Jim 'Sandman' Fullington slapping Kanyon into the pool stands out.

Like many WCW ideas, it was suddenly abandoned for no reason at all, and Raven went back to the goth sh*t. Was the ICP really an improvement on this added nuance to his character?


3. The Crockett Cup

Crockett Cup Dusty Koloff
WWE Network

The Crockett Cup wasn't technically a WCW idea, but one the company imported when Ted Turner bought out Jim Crockett Promotions in 1988. That was also the point at which, despite now owning the concept, it was inexplicably abandoned.

The cup - the Jim Crockett Sr. Memorial Tag Team Tournament, to give it its full title - was as simple yet effective as they come. Across two days, 24 of the finest tandems in the NWA would compete for a shot at a mammoth million dollar cheque (the prize was faked, naturally). It was only right and proper that the first event, taking place in 1986, was conquered by the day's very best pair: the Road Warriors.

Two further tournaments took place. 1987's bogus windfall was scooped by the team of Dusty Rhodes and Nikita Koloff, the the following year's helped make stars of two top of the NWA's most promising youngsters, Sting and Lex Luger.

Although the three tournaments had drawn thousands of fans to New Orleans, Baltimore and the Carolinas, the annual event was annulled as soon as Crockett sold his assets to TBS. It's understandable Turner wanted to disassociate an expansionist WCW from the small-time stylings of family-run JCP, but couldn't the tournament have been rebranded? It was eventually revived in 2019 as part of a joint alliance between the NWA and ROH.


2. WCW's Relaunch

WCW Reboot 2000
WWE

Years before reboots became the vogue of mainstream cinema, having realised they could re-sell a popular product ad infinitum, they were considered a hallmark of abject failure. A franchise expunging the record books and starting afresh from Year 0 was a tacit admission that their previous creative efforts were garbage.

That was very much the case in April 2000 when, having aligned Vince Russo and Eric Bischoff as a what could very generously be called a booking 'supergroup', WCW decided on a complete do-over. The malaise which beset the company was no secret at this stage, and a reset could do no more harm - especially as the business had more or less gave up the kayfabe ghost.

The 10 April episode of Nitro was promoted as 'The Night the World Will Change'. It did, and then some: every championship was vacated, all current storylines were scrapped, and the twin honchos promised a renewed focus on youth - a coded jibe against the veteran locker room elite who had been running the show.

Leading the new era was a stable of previously downtrodden stars such as Kidman, Rey Mysterio and Booker T, collectively known as New Blood. They were out to end the self-serving reign of the established elite - the so-called 'Millionaires' Club' - once and for all.

And wouldn't it have been wonderful for all involved if they had. Fans bought into the angle - mostly because it was the truth. However, it was that truth which effectively killed it. Pretty soon, New Blood were pivoted into an nWo knockoff, and the ruling class consisting of your Hogans and your Halls was positioned sympathetically. When Jeff Jarrett became the champion of the oppressed, WCW's reboot had effectively failed.


1. The Black Scorpion

black scorpion
WWE.com

Infamously, Hector Guerrero, in an oversized turkey costume, hatched out of an egg at Survivor Series '90, scotching the expectations of those who'd inexplicably expected Ric Flair's arrival. Ironically, this disappointment foreshadowed an actual Flair reveal a month later which delighted few - including the man himself.

In 1989, WCW appointed a new chief executive by the name of Jim Herd. Herd, as a former regional Pizza Hut manager, had few notions of what made the southern promotion tick, and instead wanted to transform it in the same cartoon image as rivals WWF. Only his vision was less Superman, and more the Beano. Frustrated with the new direction, traditionalist booker Ole Anderson started pitching all manner of ludicrous ideas, just to see what he could get away with. One of them stuck.

Starting August 1990, vignettes began airing depicting a hooded figure known as The Black Scorpion. The mystery man croaked that he was a former friend of WCW Champion Sting - and that he was coming to get him.

A little hokey, sure, but nothing like the preposterous drivel Herd had previously insisted upon, and more than enough to have fans intrigued. Could it be Sting's former Powerteam USA partner Dave Sheldon? The gimmick was appropriately eerie for a man known as 'The Angel of Death'. Even more exciting was the suggestion of The Ultimate Warrior, another former tag partner. He was WWE champ at the time - it would have been some coup.

Every conceit was used to conceal the identity of the Scorpion - mostly because Ole had no idea who it'd be. Anderson's voice was distorted for interviews, whilst Al Perez, Jeff Ellis and Sheldon himself cycled through the gimmick in-ring.

In the end, Anderson decided that, as Sting's ex Horsemen teammate, he was the ideal man for the role. That was until he suffered a broken arm in training, and lost interest in the angle entirely. Come Starrcade '90, the idea was hastily brought to its conclusion: if Black Scorpion failed to beat Sting for his championship, he'd be forced to unmask.

Fail he did, and out popped The Nature Boy, then in the midst of a major depush due to personal enmity between himself and Herd. Indeed, so furious was Herd with Anderson's final decision, that he sacked him as head booker.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Sting Goldberg
 
First Posted On: 
Editorial Team
Editorial Team

Benjamin was born in 1987, and is still not dead. He variously enjoys classical music, old-school adventure games (they're not dead), and walks on the beach (albeit short - asthma, you know). He's currently trying to compile a comprehensive history of video game music, yet denies accusations that he purposefully targets niche audiences. He's often wrong about these things.