3. The Big Show
"The World's Largest Athlete" has spent the last several years flipping back and forth between heel and face every few months, crying to Stephanie McMahon and just being an all-around lovable lug. He comes off as one of the most genuinely nice guys in the entire WWE, which is why this arrest is so strange and out of character. Back in December of 1998, while in town for a WCW show, Big Show (then competing as The Giant) was arrested in Memphis, TN for allegedly exposing himself to a female hotel employee. The performer born Paul Wight denied showing the clerk his big show, and since no evidence could be collected, he was released and the charges were dropped. It's hard to imagine the thoughts going through the mind of the police officers responding to a case of a 7', 500 lb giant accused of flashing his package. I imagine it was hopes that they would find the massive man in an agreeable mood. If his mugshot is any indication, he was more irritated than angry.