9 Most Disappointing Wrestling Surprises Ever

What could it be?! Only disappointment, my friend.

Rock Rikishi Foley
WWE

Wrestling loves itself a big surprise doesn't it? Whether it comes in the shape of months of vignettes, creepy videos or even just an anonymous individual within the show, wrestling history is littered with reveals that shocked us, appalled us or moved us. Sometimes a date would be announced, and speculation would run wild until the date itself came and the surprise was even more earth-shattering than we expected.

Other times, it was Hornswoggle.

Yeah, some of the most built up surprises and reveals in wrestling history have fizzled out on arrival, drawing groans and gasps from the audience, although those gasps were more through 'they did what?!' as opposed to any display of shock in a positive manner.

TNA made this into something of an art-form, promising arrivals and moves that were going to change the game but managed only to question the sanity of the game. Not to be outdone, World Wrestling Entertainment (and the World Wrestling Federation before it) has its own impressive back catalogue of questionable reveals and surprises, ranging from the downright insulting to the Hornswoggle.

But what are the most disappointing and underwhelming surprises of all time? Here are 9 that are right up there.

9. #August1Warning

August1Warning tito Ortiz
ImpactWrestling

By the summer of 2013 the Aces & Eights story had just about to outlasted its course of relevance. The Main Event Mafia had reformed to rid TNA of them forever, albeit a MEM that included Magnus and Rampage Jackson.

An #August1Warning had kept many (okay, some) on tenterhooks for a whole week. Would could it mean? Would it have consequences for Kurt Angle, Sting and the Main Event Mafia, or was time truly up for Bully Ray and his Aces & Eights?

The night came, and as Kurt Angle challenged A&E to a 5-on-5 career ending match. A brawl then ensued, because TNA. Mr. Anderson eventually accepted the challenge as only a professional wrestler can (ie; loudly), but once he did the lights went out. What could it be? Was the August1Warning about to be revealed?

It was indeed! The man behind the hashtag was revealed to be none other than MMA legend Tito Ortiz, causing the crowd to go absolutely mild. Yeah, no-one cared about Ortiz, and what followed was a very awkward minute or so of Ortiz standing with his arms crossed and Mr. Anderson looking a little perturbed. This definitely fell into the 'underwhelming' bracket.


8. Fake Razor, Fake Diesel

Fake Razor Ramon
WWE.com

Good lord this was stupid. On a number of occasions, Vince McMahon and the WWF/E creative team had the genius (ie: not genius) idea to turn Jim Ross of all people heel. Announcer alignment turns very rarely create any interest, not least when you're trying to turn the most beloved of his kind to the bad side.

Not only that, but it was attempted way back in 1996 via JR bringing Razor Ramon and Diesel back to the company. For weeks, Ross claimed he was bringing them back, and when the duo finally appeared on RAW they did so to some exceptionally tired groans. Yeah, fakes they were, and we're talking dollar store fakes at that.

Ironically, fake Razor Ramon would go on to join nWo Japan after his WWF stint ended.


7. Of Course That's Who 'They' Are

Abyss Hogan Ring
TNA

2010 was a weird year for TNA. It started with some true enthusiasm and optimism, Hulk Hogan and Eric Bischoff were on board and the company finally seemed ready to move up a level, something richly deserved by the incredible talent roster they had at the time. Then, they moved to go against WWE on Monday nights and got utterly destroyed.

Abyss was positioned as the super hero of the company, something that made as little sense then as it does now. This obviously didn't work, and Abyss subsequently turned heel by shoving Hulk Hogan's Hall of Fame ring down his throat and going on a rampage through the company. He claimed that 'they' were controlling him, and 'they' were coming. When? Coincidentally, 'they' would arrive at the Bound for Glory PPV.

If you know anything about Eric Bischoff and Hulk Hogan, you are safe in assuming that 'they' turned out to be them. It wasn't a huge surprise, but it was definitely an underwhelming reveal. The trio aligned with Jeff Hardy and Jeff Jarrett, who then aligned with Ric Flair's Fortune stable. TNA had just another monster heel stable in charge, and nobody cared.


6. Awesome Videos, Underwhelming Reveal

Chris Jericho-2012-05
wwe.com

This is a strange one, as it takes two excellent individual things and proves that gold plus gold can often equal bronze. Towards the end of 2011 a number of excellent vignettes were played talking about 2012 being the beginning of the end, or more accurately that in 2012 'the End Begins'. The videos took place in a creepy school and were generally narrated by a creepy school-kid. In short, they were awesome.

The reveal came, and the reveal turned out to be none other than Y2J, Chris Jericho. Jericho came out in a crazy lit-up jacket and proceeded to troll the crowd completely, saying nothing and leaving. All of that build up, for that? Okay, it wasn't terrible, but the two were not mutually compatible.

