John Cena’s 11 WWE SummerSlam Matches From Worst To Best

There are A LOT of Five Knuckle Shuffles in these matches.

John Cena STFU Batista SummerSlam 2008
WWE.com

The current United States Champion, John Cena, is headed into SummerSlam 2015 with the WWE World Heavyweight Champion in his sights. He's had a stellar year of memorable matches with a variety of talent. He even controversially made Seth Rollins tap out recently, after suffering a broken nose. The man keeps giving us something to talk about and SummerSlam should be no different.

Looking back at the previous eleven years, Cena has had a match on the biggest party of the summer's card and he more often than not delivers. The bottom two bouts on this list are the only truly weak matches; the rest are all enjoyable affairs. Only two of these bouts were not one-on-one matches but Cena played a significant enough role in those to allow them on this list.

One interesting stat in reviewing Cena's SummerSlam performances is his win-loss record. He's 4-7, with 6 of those losses occurring in the last 7 years. That sounds like he's due for a win, so Rollins might want to watch his back.

This article was prepared by simply loading up each bout on the WWE Network and binging through them all. I'm personally a little AA'd out by this point, but I do offer you this countdown of Cena's SummerSlam matches ranked from worst to best...

11. 2004 Vs. Booker T

Booker T John Cena SummerSlam 2004
WWE.com

The first (and worst) match on this list was from John Cena's first SummerSlam appearance in 2004. John Cena was stripped of his United States Championship by former Smackdown GM Kurt Angle. The new GM, Teddy Long, set up a Best of 5 Series between him and current U.S. Champion Booker T. 

This was their first match in the series.

It wasn't a terrible encounter, by any means, but the two didn't really have a chance to get things going. The match clocked in at just under six and a half minutes and ended when Cena hit a surprise AA (then called an FU) after Booker T was showboating with his patented Spinaroonie.

The final match in this series would come a few months later at No Mercy 2004. John Cena won that match and the series to regain his U.S. Championship.


10. 2009 Vs. Randy Orton

Randy Orton RKO John Cena SummerSlam 2009
WWE.com

This odd WWE Championship match between Randy Orton and John Cena didn't take the bottom spot on this list because the first thirteen minutes or so were actually really good. This had all the makings of a classic match, but then Orton had to go and get himself disqualified. He shoved the ref to end the match, which set up a bizarre series of events.

Lillian Garcia announced that the match would be immediately restarted per orders of Vince McMahon. If Orton intentionally got himself DQ'ed again he would then lose his title. Well, Orton then bailed by grabbing his belt and walking out. The referee counted to ten on Orton, ending the match. 

Why would Randy just lose his belt on purpose?

According to the logic of this match, he didn't lose his title. The countout loss didn't count as a DQ for some reason. This was the point that the crowd seemed really confused. Lillian announced that the match would restart a third time and if Orton got himself DQ'ed OR counted out, his title would transfer.

It looked like Cena had Orton beat with an STF attempt but a fan (who was really a DiBiase kid) would enter the ring and attack the ref. This didn't end the match and Orton RKO'd Cena for the win. 

My brain hurt after watching this.


9. 2012 Vs. Big Show Vs. CM Punk

Cena Punk Show Summerslam 2012
WWE.com

This triple threat match for the WWE Championship was in the middle of CM Punk's really long title reign. He was somewhere in the 200s as far as days holding his title. One notable thing to consider prior to this match was that there was a moment where Punk tried to get Cena to shake his hand but Cena refused. John thought that respect was to be earned, not demanded, so they were mad.

Big Show dominated a lot of this match. It seemed like he was constantly chopping the life out of his two opponents. Punk and Cena both tried to slay the giant and finally got the big man to tap out when they simultaneously applied the Anaconda Vise and the STF. 

Which guy could be credited for the win? Like the Orton match from 2009, this one also needed a restart.

AJ Lee gave the word to get this match going again and Cena had Big Show ready for a pin after an AA. Punk capitalized on this move and dumped Cena out of the ring and pinned Show himself. Punk stole the win from Cena and retained his title.

The ending might've been a little goofy but it was at least sensible. After witnessing the mess that Cena went through with Orton from 2009, this doesn't seem bad at all, in comparison. 


