It's Official: Wrestling Needs An Unthinkable Revolution
Is the audience, quite frankly, tired of having their intelligence insulted?
This week, a poorly-timed editorial dropped on this author page entitled It's Official: A New Era Is Underway In AEW.
While a stellar edition of Dynamite probably won't correct the systemic booking issues creeping into the AEW product, it was a stellar episode. A great opener, an insane party match, some trademark thoughtful plotting in the segment with Chris Jericho and Sammy Guevara, and a deft, dovetailing angle in the main event post-match, as busy as it was focused, that teased dream matches in the double digits: this was classic Dynamite.
The main thrust of the article remains accurate; the fact that there is an ideal to which AEW returned this week is evidence of that. Much of the praise directed towards the show on social media was in that vein. "That's what an episode of Dynamite should look like," was echoed across Twitter on Wednesday night. The second clause of that sentence was implied: "...not like an episode of WWE television."
The state of the promotion can not be judged on a single episode of television. It will take several weeks of great form for the feeling to return, and that's what's missing: the feeling. The buzz. The sense that the product is hot, loud, and endlessly fascinating. Different.
The promotion certainly teed up enough developments to carry that feeling in that post-match angle. Blood & Guts is slowly taking shape, and the prospect of the Elite's approach to that match is thrilling. Eddie Kingston Vs. Claudio Castagnoli was one of the best matches of the year; a sequel is guaranteed to be excellent. Eddie feuding with Jon Moxley is another hugely exciting development. Their verbal sparring was sensational in the autumn of 2020, as convincing and emotional as anything the promotion has ever done. The idea of Eddie reluctantly teaming with the Young Bucks is genuinely really funny. They'd play with the personality clash in a knowing, amusing way. Kenny Omega Vs. Konosuke Takeshita might even be Wembley stadium-sized; Omega feels like AEW's top babyface, and those Takeshita segments with Don Callis have generated the most heel heat all year (without the press of a button, anyway).
Still, there's the whole CM Punk thing to navigate. Even in the highly unlikely event that this all doesn't end in an explosion, Collision looks doomed to be a B-show with or without him. This era of AEW feels entirely untenable, and this air of inevitably makes it difficult to invest. AEW has effectively cultivated an atmosphere antithetical to the summer of 2021. Back then, everything was possible. Now, a great, harmonious run feels impossible. There's a remote, naive possibility that Punk behaves himself and embarks on the best heel run of his legendary career: he's one of the best heels of the century, he already has heat, and he seems to be in a terrible, combustible or mischievous mood constantly.
But is that enough?
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
Or does AEW need a real revolution?
On almost every single episode of North American pro wrestling television, something happens that the pro wrestling fan has watched happen for their entire lifetime. If that person never went dark on wrestling - how did you endure the Reign of Terror?! - it's likely they've seen this sort of thing every single week. Say you're a 37 year-old pro wrestling fan who grew up on Coliseum video and the twilight of Hulkamania, and have watched for 30 years. You've either stayed with WWE, or arrived at AEW through a flirtation with puro or the indie circuit. You've probably seen some form of carny wrestling booking device 1,565 times. At least; that's a rate of one wrestling cliché a week. If you grew up on the Attitude Era or the Ruthless Aggression "Era", multiply this number by whatever the f*ck you like. It hardly matters; back in that time, chicanery was a constant feature throughout every single show, and by 1999, there were two. The real number might be 10,000. It might be higher.
"Some form of carny booking device" is a musical distraction finish. A ref bump. Interference on the outside that, again, leads to a distraction finish. Grabbing the tights. A weapon shot unsighted by the referee. Basically, some sort of way of protecting the babyface so that you still think they're a winner and that they will be OK, folks. So much of wrestling books for the mentality of a child that it's no wonder that Twitter is in the state it's in. It's no wonder that an almost tangible sense of fatigue has set in amongst the AEW base, since that promotion has started abusing these carny devices.
To be blunt, virtually every wrestling character is stupid, to an extent. The referees are bumbling oafs, and that is generous. When it comes to those on the outside assisting the heels, the refs are as thick as babies. They don't have object permanence. They forget that the heel manager is there when they focus on the action inside of the ring, like an infant who cannot even scream for its mommy yet.
