AEW All Out 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True
Welcome to everyone's AEW All Out nightmares. Chicago's gonna hate it!
Some who bought tickets in advance for All Out probably hate it already because CM Punk won't be there. Those same folks might be cursing Tony Khan for suspending their hero following that backstage scrap with Jack Perry, then they'll rewatch All In with jealous eyes knowing Punk vs. Samoa Joe happened inside Wembley Stadium.
That might not be the only downer on Sunday.
Positivity? Pah! Who needs stinking positivity when there are so many nightmares lurking in the shadows waiting to ruin everything? All Out might be one of the weakest supershow cards in AEW history already, and questions are being asked about why the company planned pay-per-views on consecutive weekends in the first place.
Brace yourselves for unwanted title changes, the complete annihilation of a homegrown star's promise, one of the most bizarre gimmick matches nobody expected to see in 2023, illogical turns and more horror shows from a promotion that can't really afford any.
If all of this happens, then that post-show press conference could be interesting. TK might even produce more meme-worthy facial expressions that keep us all going for another 12 months.
10. AEW Wastes TNT Title Potential
First of all, here's something worth saying: Darby Allin is fantastic in the underdog babyface role, and he could easily have worked the same fighting champ International Title magic Orange Cassidy has been doing since last year. However, Darbs winning the TNT gold again would be stupid.
Luchasaurus turning on Christian Cage (either because Cage can't control the monster or because the big dinosaur is sick of his rubbish) should be AEW's long-term plan. Like, that literally needs to happen at some point - it's too easy a story to skip, and would be akin to Tony Khan missing an easy lay-up.
Allin doesn't need to "three-peat" just yet.
All Elite has landed on something special with Christian being a top class d*ck, and they shouldn't spurn that just to book a quick title switch at All Out. There's no sense in taking the belt from Cage/Luchasaurus quite yet. Let their story breathe!
9. Sting = Shoddy Mentor
It'd be kinda weird if Sting wasn't in the house for Darby Allin's latest TNT Title challenge. Sure, AEW's announcers could reason that Darby asked his mentor to skip the show so he could prove something on his own, but...that'd make the icon look stupid.
After all, he'd know that heels like Luchasaurus and Christian Cage couldn't be trusted to keep it one-on-one. All Elite might have a whole hell of a lot of explaining to do if the Stinger isn't in Chicago to rush out and help Allin fend off the obvious numbers game.
In fact, one of the commentary team would be forgiven for asking: 'Where the f*ck is Sting?!'. Last weekend, Sting and Darby won a 'Coffin Match' in front of 80,000+ at Wembley, so it'd be fairly thick if someone as experienced as Stinger suddenly went missing and let Allin take a two-on-one kicking.
Fingers crossed nobody looks silly.
8. The TBS Belt Bounces Around
Deep down, Kris Statlander had to be bummed out that she wasn't on the lineup for All In over in the UK. Some fans online openly wondered if that would've been the case for former champ Jade Cargill - she was always presented as a big star, so the TBS Title might've found a spot on the Wembley Stadium show with her at the helm.
Sunday is Statlander's chance to use that frustration as fuel. Or, y'know, it's AEW's chance to prove to the world that the TBS strap will just bounce around haphazardly from champion to champion for no rhyme or reason. In other words, Ruby Soho might win the thing.
Then what?
The ongoing Outcasts split story involving Ruby, Toni Storm and Saraya (mainly the latter two) doesn't need more gold. Saraya just won the AEW Women's Title, so it's vital that's the focal point in any tension. Besides, Kris deserves better than to drop the belt so suddenly.
7. Miro Squashes Powerhouse Hobbs
Powerhouse Hobbs’ AEW career has been on thin ice since the TNT Title debacle that brought his rise to a screeching halt. Can he lose to Miro at All Out? Well, yes, but the guy still has to look competitive and like he has a future fans should look forward to.
Basically, a squash loss would send him plummeting into the freezing cold depths of nothingness on a roster that's simply too large to survive such a fall. There might be no coming back for the former Team Taz and QTV man should Miro go all Bill Goldberg on him in Chicago.
Be very careful, AEW.
It's not impossible to envision a baffled Hobbs looking around like a total loser after being eaten alive by the former Rusev. Miro himself needs more to make his company career sing, and Tony Khan might reason that a certain Powerhouse is expendable right about now.
What a grim outcome that'd be.
6. Jon Moxley's Blood Overshadows
See above for Jon Moxley's wrestling heaven. The man loves being covered in blood, and he must've been loving life in amongst all that twisted barbed wire and broken wood during 'Stadium Stampede'. Christ, Mox was practically orgasmic as people recoiled in horror when some skewers were spiked into his skull.
There's no need for any of that on Sunday.
