Ranking Every Night Two WWE 2024 Draft Pick From Worst To Best

Ranking all 33 picks from closing night of WWE's 2024 Draft. Who jumped and who stayed put?

WWE Draft 2024
WWE

Next year, Triple H must set one simple ground rule for the Draft: Only announce actual brand jumps.

Of the 33 picks discussed here, 18 stayed put on the same shows they were already working for. That, dear readers, is a complete and utter waste of everyone's time. If WWE want their Draft to be taken seriously, then they need to make it a seismic shakeup of the products offered on each major brand and stick to the rosters they choose after the fact.

Fire up social media (hardly a haven for positivity at the best of times, to be fair) and you'll see a lot of moaning about how Trips formatted this thing across both nights. This time, the whinging is justified. However, there were still some life-altering moments in the 2024 Draft well worth talking about.

Several NXT stars just landed killer gigs on Raw and SmackDown, and it's interesting to see WWE toying with the idea of splitting top factions like Imperium and Judgment Day. The latter less so, but someone rather special was conspicuous by her absence from the Draft.

Here's every pick announced on Raw ranked from worst to best!

33. Odyssey Jones

Odyssey Jones
WWE.com

Draft Position:  #17 for Raw. #32 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Is this a joke?

Odyssey Jones was drafted to Raw during the 2023 shakeup, but never appeared on the flagship ahead of 2024's Draft. So, surely taking the p*ss, WWE decided to announce that Jones is coming to Raw all over again. Maybe he'll actually reach TV this time.


32. Natayla

Natalya WWE
WWE.com

Draft Position: #15 for Raw. #30 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

It's genuinely hard to get excited about anything Natalya does in 2024. Apologies if that's harsh, but she's just sorta part of the furniture in WWE these days. Creative certainly haven't helped matters by pretending that Nattie staying put on Raw was worth including in the supplemental picks.

How thrilling.


31. Kayden Carter & Katana Chance

Kayden Carter Kacy Catanzaro
WWE.com

Draft Position: #14 for Raw. #29 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Being honest, Kayden Carter and Katana Chance might've had their 15 minutes.

Again, perhaps harsh, but fans didn't really take to the team when they were Women's Tag-Team Champs. Being fair, WWE didn't do a hell of a lot to explain why people should care about them. Finding out the duo are staying on Mondays will cause endless shoulder shrugging from the fanbase.


30. Diamond Mine

Ivy Nile The Creed Brothers Diamond Mine WWE
WWE.com

Draft Position: #13 for Raw. #26 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Keep an eye out for this squad.

They've all got serious potential, and it's clear to see how infinitely talented in-ring The Creed Brothers are. Sadly, Diamond Mine suffered from the supplemental afterthought treatment this year, and the fact that they haven't actually made any moves to speak of. What was that about only announcing jumps?!


29. New Day

WWE Wrestlemania 40 New Day
WWE.com

Draft Position: #9 for Raw. #17 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

One of the biggest problems some people have with the Draft layout is this: WWE feels the need to announce popular acts and star names for the sake of it rather than because they've got news to share. New Day are a prime example here - they're staying on Raw.

Woohoo?


28. Pretty Deadly

Pretty Deadly
WWE.com

Draft Position: #9 for SmackDown #18 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Ditto for Pretty Deadly, although it's fair to say the dapper Brits have yet to get properly started on WWE's main roster. A change of scenery could've helped with that, but PD seem doomed to play second fiddle as heels behind current WWE Tag-Team Champs and pet projects A-Town Down Under.

Here's hoping the writers don't forget about these lads.


27. Naomi

Naomi WWE SmackDown
WWE

Draft Position: #7 for SmackDown. #14 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

What is there to really say about this one?

Naomi will remain in place as Bayley's buddy on SmackDown, and...that's about it. She's only there to smile next to the champ and ready fresher talents like Tiffany Stratton for the big time spots. Naomi is functional and works solid matches, but announcing she's still on SmackDown is akin to a wasted Draft pick from Nick Aldis.


26. The Pride

The Street Profits Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

Draft Position: #3 for SmackDown. #6 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

There were a ton of "wasted picks", to be honest.

Bobby Lashley, The Street Profits and new recruit B-FAB make up The Pride, and they'll be sticking around on SmackDown for a little while longer. Everyone could've slept soundly at night without this news. WWE didn't need to add Pride to the long, long list of folks who aren't jumping.


25. Bronson Reed

Bronson Reed
WWE.com

Draft Position: #12 for Raw. #23 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

It looks like big Bronson Reed could be snagging an Intercontinental Title shot soon, so it makes sense that he's still Team Raw for now. Again, did that need to be said? It's worth repeating that Triple H should make next year's Draft exclusively about brand hops.

Fair play to Reed for working his way up the ladder though.


24. Braun Strowman

WWE Raw Finn Balor Braun Strowman
WWE

Draft Position: #4 for Raw. #7 overall.

Brand Switch: N/A.

Reed won't be the only monster doing the rounds on Mondays following Braun Strowman's full-time return to action on Raw. The 'Monster Among Men' was tied to the flagship once again (that was his home brand anyway), and attacked members of Judgment Day during a segment also starring NFL player Patrick Mahomes.

Strowman feels fairly fresh again, at least.


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.