8 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (9 May - Results & Review)
WWE's go home before Backlash provides fun matches and banter-filled promos.
Drew McIntyre might've just won the award for 'Best Promo Face 2025'. His OTT impression of reigning United States Champ and 'All Gas, No Brakes' badass Jacob Fatu was a sneaky highlight on this week's episode of SmackDown. Drew's speech was full of personality and content, and it wasn't alone. John Cena and Charlotte Flair cut good-to-great promos on WWE's latest too.
Both stuck the boot in on fans for disrespect, but one was smartly kept on the shorter side to hammer home the point well. Anyone worrying that talking would dominate this week's SmackDown ahead of Backlash needn't have bothered - there was plenty of riotous in-ring action to sink your teeth into.
No less than four tag-team bouts served up lots of storyline context, and there was even time for an often-overlooked trio to work in some character development. It's a huge compliment to Legado del Fantasma that fans in Dayton, Ohio responded well to their segment. Now, the next challenge will be making sure that momentum continues in coming weeks.
Most WWE fans in Dayton bought tickets to see John Cena show up though. This company can sell tiks by the truckload just to see top stars talk; that might not be sustainable if the asking prices don't drop, but it's worth pointing out. Thankfully, the rest of the supporting cast on that WWE roster underneath made attending SmackDown even better.
Here's all the good and bad from the final stop before Saturday night's Backlash PLE. First, some pesky negatives that you may/may not even agree with...
Downs...
2. The Street Profits Sell…Inconsistently!
Yes, this is a very minor grumble, but it’s also one worth discussing if you're the kind of fan who likes consistency. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins were selling their ribs after a brutal TLC bout recently. That was good to see, but there were a few too many times when both did things someone with wounded ribs just wouldn’t do. Case in point: Ford flipping through to pose for literally no reason after hitting a move.
Look, if you’re going to go to the trouble of selling injured ribs at all and make that the story of the match, then be smarter about it. That's all this fan expects. Ford and Angelo Dawkins moving freely one minute then not the next didn’t ruin their bout vs. Fraxiom or anything dramatic like that, but it was a bit confusing to see WWE workers so seasoned do this sort of thing.
They should know better. Hopefully, somebody pulled them aside behind the curtain and pointed out that flippy poses and things of that nature are fine if they make sense. Nobody with damaged ribs should be trying it mid-match and causing themselves more pain though! At least Montez had the decency to grit his teeth, clutch at his midsection and realise he'd made a mistake.
Joe Tessitore and Wade Barrett covered for him by saying Tez just got caught up in the heat of battle. That's fair. Yep, a small gripe here, albeit one which sucked this viewer out of the occasion. The Profits shouldn't have been doing anything that hurt their own ribs without also trying to damage their opponents.
Simple as that. Who do they think they are? The Young Bucks?
1. Something Felt Off
Some combos just don't exhibit any chemistry together, but companies won't find that out until they book them in a match together. Either this was an off night for Aleister Black, Carmelo Hayes or both, or they're in the 'no chemistry' camp as rivals. Something didn’t click between Black and Hayes on Friday night. In fact, they had a pretty boring match that failed to excite the live crowd like Street Profits vs. Fraxiom did before them.
Annoyingly, Black cut a pre-taped promo saying he wouldn’t speak in riddles then…spoke in more riddles too. Everyone's willing to give him a honeymoon period and all, and it's cool to see him back in WWE, but Aleister cannot go right back to cutting endless samey promos without really doing much of note around these parts yet again. WWE's creative team have to take some of the blame if he does.
Give him an actual storyline to work with, for crying out loud. Mini-feuding with The Miz and Hayes won’t cut it for too much longer. Last week on the 2 May SmackDown, Black showed he and The Miz could do something impactful, but this match vs. Melo sucked wind early on and didn't really pick up any steam from there. It was slow, lifeless and had a flat finish.
It certainly isn't the end of the world that two guys failed to gel or knit something great together. You live and learn, but WWE needs to come through for Aleister second time around. His pre-tape felt a little too 'pick a fight with meeeee', and that's concerning.
Ups...
8. A Sweet & Slick Women’s Tag
It's nice to see Alexa Bliss back inside the ring for the first time since Elimination Chamber in early-March, but it’d be even nicer if WWE had a solid plan for her. On the bright side, Alexa might just be getting something going with fellow veteran Charlotte Flair, and that's something fans should keep an eye on. Further, Bliss and Zelina Vega made for a well-oiled team on Friday.
Speaking of which, Chelsea Green and Piper Niven are gold together. This guy still isn't sold on Vega taking the Women’s US Title from Chelsea, but you’ve got to treat each match/segment fairly in isolation. This tag bout was as solid as they come. Longer term, would anyone be adverse to Alexa eventually turning on Zelina and either winning the title herself or leading to another reign for Green? Either scenario could work.
One thing Triple H has to be mindful of is letting Zelina become overshadowed by bigger names like Alexa. It doesn't seem like her United States Title run is going to last too long, but there's no need to drop all interest and bury her without at least trying to see if there's more to her spitfire babyface act.
