The Disturbing Truth Behind AEW's Obsession With WWE
Tony Khan believes the hatred between AEW and WWE is real - but his fanbase might not buy that...
Wrestling Twitter is a horrendous experience fought between two deranged tribes.
The Bloodline saga is the latest pro wrestling Event to further the culture war. Remarking that the instant classic of an angle at the close of the Royal Rumble, while outstanding, might have gone a bit long will not do. It was perfect. Nirvana was achieved in that moment. Pointing out that the invisible camera has driven the storyline forward is not critique, but nitpicking. This is a cinematic masterpiece!
Also, because it was produced by WWE, it can't possibly be good. Even though the storyline has engaged the WWE fanbase like very few others, and has finally substantiated WWE's insistence that this current Roman Reigns run is indeed legendary, it can only be merely "good". Little old terrible WWE have once again lucked into a good story. It's uncool to admit that WWE have done something that is an unqualified and gigantic success. They can't possibly have lovingly crafted an excellent story. Other wrestling does exist, you know! You can watch Breaking Bad if you want to know what prestige drama looks like!
Over in the other trenches, every time AEW books an action-heavy edition of Dynamite, and Tony Khan preserves a heat angle in favour of advancing his big stories with a patient, indirect chapter, you'll read the same thing: man, AEW should really learn a lesson from the Bloodline saga! If only the promotion that gave us the Hangman Page Vs. Kenny Omega and CM Punk Vs. MJF stories would learn what booking is! It's just as well life on earth began a month ago, because that favours our argument!
At present, were you to hop on Twitter or r/SquaredCircle, you'd be forgiven for thinking that the wrestling war isn't being waged between WWE and AEW, but rather Paul Thomas Anderson and Pro Wrestling Guerilla.
It is relentlessly stupid out there. There is no room for nuance. Dumb, cyclical debates happen every single day.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
You'd think, then, that this unhinged level of emotion was fertile grounds for pro wrestling storytelling, particularly since everybody is extremely online. Also, AEW exists - in addition to being financed by a billionaire, which helps - precisely because WWE killed the enthusiasm of a generation of wrestling fans. The AEW base isn't made up exclusively of those who watched Being The Elite, were deep in the weeds of the US indie circuit, and were drawn to ROH and NJPW; many of its fans wanted big-time episodic TV wrestling. They gravitated towards AEW because they wanted a major league weekly experience booked by somebody who didn't hate them. WWE was the enemy.
The thing is, over the last year, the "Stand Up For WWE" character in AEW's fictional universe hasn't got over anywhere near as much as was hoped.
Early, yes, it worked, but only in limited, snarky doses. Cody Rhodes - ironic in retrospect - had some wry fun at the expense of WWE's invisible wall. The Young Bucks seemed locked in a competition to stand at the absolute dumbest angles possible when watching matches next to a backstage monitor.
Even by 2020, it got old, as most in-jokes do. The debuting Miro's "Shove your brass ring up your ass" spiel was a try-hard, edgy cliché. He meant it, and more than most was justified in saying it, but the thrill wasn't there anymore. It wasn't Jon Moxley's Talk Is Jericho appearance. The cool thing had become the lame thing - and then, two years after this had been established, AEW integrated the lame thing into its canon.
The decline of this trend accelerated with the Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club programme.
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
Incredible when it peaked - very early - Anarchy In The Arena was a seminal war that deftly obscured the sheer amount of thought that went into it. Beyond that, the very thin premise was much too shallow to work as a long-term story.
The JAS hated AEW because it was a pro wrestling promotion, the honour of which the BCC defended. That was the basis for countless derivations of singles and tag team matches, the results of which didn't matter. Those wins were only traded to advance something that existed for the sake of it. There was no deep, emotional core to that story.
It didn't truly feel as though Bryan Danielson, Jon Moxley or Claudio Castagnoli despised Chris Jericho. It didn't truly feel as though AEW fans despised the concept of sports entertainment. The "Fed bad" story lost so much momentum that Jon Moxley, months after it began and peaked, had to expressly say on TV that it was definitely set to be concluded at ROH Final Battle on December 10, 2022. That PPV wasn't sold on the promise of a huge match, but on the feeling of relief that a long, meandering and hollow storyline wasn't going to drag Dynamite down any longer.
