Every WWE Backlash Main Event Ranked Worst To Best
Triple H may get a brief mention.
Back in the day, the purpose of Backlash was relatively straightforward - to settle the unclosed grudges established at WrestleMania. For this reason, it had big shoes to fill, especially when it came to main events. Sometimes it succeeded, and sometimes it didn't.
In more recent years, Backlash has been resurrected, firstly as a blue-brand pay per view, and more recently still, as a red-blue mash up. Its identity as a whole therefore remains in flux. With the fifteenth Backlash event on the horizon, there is a balance of exemplary moments and highly questionable ones in the show's history. Nobody really knows what it's for any more, but every WWE fan has at least one golden wrestling memory that occurred under its banner.
The main events of Backlash perfectly exemplify the duality of quality in WWE. On this list, one can find the over-glorified and misconceived, through to the perfectly booked and neatly executed. With titles on the line and competitors striving to either stay relevant or get that extra big push, high quality is expected as standard, and at certain point, delivered.
14. Triple H Vs. Hulk Hogan (2002)
Yes, fans did love Hulk's WWE homecoming in 2002, and yes he was a top card draw and Triple H was the champ. So this title match was kind of inevitable, but still...
To start with, the in-ring work was a little lackluster and oversold. With all respect to a veteran of Hulk's stature, the Cerebral Assassin had no window to go full pelt on his opponent, which is what the fans had come to expect in a Triple H match. Hogan took the victory regardless, which was over-entitlement if we ever saw it.
To render this even more of a nonsensical event, the match had two completely pointless interventions. The first was from Chris Jericho, whose plan seemed to be to sabotage the match for all concerned. The second was from The Undertaker, who ran in to Hogan's aid, but then started throwing punches at him when The Hulkster rejected his support. 'Taker can furthermore be seen smiling when Hulk does win the championship. Are you guys friends or not?
The Game sneering like an angry poodle after losing the title sums up the silliness of the whole show.
13. Stone Cold & Triple H Vs. The Undertaker & Kane (2001)
The mighty fell real quick and real fast in this main event. The 'mighty' in question was of course the impressive run of excellent pay per views WWE had been pulling out the bag up until this point. Backlash 2001 was the first bad one in a long time.
Whatever the occasion, a tag team main event involving four competitors who were never known for their tag team credentials (Austin's WCW years aside) was a hard sell. Kane, Undertaker, Stone Cold and Triple H were four of the best workers in the business, so at least we got some good wrestling. In terms of narrative however, it was a car crash.
Austin sucked as a heel. By affiliation, his new best bud, Triple H had lost his edge in pairing up with him. In spite of this, they left the arena with the WWE title, the IC title, and the f**king tag team titles.
Seeing Austin and Triple H hold two belts apiece, whilst highly photogenic, represented a stark lack of progression in storytelling, as well as marking the prologue of an all-too lengthy run of bad ideas which pulled the company away from its freshest golden age.
12. Roman Reigns VS. Samoa Joe (2018)
Any occasion to see Samoa Joe work his magic can be considered a special event, but this match needed more than that. During that frustrating period when Reigns was being pushed too fast too quickly, there was at least the opportunity to give Samoa Joe the spotlight. In this instance at least, it all went a bit wrong.
Absolutely nothing of note happens in this match. It entails Joe beating all kinds of crap out of Reigns, with Roman only managing the cheapest of shots in return. It ends with the Big Dog obtaining a sly finisher, which incapacitates Joe and allows Reigns to get the three-count and retain the title. It made no sense.
Seeing Joe work his relentless brutality was easily a highlight, and his wrestling was on top form, but the one sided-nature of the match put into question the very reason for Roman's existence as a top baby face. It quickly earned itself a "This is boring" chant.
WWE had not yet gathered the message that this was not what fans wanted. It was anti-climactic on virtually every level.
11. The Rock Vs. Goldberg (2003)
No titles for grabs in this one, just pure showboating... Sort of.
On paper, and especially back in 2003, the idea of a Rock vs. Goldberg main event was something of a dream match. WWE provided, with one glaring stipulation. It was done during the time when The Rock was full swing with his Hollywood Heel persona, and so a clash of champions this was not.
Make no mistake, Rock's cowardly flexes when faced with Bill are p**s funny, and so is everything else he does in the match. He's an entertainer after all. However, when all is said and done, the main event of a post WrestleMania PPV is just not the time and place for it. While the interaction between the two competitors was great, the wrestling itself was clunky, bereft of progression and all too swift. Ultimately, it amounted to nothing more than a game of 'See how long it takes for Goldberg to catch this guy and squash him.'
Definitely not what the fans had been waiting years to see.
