8 Babyfaces The WWE Universe Turned Heel

With Cena and Reigns polarising fans, here are eight good guys turned bad by the audience.

Batista promo 2014
WWE.com

Times, they are a changing. Back in the 1970s and '80s, the good guys were cheered vociferously by the audience, as the right morals and ethics reigned supreme over the dastardly villains. Men like Hulk Hogan, Tito Santana, and The Ultimate Warrior entered arenas to deafening cheers because of their apparent desire to fight for good.

In the late 1990s, the anti-hero began to take over. The clean-cut babyface was no longer in fashion and WWE was somewhat late to the party, still trying to introduce vanilla heroes to the fans with the rationale of "well, it worked in the past". Luckily the penny eventually dropped, and the Attitude Era gave rise to such babyface stars as Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock, and Triple H.

Of course, the one thing we learn from history is that we don't learn from history, and WWE is no different in this regard. Roman Reigns is the latest babyface to be forced down the throats of the WWE Universe with the audience not being shy about their disapproval. It's been going on for what... four years now? Yup: WWE don't know their history.

Reigns hasn't officially turned heel, but a number of times in WWE history the audience's disapproval of a babyface has actively led to a switch in allegiance. Here are eight such times.

8. The New Day

The New Day Debut
WWE

After a few weeks of vignettes, The New Day finally arrived on our screens way back at the end of November 2014. Some were hoping that Kofi Kingston, Xavier Woods, and Big E. would return as some sort of Nation of Domination-type faction, despite how silly that would be in the modern age.

Instead, what we got was a whole lot of smiling, clapping, and positive feeling, which combined well with the mass eye-rolling from the audience. From the very beginning, the group as a happy-clappy babyface trio was dead in the water, but it took a long time for the creative team to latch onto this.

The audience rejected them immediately, and by the middle of 2015 the group had little choice but to turn heel. Since then, they've consistently been one of the most entertaining aspects of WWE TV - ironically leading back to a full-blown face realignment, which they've maintained ever since, selling pancakes and setting records along the way.


7. Eva Marie

Eva Marie WrestleMania RAW
WWE.com

In truth, this entry could just be every single time WWE tried to position Eva Marie as a babyface. It simply couldn't work; someone with so little aptitude for professional wrestling was never going to get over as a fan favourite, and the WWE Universe rightly dumped on it every single time.

The funny thing was that each face turn for Eva Marie came as part of a big return to the roster, the most egregious example being prior to WrestleMania 32 in 2016. Marie was revealed as the final piece in the 10-Diva tag match, fighting on the face side. I mean, I say the face side, but it included Brie Bella and Alicia Fox, so who truly knows.

The WWE audience forced Eva Marie to turn heel every time she was even vaguely introduced as a babyface, and rightly so. Eventually, the company just gave up and released her last June.


6. Alberto Del Rio

Alberto Del Rio Heel Turn
wwe.com

Alberto Del Rio's good guy run as World Heavyweight Champion in late 2012 started off well enough, as the Mexican Aristocrat showed great babyface fire in defeating the Big Show in his Last Man Standing match. ADR was all set for a big WrestleMania feud against newly-xenophobic Jack Swagger before the All-American American decided to get arrested.

From then on ADR's face character was dead in the water, not helped by the fact uber-popular heel Dolph Ziggler was Mr. Money in the Bank at the time. When the heel Ziggler cashed in on prone babyface Del Rio the night after WrestleMania 29, the entire arena went mad with joy, the final nail in the Alberto Del Rio babyface coffin.

The audience had rejected Del Rio as a face in favour of an opportunistic heel. A heel turn for Del Rio was the only way out.


5. Santino Marella

Santino Marella Home Crowd
wwe.com

As his WWE career came to an end, we the audience got used to Santino Marella as a lovable comedic babyface character. He had played that role for a few years, turning up whenever the mood needed to be lightened or someone needed to be hit with the Cobra.

