8 Problems Dixie Carter Won't Admit About TNA

Why the president is in denial as TNA lurches towards its inevitable death.

Unfortunately, for all their positive contributions to the wrestling world (namely preventing the WWE from enjoying a total monopoly), TNA have suffered their fair share of unflattering incidents. The company look to be in serious trouble regarding their current TV deal situation, and - although president Dixie Carter wouldn't admit it - do suffer from a lot of problems. The heir of Panda Energy convinced her parents to buy a majority share in TNA, before appointing herself president in 2003. The Texas native inherited a company with numerous existing flaws, but also a great deal of potential, boasting a deep (if unproven) talent pool and a distinctively separate style to the WWE. However, over the past decade or so, the negative aspects of the promotion have come to outweighed its positive attributes. Not all of these can be directly linked to Dixie. Many issues are deep-rooted, running all the way back to the very beginnings of TNA. However, Carter herself is the sole figure with the power to fix such catastrophic errors, and has sadly failed to do so throughout her tenure. Here are eight major problems with TNA Dixie Carter will never admit, regardless of how bleak things currently look for the company.

8. It Can't Compete With Ring Of Honor

The most immediate problem facing TNA is Destination America's ominous decision to bring Ring Of Honor on board, airing the hour before Impact Wrestling. Simply put, TNA can't compete. ROH benefits from a generally superior roster, more sensible, conventional storytelling, and an air of legitimacy a president such as Dixie Carter immediately dispels. ROH also benefits from a feeling of freshness - they've never had TV deal of this scale before, bringing a host of relatively unknown faces to a whole new audience. TNA, on the other hand, have appeared on television for over a decade now, and are largely thought of as a laughing stock due to their history of blunders and unprofessional behaviour. It seems only a matter of time until they finally bite the bullet, and Ring Of Honor take their place as the second biggest promotion in wrestling.

7. Unprofessionalism

From failing to pay employees on time to the infamous Victory Road 2011 main event, TNA has a history of unprofessional incidents which can't help but paint the company in a bad light. The Victory Road incident saw Jeff Hardy show up to compete against Sting while clearly under the influence of drugs. He was sent out to compete anyway, despite this being an utterly ridiculous, dangerous decision. Sting wisely ended the match as quickly as possible, holding a defiant Hardy's shoulders to the mat under 90 seconds into the bout. Paying fans, both those who bought the PPV and the crowd in attendance, were robbed of a main event, and "refunded" with 6 months free access to TNA's online on-demand service. A more recent (but equally unacceptable) incident came in mid-2014, when it was revealed that Vince Russo had been working for TNA as a consultant, despite Dixie Carter being specifically instructed not to rehire him by Spike TV. The whole thing was a huge cover-up, blown only when Russo accidentally CCd an email to a PWInsider journalist. To make matters even worse, it emerged that TNA had lied to their business partners and roster about Russo's employment in order to keep it a secret.

6. Booking Is Convoluted And Lacks Continuity

It would take a far longer article than this to chronicle TNA's many questionable booking decisions, but enough examples exist to suggest that ideas are often allowed to thrive despite lacking a clear logic or consistency. From ridiculous stipulations (such as the 'Feast Or Fired' briefcase, in which one of the winners is rewarded by having their contract terminated) to the constant need for an NWO-aping heel stable, the promotion often resembles WCW in its dying days. In 2014 TNA's booking was also accused of unoriginality, with the promotion making bearded underdog Eric Young their World Champion shortly after the WWE had done the same with Daniel Bryan. Dixie herself played the role of Stephanie McMahon, albeit in a far less convincing manner.

5. It Has A History Of Offensive Storylines

Racism, sexism, homophobia and general tastelessness; TNA has long been familiar with a wide range of controversial subjects in their angles. The rebranding of Samoa Joe, an immensely talented worker who never relied on his heritage to get over, as an ultraviolent savage was particularly unwise, but even more flagrant examples peppered the company's earlier years. The Dupps were a heel tag team whose gimmick solely revolved around the fact that they were a pair of effeminate gay men, while women have always been portrayed in a shallow, objectifying light (even by the wrestling industry's ropey standards). In recent months, the company looked to have shaken off its needlessly controversial tagline - only to introduce an angle in which James Storm knocked Mickie James onto a railroad track, presumably killing her in cold blood.

4. Homegrown Talent Has Constantly Been Neglected

For all its flaws, TNA has launched the careers of many a fantastic wrestler. AJ Styles, Bobby Roode, James Storm and Frankie Kazarian all made their names in the promotion, and are all invaluable parts of TNA history. However, each should have achieved far more than they have done, and surely would have were it not for TNA's constant neglect. The company has always favoured older, less talented names over their loyal homegrown workers, almost as a rule. The company's early years were dominated by Jeff Jarrett (coincidentally the son of then-promotor Jerry Jarrett) Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, while recent times have seen Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair and Sting rule the roost. Inevitably, the big names didn't exactly prove the most loyal or reliable of workers, many heading straight back to the WWE as soon as Vince came calling. TNA are certainly feeling the effects now, with Styles finally losing patience and jumping ship to NJPW, leaving a host of partially-developed names and complete unknowns behind.

3. It's Overly Reliant Upon Ex-WWE Stars

The TNA roster has always been swamped with WWE cast-offs, unable to resist the temptation of parading a recognisable face for the crowd. Usually unveiled after a great deal of hype, perennial midcarders such as Mr Anderson and Bully Ray are rewarded with TNA World Championship reigns and constant main event programmes. While this is obviously damaging in the same way as an over-reliance on past stars, taking attention and acclaim away from homegrown talent, it also firmly establishes TNA as inferior to the WWE. In pushing mediocre stars such as MVP and the ever-unprofessional Jeff Hardy to the moon, the promotion always appear to be admitting an inability to stand on their own two feet.

2. Mistreatment Of Employees

It was mentioned previously that TNA has a history of failing to pay its workers, but allegations of questionable treatment don't stop there - just as Jesse Sorensen. The flashy X-Divison star was severely injured in a match with Zema Ion, sidelining him for at least a year. Dixie personally promised that Sorensen would always have a place in TNA, as they were not a promotion in the business of firing injured wrestlers. Sorensen was given a role on the production team...and subsequently released. As for Zema, he had earlier been diagnosed with a bladder tumour requiring removal - a procedure TNA refused to pay for. Ion even reportedly suffered abuse backstage for "making the company look bad".

1. Dixie Lets Her Ego Get In The Way

Not only did Dixie start off with very little basic knowledge of the business, she immediately established herself as a figure of hate for wrestling fans everywhere, publicly likening her promotion's fanbase to the Steve Carrell's '40 Year Old Virgin' character. Another PR disaster came after the ill-advised decision to promote an #AskDixie hashtag on Twitter inevitably backfired, one which inevitably resulted in swathes of abuse from disgruntled fans. Carter then went on to establish herself as a major onscreen figure. First appearing as a good-natured face, then an evil authority figure in the mould of Vince McMahon, Dixie has lowered the quality of her company's televised product for the past couple of years now. Her feud with MVP (of all people) for control of the company was bad enough - a programme which the former WWE midcarder perhaps didn't take entirely seriously - but even after "losing" her position as director she refused to step away from TV screens. Dixie's next rivalry was with the Dudleys, who eventually gave the fans a small degree of satisfaction by putting her through a table. Now, as TNA continues to die a slow death, the promotion simply must correct these major problems or face its demise. Unfortunately, with Carter at the helm, this looks an unlikely prospect.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.