The babyface gets distracted too easily. Everybody else can see what is about to happen, except them, and we're meant to think they are the smart cool wrestler we like. They get distracted, again, so that they lose in a way that doesn't hurt our perception of them. AEW is the blood-soaked TV-14 alternative where you hear the word "sh*t" a lot, that advances its storylines with a relative degree of sophistication, and (this is fine by the way) expects its fanbase to have internet access (this is fine because everybody does). So why, so often across 2022 and 2023 especially, does AEW try to mollycoddle its fans? The fact that the characters inhabit the same world as the audience deepens this nagging feeling. If we can see it coming, so should the wrestler.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Promotions take the absolute piss with the rules of storytelling to facilitate these developments, too. This has been the case for years, obviously, but does it have to be timeless?
Who freely gives out manager's licences to repeat offenders? What does Tony Khan in his capacity as AEW's fictional General Manager actually expect, when, as an example, Saraya and Toni Storm flank Ruby Soho for one of her matches? Because it's an endless, tedious loop of carny sh*te that makes no sense.
The wrestling promotion is meant to be on the level, otherwise, they can't be trusted. The heels are meant to be fiendish, capable of such cunning wrongdoing that a fair mind can't anticipate much less understand it. In AEW, all too often, the heels are awarded the platform to do the easiest cheating you've ever f*cking seen. It isn't nefarious, and thus it isn't effective.
Also: why hasn't a North American major implemented a standby referee policy? These daft bastards get bumped every other week, and a standby ref should be despatched to ringside immediately when this happens to maintain order. That's what the ref is there to do. The answer, of course, is that a standby referee wouldn't allow a promotion to enable contrived storytelling.
The sheer volume of wrestling's bullsh*t is starting to just...reek. The commentators registering their indignation at the antics of the heels feels more phoney than it ever has. This might be a subjective opinion. Maybe an element of personal burnout is informing all of this. But isn't it time - particularly at a time when AEW conflating itself with WWE has only achieved a decline in popularity - to do something radical with the form?
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
An actual rankings system. Perhaps even a league table. A standby referee. A moratorium on stable members being allowed at ringside. Changes to the narrative that would get around the "heel sneak attack leads to match next week which referee is too incompetent to gain control of".
Now, something happened on Dynamite recently that worked exquisitely within the traditional wrestling approach. In the MJF Vs. Adam Cole World Title Eliminator match, referee Bryce Remsburg got bumped. This allowed MJF to grab the title belt, throw it at Cole, and bump himself to the canvas. In a fantastic twist, the old Eddie Guerrero trick didn't work because Remsburg was more hurt than MJF thought. Remsburg continued to sell as Cole realised MJF's folly. In an awesome near-fall, Cole struck MJF with the belt and lowered the Boom. Everybody in the arena counted along. The old way still works, but this was so effective because it subverted the tired tribute spot.
WWE is not going to change. For all its arrogant bluster, and how the conglomerate apparently "transcends" wrasslin', they rely on the same carny devices more than ever. The ref gets bumped in every single Roman Reigns match in order to block the stage for melodramatic Bloodline theatre. In order to function as it wants to function, WWE is anti-sport. And it works very well, commercially.
AEW however should strive to be different from WWE in almost every way.
A brand new way of formatting and presenting professional wrestling is needed. The thing is, heels need to be able to cheat, which some form of VAR-adjacent system would render untenable. Or do they? Should the other North American major take more influence from the more serious leanings of puro and adjust to that brand of psychology? Between most WWE crowds not caring about in-ring action and AEW crowds resembling them every other week in recent times, watching wrestling on TV has rarely felt more quiet.
Has the predominantly millennial non-WWE fanbase stopped caring about the same old sh*t that has been sold as a transgression for far too long? Is the audience, quite frankly, tired of having their intelligence insulted?
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Perhaps revolution in wrestling would warp the form so beyond recognition that it would no longer be effective.
All wrestling has to be unrealistic to function, to an extent. The finishing move has to be registered with a crowd that is conditioned to anticipate and want it, as an example. When the action is at its most urgent, when the stakes are highest, showmanship is required. Wrestling is inherently counterintuitive in that way. Shawn Michaels didn't stamp on the mat to power up his leg. Crowd psychology isn't a synonym of realism; if anything, it's an antonym.
But, Christ almighty, the deadening blur of interference and stupid decisions and logic gaps...wrestling is stupid, and those who prefer wrestling over sports entertainment really seem to be in a mood with it. AEW is cold. Does anybody even watch anything else?
If nothing else, evolution is required, a far more disciplined approach. Maybe silly wrestling is timeless - it's lasted this long! - and, as with most things, is best when it doesn't indulge itself to the point of parody. Imagine how much more effective MJF would be as AEW's top heel, if he was the one unscrupulous, wickedly evil ar*ehole who ruined the sanctity of the sport? Now that everybody does it every single week, as cleans wins die a death across the shows, AEW is colder.
These things, perhaps, are not unrelated.