8 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Evolution

Women rule the night, present solid PPV with top matches delivering.

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

WWE’s first all-woman PPV is officially in the record books, and as the company liked to remind us Sunday night, history was made on a historic night of history-making proportions.

Oh, and Stephanie McMahon invented women’s wrestling. If she didn’t, she brought it to the mainstream.

With those lessons in mind, Evolution has to be deemed a mild success, as they produced an event that featured only female performers and delivered a few really good matches and a card with no real drags on the show. Even the worst matches of the night were watchable at worst. We saw a title change, a tournament final, the return of Hall-of-Famers, and the future of the women’s division on center stage.

We were treated to a nice break in the norm, with even the staging at the front of the arena set up differently, which gave the event a different feel right off the bat. Overall, Evolution was a fun diversion Sunday night, with a couple notable moments and others that left you scratching your head. It’ll be interesting to see if the company tries an all-woman event like this again in the future, or if this was a one-tie deal ahead of the men going to Saudi Arabia for Crown Jewel.

With that said, let’s find out what broke the glass ceiling and what was left home on Friday night. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

6. Just Here For The Check

women's battle royal
WWE.com

No one thought that Molly Holly, Kelly Kelly or Ivory were going to win the women’s battle royal and secure a title shot. But tossing all the legends in rapid fashion was a bit much, don’t you think?

After a cool visual of the current roster of women surrounding the legends, things broke down into a standard battle royal. Almost immediately, the legends were tossed. Five of the first six women eliminated (once the match really got underway) were legends, leaving just two: Michelle McCool and Ivory.

While there was no reason to expect them all to go deep into the match, it just was jarring to see them all go bang-bang-bang over the top the way they did. It made their appearance look like it was for a nostalgia pop to fill a spot.


5. Meiko Appears At Evolution… In The Crowd

Meiko Satomura
WWE.com

Full disclosure: If this turns out the be a precursor to her appearing in a WWE ring again, then all is forgiven.

But it was an absolute travesty that Japanese legend Meiko Satomura appeared during WWE Evolution – but it was only ringside in the crowd. Meiko won over fans during her performance in the Mae Young Classic, making it to the semifinals before losing to Toni Storm. For those (like this writer) who had never seen her wrestle before, it was truly a treat to see how she lived up to her billing as a “final boss” in Japan.

By the time the tournament reached the semifinals, it seemed almost like a waste to have Satomura lose and end her run in the tournament (and WWE by extension). Considering that the earlier tournament rounds were filmed during the summer, it seemed like there would have been time to try to get Meiko to compete at Evolution.

And while she appeared in the crowd, that just was a disappointment in many ways. She could have even fought in the battle royal, or gotten a spot in a quick match to show off for more American fans.


4. Matches Get Short-Changed

toni storm io shirai
WWE.com

After eight weeks of matches, you would have thought that the Mae Young Classic finals would have been a 15-20 minute affair, giving Toni Storm and Io Shirai plenty of time to shine and win over fans.

Instead, they barely got 10 minutes.

The match itself was fine (more on that later), but just when it felt like it was getting warmed up, the match abruptly ended with Storm hitting her second Storm Zero of the contest for the win. And just like that, Triple H was presenting Toni with the trophy, bringing the tournament to a close.

But it wasn’t just the Mae Young Classic finals that felt short-changed. The NXT Women’s Championship match between Shayna Baszler and Kairi Sane also felt a little short, though it crammed a lot into that time. Still, a couple more minutes might have given it a little more of an “epic” feel for a title match.


3. Becky Is Not The Heel

becky lynch
WWE.com

Memo to WWE: Don’t make the same mistakes you make all the time with trying to tell the fans who’s the face and who’s the heel. You can nudge and coax, but if an entire arena is telling you that you’re wrong, then change your preconceived notions.

In this case, Becky Lynch is supposed to be the villainess against Charlotte Flair. However (and thankfully), she won the SmackDown Women’s Championship fairly and would retain it fairly Sunday night. She supposedly is the heel because she attacked Charlotte a while back and has taken cheap shots at her regularly. But fans love Lynch and have rallied to the Irish Lass Kicker.