Chelsea's overall importance to the wider women's game shouldn't be dismissed either. She's fantastic whether she's putting the boots to a rival or selling like the rent's due. WWE must realise the strong character they have on their hands here. At any rate, it's lovely to lavish praise on some of Zelina's work after weeks of snot-nosed disinterest before her match with Piper on last week's SmackDown.
Call 'em how you see 'em, basically.
7. Charlotte Flair Leans Into It
Anyone who witnessed the sometimes-controversial-but-definitely-spotty build up to WrestleMania 41's bout with Tiffany Stratton will be slightly taken aback by this upcoming Charlotte Flair love-in, but here goes. Charlotte was full-on heel here. Her promo was better than usual and she didn’t steal a ton of time getting to the point.
Here’s the thing: Flair is a decent talker, but she’s been bogged down in swimming against the tide for too long that it’s almost like she’s learning to promo again. There was nothing too forced or 'love me, love me' about her speech on Friday. Charlotte made a deliberately ridiculous statement by calling her match vs. Stratton “the greatest women’s match in WrestleMania history”, then she walked out and bleated about fans showing her disrespect. This is the best way to use Charlotte for now.
Let's be real about something else: There’s zero desire to see her have a stranglehold on titles in 2025 anyway. Alexa Bliss saying “let’s talk” backstage is interesting too. If nothing else, at least there’s some intrigue about what Charlotte and Alexa will do next. Will they unite as a desperate veteran faction looking to cut down relative newbies like Tiffany, Jade Cargill and more? Or, are they about to become enemies all over again?
Personally, this writer enjoyed how clearly outraged and outright heel Flair was on this week's TV. She didn't smile through the boos either, which is important. Instead, Charlotte got ticked off and tossed her microphone to the canvas before storming off. Casting her as somebody who thinks she should be thanked daily for her part in the women's revolution will work, because people love to hate on Flair and don't relate to her personal life.
6. Jade Cargill’s Best Match Yet
There would've been chortling and mirth had anyone suggested that Nia Jax would be the one to work Jade Cargill's best WWE singles match ahead of Friday's edition of SmackDown. Chortling and mirth, we say! Well, it happened, and Nia deserves a ton of credit for guiding Jade through and ensuring their bout didn't turn into a car crash of miscommunication/botched powerhouse spots.
It was astonishing how slick and watchable the match was from start to finish. This effort vs. Nia is undoubtedly one Cargill should be proud of - she showed vast improvements over some earlier awkwardness when tagging with Bianca Belair. That duo clearly helped bed Jade in and keep her learning. Now, she's putting everything she did learn into practice.
The back and forth match ended when Naomi attacked Tiffany Stratton at ringside. That distracted Cargill from the task at hand, and it left her ripe for the pickings for Nia's squash finisher. Honestly, it'd be a surprise if WWE went with Jax challenging Tiffany solo again long term, so let's see how this shakes out. Both Jade and Naomi are in the mix too, as they should be.
There's something to be said for how good Nia has been since returning to WWE in 2023. Her critics likely hate hearing about it, but she's been a different woman. Jax's matches aren't blighted by dangerous drops or clumsy strikes any longer, but she still carries an edge and gets booming "YOU CAN'T WRESTLE" chants from live crowds intent on trolling her.
In your face, Ohio. This was class.
5. Fraxiom Earn A Tag Title Shot
This might sound strange to say considering the style Fraxiom deploys, but there was an old-school tag-team wrasslin' feel to their match vs. The Street Profits on this week's SmackDown. At times. Nathan Frazer and Axiom are still largely about speed, high-flying and spots, but they knew when to slow things down a tad and suck punters into the action. That's a skill which should stand them in good stead.
More, please.
Fraxiom and The Profits got the live crowd onside early and never looked back. One can see these teams doing something truly special next time if they’re given the chance. "If". They will be given that chance. Triple H would've been impressed by what he was seeing from a squad that has only been around on the main WWE roster for a few weeks.
Frazer and Axiom are the latest to show just how valuable the doubles division is to weekly SmackDown TV. Also inconsistent selling aside, The Street Profits are a fine pick to lead the way. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins have been putting on stunners against all comers in recent months, and now they're even elevating guys coming up from NXT like they did years ago.
Strap in for Fraxiom vs. Motor City Machine Guns in a babyface vs. babyface scrap, and for Fraxiom vs. DIY. Screw it - just stick Fraxiom into the middle of another TLC and let them soar. Literally. Frazer and Axiom are off to a good start on the blue brand. Kudos to The Profits for helping to establish them as an act fans should care about.
4. Another Top Tag & Berto’s Development
Wait, wait, wait.
A fine tag-team main event pitting Rey Fenix and Andrade vs. Los Garza and some character development for Berto?! That’s a double win. Hopefully, this is Berto and Angel splitting away from Santos Escobar, not just one of them. Los Garza are a cracking team. Being fair, Angel and Santos teaming up would be fine too.