10. Triple H Vs. Batista (2005)
Long after the dust had settled on Evolution, Batista was billed as a top draw, and a self-made man. From that angle, it probably makes sense that he'd have to go through The Game, who incidentally, was in the main event of Backlash... again.
As far as wrestling goes, there isn't much to complain about. Batista is a notable monster, and Triple H is no featherweight either, so as one can imagine, there are some impressive feats of strength on display, but this also loses a lot of points for atmosphere. For the most part, the crowd seemed a little divided. Having Ric Flair offer up the occasional cheap shot does nothing for the match, and the closing act is deeply unsatisfying.
The ref gets knocked out, which means there's no count for Triple H's pin. Classic right? Except that The Game was supposed to be the heel of the piece. Without the scripted hiccup, he would have supposedly won clean. For that reason alone, Batista's eventual victory is tinted. The purpose of the main event it seemed, was to make somebody look good, but nobody's quite sure who.
9. Chris Benoit Vs. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels (2004)
From a technical standpoint, all boxes were ticked in this one. Chris Benoit was out to defend his status as the top baby face of early 2005, whilst Triple H and Shawn Michaels honourably continued their internal bickering. The chemistry between the three competitors was always going to make this a good match, and so fans were treated to a neat swill of technicality and honest brawling.
Ultimately, it was a slightly toned down version of the WrestleMania predecessor, but the audience were fully behind it, and the victory was as triumphant as we could ask for in a Backlash event.
There is of course a glaring reason why this isn't a watchable classic. A black cloud hangs over any match involving Chris Benoit, but this one is especially harrowing. In this particular event, the entire Benoit family can be seen watching in the front row. In hindsight of future events, the numerous shots of Chris Benoit's wife and two sons, as can still be viewed on the WWE network, render this whole episode too heartbreaking to enjoy to any full extent.
8. Randy Orton Vs. Triple H Vs. JBL Vs. John Cena (2008)
Who doesn't love a good elimination match; four contenders getting gradually whittled down to a final two, over an evenly-distributed period of time. It's a gripping format...
...except that it was grossly misused in this instance. After going through the motions of having four contenders make their patented entrances, including JBL's limousine shtick, it only took 11 minutes before JBL was eliminated. Cena is then knocked out a handful of seconds later, which leaves another 20 minutes of Orton and Hunter going one on one.
Ultimately it was false advertising, and should have been billed simply as Triple H versus Randy Orton. It's obvious Orton had to stick around, as he held the title, but the fact that Cena and Bradshaw missed out so swiftly killed any sense of storytelling.
That's not to say that Randy and Helmsley didn't put on a good show, but by that time, the damage had been done. The next dubious component came in the result. It was 2008 and The Game won the title clean. Make of that what you will.
7. Edge Vs. Triple H Vs. John Cena (2006)
This had the potential to be so much more and by all rights, started out great. There were some extremely entertaining interactions followed by some high-intensity wrestling. The neat balance of an otherwise great spectacle was, however, swiftly shifted. By 2006, it was apparent that Triple H had become an essential ingredient to the Backlash main event, whether fans wanted it or not. Here, we had a frank example of him stealing the show by force.
It may or may not have been intentional for him to start p**sing blood from the forehead, in a manner more appropriate for a street fight/three stages of hell match, but it seemed to immediately detract from the perfectly reasonable bout between Cena and Edge. Worse still, Helmsley ended up laying out both competitors with a sledgehammer before doing DX 'suck it' gestures in the middle of the ring. The victory therefore went effortlessly to The Game.
With all other intentions thrown aside, it became the Triple H show 2.0. At this stage in his career, it was fully unnecessary.
6. The Rock Vs. Stone Cold (1999)
Stone Cold's victory at WrestleMania XV was an uplifting segment of the Austin vs. The Corporation saga, even if the match itself was a little swift. The follow-up came one month later, in the debut Backlash of 1999.
It was an improvement in every sense. With the match sprawling into an all-out street fight, Steve was blatantly in his element. At the same time, Rocky was content in doing nothing other than becoming the centre of attention. He even took to the commentary box, and tried to film his beating down of Austin which, to the crowds' delight, backfired.
It's clear that the two superstars loved working together. There was no real venom in this particular rivalry, only pure entertainment. The match was everything the fans could have hoped for and more.
It was also nestled in that bat-s**t crazy Corporate-Ministry storyline, which meant that Vince McMahon was of a relatively noble standing. His honest handover of Stone Cold's customised championship belt provided ample closure. Keep in mind that the ridiculous 'It was me Austin... It was me all along' angle had not yet reared its ugly head.