Jon's bout with Orange Cassidy must be a straight-up pro wrestling clinic. Both are capable of exciting the crowd without any bells and whistles, and it'd be pretty rotten if Moxley's obsession with bleeding all over the place overshadowed what could be Cassidy's final International Title defence.
No, keep it simple. Seeing Mox return to the aggressive, no-frills style he deployed in New Japan and AEW post-WWE would be for the best. The BCC member shouldn't bring buckets of blood and gimmicky ultra-violence to the ring with him every single time; only when it suits.
5. The ‘Strap Match’ Actually Happens
This doesn't feel real.
AEW has touted that Ricky Starks will challenge the legendary Ricky Steamboat to an f'n 'Strap Match' on Saturday's episode of Collision. Now, it's likely TK has some shenanigans up his sleeve instead (and CM Punk was probably supposed to run in on that segment), but it's still hella weird.
What if they actually go through with it? What if Steamboat hauls on some boots to face Starks in 2023's most unlikely gimmick showdown on pay-per-view? The card, whilst definitely lacklustre, doesn't need this sort of thing to round it out. It sounds like a step too far, and an unnecessary one at that.
Yes, Steamboat defied expectations to have a scorcher vs. Chris Jericho in 2009. In two thousand and nine. That Backlash '09 showing was over 14 years ago now, and he was past his prime then. Do AEW really want to risk this when there's so much doubt heading into All Out anyway?
4. Don Callis Wrecks A Killer Match
Don Callis is a top wrestling manager, and this writer (as a former manager himself) appreciates what he brings to the table. However, picking one's spots is crucial when managing, especially if you're around ringside for a hotly-anticipated match. Kenny Omega vs. Konosuke Takeshita is certainly that.
Most of the build towards this match has revolved around Callis turning on Kenny and Omega's revenge bid. That's cool, but AEW shouldn't shine all of the spotlight on that by having Don interfere too much on Sunday night. In fact, keep his involvement in the bout bell-to-bell to a bare minimum.
Omega and Takeshita deserve that, and so do fans plonking down pay-per-view dollars.
A sideward glance over at Paul Heyman on the WWE side should reveal the best course of action. Paul E rarely gets physically involved in Roman Reigns' matches unless it makes sense. Picking Don's spots and making sure they don't encroach on a killer match is gonna be key.
3. AEW Books An Illogical Turn
Please, no!
A few folks sitting close to this guy at Wembley thought Adam Cole might stab (not literally) MJF in the back following their World Title headliner last week. It didn't happen, and rightly so. AEW can spin this out a while longer, because both guys have serious chemistry together.
It'd be a morale-sapping nightmare for people watching All Out if MJF or Cole turned on the other man this Sunday. Smart money would have to go on Adam doing the dirty eventually, if only 'cause Max is clicking as a breakout babyface who still struts around like he hates the entire world.
Seeing Friedman get Cole's head in the game for their ROH Tag Title defence, only for Adam to side with Roderick Strong and The Kingdom anyway, would suck. It'd be illogical at this point in the story, and would be one of those wrasslin' turns for the sheer sake of it.
2. And Another Unwanted Title Change
(SPOILER WARNING FOR RAMPAGE AHEAD!)
It could also lead to another unwanted title switch.
Dark Order members John Silver and Alex Reynolds won a Battle Royale on the pre-taped episode of Rampage that airs/aired (depending on when you're reading this) on Friday. That win guarantees them a crack at the ROH Tag-Team Titles on All Out's main card, which is...a bit meh, to be honest.
The real juice in this situation comes from the odd couple chemistry MJF and Adam Cole have. Dark Order challenging feels more weekly TV than pay-per-view worthy, but the creaking AEW gimmick could leave Chicago with some gold this weekend.
That'd stomp all over what happened during Wembley's 'Zero Hour' pre-show, and it'd throw away weeks (if not months) of story work between Better Than You, Bay Bay. Stranger things have happened in this biz though, so don't be too shocked if Roddy Strong and The Kingdom lads screw MJF and Cole over.
1. It’s The Worst AEW PPV Yet
Generally, AEW's pay-per-views represent terrific value for money. They're long, but the core audience likes that, and they know they'll see some world class wrestling by purchasing. That's technically still the case on Sunday (Omega vs. Takeshita, for example), but things are paper-thin.
This is up there with the second Forbidden Door show as one of All Elite's most skippable supershows. Of course, that depends on the type of fan you are. Those who devour everything with glee will still have fun. Those who want proper build towards every match on the card probably won't.
Could this be Tony Khan's worst PPV yet? It's possible. All Out 2023 has several matches that are nowhere near supershow quality; Samoa Joe vs. Shane Taylor, MJF and Adam Cole vs. Dark Order and Kris Statlander vs. Ruby Soho spring to mind there.
Strap yourselves in. This could be bumpy.
Which other nightmares could come true at AEW All Out 2023? For more like this, check out WWE Payback 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE Payback 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!