On the other side of the equation, it does feel like Fenix has cooled off a little since his debut on the 4 April episode, so WWE should arrest that ASAP. He’s still capable of putting on bangers in-ring though, and he meshed well with Andrade. No shocks there. These lads are all highly skilled, complement one another well, and are so unselfish when it comes to giving both partners and opponents lots to work with during matches. Long may that continue.
If Triple H manages to develop Humberto Carrillo into a character WWE fans get behind, then build another statue. He might also be ringing up Booker T and saying there's a new "King Booker" in town. So to speak. No-one could've guessed that Berto showing out and standing up to Santos would get such a healthy reaction from the masses in 2025. That speaks to how well recent Los Garza matches have done for their standing on the roster.
Come for the glossy in-ring work between four top pros, then stay for the post-match storytelling. Angel being caught between going off with his tag partner or sticking by Escobar's side is another plus point for the trio. That's something creative can work with going forwards.
3. “Tomorrow, Your Childhood Dies”
Obvious statement of the year incoming: John Cena is really, really good at this sort of stuff. He cut a supreme ‘go home’ promo on the match with Randy Orton at Backlash. Cena even got everyone there live in Dayton to lower their guard by saying Randy was at home in St. Louis with his family so wouldn't be there.
That was a little sleight of hand by WWE. Orton was there to deliver a thumping RKO and send everybody home happy, but not before some extra sprinted out to take an Attitude Adjustment. In a neat moment, John didn't even look at that person, so the insinuation was that he thought he'd cut Randy's latest attack off successfully whilst barely trying.
Sorry, JC, but you were wrong.
Before the RKO, lines like: "Tomorrow, your childhood dies" resonated with the audience. Cena did everything he could think of to get people hyped for what's actually a glorified exhibition vs. Orton at Backlash. It'd be one of the biggest WWE swerves in recent memory if Randy left his hometown with the WWE Title, let's be honest. Cena winning is practically a formality.
Hopefully, full-timers on the WWE roster were backstage watching, paying attention to all of this and taking notes. This, dear readers, is how a top tier star puts some last-minute garnish on the build for a PPV/PLE match without droning on and on and on for 20+ minutes.
One thing Cena's biggest critics always admitted during his prime was that he could carry things on the mic. The dude still has that in his arsenal.
2. Uneasy Allies Come To Blows
On the whole, Damian Priest and LA Knight have been doing a good job of coming across as babyfaces who respect what the other man can do but don’t necessarily get along. They're totally different as people, and that's fine. Not everybody has to get along with others just because they're fellow faces or heels. It's more realistic and human if wrestlers act like real folks and not just robots in a video game.
Priest and Knight's work opposite Jacob Fatu and Solo Silo was fab on Friday. There was constant dissension between them throughout the match, then they traded strikes post-win after going from partners back to United States Title enemies. This whole four-way situation for Jacob's belt is heating up nicely ahead of Backlash. More on that in a bit.
It'd be deserved to single out Knight and Priest for what they've been doing over the past couple of weeks though. They've been uneasy allies who clearly don't really want to team up together but know they can help one another out when faced with monsters like Fatu. That's important, and so was the way they naturally slid back into being at loggerheads once the tag was old news.
Finally, Solo eating another pin when he claims he’s trying to help Jacob will only feed into their impending split story. It's looking more and more likely that Sikoa will try to cost a family member some gold soon, then Fatu will moonsault him into oblivion. Those moves will look so crisp it'd be more accurate to call it Oblivion Remastered.
Bring on that and more US Title merriment.
1. The General Danger Of The US Title Scene
SmackDown's midcard belt crowd will try to mimic what Raw's lot did with the Intercontinental strap over WrestleMania 41 weekend. In other words, the four-way for this United States Title at Backlash on Saturday must come out smelling of roses the way Bron Breakker vs. Finn Bálor vs. Penta vs. Dominik Mysterio did in Las Vegas. That was a real surprise package of a match.
Over to you, blue boys.
There's surely no way they'll fail. Jacob Fatu is a seriously strong champion. Look, he isn’t dropping the belt this soon after 'Mania, but that four-way at Backlash has some juice to it, man. Damian Priest and LA Knight are worthy challengers, then there’s Drew McIntyre. Booking him to level Fatu with a Claymore Kick was smart (what a one-on-one that’d be someday!) and unpredictable.
Bonus points go to Drew for cutting a banter-filled promo backstage afterwards. He explained why he'd decided to target Jacob on SmackDown by calling him one of the most dangerous around. McIntyre likes the thought of cutting Fatu down to size then taking his title. It's a simple story, but an effective one.
The word "dangerous" fits this US Title scene. There are threats everywhere the reigning champ looks. Priest is a former World Champ, Knight is the guy Jacob beat to win the thing, Drew is one of the best in the business, and even Solo Sikoa can't be trusted.
If John Cena vs. Randy Orton wasn't on the card this Saturday, then the four-way for Fatu's US prize could headline. That's how strong it is.
What did you think of this week's episode of WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE Backlash 2025: 7 Things That Must Happen and WWE Backlash 2025: 7 Nightmares That Could Come True!