How AEW Just Took Fan Service Too Far

In which AEW must Do The Work.

Cody Dynamite
Lee South/AEW

AEW in 2020 is a tremendous pro wrestling promotion that inspires fervent praise from its audience, not least because that audience feels like an active participant - an influence, even. It feels to those fans like their critique has shaped the trajectory of the product.

"We listen..." Cody himself said, in his seminal Full Gear go-home promo. He wasn't bullsh*tting the people he was selling his pay-per-view match to.

AEW listened to various, justified complaints to embark on what was, before the world went to sh*t, an all-time great run of episodic wrestling television: Kenny Omega's grasp of details-heavy bangers operated within and advanced the TV match genre; Hangman Page got over in those same, excellent matches and with his distinct, offbeat comedy; the inspired booking was paced immaculately to reach a crescendo at the precise time at which the company asked for your money.

None of this would have happened, had AEW not listened to complaints over excessive, blanket match durations, the lack of promos and vignettes, the powerfully bad act that was the Nightmare Collective, the failure to project the Elite to the masses.

AEW empowers its audience. This might not be a uniformly brilliant thing, as it turns out.

CONT'D...(1 of 6)


AEW Dynamite TNT
AEW

We don't know of the storyline explanation for the newly-announced 'TNT Championship' that those fans have willed into existence on social media for months - only that it will likely function, as most modern midcard titles do, with a certain, cynical pragmatism.

The name itself has drawn scorn, but that's the last thing to worry about. It's an obvious appeal to the paymaster, one that can only help AEW's most pivotal relationship, but it doubles as real sports presentation. Virtually every competition in English sport is sponsored, for example. It's also a synonym of the Television Championship. That is easily inferred.

It feels like an inelegant means of getting under-utilised acts on TV beyond the believable grudge element that separates the best companies from the most functional. There's a general vibe of consolation and obligation to a midcard title, much as AEW will reject that pejorative designation publicly. That's ultimately what any non-World Title is in an era in which the World Championship is no longer toured.

A midcard title is oxymoronic.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)


MJF Sammy Guevara
AEW

Even the gentler description, the secondary title, instantly positions it as lesser-than. And if the idea is to get it over as a true prize equivalent to the World Championship, why? The AEW World Championship is already very prestigious in its feel, which is deeply impressive. Why dilute that?

A midcard/secondary title can develop a sense of prestige through identity. The WWF Intercontinental Title comfortably coexisted with the winged eagle because it set itself apart stylistically; the secondary title was the preserve of the technical artist and or the emerging singles player, where the WWF Champion was the hulking, larger-than-life megastar. The early model for the Television Championship, in Mid-Atlantic, made tremendous use of stakes for its broadcasts in a way that complemented and did not detract from the aura and purpose of the touring World Heavyweight champion.

The TNT Championship requires an identity - or an in-canon reason to exist, at least. What we know of AEW's territorial inspiration leads one to suspect that the Television Title is the clear model. The shorter time limit would allow for more urgent and dramatic bangers, and if the Mid-Atlantic/JCP prophesy is in fact fulfilled, watching a Sammy Guevara or an MJF find creative ways to run down the clock and retain the strap should make for tremendous television - and a tremendous pay-per-view moment, when the clock runs down on them. But even at its most theoretically promising, the TNT Title feels like a device more than a prize.

The secondary title isn't purely an anachronism in the modern era.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)


Darby Allin
Scott Lesh Photography/AEW

New Japan Pro Wrestling gets away with its Intercontinental Title through its roster of huge stars - it's necessary only for business reasons, in that it headlines shows on two and three-legged destination events - and is the only workable modern vision of a secondary belt. It still isn't the same. The IWGP Intercontinental Title match never feels as big nor as unmissable as the epic Heavyweight clash. The secondary strap sells some tickets, and the matches are great, and that's ultimately what all of this is for, but there's a ruthless precision to it. No Young Lion dreams of winning the IWGP Intercontinental Title.

Consider Darby Allin. His winning the TNT Championship dilutes his journey to the absolute pinnacle. He started in AEW as a total unknown in mainstream circles. He got over with his artistry, creativity, and super-dynamic polymath ring style. There's an in-character explanation for his suicide dive, otherwise the most flagrantly cannibalised move in the entire industry. Kids are copying his iconic look. He has gotten over by losing repeatedly, but showing enough spirit and quality to forge a connection with fans in narrow, harsh defeat. There's something magical about the prospect - and what it says about the belief one can place in AEW's process - of Darby Allin going all the way and winning the big one.

There's something almost patronising about the alternative, or at least deflating. He has earned - or is on his way to earning - the distinction of becoming the champion of a wrestling world that stupidly saw nothing in him. Outcast punk artist Darby Allin instead winning a corporately-sponsored second-rung prize feels off, in some hard-to-place way. Allin, to use AEW's own nomenclature, was undesirable. An AEW World Championship win would make him undeniable. A midcard, nearly-there title is almost an asterisk in his story. He doesn't have to win it, of course, but AEW falls into a plot hole otherwise.

CONT'D...(4 of 6)


Jungle Boy
Scott Lesh

AEW should have instead created a Trios Championship. Organically, the pieces are already in place. Jurassic Express, SCU, Death Triangle, MJF, Butcher and Blade, Best Friends and Orange Cassidy, Strong Hearts, any derivations of the Elite and the Inner Circle: there are several existing groups that could contend for it, and a Trios division is something unexplored on national U.S. television. It represents a guaranteed banger of a segment every other week, the likes of which furnish AEW with another, exhilarating USP. More lenient officiating could also play better to the impulses of some of the roster without irritating the tag team traditionalists. A Trios title just feels more futuristic and consistent with AEW's alternative philosophy. It's a WCW Cruiserweight division for the 21st century.

To get over, the TNT Championship will require - and is getting - significant focus. This will further marginalise the Women's division, which logistically cannot get over with one segment per Dynamite. It stigmatises the women as inconvenient, lesser talents the company is obligated to promote, and vanishes too many of the acts that had generated interest (Shanna, Jamie Hayter).

The counterargument - that those on the roster need "something to do" - is coldly utilitarian and not made in the spirit of true achievement. It's a 'something to do' title until it is established as something more than that, and there are several members of that ballooning roster in need of focused creative. There are several young talents years - and in the case of Jungle Boy, personas - away from capturing a World Championship.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)


Cody Rhodes
Scott Lesh Photography/AEW

The TNT Championship feels like an uninspired vehicle to do that. The joy of Jungle Boy's match with Chris Jericho late last year was in measuring his proximity to a legend, as much as the wild dynamic in itself. With a designated division of midcard acts all but imminent, this narrows similar creative opportunity - particularly since, with a rating to grab or a segment to fill, there is a shiny new temptation to build matches with tropes, and not imagination - contention battles and the like.

Perhaps this is another anxiety stemming from a brain broken by WWE. AEW has thus far subverted our expectations of contract signings, of long-term storylines, of gimmick matches, of so much that has long lost all meaning and purpose. But for now, this feels like a generic idea - a misstep designed to appease fans and possibly talent. Appease is not the same as 'award'. It's nowhere near as powerful.

Cody is going to have to sell the sh*t out of - and compete for - this TNT Championship.

It's more pyro than unscripted promo on the list of demands.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!