5. Randy Orton Vs. Jinder Mahal (2017)
The main event of this SmackDown-oriented Backlash might look a little strange on card, but it really worked. The Modern Day Maharaja was propelled into the spotlight, and now was the time for him to prove his worth. As far as this match was concerned, everything snapped together neatly, and the wrestling was top notch. Were the crowd divided? Yes. But they were also electrified. Those who weren't paying attention to Jinder Mahal before, certainly were at this point.
Kudos also goes out to The Viper. As well as being a vet of almost 15 years, who'd had more than his fair share of breaks, Orton was able to prove that he was still worth the price of a ticket. Skip to this from his Legend Killer years and you can witness an athlete fully capable of improving with age.
Even though Jinder won the title by being a bit of a cheat, which wasn't really necessary given his ability, this was a great put-over for him, and dumbfounded audiences in the best possible way. It's a shame that the momentum didn't sustain itself for very long after this extremely decent event.
4. John Cena Vs. Edge (2009)
It seemed in this case that WWE had learned from past misgivings. John Cena and Edge would have a had a perfectly reasonable main event back in 2006's Backlash, if Triple H hadn't snatched the moment. This time around, it was pure one on one, and in Last Man Standing format. It ensured that the bout was of substantial length, and also that both competitors were able to unveil every morsel of skill in their wrestling arsenal.
In this test of endurance, Edge and Cena had the opportunity to elevate their rivalry to dream match status. All the tricks, and a few bonuses, were on display, including a moment when Cena threw Edge into the audience.
A fun finale to this classy match came at the hands of the BIg Show. A silly as it sounded on paper, his choke-slamming of Cena into a giant spotlight was remarkably effective. The piros went of at the exact right moment, and Cena's lifeless form, slouched inside the light's broken frame really made you feel for the guy.
3. AJ Styles Vs. Dean Ambrose (2016)
It was 2016, AJ Styles had landed, and the fans wanted more. A rise to title status was a given, but it was important that it was done right. The match at Backlash provided, and was an outright triumph for the blue brand.
Still a fresh baby face, and full of life, Dean Ambrose proved himself to be the man for the job. Sure he was going to lose the belt, but he was going to lose it with class. In wonderfully rich 30-minute event, brawl met technical brains, chemistry was through the roof, and the selfless high-risk escapades of both competitors ensured that they had the audiences' full attention for the entire duration.
Alas the crowd were mostly backing a notably devious AJ, despite the fact that he low-blowed his way to victory. It didn't matter at this point, as both competitors put bone, brain and guts into their performances. It proved that while the promotion was struggling, the quality of talent was unquestionable. The 'This is Awesome' chant was well earned.
Watching back, it reminds us why these guys, in their own separate quarters, are still on top.
2. Edge Vs. John Cena V.s Randy Orton Vs. Shawn Michaels. (2007)
Particularly for a main event, a Fatal Four Way can be a tough pitch at the best of times. A good start would be to find reasons why matches like this were even invented in the first place. Cue Backlash 2007. The main event between Cena, Orton, Edge and Michaels is an exercise in how the four-man format can sometimes go very very right.
Here we had a group of polar opposites who were not only able to hold their own corner, but to also bring out the best in each other. There was no dominant figure here, just a gathering of athletes striving to continuously one-up each other. Yet it was done with so much humility, that all four men were clearly wavering personal interest in favour of putting on the best show possible for the crowd...
and that they did. High risks, hard knocks and double crosses, all came thick and fast. The chemistry, and the timing were top notch, nobody lagged and everybody had their moment to shine. Irrespective of result, it was damn near perfect, and what pro wrestling is truly about on any given day.
1. The Rock Vs. Triple H (2000)
Sometimes, everything just clicks.
Yes the closing act of Backlash 2000 was a little silly and anarchic, but with it came one of the purest forms of good versus bad in WWE match history. The premise was effectively simple. The Rock was out to claim the gold from Triple H, and the McMahon family were on side to place every obstacle possible in The Great One's way. Rocky's only hope of victory lay in the prophesied return of Stone Cold Steve Austin, who had been out of action for six months prior.
In this particular story, every character was in their greatest element. Vince was the corporate cheat, his kids were the entitled arseholes, Triple H was the glory-hunting bully, and Rock was the lone warrior hell bent on dismantling the entire faction.
As for Austin himself, his return at The Rock's most perilous moment came with one of the most deafening roars from a WWE crowd, and from commentary too for that matter. Nobody cared that The Rattlesnake was still recovering from surgery, and was therefore not actually capable of wrestling. Umpteen chair shots later, and the house was cleared. Rock took the title and he and Steve cracked some beer and toasted to the belt.
Pure gold.