Lynch isn’t wrestling royalty, as Michael Cole noted, which would make her the common person’s wrestler. But that hasn’t stopped the writers and announcers from pushing the narrative that Becky is the sniveling heel (she begged off of Charlotte after she made a superwoman comeback) while Flair is the fan favorite.

WWE needs to figure this out, as they have an organic babyface who they want to be booed. Sounds familiar, but in reverse, doesn’t it?


2. Remember Who’s Responsible For This

evolution ppv
WWE.com

So if you had to place money on who was the first voice you heard on WWE Evolution, odds are you made some cash.

Because everyone had to know that Stephanie McMahon and her speech about the women’s evolution would be the overriding theme of the entire PPV. And so it was Stephanie’s speech that was played over a backdrop of highlights, which then segued to other women on the roster talking about what all of this means to them.

This isn’t some huge sin – McMahon is one of the highest-ranking officials in the company – but it definitely was an “of course she was front-and-center to start” moment. Anyone could have done a voiceover to give the moment some gravity rather than Stephanie reminding everyone that she is central to this too.


1. Video Packages Galore

paige evolution
WWE.com

We get it – WWE is making history with this all-woman PPV. But we didn’t need 37 video packages with interviews of every woman on the card to tell us how history-making and special this night was.

By the time we got to the fourth special video package, it was everything not to just turn the TV off and walk away for five minutes. (Instead, it was time to get a piece of pie.) We get that Evolution means a lot to the women on the card, and they showed it through their performances on the PPV. We didn’t need to hear all of them tell us about it in-between every match.

They easily could have squeezed another match or two onto the card (Meiko Satomura? NXT?) or lengthened the existing matches if they cut down on the videos and Barry Horowitz-like patting themselves on the back.

But that wouldn’t be WWE’s style.


Ups...

8. A Nice Touch

lillian garcia
WWE.com

If you pay attention on Raw, you know that the red brand already has a female ring announcer in JoJo. However, she was not the one doing introductions to open Evolution.

WWE brought back Lillian Garcia to do the honors of introducing wrestlers at WWE’s first all-female PPV. Garcia was a ring announcer throughout the Attitude Era, into the 2000s, and for the first half of this decade. While she has been given to mistakes, she was a consistent presence for the better part of 15 years.

It was much more meaningful to have Lillian announce the wrestlers than to have JoJo, who most fans wouldn’t even know if they hadn’t watched Raw when she was on the first season of Total Divas.


7. Battle Royal Finishes Strong

nia jaxx evolution
WWE.com

Battle royals are often death on a PPV. The WrestleMania battle royals have mostly been forgettable messes, and this one risked falling into that category.

Once things whittled down a bit, we got a nice little bout, with several interesting little side parts, such as Asuka and Naomi teaming up on Tamina, Ivory hitting a crossbody on Tamina, and a great underdog bit from Ember Moon. Moon tossed Carmella, Asuka and Tamina, and she battled against both Tamina and Nia Jax as the final three.

We even got the false finish, with Zelina Vega sneaking in and thinking she had eliminated Nia and Ember, only to get press-slammed out of the match. While it wasn’t a memorable match that will be talked about for months, it filled its spot on the card and actually had a nice ending to it.


6. Six Woman Tag Match Dials It Up

six women's tag
WWE.com

Give the Riott Squad, Sasha Banks, Bayley and Natalya credit: They all came out firing on all cylinders Sunday night. Their six-woman tag match could have been a paint-by-numbers bout ripped out of Raw.

But they delivered a tag match that served its purpose really well, with Bayley and Sasha taking turns as face-in-peril, getting fans fired up as the Riott Squad beat each of them up. The finish, a powerbomb, elbow drop, frogsplash combo from the faces to Liv Morgan, was a great way to end the match and really get the fans into it.

The negative component, which won’t get its own item here, would have to be the Riott Squad itself. At some point, all the talk about them being a cohesive unit has to pay off in a blowoff match. They need to win something other than an occasional Raw match.

And Sasha and Bayley need to do something of consequence soon. This was perfectly fine, but considering their contributions to women’s wrestling the last few years, you’d think they’d be in a bigger position for the first WWE all-female PPV.


