8 Wrestlers Who Broke All The Rules

Those names who went against the very fundamentals of what's supposed to makes the business tick.

Orange Cassidy
AEW

These days, professional wrestling is an industry that is forever changing and constantly looking at ways to appeal to different tastes. Whatever you like to see from your pro wrestling, chances are there's a promotion out there perfectly tailored to what you're looking for.

Over the decades, however, there have been certain rules in place in the wrestling business. Not the rules of a wrestling match exactly, but more the traditions and fundamentals that are supposed to make the industry tick.

To this day, there are still certain elements of pro wrestling in place here in 2020 that were in place back when, for example, Lou Thesz and Whipper Billy Watson did battle in the 1950s. While the business has long been built on these established traditions, though, there have been performers over the years who have managed to go against type, to go against the norm, to go against what has been so proven to work - and manage to be hugely successful as a result!

It takes a special sort of talent to flaunt the status quo and come out smelling of roses, but here are eight (well, technically nine) wrestlers who have done just that.

8. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin - The Non-Babyface Babyface

Steve Austin WrestleMania 13
WWE.com

A babyface flipping people off? While cursing profusely? Drinking beer on TV? And kicking the sh*t out of authority figures?

That is the formula that propelled Steve Austin from the Ringmaster to Stone Cold, but it was something that, according to wrestling lore, was simply not supposed to be possible.

The babyfaces were the good guys and gals who kissed babies, hugged grannies, took their vitamins, said their prayers, and forever had the cheesiest of cheesy grins etched across their face. At the time that Austin's rise to prominence began to gather traction, he broke any and every rule that was historically tied to a babyface.

Laying your hands on an authority figure on its own was enough to mean that someone was a fully-fledged villain - just imagine Hulk Hogan laying out Jack Tunney - let alone going to the extent of swearing like a sailor on international TV as you proudly paraded your middle fingers around.

From purely a characteristics stance, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin was every bit the traditional heel. Only he wasn't, for the business was evolving away from perma-tanned, skullet-adorned heroes, with the aggressive anti-hero kicking the door down and changing what really made a babyface.

Austin's act was the hottest of the hottest time in the wrestling business, yet it was an act that went against every rule in the book.


7. Chyna - The Female Muscle

Chyna Ic
WWE

Joanie Laurer was an undoubted trailblazer of the professional wrestling business.

As Chyna, Laurer broke down so many barriers, did things never before seen in a mainstream wrestling promotion, and most certainly smashed through plenty of the established rules of the business that were once in place.

By the time of Chyna's arrival in the then-WWF in 1997, a women's division was non-existent in the company - with the WWF Women's Championship deactivated after Alundra Blayze had famously thrown said title in the trash on the 18 December 1995 episode of WCW Nitro.

Even if that title was still in circulation in '97, it seems doubtful that Chyna would've been in contention for it. Instead, WWF utilised Joanie Laurer in a way never before seen for a female performer. Going against the established fundamentals of the industry, Chyna debuted as the ass-kicking bodyguard of one Hunter Hearst Helmsley.

Continuing to throw the rules of the business up in the air, Chyna would go on to compete in the men's Royal Rumble match, competed on a semi-regular basis against male grapplers, won the Intercontinental Championship, and was even at one point seriously talked about as beating 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin to become the WWF Champion in 1999.


6. Chris Jericho - The Veteran Who Craves The Challenge

NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 13 Chris Jericho Tetsuya Naito
NJPW World

Chris Jericho has long been one of the smartest people in the wrestling industry, with the Canadian having his finger regularly on the pulse when it comes to changing his character up and making sure that he remains fresh and engaging.

Why Jericho warrants a spot in this article, though, is for how he opted to walk away from WWE in order to return to New Japan Pro Wrestling.

Jericho isn't the first big name who decided to try their hand elsewhere, but Le Champion is a rare breed who went against what had for so long been declared the norm of pro wrestling. By that norm, it's the path of signing with WWE, becoming a main event star, then either seeing your in-ring days out in WWE or maybe heading to IMPACT Wrestling for a lighter schedule.

For Jericho, he made the call to return to NJPW at the age of 47 purely for the chance to mix it up with the likes of Kenny Omega and Tetsuya Naito.

Other top stars may have left WWE to work elsewhere, but nobody of that status (and, frankly, that age) had walked away from WWE to head to NJPW simply for the love of the profession and to match-off against some of the hottest talents in the game.

At 47 years of age, anybody else would've happily re-signed with the safety blanket that is WWE as they looked to wind down their in-ring days. But no, not Chris Jericho.


5. Trish Stratus And Lita - Women As Main Eventers

Trish Lita
WWE.com

Chyna may have broken the rules when it comes to a female dominating their male counterparts, but the majority of the Eighth Wonder of the World's time in the then-WWF saw women's matches consist of bullsh*t bra and panties contests and gravy bowl matches - meaning solid workers like Ivory, Jacqueline, and Luna Vachon were often overshadowed by far less accomplished 'wrestlers' like Sable, The Kat, and Terri Runnels.

