8 Things About Wrestling That Just Don’t Make Sense

He's on the ground out cold, why are you dancing? Pin him! Pin him!

We've all had those moments when you're sat there watching wrestling and then something happens that just makes you think to yourself €œHang on a minute, this doesn€™t make any sense whatsoever!€ It might be that you've spotted a severe flaw in the rules that the wrestlers seem completely oblivious to. Or perhaps a wrestler€™s actions in the ring are just baffling. And sometimes you€™re just left wondering how some fairly simple moves can end up being so devastating to an opponent. Obviously in most of these cases the reason behind these seemingly unexplainable instances is that they are done in the name of entertainment. We all know that in any wrestling match we watch the two wrestlers in the ring are working together in order to put on a convincing show for the audience rather than actually trying to hurt each other (although as Lewis Howse€™s excellent article earlier in the year pointed out, this isn€™t necessarily always the case!). For this reason we, as wrestling fans, allow ourselves to accept that what is going on in the ring is real as it adds to our enjoyment of the show. We let ourselves believe that the two co-workers who hang out together backstage actually hate each other guts and are trying to beat the hell out of each other. However there are some things that happen all too often in wrestling that take you right out of the moment and makes it all too obvious that what is happening in front of you is just for show. This article outlines 8 of these instances that frankly don€™t make any sense.

8. Titles Don't Change Hands Following A Disqualification

One of the rules creative writers in wrestling like to capitalise on all the time is that if a champion loses a title match via disqualification they still remain champion. This allows them to let the champion retain their title, whilst at the same time making the challenger look strong as a result of having not lost. It is a ploy often used to allow feuds to continue longer, as a rematch usually follows at the next PPV, often with higher stakes €“ a No DQ match or a Hell in a Cell match for instance. More often than not the standard formula for this to happen is when a cowardly heel champion is defending their title against a babyface wrestler. Just as the babyface challenger is looking like they€™re about to win, one of the heel€™s faction comes in and attacks them (or the heel lands a low blow) resulting in a disqualification and the heel leaves with their title. The heel champion then celebrates the victory and talks the next night on Raw about how it was a cunning move on their part, because they would do ANYTHING to retain their title. That€™s all well and good and from a storyline perspective makes for entertaining viewing. However the whole concept is very flawed. If it was the heel€™s plan to cheat all along why do they wait nearly half an hour until they€™re about to lose before executing the plan. Especially if they€™re a cowardly heel who every time they€™ve been in the ring one on one with their opponent in the build-up they€™ve, to paraphrase J.R., €œran like a scalded dog€, then why on the night of the PPV do they suddenly decide not to chicken out right away? It just doesn€™t make sense!

7. Manager Are Allowed At Ringside

Continuing with the theme of disqualifications, why is it that managers/tag team partners are still allowed at ringside during matches? It is almost a given in wrestling that if a manager is at ringside then they will, at some point in the match, illegally interfere. Often they interfere by distracting the referee on their client€™s behalf, allowing the client the use a foreign object or to recover after a high impact move. Again, from a storyline perspective, this all makes perfect sense as if often adds suspense to the closing stages of a match. However when you take a step back everything crumbles. We€™ve seen on numerous occasions that the referee has the power to send managers away from ringside and yet it doesn€™t happen nearly as often as it should and the manager is allowed to distract the referee several times per match. Taking a further step back, why are managers even allowed out there in the first place? You would think with the amount of the matches that have been influenced over the years by managers being present the referees might have got together backstage one day and decided to ban these people that distract them from doing their job. After all we€™ve seen referees blamed and in some instances fired by characters in authority for allowing these distractions to influence matches, so why are they risking their livelihoods to let managers stand at ringside? It just doesn€™t make sense!