It wasn't all that believable, either. Bryan Danielson literally wrote of his love for Vince McMahon in his outgoing Player's Tribune article, and didn't leave WWE because he hated it. He loved it, but simply wanted to try something new. If the idea was to reach that extremely online fan, that fan already knew it wasn't credible.
It's happening again with the ongoing AEW "homegrowns" versus ex-WWE imports storyline in the women's division.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
Saraya's babyface run was deemed to fail because she arrived as an entitled figure who cut promos indicating that she was there to kickstart another revolution. The apathetic crowd response to her match with Dr. Britt Baker at Full Gear underscored that no revolution was required - at least, not one that Saraya was to lead. This wasn't Twitter bubble stuff; the live crowd rejected Saraya.
Tony Khan pivoted, and turned Saraya heel, but again, she's Standing Up For WWE, and nobody is reacting to her like she's Vince McMahon. Fans aren't behind Jamie Hayter because she rose to major league prominence in AEW; they're behind her because she's a killer, stiff pro wrestler capable of elevating the division close to best in class. This flat nWo retread isn't working. The acting is bad and only serves to underscore that there's no real, competitive hatred here. Tony Khan is playing to the gallery.
AEW positioning itself as the irritant "challenger brand" is only half the problem. It makes AEW feel like the number two promotion, yes, but AEW fans - the ones who matter - don't hate WWE quite enough to justify a long storyline based almost entirely on their lack of interest in it.
Certain digs at WWE still work. CM Punk ripped the piss out of the WrestleMania 38 ticket sales last year, and drew a massive pop, but his incredible programme with MJF won't be remembered for that. It will be remembered as a textured story, a war between characters so complex that they were able to perfect the blood feud and question its old-fashioned contrivance at the same time. Nobody fondly remembers the "less famous Miz" line; they remember the feeling elicited when MJF manipulated Punk into taking pity on him, and if he might have actually deserved pity.
When the whole story becomes about WWE, that story fails. AEW fans enjoy enjoying AEW more than they enjoy hating WWE. All Elite Wrestling is better when they show their fans that they're better at storytelling than WWE. That is the first rule of storytelling, and AEW continues to break it.
Tony Khan has proceeded because he's on the pulse of the wrestling fandom, and by his own admission has read about wrestling online every day for 30 years - but is he guilty of listening to the wrong people here?
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Under 20% of internet users in the US are subscribed to Twitter. On more than one occasion, an AEW wrestler has referenced some backstage report or other to crickets. In September, Max Caster rapped about the talent meeting held to ease backstage tensions, and nobody reacted. Not everybody cares about this sort of thing. Eric Bischoff once tried to get a pop in WCW by referencing the scissors fight between Arn Anderson and Sid. He had to repeat the line, under the impression that it was so great that the only possible explanation is that the fans mustn't have heard. They did; they just didn't get it.
Don't confuse this for some "AEW needs to reach the casual fan!" rubbish. The uncompromising, patient vision is obviously engaging an audience with which Warner Bros. Discovery. is happy. Still: at times, AEW occupies the other end of the extreme.
What AEW is doing, as part of storylines with significant time investment, is a virtual strain of cheap heat. They're all but wearing the colours of the local sports team for five months on end. Khan is on record as saying, on the Dan Le Batard show, that the hatred between AEW and WWE is real, citing WWE's alleged contract tampering and their apparent attempts to unsettle AEW's business relationship with NJPW as motivating factors.
Recent evidence would indicate that he hates WWE more than the vast majority of his fanbase.
Bryan Danielson felt lost throughout much of 2022 because his character was wrapped up in this petty dispute between billionaires. The JAS Vs. BCC storyline coincided with AEW's least revered period in its history. That's when it becomes a problem. It's also a problem that this happens so often, and if the trend must continue, it should be reserved for MJF exclusively. If there is something to the "Bidding War of '24", it can't be anything when so many other characters are doing the same bit.
It isn't 2019 anymore. AEW is in no immediate danger from WWE's spiteful games. The promotion exists in a healthy state. AEW fans no longer receive WWE as a threatening entity that, through the Wednesday Night War, might kill AEW before it gets off the ground. WWE, as a heel, has lost its heat.
It's time that AEW stops selling for it.