8 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (May 27)

Perhaps booking Mike Tyson wasn't such a bright idea after all.

Chris Jericho Mike Tyson
AEW

Double Or Nothing 2020 was one of the year's better American wrestling shows, Empty Arena Era or otherwise, defying meek expectations born of a lukewarm build and potentially disruptive show-week injuries to Britt Baker, Matt Jackson, and Rey Fenix. The buyrate isn't out yet, but early reports suggest a strong number despite the ongoing global situation, potentially marking 23 May as an objectively successful evening for the upstart promotion.

Last night's Dynamite was a palate cleanser. Fallout from what would normally be the year's biggest AEW pay-per-view was everywhere. Cody addressed his TNT Championship victory over Lance Archer, then learned his first number one contender later in the eve. Mike Tyson returned to face off with Chris Jericho after presenting the TNT strap at Double Or Nothing. In the World Title scene, Jon Moxley met Brian Cage for the first time, having overcome Mr. Brodie Lee in a violent war. New Women's Champion Hikaru Shida was out to build further momentum after taking the gold from Nyla Rose.

There was a lot going on. It didn't all hit, of course, but Dynamite was a net positive as a whole, though one of the night's big angles was nothing short of shambolic.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

3. Shida Should've Squashed

Hikaru Shida
AEW

Hikaru Shida's AEW squash matches are often too competitive. We saw it prior to Double Or Nothing, as the Japanese star laboured through a 50/50 enhancement bout days before challenging Nyla Rose, and it happened last night, as she faced returning Brazilian Christi Jaynes.

Jaynes is a promising wrestler but should have been run over by Shida here. She instead found multiple avenues back into the match across its five minutes and worked some good heel shtick in the process, but the competitiveness rendered Shida's victory rub useless. A one-sided hammering would have been the operative way to go. If AEW didn't want to use Jaynes for that role (perhaps they'll Alan Angels her), another jobber should have been used.

The 50/50 layout would have been believable had the idea that Shida was struggling thanks to the beating Rose put her through been put over, but it wasn't. This was just a flat TV match that should have been a showcase.


2. Bland Battle Royal

Wardlow battle royal
AEW

The battle royal to crown Cody's number one contender didn't hit, continuing AEW's tradition of delivering lacklustre over-the-top-rope scrambles.

Things were particularly rough early going. Wrestlers looked like they were stepping on each others toes as they struggled for space and cues, resulting in several moments where performers were standing around visibly waiting for others to get out the way. It was messy. Highlights came only in short bursts (Luchasaurus' Chokeslam elimination of Luther was awesome) before the bout fell down again, and the end result was a lacklustre battle royal with nothing to differentiate it from the dozens of others you'll see on wrestling shows this year.

That a contendership match had so many lower-ranked wrestlers in it didn't help either. Peter Avalon, Brandon Cutler, and Luther were all in contention for a title shot. Sure, it's the secondary belt, but having these guys orbiting the title scene's periphery doesn't exactly present it as prestigious.

Things at least got interesting later on as Wardlow and MJF were eliminated shortly after the latter had accidentally blasted his heavy with the Dynamite Diamond Ring, leaving Orange Cassidy and Jungle Boy to battle it out. The Jurassic Express man won. He's a good choice who Cody will get over in defeat, pushing him closer to the Sammy Guevara/Darby Allin tier of prospects.


1. Tyson & Jericho

Mike Tyson Chris Jericho
AEW

Where to start with this mess?

If not for The Dark Order's 18 December disaster, this would be the most dysfunctional segment in AEW Dynamite history. The Inner Circle's pep rally began with the group gathering to exchange gifts after the pain of losing the Stadium Stampede, producing fun moments like Chris Jericho's King of Dad Jokes trophy, Jake Hager's poem, and 'Le Champion' upgrading Sammy Guevara's "nerdy crutches" to an even nerdier scooter. Amusing, but not exactly worthy of a main event spot.

Things unravelled when Jericho called Mike Tyson out, citing the former heavyweight boxing champion knocking him out on Raw back in January 2010 as a motivator. Jericho claimed he'd spent every single day dreaming of getting his hands on Tyson's "fat head" since that incident. At Dynamite, he wanted it on a platter.

