4 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (15 May - Results & Review)
Royce Keys levels up; Women's division struggles; Trick Williams = top player.
There's a definite freshness to WWE's main roster post-WrestleMania 42 and now Backlash that's hard to deny. On the Raw side, Jacob Fatu gunning for Roman Reigns has been excellent. Over on SmackDown, new arrival Gunther is trying to big league his way to the WWE Title by acting like he, not brand GM Nick Aldis or reigning champ Cody Rhodes, is the one calling the shots.
Both top stories are working, but we need to talk about SmackDown's undercard. It's a bit rough all of a sudden. There are shoots of recovery in the form of star boy Trick Williams as United States Champion, and there could be something to Damian Priest and R-Truth as odd couple tag champs, but that women's division?! Ooft. It ain't great when the storytelling is this wishy washy/weak.
Honestly, give these ladies a fighting chance creative! Expecting them to make magic out of mush is unrealistic, lazy and more than a tad insulting considering the strength in depth around here. Names like Rhea Ripley, Jade Cargill, Charlotte Flair, Alexa Bliss and the recently-returned Paige are knocking around waiting for things to do. Meaningful things to do.
If it wasn't for Jacy Jayne and company in Fatal Influence, then things would be even worse - Jacy, Fallon Henley and Lainey Red didn't really get featured this week though, which added to the problem.
Here's all the good and bad from a Smackers that juggled the next Saturday Night's Main Event and lined up some fare for Clash In Italy at the end of the month.
Downs...
5. Wait, What?! Priest Talks Pure Nonsense!
The crux of Damian Priest's backstage segment with R-Truth was that he can’t trust Royce Keys because Solo Sikoa and the MFTs (which isn’t even really a thing anymore) don’t attack him. Huh? Talla Tonga literally ambushed Royce and Jacob Fatu mere weeks ago. How that slipped the net when writers were formatting these scripts for their own show is anyone's guess.
Priest needs Liv Morgan’s Netflix log-in so he can watch programming back after the fact. Sure, this is the most minor of minor grumbles, but it counts. It's also annoying considering this literally just happened not too long ago. Keys has even spoken about it in follow up promos arguing with Sikoa! Therefore, WWE's writing team don't get a pass in these pages.
It's so, so poor when they fumble things this easy.
You don't even have to dip too far back into the SmackDown archives on WWE's official YouTube channel to see Talla laying out Fatu and Keys. It happened on the 1 May episode of the show. Come on, guys. Pay attention and give fans a reason to care about what these men and women say week to week. Even Truth should've pointed out the flaw in Damian's logic on this occasion.
Post-match with Tama Tonga, Priest fell victim to Solo and Talla. If they so much as dare to suggest that Damian is hot about Royce apparently escaping butt-kickings he's definitely getting after this, then people will have to reason that ChatGPT is steering the ship after all.
ChatGPTrips.
4. This Tag Story Needs Some Movement
Priest vs. Tama Tonga didn’t ever feel like it properly got going before Priest won with South Of Heaven.
It’s weird that much of SmackDown fell right off a cliff after the opener between Trick Williams and The Miz, not least because that match was a placeholder for Trick itself. Yep, Priest needs a new wrinkle going forwards, and Tama’s tension with Solo has been going on far too long without much payoff. It honestly feels like every side of this coin needs some shining.
There was an annoying stumble from Damian when he lost his balance on the top rope before Tonga could cut him off as planned, but they worked through it. That slight botch aside, it's true to moan that the pair lacked true intensity as they were slugging it out. The wheels have come right off Priest as an ongoing concern - he doesn't feel like a main event level star at all now. At times, he's barely thriving on the midcard.
Meanwhile, Tama's drama with Shinsuke Nakamura has been trundling along as a side quest with no light at the end of the tunnel, and there's nothing to him defying Sikoa's orders because Solo has no authority in the eyes of the fanbase. Everything about this match, the backstory behind it and the feuds these guys have going on is paper thin, and that's problematic.
Priest vs. Talla was way better than expected last week, but he couldn't carry that momentum into this bout with Tama on Friday night. That's a pity.
3. Familiar Struggles
It’s almost ironic that Carmelo Hayes was out here with Ricky Saints, because Saints is starting to feel a whole hell of a lot like Melo did when he first landed on the main roster. Sure, the dude’s having solid matches, but he doesn’t feel like a big deal just yet. Saints sort of did when confronting Cody, but since then? Nah.