5. MMA Four Horsewomen Make Impact

shayna baszler kairi sane
WWE.com

Kairi Sane and Shayna Baszler had a hard-hitting match that crammed a lot of action into 15 minutes, with Baszler emerging as the first two-time NXT Women’s Champion, but that wasn’t the only big story that emerged from the bout.

The remaining two members of the MMA Four Horsewomen finally emerged from the shadows and made their presence felt, coming to Baszler’s aid and helping her win the title. Jessamyn Duke and Marina Shafir both got involved in Shayna’s match, with Duke’s headkick to Sane directly leading to Baszler winning back the title.

With Ronda Rousey on Raw, it might only be a matter of time before the MMA horsewomen have a real run-in (not just a backstage angle) with the WWE Four Horsewomen.


4. Shirai Flies, Storm Shines

io shirai toni storm
WWE.com

Throughout the Mae Young Classic, we kept hearing how Io Shirai is the “Genius of the Sky.” But aside from a couple moves, we didn’t really see a lot of aerial attacks from Io.

That changed Sunday night, when Shirai flew around the ring, hitting a springboard dropkick and following up with a running, leaping moonsault to the floor in rapid succession, followed up by a springboard sunset flip pin attempt later on.

Shirai and Toni Storm had a good but too-brief match, as both showed that they have the chops to take the women’s division into the future. Storm has a charisma about her that will serve her well, and Shirai has the goods to be a multi-time champ.

Let’s hope they get more opportunities to impress fans as they go forward.


3. Bella, Rousey Do No Harm

ronda rousey nikki bella
WWE.com

The best you could hope for with Nikki Bella challenging Rowdy Ronda Rousey for the Raw Women’s Championship was a perfectly serviceable match that closed out the night on a high note. The floor was to not do any harm – to the competitors, to the title and to the PPV.

Fortunately, the women stayed with what they knew, as Nikki relied on a couple cheapshots and copious interfering from Brie Bella to temporarily overcome Ronda’s strength advantage. But that didn’t last long, as Rousey would eventually take out both sisters and put Nikki down with an armbar.

Rousey is clearly improving out there, but it doesn’t look like she’s learning to work a traditional WWE match. That’s probably good in some ways, so she retains her uniqueness and is truer to herself. But you’ve got to think at some point she’ll do a normal hiptoss or suplex. Still, she’s obviously growing as a performer.


2. Shaking The Cobwebs

Trish Stratus Mickie James
WWE.com

You’d be excused if you had low expectations for the tag match featuring two WWE Hall-of-Famers. After all, Trish Status hadn’t wrestled a match (not counting the women’s Royal Rumble) in more than eight years, while Lita had wrestled only a couple mixed tag matches since her 2006 retirement (discounting the Rumble and a 2012 “match” against Heath Slater).

However, Trish and Lita held their own in a tag match against Alicia Fox and Mickie James Sunday night. The PPV kicked off with the bout, which was a smart way to draw fans in – with two of the most well-known women in the last 25 years.

The women stayed mostly safe, though Trish hit a frankensteiner and Lita hit a couple ranas. We’ll even give Fox a pass on missing her cue to break up a pinfall near the end, as fans were into the entire match, and it delivered exactly what they wanted: Lita and Trish hitting their signature spots and winning.


1. Last Woman Standing Gets Standing O

becky lynch charlotte flair
WWE.com

During the past few years, WWE has made sure to check off all the women’s firsts they can: first Money in the Bank ladder match, first Hell in a Cell match, first PPV main event, etc.

Sunday, we got the company’s first Last Woman Standing match, with Becky Lynch and Charlotte Flair doing the honors. The two women tore into each other, abandoning a straight up wrestling match after a few minutes and switching to a hardcore match with chairs, ladders, tables and kendo sticks. Flair nailed a senton through a table, while Lynch hit a legdrop off a ladder through a table.

In the end, it was a Lynch powerbomb off the top rope through a table on the floor that secured a strong win for the SmackDown Women’s Champion. That was also the right call, having Becky retain without resorting to shenanigans.

Hopefully, this marks the end of the feud and allows Becky – who was wildly cheered throughout – to continue a successful reign that doesn’t just try to shoehorn her as a heel.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.