Deep Dive: Roman Reigns Vs. Jey Uso Was WWE At Its Absolute Best

Reigns vs. Uso excelled because WWE kept it simple, stupid.

Roman Reigns Jey Uso
WWE.com

Professional wrestling need not be complicated.

We forget this at times, but who can blame us? Vince McMahon loathes the word "wrestling." The bulk of his tenure as WWE Chairman has seen him attempt to steer the market-leading promotion far away from its roots as scripted combat. This is Sports Entertainment, pal, not rasslin'. The people you watch on television aren't rasslers, but Superstars, and you, dear viewer, are a member of the WWE Universe.

McMahon isn't the only person complicit in this (what's up, Vince Russo?), though he is comfortably the most influential. His product is often closer to a television show about wrestling than a wrestling television show. Recent episodes of Raw have been built around RETRIBUTION waging company-sponsored "chaos" on an entity that gave them contracts regardless, a Mysterio family feud lowlighted by romantic teases between 19-year-old Aalyah and 31-year-old Murphy (plus Seth Rollins' "not the father" bit), and pointless, nonsensical tag team splits.

Logic is lost in this realm. Almost 20 years on from the Monday Night Wars, the game's most successful company is increasingly intent on presenting a full-on soap opera with a side serving of combat when it ought to be the other way around. Yes, wrestling should be open to evolution, and its wackier side has yielded hundreds of iconic moments, but WWE often veers so far from the source that it isn't even in the rearview anymore. For the most part, the illusion of "competition" has rarely been less important in this realm.

Which is why Jey Uso vs. Roman Reigns was one of the best stories WWE has told in years.

CONT'd...


Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Having opted to safeguard his family's wellbeing at the onset of the global health crisis, Roman Reigns blasted back in spectacular fashion at SummerSlam 2020. Bray Wyatt had just defeated Braun Strowman to become Universal Champion for a second time. A familiar theme hit and out came 'The Big Dog,' finally triggering a heel turn fans had been waiting five years for by trucking the main-eventers, then holding the belt aloft. His intentions were clear.

Concerns that this wasn't a true heel turn were assuaged when Reigns shockingly connected with Paul Heyman on the following week's SmackDown. Two days later, Roman left it until the last minute to sign his match contract, impose himself on Wyatt and Strowman's Payback walk-and-brawl, and lift the Universal Title. His opponents had already done the hard work of beating the tar out of each other: all Reigns had to do was collect his reward.

Roman wins lol became the character. And it ruled. If it upset you, it was because it was supposed to.

Breaking bad fundamentally changed Reigns' relationship with every other character on the roster. With regards to his first cousins, The Usos, WWE could have gone one of two ways:-

1. Reform the Bloodline and present them as a heel unit for the first time. A compelling choice despite Jimmy's absence, as he and Jey proved themselves excellent at playing aggressive villains after their incredible 2016 turn.

2. A collision course.

While the promotion may eventually go back to point number one, they made the right choice. Running Jey against Roman was inspired.

CONT'd...


Jey Uso
WWE

Jey's ascension came weeks into a Big E singles push many had been waiting a long, long time for. The New Day man was placed into a number one contendership bout on the 4 September episode of SmackDown as part of this. Baron Corbin, Matt Riddle, and Sheamus would have been his opponents, but E was taken out by the Irishman beforehand, leaving Jey (who'd already met with Roman earlier in the evening, asserting he'd always have his back) to take his place.

That there was no major backlash for E losing this spot speaks to how well it was played. Jey now had a guaranteed shot at a World Title held by his cousin, creating the most perfect tension without needless complications.

The story was simple enough for a child to comprehend, but layered and nuanced - characteristics one doesn't usually associate with WWE storylines. Jey "had his cousin's back," but he was still going to be Jey, while Roman's attitude had flipped completely, and he'd have to crush his own flesh and blood's dreams to prevail. Brilliant, engaging stuff, and true to wrestling's core. A competitive framework plus a deep-rooted personal relationship equals money, every single time.

A masterful build highlighted by that scowl on 18 September and a phenomenal promo battle the following week concluded with the 'Tribal Chief' laying out a man he claimed could never ascend to his throne. The fight was on.

CONT'd...