However, on a much brighter note, Ricky can look sideways at Hayes to see how well things shake out if you stick at it and forge a connection with the crowd. That’s the silver lining here, but it isn’t enough to turn the scenario into an ‘Up’. Another subtle positive would be that Carmelo scored a win and the fans were into him, at least. Again though, nowhere near enough to gush with praise for this.
One of the most obvious issues staring Ricky straight in the face is that he's trying to work a dominant style better associated with bigger workers. Here, he acted like it was Gunther in the ring with Hayes rather than a couple of guys who are zippy and the same size. That was an odd choice. It needs to stop. Maybe things would be different if that style worked for Saints, but it doesn't.
Not on WWE's main roster anyway.
There's plenty of time for the ultra-talented Ricky to get things right, but you've got call 'em how you see 'em sometimes and this was far from his or Melo's best. Fingers crossed they're better prepared and more over (in the case of Saints) when WWE run it back in the future.
2. It’s Official: Women’s Tag Champs Are Dull!
Paige winning during her surprise return at WrestleMania 42 was a cool moment, but her reign with Brie Bella has been dull as dishwater thus far. Look, there was nothing technically wrong with the pair’s tag bout vs. Kiana James and Giulia, but it quietened the crowd early and they didn’t come back up for the babyfaces at all unless Brie was doing her Bryan Danielson bit.
Also, can we just get to the Kiana and Giulia breakup already? What’s the hold up? It’s hardly like they’re over as a double act, so the hesitancy is strange. It should give Triple H and his writers headaches that their split and grudge match could play before crickets in an arena soon. They've done such a poor job with Giulia on the main roster, man, but she hasn't exactly been nailing it on her side either.
Personally, this writer is kinda worried that Brie and Paige could do to the Women’s Tag Title scene what The Wyatt Sicks did to the men’s division. They’ve got it in a chokehold for now, and it’ll be somewhat of a relief when they drop the belts to a better duo. That's sad to say so soon after Paige's grand comeback, but it's the unfortunate truth.
Realistically, those titles were better off on Nia Jax and Lash Legend than Paige and Brie. Bella's promo delivery is some of the worst, and her in-ring work never makes up for that. This whole deal was a total miss and only served to eat up some time on the 3 hour show.
1. Second Women’s Tag Is Seriously Painful
Jade Cargill’s promo about running the women’s division was unconvincing, then Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss vs. Michin and B-FAB played before silence unless Flair was running through some traditional spots. There’s just zero menace to Jade and her crew, and it’s almost impressive that FAB and Michin have made Cargill look less-than when she should've been riding high after turning heel.
Their group also pales in comparison to newcomers like Fatal Influence, and that’s glaringly obvious to everyone other than WWE’s creative team. There was nothing to see here. Not anything worthy, at least. The crowd in South Carolina wanted Rhea Ripley but didn’t get her, and that rendered this entire promo-into-match segment useless.
It was even something Flair and Bliss brought up during a brief exchange backstage later on. They're not sure if they can trust Rhea, but bizarrely spoke about 'Mami' like she's some old pal who has had their backs all along. Erm...the entire plot of their union has been that Charlotte and Ripley don't get along, so why is Flair now pretending to be stunned that Rhea doesn't camp out around ringside for all of her matches?!
The writer who penned that Damian Priest promo must've handled this one too.
Sorry to say this, but it's over for Michin and B-FAB as a tag-team. They offer precious little, and they're not even good backup for Cargill's "I'm THAT Bitch" claims either. Stop this madness and find something else for these women to do, please. This is tortuous. Bringing them together under one roof didn't even make sense in the first place.
Ups...
4. This Is Really Good Character Work
Backstage, a remorseful looking Sami Zayn approached Nick Aldis to say he’s ashamed of himself for his actions during the Backlash match vs. Trick Williams. Then, he asked for a rematch, but Aldis pointed out that Sami’s had his rematch so would need to earn another one. Following that, the lesser spotted Rey Fenix tried to calm Zayn down when he got hot about it.
You just know there's a match coming between those men at some point. Probably when Zayn blows another gasket.
The internal struggle between being a good, honourable person who keeps tripping up and a heelish scumbag is interesting to witness, and Sami is playing it perfectly. Gingerbread Man silliness aside, he’s doing well with this. That story swerve was an unfortunate hiccup, but it looks like WWE will get away with things in the end. Triple H must know by now he can rely on Zayn to produce the goods when it comes to character work.