8. 2010 Team WWE Vs. Team Nexus

Team WWE vs. Nexus SummerSlam
WWE.com

It's hard not to watch this match and think of it as a prime example of a Cena burial. After mentioning that, there's still a lot of enjoyment that can be had with this 14-man elimination bout without getting frustrated at the disregard of the long-term story that could've been.

First of all, the crowd was hot for this. Even at well over a half an hour there were very few lulls. Everyone in attendance stood pretty much the whole time. Bret Hart, in particular, got a huge reaction. The Edge and Jericho drama against Cena was entertaining as well.

The wrestling was exciting, too. R-Truth turned a suplex into a Stunner variation in one of the matche's more creative spots. Daniel Bryan got a chance to have a late match surge that was fun. And as a personal Heath Slater mark, it brings a smile to my face to go back and see him eliminate both Edge and Chris Jericho.

Those were the days...

What sours this match is the fact that it eventually became a showcase for Super Cena. He only sold a deadly DDT onto concrete for all of a minute before delivering the final eliminations to Justin Gabriel and Wade Barrett. 

Even so, the crowd in attendance very much loved the Cena win.


7. 2006 Vs. Edge

795411

By the time of their SummerSlam 2006 bout, Edge and John Cena already had a good bit of history behind them. Not only did Edge have a successful Money in the Bank briefcase cash-in earlier in the year against Cena, but he also slapped his father just before this event. 

Even though this was in Boston and should have been a mostly pro-Cena hometown, the audience was still split. There were several signs that said "If Edge Wins We Riot" but both guys had vocal supporters and detractors.

A stipulation was added to this match that if Edge lost the match by DQ then the title would change. In spite of this, Lita kept trying to give the Rated-R Superstar foreign objects to use during the match. I'm watching this years later without much context and it feels like either Lita is trying to make Edge lose or she's just really stupid. Edge naturally kept refusing her offerings because he wanted to keep his title.

Lita was finally successful in giving him an unfair advantage when she slipped a set of brass knuckles onto Edge's hand. She was the recipient of an FU for her troubles, but Edge was able to use the knuckles without being noticed. So it worked.

Other than Lita looking like a moron, this was a great match that still holds up well after nine years.


6. 2008 Vs. Batista

Batista Vs John Cena Summerslam 08
WWE.com

Due to the brand extension, wrestling megastars John Cena and Batista had never wrestled in a one-on-one match prior to SummerSlam 2008. They had a memorable finish when they were the last two in a Royal Rumble a few years prior, but never in a straight up singles match. 

This match was their first meeting and it delivered as a big-time slugfest.

The crowd was pretty hot for this one. Lots of cheers and boos for both guys and even a fun "Yay" and "Boo" sequence when they they were very fatigued but still swinging. The crowd popped for a Figure Four by Batista (Ric Flair departed from WWE right around this time, so that probably had something to do with the reaction).

The finish came about when Cena went for his top rope leg drop. Batista caught him and fell into a Powerbomb. This actually didn't finish him, but the Batista Bomb that followed it did.

This doesn't seem like it should've been as exciting as it was but it really delivered. Cena and Batista made this battle feel pretty epic.


5. 2007 Vs. Randy Orton

Cena Orton
WWE.com

The 2009 SummerSlam match between Randy Orton and John Cena might have been a confusing mess, but in their 2007 SummerSlam encounter they got it right.

Orton began targeting Cena, saying they had never met in singles match for the WWE Championship before. That lead to Jonathan Coachman naming Orton the Number One Contender. On a Saturday Night's Main Event just before this, Orton delivered a sick RKO to Cena onto a chair. 

Orton played the role as the aggressor throughout most of the contest. He really seemed like he had Cena scouted and the crowd had a big segment of fans that wanted to see Cena lose.

Near the end of the match, Orton tried to Punt Cena's head but he moved out of the way and applied the STFU. Orton was able to reach the bottom ropes to break the hold. After recovering, he hit an RKO that only held Cena down for 2. Cena then hit his FU to secure a successful title reign.

This was a great match that's mostly hindered because of their careers since then. It's a good match, but it's hard to get excited to go back and watch Cena vs. Orton because it's been done so much. Nevertheless, this is a darn good match and the fifth best of Cena's SummerSlam CV.