6. The Royal Rumble Rules Are Full Of Loopholes

The Royal Rumble match is one of the highlights of the WWE calendar every year, with 30-men battling it out in a Battle Royal match to earn a title shot at Wrestlemania. There is one key rule to this match €“ If you are thrown over the top rope and both your feet touch the ground then you are eliminated. Unfortunately this seems to be the ONLY rule in the match which poses a number of questions about the intelligence of the wrestlers involved in the match. Take a typical Royal Rumble match for instance. Wrestlers #1 and #2 get into the ring and the match starts. After a minute the buzzer sounds and out comes Wrestler #3. Now if you€™re Wrestler #3 and your dream is to compete in the main event at Wrestlemania then what incentive is there for you to actually get into the ring so early on in the match? There just isn't any! Or indeed let€™s look at another example of being able to exploit the lack of rules that some wrestlers actually do take advantage of (but not often enough for us not to still question their intelligence). If things get too heated in the ring then why not exit throw the bottom ropes and give yourself time to recover? There is no penalty for doing this and also no limit to the number of times you can leave during the match. The 1999 Royal Rumble is a prime example of this flaw, with Vince McMahon winning the match despite leaving the ring on numerous occasions, even joining the commentary team at one point! The annoying thing about this lack of rules is that it is an easily fixable problem that won€™t change the Royal Rumble match in any way other than to increase its legitimacy. Simply introduce these two simple rules: - A Wrestler who doesn€™t enter the ring before the next participant enters gets eliminated (this rule could even be used to add suspense if a popular babyface is attacked on his way to the ring and has to fight off his attackers to make it into the ring in time). - Wrestlers are eliminated if they exit the ring (without going over the top rope) more than twice and also if they don€™t re-enter the ring within a minute of leaving it. Problem solved!

5. Attempting Quick Pinfalls In Heated Grudge Matches

This is the one thing in wrestling that annoys me more than most. It is something that happens all the time and, unlike most of the other entries on this list, doesn€™t even make sense from a creative point of view. In fact if anything it takes away from the storyline and the excitement of the match. So here€™s the scenario, you have two wrestlers that hate each other within the storyline (or in real life if their names are Edge and Matt Hardy). You start building a feud between them. €œI€™m going to kill you for not inviting me to your birthday party!€ one might scream at the other one week. The next week the other will yell back €œI€™m going to take my time punishing you for those rude remarks you made about my granny!€ (admittedly there€™s a reason why I€™m not writing storylines for WWE). This goes on and on for weeks with both wrestlers threatening to show no mercy and beat their opponent to a pulp. Then the night of their PPV match finally arrives and two minutes into the match one of the wrestlers tries to win with a roll-up pin! What happened to the long drawn out punishment you promised? This is the man that abducted your pet turtle €˜Herman€™ for crying out loud! Why are you trying to let him off the hook this easily?! It just doesn€™t make sense!

4. Wrestlers Who Can't Climb Ladders

There are many great mysteries in life. Why are we here? What is our purpose? Why was The Miz ever a WWE Champion? There is one great mystery however that pops its head up all the time in wrestling that nobody knows the answer to €“ Why do wrestlers not know how to climb a ladder? Every wrestling fan, at some point in their life, has presumably seen a ladder match. During their first time watching such a match I wouldn€™t doubt that every wrestling fan probably wondered why watching the wrestlers€™ woeful attempts to master the art of ladder climbing only served to remind them of the scene in €˜Bambi€™ when Bambi first learns how to walk. However the thing that is most frustrating about this apparent inability to climb a ladder isn€™t just the fact that we assume they are much better at it. It€™s the fact that, more often than not, we €œknow€ that they are more than capable of doing it because of the way they flew up the ladder in the early stages of the match when they wanted to jump off it onto their opponent! It€™s not until later in the match, perhaps after one too many shots to the head, they seem to forget everything they ever knew about ladders. Hell, some of them even struggle when it comes to setting the ladder up! It just doesn€™t make sense!

