8 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (November 29 - Results & Review)
Eddie Kingston brings the sport, MJF goes back to basics on a quietly encouraging Dynamite.
The Continental Classic didn't fail to launch, exactly - God bless Eddie Kingston and Brody King for grasping the do-or-die importance of tournament wrestling in their fabulous Collision main event - but last week's round of Dynamite fixtures was hardly great.
Is that pedantic, fickle?
AEW dreamt up a major tournament in a format that fans have requested since 2019, mandated clean finishes, and generally went with the sports-oriented presentation that critics have missed in recent months. Still, the execution was lacking.
Swerve Strickland Vs. Jay Lethal was fine, but opening the broadcast and tournament with the most obvious pin-eater in the field was uninspiring. Jay White went over Rush in a better match that still wouldn't trouble TV Match of the Year rankings. It was only easy to feel something when Mark Briscoe threatened to survive Jon Moxley, but Tony Khan didn't opt for Gedo's tone-setting early twist.
What was special, exactly, about watching some very good if predictable matches, each resulting in the expected outcome? Beyond the sports entertainmentification of AEW, that is still the quintessential Dynamite experience most weeks.
Was last night's Gold League a little more glittering...?
Downs...
2. They Simply Do Not Care Or Try
It's never going to get any better, is it?
The AEW women's division is a cliché that is now descending far beyond parody. It is the easiest game of bingo ever called.
This 'Down', it should be stated, has little to do with the efforts of the women involved, though Julia Hart Vs. perennial loser Emi Sakura was hardly outstanding. Some of Hart's strikes looked far too gentle, and it looked as though Sakura, the veteran, had to roll into the moonsault finish, making it look like an ill-fated reversal attempt, to prevent Hart from missing it entirely.
The entry has everything to do with how apathetic this all is and will continue to be. There's just a criminal lack of thought and passion. Emi Sakura is a great wrestler, but she functions exclusively to eat pins for new champions attempting to "establish" their reign.
Was Nyla Rose too busy? How about Marina Shafir?
There's always next week. You'll fill that line soon enough. Everybody wins at AEW women's division bingo, except the women. This is Kris Statlander's reign, already, again. In AEW, various women simply play the role of "Person we book because we have to, for the optics".
1. The Devil Is Still Less Than Terrifying
MJF cut a good and sorely needed promo, more on which later, but the post-match was lame.
He was attacked by the Devil's stablemates or henchmen or whatever. They're about as intimidating and over as the Dark Order creepers of 2019, and that they look visually identical (albeit a bit more ripped) is less than ideal.
Samoa Joe stormed the ring to protect MJF, who he wants at his best ahead of Worlds End. While that made sense, the Devil and his cohorts badly, desperately need credibility. They should have kicked seven bells of sh*t out of MJF a while ago. Then again, with this presentation, would it matter?
The lights flickered on and off ahead of their arrival. The Devil, via text scroll on the big screen, then requested a tag match with MJF and Joe next week. The AEW commentary team let viewers know that AEW's security team believe that the broadcast had been compromised or hacked "internally". Was this welcome confirmation that there is so supernatural bullsh*t afoot?
Possibly, but it's still very lame either way.
Ups...
8. A Nice Moment
People still want AEW to be great. People are still fighting for it. One of the reasons why is that AEW is often just a plain nice promotion that does nice things for its talent.
Dante Martin returned, somehow, from an injury in which his foot turned backwards just this past spring. He did so in his home state. As a result, the match was overflowing with lovely vibes, and, considering the 2023 Hardy Boyz were in it, exciting fast-paced action. You'll have seen hundreds of better trios matches than this, but in a weird, roundabout way, the Hardys being so slow enhanced the drama.
More than once, they arrived late on the scene to break up pin attempts, but the result was something closer to "2.9 ad infinitum" than perhaps intended. Which is good. A happy accident.