4. 2011 Vs. CM Punk

John Cena Cm Punk Summerslam 2011
WWE.com

This was the followup to the legendary bout between CM Punk and John Cena at Money In The Bank 2011. Punk was the WWE Champion who 'left' the company while John Cena earned his title in the interim. With Triple H as the special guest referee, this match decided who the true champion really was.

While not as good as their MITB encounter, this is still a great match that got a huge reaction from the crowd. Punk was as popular as ever at this point and the nearfalls were insanely good at times.

One cool moment in this match was when it appeared that both Cena and Punk were going to get counted out. Triple H counted all the way to 9, then exited the ring. He personally reinserted both wrestlers into the match because he wanted a winner.

The win came after Punk hit the GTS on Cena, but the pin was tainted because Cena placed his foot on the ropes. Triple H didn't see it.

Post-match shenanigans ran wild on this night as Kevin Nash gave a Jackknife Powerbomb to Punk. Then, Alberto Del Rio cashed in his MITB briefcase to easily win the WWE Championship.


3. 2005 Vs. Chris Jericho

Cena Clothesline Chris Jericho SummerSlam 2005
WWE.com

In the midst of the 2005 brand split, WWE Champion John Cena found himself drafted from Smackdown to Raw. GM Eric Bischoff was none too happy about this, because Cena let it be known that he wasn't about playing politics. Bischoff set up this match with Jericho as the challenger to foil the champ.

The backstory going into Summerslam 2005 is that Chris Jericho was about to leave the company. This was his next to last night in WWE for this run and it was pretty well known. Despite the obviousness that Cena was going to win, they wrestled a match that helped us buy into the idea that Jericho just might pull through in spite of his impending departure.

I'm a little off on exactly when Cena started getting crowd backlash but this match might've been the first real dose of it. One of the most passionate dueling chants I've ever heard erupted during this as the crowd ferociously chanted "Let's go Cena/Let's go Jericho."

The rowdiest point in this match was when Y2J had the Walls of Jericho locked onto Cena. The pro-Y2J part of the crowd really wanted him to win while the pro-Cena populace let it be known that they wanted the champ to retain. Cena ultimately won via FU.

This match was such a fun viewing experience and an important bout in both guys' careers.


2. 2014 Vs. Brock Lesnar

881776

It might be controversial to chart this match so highly because it wasn't a technical masterpiece or an intricately woven showcase of psychology. This match between Brock Lesnar and John Cena for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship was as one-sided of a beatdown as they come, and that's what made it so entertaining.

The two locked up in Lesnar's first match back with WWE at Extreme Rules in 2012. It was a particularly violent affair that saw John Cena come out on top. A couple of years and a broken WrestleMania streak later and Lesnar was looking as strong as ever. 

Going into this, I wondered how they could top their previous match.

They topped the previous match with sixteen German suplexes. The Germans were preceded by an opening minute F5, which set the tone for the rest of the match. Cena would have a few moments to shine here and there, but it was all very brief. Lesnar won with an F5 at around 17 minutes.

Once again, this was not a technical masterpiece, but it was a performance that shocked and amazed. Lesnar really established his dominance with this unmerciful assault of John Cena at SummerSlam 2014.


1. 2013 Vs. Daniel Bryan

WWE Daniel Bryan kicks John Cena at SummerSlam 2013
WWE.com

John Cena's best SummerSlam match coincided with the long-awaited ascendance of Daniel Bryan to the top of WWE. Sure, Bryan had carried major titles before this, but this win on this night was the biggest stamp of approval in his career (well, until the following WrestleMania) and John Cena helped make the moment.

John Cena was THE man in WWE and had been for quite a while. But no one could deny how over Bryan was at that point. Cena hand-picked Bryan to be his challenger at SummerSlam 2013 and the two fought a great match.

Bryan really was Cena's equal in this. They went toe-to-toe and brought the best of their arsenals against each other in this nearly thirty-minute bout. A late match slap-off was particularly fun, which saw Bryan come out on the winning side.

A running knee strike and pinfall sealed the deal for Bryan. It was a great moment in which a star was made. Bryan benefited by having Cena putting him over. Bryan suffered from extremely awkward booking following this match, but that doesn't take away how special this one was, or how selfless Cena was on the night. 


Contributor
Contributor

I'm a dad who loves professional wrestling. Find me on Twitter @MitchNickelson or email me at leonardbeats@gmail.com.