WWE Clash of Champions 2020 Roman Reigns Jey Uso Jimmy Uso
WWE.com

Uso and Reigns' Clash of Champions showdown was often heavyhanded in its delivery, but the story beats were perfect. This will go down one of the most memorable main events in modern WWE history.

An extended squash in the vein of John Cena and Brock Lesnar's SummerSlam 2014 bout saw Uso and Reigns enter elite performances in contrasting roles. The Universal Champion was cold and ruthless, but also methodical and composed, informing Jey's early offensive spurts and the controlled dominance that would follow later on. His opponent sold as well as he timed his comebacks, spiking sympathy and drama at all the right points. A live audience would have gone nuts for him.

Jey was soundly defeated in the end, the lopsided pounding forcing his injured brother Jimmy to throw in the towel. Reigns, definitively, was the 'Tribal Chief.' The family hierarchy was now undeniable.

The layout was of great importance here, as a textbook back-and-forth main event would have undermined the goal of establishing Roman's superiority. He needed to look like a monster at Clash of Champions. The normalisation of 50/50 booking has broken fans' brains, instilling a belief that wrestler A should always look like wrestler B's equal, prompting absurd "burial!" accusations whenever somebody looks halfway dominant.

Yet nobody left Clash of Champions thinking Reigns had buried his cousin: a testament to two excellent performances and equally high-level storytelling from the promotion that created these warped perceptions in the first place.

And Reigns emerged from Clash not only his tribe's alpha, but WWE's as a whole.


Roman Reigns Jey Uso
WWE.com

Jey lost nothing from falling to his cousin in this manner. His character's pride will be dented, sure, though he lost to a man who looks more fearful in WWE's comic book universe than Thanos does in Marvel's. Not even a time-travelling Avengers force could have felled Reigns at Clash of Champions; Iron Man would have died in the first act.

And this storytelling - this simple, uncomplicated storytelling - is what WWE must return to over the coming years.

WWE Raw pulled 3.330 million viewers on this week in 2015. Five years later, it will hit roughly half of that for last night's show. A recent Variety Intelligence Platform survey quizzed 471 lapsed fans aged 18 or older on why they'd given up on professional wrestling, with 30% responding "it seemed more cartoonish than when I liked it," a combined 57% saying "storylines/characters were not as good/interesting," and 14% citing the content being "more geared towards children."

Reigns vs. Uso addressed all of these issues. This was a storyline straightforward enough for kids to invest in and understand without sacrificing the depth required to keep adults hooked. Although some of the match's expositionary trash talk bordered on hand-holding, at no point in the feud did it feel like WWE was taking your intelligence for granted. Besides, most viewers seemed to love the smack-talk.

This was a history-rich, competitive tale that straddled the line between sport-like and Sports Entertainment perfectly. It was everything the people surveyed by Variety said was missing from today's product when they spoke of cartoonish programming geared towards children.

CONT'd...


Roman Reigns
WWE

This week's SmackDown will likely tell us what's next for Roman and Jey.

It could be that their feud is over. This would be fine, as Clash of Champions would be an excellent way to put this relationship on ice for now, with the storyline's events and developments giving both men plenty to work with - together or apart. Uso is a bonafide singles stud now, while Reigns is almost Lesnar-like in his aura - and on a full-time schedule. Neither man is the same as when they crossed paths after Payback.

Or perhaps this was just the first act in a longer story, as there's still plenty of ground to explore not only between Roman and Jey, but Jimmy and other Samoan dynasty members as well. Afa, Sika, and Rikishi all appeared in one of the pre-match video packages. Involving more tribe members could serve to expand the war, or reform the Bloodline - as touched upon earlier.

Jimmy isn't expected to be cleared until January 2021. Who says Clash needs an immediate follow-up, though? A lack of long-term storytelling is another deep-rooted WWE problem; utilising the same restraint shown prior to Bayley and Sasha Banks' implosion would defy it. While attention spans feel shorter than ever in 2020, hooking viewers for longer than three or four weeks at a time is critical to WWE's recovery. This is done through rewarding investment.

Objectively, Vince McMahon is the most successful wrestling promoter of all time. WWE's financial power and indomitable market share speak to this. Subjectively, he is an increasingly lousy booker propped up by monstrous television rights fees, making his company failure-proof despite its myriad creative issues.

Penning more feuds like Roman Reigns vs. Jey Uso can change that.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.