WWE: 10 Superstar Gimmicks That Are Total Rip Offs

Haven't we seen these before?

Kurt Angle Jack Swagger It is no secret that recycled ideas are a common theme in all forms of media; Hollywood have been offering us identical movie sequels for years. Take The Hangover, how often can a group of bewildered guys wake up in a hotel room alongside a potentially dangerous animal? The answer being for as long as it is a box office hit; look out for Hangover 47 this August. Well, wrestling is the same. Do you remember when Shawn Michaels was bankrupt and started working for JBL? He was made to do everything he could to ensure JBL the headline spot at WrestleMania. The storyline wasn't a massive hit, but the WWE aren't against creating a sequel for a bad story; after all they gave us the Marine 2 and 3. Shortly after HBK€™s financial disaster, Big Show would suffer the same fate; only this time giving his services to The Authority. His actions during this time included him killing the momentum of the Battleground PPV main event, by entering the ring before punching both competitors and the referee; with his interference subsequently ending the match. This attempt at a bankrupt wrestler also failed. So to clarify, two of the company€™s longest serving wrestlers both became broke within a matter of years? Either the WWE does not pay as much as we're led to believe or these guys now own the Mona Lisa, the Statue of David and Christ the Redeemer. Nevertheless, expect John Cena to be €˜broke€™ in two years time. Wrestling€™s worst copycat crime however, is producing new characters that are identical to popular wrestlers of the past. Read on to see how poorly disguised some of these rip off gimmicks have actually been.

10. Chuck Palumbo

Taker Chuck

Original Gimmick: The Undertaker The Undertaker has had more character changes than Madonna, but, the version that stands out like a sore thumb when you think of Big Evil is €˜the American Badass€™ gimmick. The wrestler€™s other personas such as the Deadman, The Lord of Darkness and The Phenom were all very mysterious, demonic and dominant. The American Badass on the other hand was a tough guy biker, who would come down to the ring on a Harley Davidson as his Limp Bizkit entrance song rocked out across the arena. In 2007 Chuck Palumbo re-emerged after a short absence from the WWE, and appeared to have raiding The Undertaker's old wardrobe. He also had an entrance that would see him cruising down to the ring on a motorcycle as rock music played. Whilst many fans found The Undertaker€™s biker gimmick hard to stomach, due to not being keen on seeing a €˜human€™ version of the wrestler, even less people were ready to accept Palumbo as being legit. Chuck€™s last popular gimmick was a very camp character that had pigtails, a personal stylist and was €˜engaged€™ to his tag team partner. The fans had no interest in entertaining the idea of him as a badass biker. The irony being that Palumbo is actually a big motorcycle enthusiastic in real life. Palumbo€™s character soon went away and The Undertaker would morph into The Phenom, making the whole world happy again.

9. The Straight Edge Society

Rtc Straight Edge

Original Gimmick: Right to Censor Within the year 2000 the WWE was running riot, we witnessed a Hardcore title match taking place in a kids ball pool and Mae Young flashed her double lattes to the world. There was an obvious heel gimmick to surface amongst the mayhem, a person/ group looking to tame life within the company; step forward Steven Richards. Right to Censor€™s feud were often based around them trying to ban something inappropriate on the show such as The Godfather€™s hoe train and Rikishi€™s ass. He was after all a €˜thong wearing fatty€™ if you agree with The Rock. It is no secret that CM Punk keeps a straight edge lifestyle and the WWE played that into a storyline when he feuded against notorious drug abuser Jeff Hardy; the rivalry was a great success and the company therefore decided there was more life in the gimmick. CM Punk became a preacher, very much like Richard€™s character in Right to Censor; only Punk wanted to save the general public from alcohol and drug abuse not Rikishi€™s Titanic tushy. He would also frequently complain about the inappropriate behaviour of other wrestlers and collected a group of followers that agreed with his idea of improving the conduct of those associated with the WWE, just as Steven Richards did. Whilst CM Punk had some high profile feud during his time as the leader of The Straight Edge Society, such as matches against Rey Mysterio and The Big Show, Right to Censor were the more successful stable. Both the Tag Team belts and the Women€™s Title were within the camp at one point.

8. Mark Henry

Patera Henry

Original Gimmick: Ken Patera Patera was an athlete outside of wrestling prior to his debut; he would compete in weightlifting contests before going on to enter the World€™s Strongest Man competition in 1977. Sounding familiar? Sure, as it stands it is not actually a gimmick but rather a shared hobby; until the WWE endorse those achievements of course. Patera wrestled with incredible stamina and ruthless aggression, he would also find great pleasure in injuring other wrestlers, earning the character great heat. As a competitor, Patera was highly respected for his strength and had great matches with the likes of Andre the Giant and Bruno Sammartino. Mark Henry€™s background is almost identical to Patera. Henry was signed by the WWE, after the company were made aware of his successes in weightlifting competitions; he also won the Arnold Strongman Classic contest, which is similar to The World€™s Strongest Man event. There are ways in which they do differ though; Mark Henry is the father of a hand. Patera is not. Within the ring, Henry€™s nickname is the €˜World€™s Strongest Man€™ and is also an aggressive heel that enjoyed injuring other athletes. In fact he even created a club called the €˜Hall of Pain€™ for them to join. Previous members include The Big Show and The Great Khali.