Better in-ring workers would end up in the company as we entered the 2000s, with Molly Holly, Victoria, Trish Stratus, Lita, and Jazz arriving over the next few years - but still, the traditions of wrestling at that point called for there to be only a minor spotlight on female wrestlers.

It took far too long to get to it, but 2004 saw those outdated traditions thrown out of the window when Lita and Trish Stratus were given the opportunity to main event an episode of Monday Night Raw.

On a Raw featuring Triple H, Randy Orton, Batista, Ric Flair, Chris Jericho, and Chris Benoit, it was left to Women's Champion Stratus defending the gold against Lita to close out that 6 December 2004 show.

That main event is a huge moment in wrestling history, and it's one that paved the way for how female wrestling is these days perceived in WWE. It's just a huge shame that Trish vs. Lita on that 2004 night only got seven minutes.


4. John Cena - 15 Years A Hero

John Cena Raw
WWE.com

Is John Cena the first top babyface who crowds began to sour on? Absolutely not. Where Cena broke the rules of professional wrestling, though, is in how WWE just powered forward with Big Match John as the uber-hero regardless of the intense boos so often directed his way.

Before Cena, even the biggest of stars would eventually be turned heel once the bloom was off the rose and the fan response began to wane. You can point to heavy hitters such as Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, The Rock, and even 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin who became villainous when the crowd response dictated a character change.

For Cena, once his early heel run as the Doctor of Thuganomics was so popular that it led to a babyface turn, the multiple-time World Champion has never once embraced the hate. To have a top star remain a babyface for over 15 years in itself is largely unheard of unless your name's Bruno Sammartino, and even more unique is having a top star remain a babyface for 15 years when a large portion of every venue is raining down boos on said star.

After doing this with John Cena, it looked for all the world that WWE was again going to follow this path with Roman Reigns. That was, of course, until Reigns joined forces with Paul Heyman just last month.


3. Bret Hart - A Simultaneous Babyface AND Heel

Bret Hart WWE champion
WWE.com

You could make an argument that Bret Hart broke the rules by being a slightly smaller World Champion at a time when beefed-up giants were commonplace - even if it took a steroid scandal for Hart to get the nod - but the reason for the Hitman's inclusion here is his run in 1997.

How Hart broke the rules here, is that he was able simultaneously to be both a heel and a babyface.

With the Excellence of Execution a whining villain to American audiences but a morally correct hero to the rest of the world, Hart played both roles to perfection in ways that felt nothing if not sensical and logical. It was brilliant from Bret, with 1997 showcasing an added layer of character depth to the Hitman character and to Bret Hart as a performer.

Never before had somebody managed to pull off such a daring trick of being two different personas to two different audiences at the same time, and it's testament to Bret Hart's talent in and out of the ring that he was able to do just that.


2. Orange Cassidy - The Wrestler Who Can't Be Bothered To Wrestle

Orange Cassidy
AEW

A wrestler who doesn't wrestle? That was the initial baffled thought of casual viewers upon seeing Orange Cassidy debut in All Elite Wrestling.

Of course, those who were familiar with Cassidy's previous work - in particular for Freshly Squeezed's time as Fire Ant in Chikara - knew that Orange was a hell of a worker..

By the very definition of it being a competitive contest, professional wrestling is based around wanting to win a match. And to do that, you obviously need enthusiasm and at least enough gusto to be bothered to launch proper offense on an opponent. Not our boy Orange, for his whole shtick is that he usually couldn't give a solitary sh*t about anything should it require even a modicum of effort.

Hailing from wherever, weighing in at whatever, the general presentation of Orange Cassidy is of a pro wrestler who really cannot be bothered to wrestle - as shown by the hands in his pockets, the half-assed shin kicks, and the fact that Cassidy can't even muster the effort to take his sunglasses off.

Orange Cassidy goes against so many wrestling rules, yet it's in taking that approach that has helped Orange stand out from the pack. Plus, y'know, he can put on a ridiculously entertaining, competitive match when the time calls for it.


1. Terry Funk - From Classic Wrestling Champion To Death Match Icon

terry funk
WWE.com

Terry Funk is one of the greatest wrestling champions in the history of the National Wrestling Alliance - with the emphasis here on wrestling.

Funk's contemporaries in that regard are the likes of Harley Race, Jack Briscoe, Ric Flair, and Dusty Rhodes. With a 14-month reign under his belt as the NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion, the Funker was viewed as a great traditional grappler who would always be happy to brawl when called for.

So, it came as a huge surprise when the later years of Funk's career saw him become a death match wrestler and a famed hardcore icon when in his 50s.

A traditional wrestler like Terry Funk was previously viewed as being above what many perceived as merely violent trash that had no place in the wrestling world. Would Ric Flair have partook in IWA's King of the Death Match tournament? Would Harley Race have matched Sabu with his love of barbwire? Could you ever imagine Jack Briscoe stepping foot in a ring featuring C4 explosive boards?

This just wasn't the norm for one of the NWA's finest ever champions. Yet Terry Funk went against all of that, going on to reinvent himself as a fully-fledged hardcore wrestler in the '90s - which in a bizarre way, despite the more dangerous nature, led to Funk's career being extended.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.