That, or their timing was spot-on, and it was simply hard to believe that they'd get there on time. Being the Hardys in 2023.
Either way!
The match was built entirely around Dante, rightfully so, and he looked remarkably sharp and at ease during his two exhilarating hot tags and a neat sequence in which he took a Hardy Party tandem move and looked close to defeat.
They crafted a touch more drama than you'd expect, given there was only one finish here.
7. Might As Well
To keep Wardlow in the mix and to remind fans that he remains a threat to MJF, he squashed AR Fox. It was fine, mostly, although his catch of Fox's run-up moonsault was class. Elsewhere, it was the usual Wardlow squash.
He defeated Fox via Powerbomb Symphony knockout which, if nothing else, is a timely reminder that MJF is susceptible to that move.
6. A Better Night For MJF
MJF has tried to score volleys from 40 yards over the past few months.
Mystery angles, the most fighting from underneath performance ever, attempting to focus on and build multiple World title challengers: he has strained under the weight of his own ambition. He hadn't hit the target in a while, but on last night's Dynamite, he calmly rolled one in with a strong, basics-forward promo that acted as a reminder that, if all people want him to do is sell a fight, he can do that with the best of them.
He put over Samoa Joe huge as a founding father of modern wrestling and a man better than every promoter he worked for (other than Gabe Sapolsky, you'd imagine). He then put himself over, promising not to win but to fight like hell, which was refreshing. They aren't signposting this like they did the Jay White Full Gear match. He then snapped his walking cane to a huge reaction.
"You're good, I'm better" is the simplest pro wrestling promo, and on a night that mostly seemed aware that crawling can be beautiful, and didn't run away with itself, MJF cut a damn good one. The Devil stuff remains...eurgh.
5. That's More Like It
Jon Moxley Vs. Jay Lethal was not a hugely exciting prospect.
Lethal exists to eat pins, Mox after four outstanding years is starting to wear a look of familiarity, and they wrestled more than once last year. The match promised "good" at a time when fans are questioning if AEW can ever again become hot, must-see, great.
This match wasn't blow-away great, but the key story thread was welcome and worked twofold. Mox tweaked his knee early in the match in a gnarly, believable looking spot when he crashed from the apron to the floor, still trapped in a figure-four leg lock. This ugly, awkward clash of limbs informed the most basic but in this case necessary story. Mox, invincible and double tough, has felt less human than ever in 2023 (in AEW, anyway). Through the trappings of the charmless Blackpool Combat Club, his toughness has become his defining characteristic. Here, he was vulnerable and sympathetic. His selling was authentic. It was easy and rewarding to actually feel something for him again.
He got over so much in AEW originally because he was a charming man smarter than the rest. He twice outwitted Lethal by baiting the leg, and glimpsing the Mox of old elevated the easiest story in wrestling.
Secondly, the idea that injuries can be used as stakes in a sporting context should add some much-needed, tournament-specific heft to the Continental Classic. Can Mox make it to the final?
That felt like a formality last week. Now, perhaps, it's not so obvious.
The finish brought that all into question - that was some recovery from Mox, worryingly - but this, in every which way, was a lot more like it.
4. AEW Brings The SPORT
Selling the frustration of defeat, which should always matter but should especially matter in the context of a big tournament, Eddie Kingston cut a promo taped immediately after his defeat to Brody King at Collision.
This was great. AEW should capture more comments made in the immediate aftermath of a match. Kingston looked battered and gutted. He felt like he'd just taken a beating. He felt real, and so did his words. He punished himself for his arrogance in a super effective means of drawing sympathy without making any excuses.
He put his titles on the line, and he's "behind the eight ball" already. But he won't feel sorry for himself, even though he has the formidable challenge of Bryan Danielson waiting this Saturday.
Danielson was priceless on commentary in response. He told Eddie off for feeling sorry for himself and entering the match with the wrong attitude. Unlike Eddie, he's in it to win it, injuries be damned.