3. Some Wrestlers' Finishers Are Truly Pathetic

There are some impressive, high-impact finishers in wrestling that genuinely look like they are capable of inflicting great pain on an opponent (check out Alexander Podgorski€™s article for a superb list of some of these moves). Then there are also some brilliant submission manoeuvres which at times look like they could amputate an opponent€™s limb. Given this impressive array of moves some wrestlers display it remains baffling how some fairly tame looking finishers are portrayed as causing such damage. Let€™s start with everyone€™s favourite scapegoat Roman Reigns. As all wrestlers do, Roman will throw the occasional punch at his opponents causing them to stagger, or at most knock them off their feet briefly. So why is it then that simply jumping in the air before throwing his a punch, as he does when performing his €˜Superman Punch€™ finisher, seems to result in some sort of Mike Tyson-esque knockout blow that devastates his opponent? Although at least Roman has the decency to jump before throwing his punch. Big Show€™s €˜Knockout Punch€™ on the other hand is just a simple punch to the head. A basic punch! A move so simple you can perform it with any wrestler in WWE 2K15 by pressing the €˜strike€™ button! Why are we supposed to believe that this is such a painful move when punches are thrown all the time in wrestling with very little impact? Even two of the greatest wrestlers of all-time €“ Hulk Hogan and The Rock €“ have finishers which, when you think about it, are pretty pathetic. Leg drops are performed all the time in wrestling with minimal effect, however not when it€™s Hogan€™s €˜Atomic leg drop€™. Maybe it€™s just his technique, eh? The Rock€™s legendary €œPeople€™s Elbow€ a move that we all grew up thinking was one of the coolest moves we€™d ever seen, is just essentially just an overly elaborate elbow drop. And yet people almost never kicked out of either move! It just doesn€™t make sense!

2. Submission Rope Breaks Make The Move Look Fake

The ability to end a submission manoeuvre by reaching the ropes is key in wrestling as it gives wrestlers a method of breaking out of a hold without actually having to physically break the hold. In theory this makes perfect sense, after all you wouldn€™t want to make a wrestlers submission finisher seem weak by having it countered all the time and so rope breaks allow the submission to be released whilst still maintaining the impression that it is difficult to escape from. Where this idea is let down however is in its execution. Chris Jericho€™s €˜Walls of Jericho€™ submission finisher is perhaps one of the best examples of this point. When Jericho locks in this submission hold in order for his opponent to reach the ropes to break the hold, Jericho has to move to the ropes with him. Even if you are open minded enough to believe that the opponent has the strength to force Jericho over to the ropes with him, the problem arises because of the fact that the move requires Jericho takes a number of very obvious and blatant steps backwards in order to allow his opponent to reach the ropes, which just results in making the move look fake. John Cena€™s €˜STF/STFU€™ is another prime example of this. Whilst you don€™t often see it because of some greater camerawork, or indeed because opponents rarely escape the move (Cena wins LOL), Cena has to actively crawl with his opponent towards the ropes in order for the opponent to reach them. Walking backwards is one thing, but to physically crawl with your opponent to the ropes? There€™s no way of disguising the effort required to do that. And yet despite Cena doing this we are still supposed to believe that he€™s trying to hurt his opponent? It just doesn€™t make sense!

1. Choosing The Weakest Wrestlers As Bodyguards

Here€™s a hypothetical situation for you: It is the 2nd of June, 2014 and you are future WWE champion Seth Rollins. You have just betrayed your closest allies The Shield and aligned yourself with The Authority. Over the next couple of months you make a lot more enemies than friends and eventually you decide that you would like some bodyguards to help protect yourself. Who do you pick? Well it€™s obvious isn€™t it? You pick two former wrestlers who spent most of their WWE careers getting beaten up by a bunch of mid-card talent. Nobody is going to mess with you now surely! Hang on a second€ This is another of those odd things that happens all the time in wrestling that always seems just a bit too strange. Yes, from a creative point of view it makes some sense to use talent, that might otherwise not receive any screen time, as supporting characters for a main superstar. However from a storyline point of view? I mean are we really supposed to believe that wrestlers like Seth Rollins are any better off by hanging out with a few guys who get their asses handed to them every time they try to offer protection? It just doesn€™t make sense!

In this post: 
AJ Lee
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Sports betting enthusiast whose main interests are rugby, football and MMA. Also a huge WWE fan and a self diagnosed TV & movies addict, with a particular love of anything Marvel or Dan Harmon related.