It is easy to forget, however, that when Santino Marella first arrived on the main roster he did so as a hometown hero, plucked from obscurity (well, the Milan crowd) to defeat Umaga for the Intercontinental Championship. His 'hometown' crowd went wild as the Milan Miracle made the most of a Lashley interference to win gold on his first night.

The problem was that once that novelty had worn off, the fans utterly despised him. Outside of the shock debut bubble, Marella was a joke, and when Umaga destroyed him to win the IC Championship back the crowd cheered along with the Samoan Savage.

A heel turn was the only option.


4. Bret Hart

bret hart canada
WWE.com

It wasn't a completely international heel turn, but in 1997 Bret Hart turned on the fans of the United States of America due to a perceived lack of respect shown. The storyline reason for the turn was fairly accurate, but the truth was that after a singles babyface run that had lasted five years, fans had seriously soured on the Excellence of Execution.

Bret was a modern wrestler with a traditional mind, a fairly vanilla babyface covered in a layer of bitterness and disdain. The times were changing and the WWE audience were more excited to see a particular anti-hero rising through the ranks, and more willing to cheer nihilistic anarchy as opposed to excellence.

The crowd turned on Bret, and a heel turn was the only way to go. The turn was masterfully pulled off in one of the greatest WrestleMania matches of all time: the famous submission match against Stone Cold Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13.


3. Randy Orton

Randy Orton 2004
WWE.com

This one was something of a misguided decision by WWE creative. Randy Orton experienced one heck of a rise in 2004, starting the year a bland nobody before benefiting hugely from a fabulous feud with Mick Foley. His rise continued all the way to SummerSlam that year, where he defeated Chris Benoit for the World Heavyweight Championship and became the youngest champion in the process.

The crowd were firmly behind Orton on that night in Toronto, and WWE took this as a sign to move ahead with plans to turn him babyface. The turn came the next night on RAW, as Orton was betrayed by his buddies in Evolution.

The problem was that that the Toronto crowd was firmly based in Bizarroland, and Orton as a face was as bland and generic as they came. The crowd turned on him practically instantly, and once he dropped the title to Triple H it was back to the bad side for the Legend Killer.


2. Batista

Batista Quits Raw 2014
WWE.com

Batista returned to WWE to much fanfare in 2014, having left whilst arguably doing his best work four years earlier in 2010. The Animal was back, and he immediately made an impact by winning the Royal Rumble and going on to main event WrestleMania XXX. Sounds like a pretty fantastic return, right?

Well, the only problem was that Batista was brought back as a babyface. Vince McMahon was probably the only individual interested in seeing Batista as a face in 2014, and the crowd, furious their real hero Daniel Bryan had been snubbed, subsequently took a collective dump all over Big Dave's grand return.

Once a planned program with Alberto Del Rio was completed, Batista settled into a de facto heel role before completing his turn in time for the triple threat match at WrestleMania. He took the fall in that match, and this was another victory for the WWE Universe.


1. Rocky Maivia

Rocky Maivia The Rock
WWE.com

It is unlikely that there will ever be a more famous example of a crowd turning on a babyface in WWE history. Heck, these days Dwayne Johnson is the highest paid actor in Hollywood and a future WWE Hall of Famer. It is a far cry from his tentative first steps into the professional wrestling world as Rocky Maivia.

Rocky Maivia was introduced to the then-WWF world as a third generation blue chipper, all smiles and clean-cut image. He was literally referred to as 'The Blue Chipper', which pretty much guarantees a crowd turning against someone. His wrestling inexperience certainly didn't help, and this combined with a change in attitudes from wrestling audiences made chants of "Die Rocky, Die" an inevitability.

Well, that's somewhat dramatic but it is what it is. The audience turned on Maivia with a vitriol not seen before, and watching the young third-generation star try to grit his teeth and smile through it was painful to say the least. Luckily for him, it didn't last forever.

WWE had no choice but to turn him heel, which they did by aligning Maivia with the Nation of Domination. Rocky Maivia was dead, to be replaced by The Rock. The rest is history.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Batista
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.