Injury threatening a contender. A sentimental favourite suffering a crisis in confidence, concerns over form. A heavy, cocky favourite you want to see knocked off their f*cking perch.
That's sport, and AEW nailed it across the first 20 minutes of Dynamite.
3. A Deliberately AND Accidentally Good Match
Mark Briscoe and Rush were well on their way to putting on a fabulous match before they had a very different but no less engrossing match by accident.
Unless he was selling, and strap him up as the top babyface if he was, Rush suffered some sort of injury to his leg early in a match that, prior to the defining moment, was an awesome hard-hitting sprint premised on the simple, glorious idea that the winner would be the man who beat the other to a pulp as quickly as possible. An injury is always unfortunate, but it was particularly unfortunate here. It's very rare that a back-and-forth US TV match is worked so well that you can buy it ending within five minutes.
The injury slowed everything down, but Briscoe, who you could call a master with no hyperbole whatsoever, sold so well that it never really felt like he was waiting around for Rush to flood himself with adrenaline. Briscoe also took a demented header to the floor from an apron suplex, which helped the match retain its realistic feel. In an awesome moment, Rush, injury and all, hit his finish so well that it turned Bryan Danielson into an animal on commentary.
That display of guts will ironically only help Rush, whom fans are already embracing as a cool, super credible human shotgun.
Briscoe lost, which is a shame and, potentially, a strategic error. There are few better babyfaces in all of wrestling and he's a quarter hour hitter, too. Here's hoping he gets a big, shocking win late to set up a PPV rematch.
2. A Fitting Main Event
Swerve Strickland Vs. Jay White overcame a less than ideal dynamic to get really, really damn good by the finish.
Throughout, both wrestlers hit each other very hard with vicious chops, agonising suplexes on the thin edge of the barricade, neck-jamming DDTs. With no true babyface/heel dynamic, this was instead imagined as a shoot-out. As much impact was felt throughout, it was difficult to feel much emotion. Swerve was the default babyface but stayed true to his conniving, remorseless character.
As such, this didn't build nor flow elegantly into the finish. With nobody to get behind, really, sometimes the wrestling, gruesome as it was, was just happening in front of your eyes. Then, two of the best craftsmen in the game clicked into a higher gear.
With no traditional structure with which to draw fans in, Swerve and White relied on their immaculate execution. Every head drop looked near-fatal. White sells the frantic terror of being hit by moves in the spaces between better than the vast majority of his peers (and seniors), and Swerve's arsenal more than justified his flailing. The near-falls were scorching in a very good (if a touch weird) and unpredictable match.
While it did feel like 5 awesome minutes tacked onto the end of a curiosity - and shouldn't White have sold his arm a bit more? - those five minutes were awesome.
1. Adam Copeland And Christian Cage Do It Like Old Pros
Christian Cage and Adam Copeland came face-to-face in a fantastic verbal segment that subverted their first AEW interaction magnificently.
When Adam Copeland first appeared on Dynamite, he pleaded with Christian Cage to remember who he once was. He once idolised Sting, and now he was trying to break his neck. Copeland urged Christian to team with him, return to his old self, and stop being "even more of a d*ck" than usual.
Now that Cage has ran out of road, and Copeland has taken out his stable, he said the exact same thing to Copeland. This was such great heel work. In the last refuge of the scoundrel, Cage mentioned that he was Copeland's brother all those years ago in the absence of a father figure. In two great bits of mirroring, Cage, operating out of pure desperate cowardice, almost verbatim asked Copeland what Copeland had asked of him back in October. Let's be friends. Let's reform the tag team.
In the second great bit of mirroring, Copeland saw through the rat and told Cage to go f*ck himself. After some not great developments - the idea that nobody on the AEW staff gave a sh*t about Nick Wayne's mother last week, Copeland going to the dreaded "that place" on Collision - this was very elegant storytelling from two old masters.