He's still banging on about his "ride or die" fans who believe that he's a good person, but even that plays before boos when he mentions it. The fact Sami is a cheating heel who claims he's being pushed into doing that by a system rigged against him is fascinating. This is the kind of character development pro wrestling needs more of.
Compare and contrast how compelling Zayn is as a personality next to Fenix. It's night and day. This is how you get people to care about your cast, WWE.
3. Gunther “Overplays His Hand”
Since jumping from Raw to SmackDown, sneering villain Gunther has been messing around making demands of Cody Rhodes and management before signing the contract to wrestle Rhodes at Clash In Italy. Here, Royce Keys came out to sign instead, but Gunther was having none of it. Then, Nick Aldis made that match the main event for SmackDown.
What a neat and tidy twist on the usually lifeless contract signing concept.
It'd be tough to argue against trying something like this, and even being in the mix with guys like Cody and Gunther is a big step up for Keys. Everybody knew he was never winning, but it's still a jump up the card to wrestle someone like the 'Ring General' in a TV headliner. That's way better than slumming it with Solo Sikoa and the MFTs in some lacklustre lower card drama.
Also, why wouldn't somebody try to make a name for themselves by poaching a contract Gunther is refusing to put his name on? If nothing else, Royce bursting out from behind the curtain, staring down a top heel then offering to wrestle for the WWE Title made the belt look cherished and lofty. It should - it's the richest prize in the industry, so everyone should do whatever it takes to hold the thing.
On paper, this segment likely looked kinda throwaway, but it did more for Keys than some may give the promotion credit for. Win or lose, he could only look like a bigger deal by rubbing shoulders with established main event guys.
2. Gunther Gives and Keys Thrives
After that, between the ropes when it counted, both men smashed it.
Gunther is a very giving heel these days, and that's working for him. It makes his matches well-rounded and works a treat when he’s in there with powerhouses like Royce Keys who can realistically push back against his domineering style. This was a high profile position for Keys to be in, and he did well with it. His tale with Solo Sikoa might be lukewarm, but this bout was a legitimately fresh main event for SmackDown and that made for a welcome change of pace.
Gunther was always winning to get to Clash In Italy and that match vs. Cody, but Royce can be proud of his work on Friday night. Cody dropping Gunther post-match was the cherry on top of the cake, because that brought things back round to the real issue: Rhodes fending off a new threat who nonetheless has some history with him in select Royal Rumble matches.
WWE's creative squad deserves praise for booking things this way. Keys got to show out more than he ever could in squashes against stragglers like Los Garza, and Gunther did what he does better than most: He wrestled a robust match with some cool twists and turns before a conclusive finish.
Then, right at the end of SmackDown, WWE put a bow on the upcoming Clash In Italy main event. They're really doing a wonderful job with these World Title storylines, and that should be spotlighted. It isn't always the case.
1. Hot Homecoming For Trick Willy
SmackDown opened with a fairly by the numbers opening promo segment between Trick Williams, Lil Yachty, The Miz and Kit Wilson, but that’s not a complaint. It’s amazing what a hot live crowd can do to elevate this sort of stuff, and South Carolina was on fire for Trick. He came across as an absolute star from start to finish, and it’s tough to deny that it was a vast improvement over the crappy Gingerbread Man stuff with Sami Zayn.
There was even a “Trick For President” sign around ringside.
The follow up match with Miz was functional too, but again, that isn’t meant to sound bad. The Miz is perfect for this sort of role, and it’s clear that WWE plan to strap a rocket to Williams as United States Champion. He was booked to be at least one step ahead of Miz at all times. Well, unless Kit was interfering from ringside. Wilson then found himself totally nullified by Yachty and some well-placed weapon shots to the spine.
There's a certain unique joy to be found when rising stars are in their home market and have some friends/family in attendance. You could see just how proud Trick felt as he was working in front of his parents. That's a memorable moment for the man. Well played, sir. This was how you bounce back from the tepid Gingerbread Man fluff in a hurry. Simple, straightforward, to the point and never anything but entertaining to watch.
Good stuff, people. Good stuff indeed.
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestlers WWE Protected In The WORST Way Possible and 8 New Directions For WWE After Backlash 2026!