Out came 'Iron Mike' flanked, for no reason, by MMA fighters Rashad Evans, Henry Cejudo, and Vitor Beflort, actor Mickey Gooch (what a name), and some other goobers. Awfulness followed. Tyson's awful, over-the-top acting had him coming off cartoonish. A man dubbed the baddest on the planet couldn't tear his t-shirt open. It faces a farce - and the ensuing pull-apart brawl tells us it isn't over.

On top of all of this, The Inner Circle, AEW's big heel stable, felt like the babyfaces.


Ups....

8. Sabian & Havoc Elevate

Kip Sabian Jimmy Havoc
AEW

AEW's second Tag Team Title contendership match in less than a week went down on Dynamite, with Kip Sabian and Jimmy Havoc earning their shot by beating the SoCal Uncensored duo of Frankie Kazarian and Scorpio Sky. They'll face Kenny Omega and Hangman Page next week with the winners defending against Best Friends at Fyter Fest.

The tandems overcame some initial clunkiness to produce a solid little undercard tag. At its best when Havoc was working his grimy gouge-heavy tactics during the control sequence, it saw SCU presented as rusty, as Sky and Kaz haven't teamed since February. Havoc and Sabian, meanwhile, have been working together every week on Dark and Dynamite, giving them an upper hand that wouldn't have existed during SCU's title reign.

Sabian and Havoc's victory came with Michinoku Driver/Dropkick combination and is a considerable upset, as well as a sign of progress for this growing heel unit. They don't always click, but they did here.


7. This Version Of Taz

Taz promo
AEW

Bellicose Brooklynite Taz came out of his shell at Double Or Nothing and cut a good follow-up promo on Dynamite, letting Jon Moxley know that Brian Cage was about to rip his heart out.

Though nothing earth-shattering, this was solid stuff. Taz is a good talker, particularly when he's allowed to get rowdy, and he came off well as he put Moxley and Cage over, then pulled a variation on his old "survive if I let you" line to close, leaving Mox and 'The Machine' staring each other down between the ring and announce table.

How this new role will impact Taz's commentary position on Dark remains to be seen, but Taz, the manager, is off to a decent start. Cage has the ideal complementary piece for this main event run.


6. MJF: The M Stands For Magnifique

MJF promo
AEW

This week's obligatory Good MJF Promo was pretaped and focused on 'The Salt of the Earth' addressing his lack of title shots in AEW so far.

Citing his year-long undefeated streak, MJF said he was starting to think that somebody in the office didn't like him. When he heard AEW was hosting a battle royal to give a certain somebody a number one contender, he decided to enter to ensuring Cody had good competition and with Wardlow in there as an insurance policy, the duo were going to make it all the way to the final two.

Tensions flared as Wardlow opened his mouth for the first time. MJF immediately got in his face before playing it off as a joke, though the big man clearly had designs on winning the bout himself, going against his benefactor's orders.

It feels too early to be teasing a Wardlow/MJF split at the moment, though passing strong judgment on it would be a kneejerk at this stage. Let's be patient and see how it plays out. For now, an effective heel promo makes the Ups side of the column.


5. Brian Cage Kills A Man

Brian Cage
AEW

Brian Cage's squash victory over Lee Johnson was played perfectly.

A true one-sided shellacking, it was accompanied by a casually-dressed Jon Moxley on commentary. The AEW World Champion witnessed his next challenger decimate poor Lee Johnson, who was mauled at the bell, thrown around like a carrier bag in a Tornado, and sent most of the way across the ring with a German suplex. A Powerbomb, Buckle Bomb, and Drill Claw ended his night in under two minutes.

This was a good bit of business. 'The Machine' looked monstrous, Johnson bumped and solid like a pro, and everyone went home happy. Job done.


4. Spot Monkeys

AEW flippydoo
AEW

Dynamite opened with a brief backstage promo in which Matt Hardy reverted to the oldest version of himself, 'Surge,' asking The Young Bucks if they wanted to be spot monkeys for the night.

