The Untold Truth About WCW Champion David Arquette
Scream if you wanna go (out of business) faster.
On August 18th 2019, David Arquette and partner Brian Anthony fell to Jerry 'The King' Lawler and Keith Youngblood in a sort-of run-of-the-mill Tag Team Title match for independent promotion Northeast Wrestling.
Sort-of because a clip did the rounds on social media of Lawler hitting the Stone Cold Stunner on Anthony before Arquette nailed a Diamond Cutter for good measure, all after an earnest 10 minute match either side of the former Enzo Amore and Big Cass working singles encounters. Sort-of because Lawler continues to work the weekends despite wrestling nearly taking his life in 2012. Sort-of because David Arquette is David Arquette.
It's perhaps not a story to you the wrestling fan reading this now, if you happen to take a passing interest in the scene. But even if you weren't aware that Arquette has been embracing the grass roots of an industry he once guest-starred in at the highest level, his name still won't feel that odd in this context because of his infamous involvement in the industry during pro wrestling's hedonistic turn-of-the-century heyday.
The Stunner/Diamond Cutter clip was an enjoyable slab of indie wrestling patter to entertain Twitter whilst the rest of the platform went into confused meltdown over NXT's move to the USA Network, proving that even the worst ideas can eventually have some merit. Arquette was at long last a welcome distraction for wrestling fans, nearly two decades after being one of the most accursed figures in its complex and convoluted history.
Much like Dewey Riley in the Scream series, he was the babyface all along. The corporate world that birthed "David Arquette: WCW Champion" was so full of disconnected nincompoops and accidental heels that nobody stopped to see the damage his latest role was about to do.
CONT'D...
A quick backstory for those that haven't undergone the oxymoronic experience of enjoying WCW's output from 2000 on the WWE Network, or simply not revisited some of the biggest moments from the organisation through a prism other than far-from-impartial documentary series' or history as written by the winners and highest-paid losers.
The April 26th 2000 Thunder started much like half of the product did back then. Clips of another wild Nitro two days earlier focus on hummers and contracts and divorce and calling Hulk Hogan "Terry", but also show special guest star David Arquette rather comically getting in the mix whilst on the promo junket for WCW tie-in movie (and objective turkey) Ready To Rumble. In keeping with how these things often go, the mainstream visitor sides with a babyface to p*ss off the heels. In typically WCW fashion, this is escalated to an absurd degree.
Sticking up for newfound friend Diamond Dallas Page, Arquette finds himself in an actual match against Eric Bischoff, with the stipulation set that DDP would get a shot at Jeff Jarrett's WCW Championship if he could win. The contest was mostly comedy, but the heroes prevailed. It being WCW, the shot took place that night, and Page scooped his third reign in the company's 10th title trade of the year. It was April.
Much of the same pyro and ballyhoo (two eyes emoji) kicked off on Thunder to craft a tag match between the respective goodies and baddies with Page's newly-won strap on the line. The winning pin struck gold for the victory, but as the referee's hand slapped the mat for three, it was clear the company should have just kept digging.
CONT'D...
In the years that followed, David Arquette spoke on the decision, noting that he was hugely against the move. A lifelong mark for the industry, he wasn't such a mark that he didn't realise how bad the belt might look around his waist to the wrestling audience and the wider public at large. Admirable, and not the only time Arquette comes off as the only hero in this murky action adventure tale.
Noting how toxic the environment was backstage as result of the call, he once explained the reality of the poisoned chalice he was suddenly forced to sip from. Speaking to Sunday Night's Main Event, he said, "There was a lot of hatred, and a lot of people got so pissed off. I remember telling one wrestler, I'm not sure who it was...but it was someone who hadn't ever been the champion before. And he was just so pissed. I was like I don't know what to say, man."
Many have posited that his recent sideways entry into the independent scene via some bloody hardcore spotfests and ticket-selling showcase encounters such as the aforementioned Jerry Lawler p*ssabout are yet more efforts in atonement from the man who really shoulders the least blame for the shoddy situation.
Again, there's not enough good to be said about his contributions to a business he was as much a fan of as his actual own industry. In these circles at very least, an objectively great guy. Maybe WCW giving him the gold wasn't so stupid all along?
No. Of course it was.
CONT'D...
The titular untold truth only remains untold in certain corners of the wrestling internet because so few people that formed its original incarnation cared to listen. Despite occasional contradictions below the line on websites such as this one, the internet can be a much nicer place now than it once was. Anonymised forums and newsgroups have been shunted to the fringes of the world wide web in place of social media landscape made up of names and faces and lives and careers - few would be so furious with a booking decision that they'd risk any of the above on lambasting it with the sort of biliousness that was once so commonplace.
This can't be understated - people f*cking despised this decision.
David Arquette winning the WCW World Heavyweight Championship wasn't the death of WCW, just like the Fingerpoke Of Doom wasn't, nor Judy Bagwell On A Pole wasn't, nor Jamie Kellner's axing of it from the TNT schedule wasn't. Death by a few thousand paper cuts and a few million squandered dollars, the company perished for all of the above and many more micro-moments like them. But it was yet another case of the company picking at the already-frayed stitches of the organisation's fabric, and unlike much of the worked shoot sh*t airing on Nitro and Thunder whilst audiences deserted the show in droves, this blunder had to be high profile to justify its very existence.
The mainstream world took one look at it, laughed, and bantered it off. The wrestling world didn't want to look, but couldn't stop staring in disillusioned disbelief. The company had booked the worst of both worlds.
CONT'D...
As noted, the actor didn't want to take this part.
He didn't want to sully the legacy created by Ric Flair, Harley Race and even Hulk Hogan. He didn't want to be the mug mark trying to clear competing with his wife Courtney Cox as she questioned his sanity in a largely-forgotten Nitro segment that also featured Kurt Russell. He didn't even want to take the money he was handsomely paid for it.
A wrestling fan to the core, Arquette generously gave his WCW wages to the families of Owen Hart, Brian Pillman and Darren Drozdov. Diamond Dallas Page's ardent defence of him years later remains powerful viewing because of the powerful sentiment. WCW management were making a huge, huge error, against the best advice of the people directly involved with it, but made it all the same.
A brief history of the World Title's journey either side of Arquette's reign can contextualise and conclude this bizarre period in its troubled tenure. Dangerous Dave defeated Eric Bischoff to win his friend DDP's title. DDP had toppled Jeff Jarrett a day before. Jarrett and won the (vacant) title a week earlier. Arquette's one pay-per-view match (a 'Ready To Rumble' Triple Cage encounter that finally, in name only, got to the f*cking point of his participation in the first place) saw him turn heel on Page to gift the title to...Jeff Jarrett. So did it need to even happen in the first place?
In their desperate quest for notoriety and news that month, WCW simply forgot to ask the question. They always did, until the entire wrestling world simply stopped going to them for answers.