Rebooking WWE Great American Bash 2005: 8 Ways To Make It Better

This time, we try NOT to kill off Muhammad Hassan.

WWE decided to revive the Great American Bash in 2004, with the former WCW event becoming Smackdown's July PPV. When the news first became known, WWE fans were optimistic. It would probably be far different from WCW's version of the event, but at least it was a different concept than usual. How disappointed fans must have been, then, with the first incarnation of the WWE Great American Bash. Featuring a card comprised mostly of house show quality matches and featuring one of the most awful WWE main events ever (the Undertaker/Dudley Boys Concrete Crypt match), it was a total washout. Would 2005's version be any better? No, not really. After a very good Judgement Day in May, it was hoped that the Smackdown crew could knock it out of the park, once again. Sadly, they could not. Featuring more poor matches and awful booking decisions, the 2005 Bash was only slightly better than the 2005 version. But it could have been really, really good. Smackdown had a decent roster at the time, a roster that was freshened up in the month-long June WWE draft. Taking into account who was on the Smackdown roster at the time (and trying not to mess with heel/face dynamics), let's go back a decade and try and sort out one of the most disappointing PPVs of 2005.

8. MNM Vs. Booker T & Hardcore Holly - Tag Team Title

The original opener to the 2005 Great American Bash saw MNM take on the reformed, bastardised version of the Legion of Doom. With a beer bellied, clearly past-it Animal and a completely useless Heidenreich standing in for the deceased Hawk, this was so transparently a shameless way to promote the forthcoming Road Warriors DVD. That the über-talented MNM lost the belts within six-and-a-half minutes, was insulting. Instead of that shambles, this version of the GAB would have MNM (successfully) defend the straps against the hard-nosed veteran tag team of Booker T and Hardcore Holly. Bombastic Bob had failed in his bid to win the belts at Judgement Day and, with his partner recently fired, would recruit an invigorated Booker T, who had just found his mean streak after his personal feud with Kurt Angle. Holly and Booker had been teaming on house shows, anyway (usually against MNM). MNM would win a competitive 10-15 minute match with the Snapshot. Oh, and if they wanted to pimp the LOD DVD so bad, they could do it via a backstage segment, or something. Perhaps Ron Simmons could say 'damn'.

7. Chris Benoit Vs. Christian - United States Title

Booker's original opponent Christian was trying to establish himself on Smackdown after switching from Raw in the draft. He'd recently experienced one of the most successful periods of his career, putting in great performances both in the ring and on the mic. These performances are so good that he was placed into a spring feud with John Cena and Chris Jericho over the WWE Title. He didn't win, of course, but he proved he could hang in that setting. Instead of going straight after the World Heavyweight Title on the blue brand, he would target US Champion Chris Benoit. The Rabid Wolverine had also recently made the switch and their match, although it had happened recently on Raw, would look fresh in the new surroundings. Benoit faced the not very good Orlando Jordan at the real 2005 Bash in a match that was average for Benoit's standards (but actually one of OJ's best matches ever). Benoit would be coming in as champion here, having recently defeated Jordan on Smackdown. Orlando's interference would make sure that Captain Charisma left with the gold after a 15 minute match, setting up a 3 or 4 way outing at SummerSlam.

6. Mexicools Vs. Paul London/Billy Kidman/Akio

In real life, Kidman and Akio were cut before the Great American Bash PPV, victims of the cost-cutting that was undertaker in order to clear funds to bring Brock Lesnar back. Another theory as to why they were let go was that, with WWE bringing in three new cruiserweights in the form of the Mexicools, three had to be released. In this retconned version of events, Akio and Kidman keep their jobs and team up with Cruiserweight Champion Paul London to battle the would-be luchadores. At the original 2005 Bash, the Mexicools squared off with the bWo, in a horrible mess. London, Akio and Kidman would provide much more compatible opposition. The Mexicools would win, since they need to be kept strong having only recently debuted, in an eight minute match. Mexicools leader Juventud would pin champion London, setting up a programme between them two.