They most certainly did.

The Bucks and Hardy vs. Private Party and Joey Janela was a pure spotfest. Viewers averse to that style won't have gotten anything out of it, though it was the kind of highlight-filled display that would have ignited a Dynamite audience before the global health crisis kicked in. All big bombs and giffable moments, it was fast, fluid, exciting, and crammed with fun bits like Isiah Kassidy's tongue-in-cheek abdominal stretch and the accidental Superkick to The Blade that would later come back to haunt the Bucks.

We also got some tremendous selling from Marq Quen, who played up a worked knee injury so convincingly he had fans worried he was legitimately hurt after the show. This took him out of the match, giving the Bucks and Hardy the advantage, with the More Bang For Your Buck-induced finish coming soon after.

This was just fun. Sometimes, that's all you need.


3. Roll Model

Britt Baker Roll Model
AEW

It's a shame that Britt Baker is going to be out of action until All Out because she was absolutely marvellous last night.

Wheeled out onto the stage by former TNA star Rebel, the injured dentist delivered the third instalment of her Rules of Being a Role Model series: "don't hurt the Role Model." Wheelchair-bound, she talked about the "egregious assault" that left her with a broken tibia ahead of Double Or Nothing, calling it a conspiracy and a 3-on-1 calculated attack that had been in the making since AEW started.

Shida, Baker said, was a fraudulent champion who broke he nose, cheats, and carries a weapon. Kris Statlander being an alien is a "crock of sh*t." Having seen Nyla Rose come off the top ropes with precision several times before, the move that broke her leg must make her a conspirator as well.

Then came a ridiculous, elaborate graph linking every conspirator in the women's division together, with Aubrey Edwards right there in the middle. Baker said the referee had been there every time she'd been hurt - and thus begins her newest crusade.

This was tremendous. Baker is the most convincingly deluded heel in the sport right now and her paranoia was pushed to the forefront as she unfurled her conspiracy theory, then left on her "Roll Model" wheelchair. Let's hope the promos don't stop while she's hurt.


2. Fighting Champion

Cody TNT Title
AEW

Cody's post-TNT Championship victory promo was a very Cody promo, but an excellent example of one, as 'The American Nightmare' put his ugly little strap over huge.

AEW's de facto ace presented himself as a workhorse here. In his words, he was first called onto television as a green 21-year-old who barely knew how to run the ropes. His brother Dustin got all the Dusty, he said, and talked about his mother instilling hard work and grit in him, adding that when Tony Khan wanted to create a merit-based wrestling company with the best wrestlers in the world, he didn't get the first, second, or third call.

A promise to stand and defend the TNT Championship every single week followed. Cody presented it as an "open challenge," saying that the fans' dedication to AEW created an obligation for him to give his very best every single week, and so, the TNT Title becomes AEW's workrate belt.

If nothing else, this gives us a potentially fun midcard scrap to look forward to every week. Strong performances will further justify a spot earned by virtue of being the most popular babyface in the company. This won't stop the trollbase's worst elements screaming "burial!", of course, but you can't please bad-faith actors.


1. Finally, FTR

The Young Bucks FTR
AEW

It's good to finally see Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler on AEW television. Their debut was an inevitability from the moment they walked out of WWE, and now, with them and The Young Bucks under the same roof, fans can start preparing for their long-awaited programme.

The Butcher and The Blade attacked the Bucks after Matt and Nick Jackson had laid them out during the opener. An old pickup truck pulled up to Daily's Place and out stepped FTR, who stomped to the ring, teasing that they were going to destroy the Jacksons. Instead, they swerved Butcher and Blade, downing them with a Spike Piledriver and the move once known as the Shatter Machine, before rejecting the Bucks' offer of a handshake and bailing.

A well-played angle that didn't overstay its welcome, this would have unquestionably gone down better in a packed building, but this is the new reality. Lord knows how long AEW will be waiting for the noise to return. For now, they did the right thing in removing FTR from the unemployment line.

Time to find out if FTR still have their old NXT form in them. This columnist wouldn't bet against them...


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.