How Vince McMahon Destroyed Typecasting In WWE
The Fundamentals Of Caring
What's not to love about Paul Rudd?
For those that may not have fallen for his dreaminess in a twenty-minutes-too-long Apatowian nightmare, enjoyed the one actually relatable character amongst a group of six Friends you'd struggle with in real life, or marvelled at him gamely attempting to humanise the superhero genre in Ant Man, Paul Rudd is all the right parts for a particular part. Steady, humorous and humble, Rudd mostly sticks to roles that exploit his natural charms and the movies are better for it.
Such logic shouldn't stray too far away from pro wrestling - particularly Vince McMahon's version of it, he literally said as much in a toe-curling Beyond The Mat moment - and yet the billionaire that should only be a millionaire has in recent years completely lost sight of the real people behind his supposed Superstars.
Becky Lynch and Braun Strowman are recent cases of characters turned for a supposedly greater good that seems impossible to parse, but the problem cuts much deeper than taking away your heroes. Villains too so rarely get the opportunity to be the b*stards they can be, but a richer-than-ever Vince McMahon is so financially immune from his own mistakes in 2018 that's he stopped bothering to learn from them.
CONT'D...
McMahon was still looking for "the next" Hulk Hogan before he realised the first Steve Austin was the real answer to his problems. En route to 'The Rattlesnake' he took one of his most expensive wrong terms on a f*cking massive bus. The Lex Express' translucent windows couldn't hide the transparency of the gimmick himself. Lex Luger looked like the United States had vomited on him, which was ironically as close as the gimmick came to representing the true feelings of the audience.
Frustratingly, he'd got Luger right on Day One. Signed for his World Bodybuilding Federation ahead of a transition to the wrestling when that collapsed (because of course it did), 'The Narcissist' was allegedly not that hard a role for Lex to do the method work on. That his body was every bit a 'Total Package' during a crackdown on steroids sold the persona too. He wasn't a patriotic babyface, but - distracted by his struggling empire and an incoming federal trial - McMahon was desperate for a quick fix, and size was a safety net.
Sound familiar?
He got it wrong again when he misunderstood the cheers for the cool-as-f*ck Kevin Nash in 1994. Diesel was a breakout star in the Royal Rumble for the manner he which he drove through several foes before the field (and then-friend Shawn Michaels) conspired to oust him. He overachieved for the remainder of the year, and his imposing height and electric charisma was enough to convince McMahon to run his organisation on Diesel Power.
It ran out fuel the very second he made the bad*ss a grinning geek.
Sound familiar?
The Shield is WWE's greatest ground-up in-house creation of the decade, but Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose have -at one time or another - all been mowed by the mind that created a smiling Diesel Truck and red, white and blue bus.
What does he see now that none of us do?
CONT'D...
In Roman Reigns, Vince McMahon sees Stone Cold Steve Austin the Attitude Era babyface and Alliance heel at the very same time. Seth Rollins is part-Cyril Sneer, part-Superman, all-unbuttered toast. The 'Monday Night Rollins' narrative has done a good job of beating audiences into submission with the view that long matches are good matches, but the former WWE Champion hasn't knocked out a run of contests as good since before he was the b*llocked offspring of Stephanie McMahon and Triple H in 2015. Dean Ambrose is neither a wacky neighbour from a sitcom nor frightening loner from a horror film, but 'The Luntatic Fringe' was pegged as a nailed-on topliner by Mick Foley, William Regal and others before he even made it to the main roster.
These are men McMahon once couldn't do without, but yet again the monumental paradigm shift has adjusted everything about how The Chairman's warped mind works.
Characters aren't reliable from week-to-week, and the bewildering behaviour isn't exclusive to babyfaces. Kevin Owens was brutalised over the summer by Braun Strowman, but helped him beatdown The Shield for reasons as-yet-unexplored. Less than a month later, he begged Strowman for mercy in a Mixed Match Challenge encounter by using this very rationale for reason. 'The Monster Among Men' paid it no heed and battered him yet again.
These are the days of big paydays and small mercies; neither of which particularly satisfy audiences. But then Vince can't even cast his the 'WWE Universe' correctly either...
CONT'D...
Chad Gable's recent reinvention on Raw is that of Bobby Roode's biggest fan. He hops, skips and jumps alongside 'The Glorious One' on Raw, all the while enhancing their matches with dynamic decadence beyond the ability level of his peers. Not like that matters. His own excellence is the subplot in this particular story - the focus is how rattled Roode is with Gables' earnest enthusiasm. It'll thankfully almost certainly end in an overdue heel turn for the former NXT Champion (yet another completely misconstrued character), but the bigger issue is the characterisation of Chad in particularly that will get them to that end point.
Gable - giddy to the point of irritation - is how Vince McMahon views his entire audience. Happiness is an emotion to be demonised, support one to be squashed. Roode, by all rights, should be absolutely buzzing to find a friend as talented as Gable willing to fight his corner so fanatically. He instead furrows a brow and curls a lip, stopping only short of screaming F-words as McMahon probably does in Michael Cole's ear when it's time to talk over boos for babyfaces and cheers for heels.
We are all Chad Gable. Gable helped Jason Jordan over a hump. Gable made Shelton Benjamin a somebody again. He was a guy that cared enough about Sports Entertainment - and enjoying his time within it - that he found a way to make it all make sense. That very same task is now being dished out to the ticket-buying public. Punters too, are having to put in work to support their favourite workers.
CONT'D...
To be typecast is often viewed as a weakness in Hollywood, but it's an excellent way to set a scene or even an entire film without needing to lay too many narrative foundations. Paul Rudd is cinematic bliss for this reason. His personality radiates so powerfully that viewers want to support and nurture his characters. Such a performer is a gift to Vince McMahon - creating a universally beloved star is one of the hardest jobs in the industry but has repeatedly proven one of the most profitable done right.
Yet, just six months removed from a real life return about as cinematic as the company could muster, Daniel Bryan is now an also-ran. Fans back winners, and a return to full time work in WWE has reduced responses because Vince McMahon just can't see it. He's literally seen it before - he saw every single screen on Kevin Dunn's video wall as Bryan held both titles aloft at WrestleMania XXX when he got back from taking The Undertaker to the hospital, but conveniently forgot that sea of satisfaction when booking Bray Wyatt to dump him out of the Royal Rumble a few months later.
It continues to this day.
CONT'D...
Becky Lynch and Bayley are two of the most naturally likeable performers to ever come through the WWE system. One's a heel and one's completely hidden. Lio Rush is about to become a babyface sensation on Raw but was being pre-banned from the company locker room for idiotic remarks at the recently-fired Emma's expense. Kevin Owens is neither good guy or bad guy, just a really bloody stupid guy. Shane McMahon - the owner that sent him packing to Raw - was almost arrogant in dismissing him, but will be a babyface because of the literal baby's face his father still sees when he stares proudly upon his progeny.
"I Love You, Man" was a film entirely dependant on the unparalleled loveliness of Paul Rudd. The p*ss funny comedy required him to find a Best Man having only ever enjoyed the company of female friends. He is impossibly wonderful in the role because it's the person he plays best, and hopefully the one he is in real life too. And that's the point of performance art - we'll never know for sure if he's as nice as he seems, but we'll continue investing in him as long as we perceive it to be true.
Vince McMahon isn't the desperate promoter he was in the mid-1990s, nor the architect of the anti-heroes he styled himself as during the Attitude Era. But it's hard to view him as anything other than a stubborn old b*stard in his ageing years instead of the wisened genius of Sports Entertainment. If he hadn't f*cked with the very concept of typecasting so much, we might yet be able to view perception as different from reality.