5. JBL Vs. The Blue Meanie - Street Fight

One of the most interesting stories to come out of the ECW One Night Stand PPV was that a drunk JBL deliberately and viciously attacked The Blue Meanie in an unprovoked assault during the show-closing brawl. Meanie considered filing a lawsuit against JBL and WWE, but managed to reach a deal with the company and dropped it. The deal was that Meanie would get a (worked) match with JBL at a Smackdown taping (which he won, thanks to interference from Batista) as well as a PPV match at the Bash. Why not kill two birds with one stone and have Meanie face off with JBL at the Bash instead? JBL versus Batista, the Bash 2005 main event, completely sucked because JBL was allegedly sangbagging Batista and otherwise not cooperating properly. Stick him in with Meanie and try and cash-in on the One Night Stand incident. As a match, it wouldn't be anything special, but it could be an entertaining brawl under street fight stips. The Wrestling God would win, of course, since Meanie isn't going to be sticking around for long. Give it about ten minutes and lots of gimmicks and see what happens.

4. The Undertaker Vs. Kurt Angle - No.1 Contenders Match

Angle was another wrestler who moved from Smackdown to Raw in the June 2005 WWE draft. His swan song was a deeply offensive feud with Booker T, where the Olympic gold medalist was more concerned with sexually assaulting Booker's wife Sharmell than he was with actually wrestling. It was a bad way for Angle to leave Smackown. While in this version of events he would still have been drafted, Teddy Long would make sure he'd signed a contract to compete at the Bash in a match against a wrestler of his choosing. That wrestler would be The Undertaker. Angle would claim he would only do it if he gets a future title shot, threatening to rob Smackdown of its prized possession and take it to Raw. Undertaker would agree, getting a title shot if he won, too. The Dead Man would overcome Angle in a good, long match, sending Angle to Raw and setting up Smackdown's main event for WWE SummerSlam.

3. Melina Vs. Christy Hemme

After that expected barn-burner, the fans would require a cool down match which, during the clothes-ripping, poor wrestling years of the mid-2000s, mean the divas match. At the 2005 Bash, Melina wrestled Torrie Wilson in a bra and panties match that went exactly as you'd imagine it. In this version, Melina's still in that spot, but this time she'd be facing off with Christy Hemme, who had just been transferred to Smackdown in the draft (in reality, she would be transferred in late August, once the draft was over). This wouldn't be long, about five minutes or so, with Hemme coming out on top.

2. Rey Mysterio Vs. Eddie Guerrero - Steel Cage Match

The Eddie Guerrero versus Rey Mysterio rivalry dominated the Smackdown brand in 2005, lasting the entire summer. In total, Rey and Eddie clashed on four separate PPVs and countless times on television. Although it was marred somewhat by the whole Dominick storyline, it was still one of the feuds of the year. Keeping the Dominick/secret theme (that Eddie himself pushed for), their match at the Bash would be a steel cage match, a stipulation enforced by Smackdown GM Teddy Long to make sure that Eddie didn't harm Rey's kid, who would be at ringside. The cage would also provide the perfect setting for such an intensely personal rivalry. Eddie and Rey actually clashed in a cage when Smackdown switched stations in September. Why not bring that match forward a little? Another singles match is fine (their match was the best of the night at the 2005 Bash), but a cage adds an extra dimension and would, hopefully, increase audience excitement a little. Rey would win, following some drama with Dominick at ringside, allowing the feud to continue until SummerSlam.

1. Batista Vs. Muhammed Hassan - World Heavyweight Title

Now this is where things get really interesting. Rumour has it that big Dave was supposed to face Muhammad Hassan at SummerSlam, in Batista's home state of Washington, D.C. Legend is that Batista would actually drop the World Heavyweight Title to Hassan, which would no doubt generate nuclear heat on the night. In our alternative 2005 Great American Bash, Hassan would challenge Batista for the title and win, instead of getting killed off by The Undertaker. WWE were forced to drop the Hassan character under pressure from UPN, following the ill-judged and unfortunately timed 'terrorist' angle on the July 7th Smackdown. After moving over to Smackdown from Raw in the draft, Hassan would immediately target Batista. Winning a tournament, featuring the likes of Rey Mysterio, Holly, JBL, Benoit, Booker etc., he would be named No.1 contender three weeks prior to the show. Over the next several weeks, he would talk down the 'American Superman' Batista, claiming he was everything wrong with the country. Dave would respond by destroying Hassan's manager, Daivari. The two would meet at the Great American Bash, with Hassan winning the WWE title in about ten minutes, after interference from a returning Randy Orton (who had been out since April following shoulder surgery). Batista was not translating well as champ, anyway, and it would set up both The Undertaker versus Hassan and Batista versus Orton at SummerSlam. What would you do differently at the 2005 Great American Bash? Was Muhammad Hassan ready for the World Heavyweight Title? Let us know in the comments section below!

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...