The videos built up the idea that something major was about to change, but what we got was a silent Jericho who then finished runner-up in a Royal Rumble he obviously should have won.


5. Why Rikishi, Why?

Rikishi Heel Turn
WWE.com

At the 1999 Survivor Series, tragedy struck Stone Cold Steve Austin as the Texas Rattlesnake got hit by a car. It was a hit and run attack alright, but the identity of the assailant remained a secret. The story ran for 11 months (ELEVEN MONTHS). Who ran over Austin? Could it have been Triple H? Was it Vince McMahon? Hornswoggle? The 1997 Denver Broncos?

Well, not quite. Mick Foley felt sure he had got to the bottom of the case, pointing the finger square at WWF Champion The Rock. Foley was wrong however, and Rikishi of all people confessed to running over Austin. He then famously proclaimed that he did it, for The Rock.

You know, it all kinda makes sense. Rikishi wanted to protect his family's spot at the top of the business, I can accept that. But it was yet another poorly-planned attempt to turn a wildly popular babyface heel that ended with disaster and thumb-twiddling.


4. Hornswoggle 1 - The Anonymous General Manager

Edge Anonymous Raw General Manager.jpg
WWE.com

I might as well just get these two out of the way back to back. The running joke is that if something or someone is going to be the secret reveal to a story, the chances are that person is going to be Hornswoggle. Well, this will no longer be the case as the Little Bastard has been released from WWE, but he was indeed the reveal for two high-profile stories that simply demanded a better outcome.

For one whole year, Monday Night RAW was controlled by an Anonymous General Manager, who sent emails to a laptop to be read out by Michael Cole. This was the state of affairs for one year, and even then it was never revealed as to who the man in charge was.

The reveal came yet another year later, during the 998th episode of RAW. It was Hornswoggle, in what amounted to nothing more than a sweeping under the carper (sweeping under the ring) of a major storyline that WWE clearly had no idea where they were going with from start to end.


3. Hornswoggle 2 - The Illegitimate Son

Hornswoggle Vince McMahon Triple H
WWE.com

Why Mr. Kennedy, why?! Rumour has it that Ken Kennedy was going to be revealed as Vince McMahon's illegitimate son in 2007, but a Wellness Program violation put an end to his planned monster push. WWE was too deep into the son angle to turn back, so a back-up plan was made and carried out. That back-up plan? Hornswoggle.

Yes, what was going to be a career-changing story for a potential main event talent became a comedic afterthought, which eventually concluded with a JBL/Finlay WrestleMania match of all things. Hornswoggle as Vince McMahon's illegitimate son made little sense, and screamed of nothing more than lazy contingency booking.

It was also frustratingly underwhelming.


2. The Gobbledy Gooker

Gobbledy Gooker
WWE.com

For those of us born in the middle of the 1980s, the 1990 Survivor Series may very well be the first real wrestling memory. The Undertaker arrived on the scene that night, causing many of us to have nightmares for the next few weeks. Funnily enough however, the arrival of the man who would go on to have the most respected career in the business wasn't the main talking point coming out of the show some 26 years ago.

No, the main thing to happen on that show at the time was actually the hatching of a giant egg. The egg had sat ominously for months, just waiting to hatch, holding either secrets or something terrifying. It turned out that it actually just held Hector Guerrero in a big turkey suit, as 'Mean' Gene Okerlund revealed what was known as the Gobbledy Gooker.

The whole thing was quite obviously a sham, and went nowhere fast. Needless to say, Undertaker has experienced longer success.


1. The Higher Power

Triple H Vince McMahon The Undertaker Higher Power
WWE.com

Some may disagree with this being the most disappointing surprise ever, but is it the most confusing, the most ridiculous, the most illogical? Well, yes.

In 1999, Vince McMahon's Corporation began beefing with The Undertaker and his Ministry of Darkness. Taker was particularly satanic during this time and actually kidnapped Vince's daughter Stephanie, in an attempt to have some sort of weird dark wedding with her. This happened twice, and the second time Steph was saved by Steve Austin of all people.

Vince and Austin reconciled their differences, as it seemed Vince was starting to soften in his old age. Sensing this, Shane McMahon booted him out of the Corporation and actually merged it with Taker's Ministry. Of course, during this time Taker claimed to be working under the orders of a 'higher power'. The time came to reveal just who that power was and, as we all know now, it turned out to be Vince McMahon. Why?

To screw with Austin.

It made no sense then, it hurts the brain even more now. What could have been a truly juicy, psychologically thrilling storyline reverted straight back into the McMahon family saga. Beware, Sister Abigal fans, beware...


In this post: 
Hornswoggle
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.