7. Jack Swagger

Angle Swagger

Original Gimmick: Kurt Angle Kurt Angle arrived in the WWE as an Olympic gold medallist, which he liked to mention a lot. He was shown as a very proud countryman who was living the €˜American dream€™; wearing a red, white and blue singlet wrestling outfit. Angle€™s finishing move was the ankle lock; he is also highly considered one of the greatest technical wrestlers the business has ever produced. Jack Swagger was not quite an Olympic gold medallist but did also have an amateur wrestling background, becoming an All-American and collecting a record number thirty pin falls within one season. Swagger€™s nickname once joining the WWE became €˜The All American American€™, his finishing move was identical to the ankle lock, however with a title change of the patriot lock. Swagger has never been considered one of the greatest technical wrestlers the business has ever produced by anyone, ever. Verdict: WWE created a poor man€™s Kurt Angle. Angle was asked about Swagger€™s rip-off gimmick live on radio and responded as follows: €œI think Jack Swagger needs to be Jack Swagger and not Kurt Angle. It€™s not fortunate but that is the direction they want to go with him and we'll see how it works out. I don't think anything like that pans out in the long run.€

6. Legacy

Evolution Legacy

Original Gimmick: Evolution Evolution were/ are an incredible stable made up from four of the most successful men in the wrestling business: Triple H, Ric Flair, Randy Orton, Batista. The concept of the group was pretty straight forward; between them they represented the evolution of wrestling. The two rookie wrestlers being the future, Triple H's recent dominance representing the present and Ric Flair€™s history in the business symbolising the past. It€™s questionable how flattering it is to be the past€™s representative, when you€™re still an active member of the roster, but either way, the group made one hell of a team. Only three years after Evolution parted ways the WWE brought us legacy. Randy Orton was the leader within the faction and had upgraded to the present force within the WWE, the viper held the WWE title whilst leading the group. The other two members of the stable, Cody Rhodes and Ted DiBiase, were a pair of young, relatively new wrestlers that would help Orton out when he was in trouble, very much duplicating Batista and Orton€™s old roles in Evolution. Each member had a father who previously had success with the WWE in the past; hence the name Legacy. Both groups were very successful and held various titles during their runs. They were shown to have the mentality of a ruthless pack of wolves and would assault a fellow member€™s opponent to change the direction of a match; both stables received major heat from the crowd.

5. Carlito

Razor Carlito

Original Gimmick: Razor Ramon Before either Razor Ramon or Carlito made their debut in the WWE, they were both shooting promos to showcase their characters; and at times they were almost identical. They would slowly walk down a €˜Caribbean€™ street, explaining how they were the essence of cool, as traditional island music played in the background. In one particular instance they even both spat fruit into the face of a man working on a street stall, to emphasise a lack of respect. They were so similar, that you could probably find more differences in the lead character of Rocky I and Rocky II. €˜Spitting in the face of people that don€™t want to be cool€™ would of course become Carlito€™s leading gimmick; with him often spitting his apple on popular wrestlers such as Maria and even John Cena. The gimmick was a reasonable success for a brief period of time and the crowd seemed to genuinely dislike his bad attitude. Unfortunately, Carlito€™s character didn't have many dimensions to it and would gradually lead to the wrestler€™s downward spiral with the company. Scott Hall on the other hand, was able to find longevity and prospered with the Razor Ramon character. He had some of the greatest feuds the WWE has ever seen under the gimmick; including some of the company€™s most historic matches, such as his two ladder matches against Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania X and SummerSlam 95.

4. Chris Masters

Lex Masters

Original Gimmick: Lex Luger Lex Luger was renowned for his impressive muscular physique and actually originally signed for McMahon€™s short lived WBF, rather than WWE. The World Bodybuilding Federation lasted a mere two years; the reason being that Vince attempted to turn bodybuilding into a WWE-style show. However rather than wrestle, each character would just stand and flex their muscles at a camera; imagine staying up for two hours of that every Monday night. Mr McMahon is undoubtedly a top business entrepreneur, but he is clearly determined to challenge that widespread view at times. With the WBF dead and gone, Lex Luger debuted in the WWE. As a wrestler, he was known as the €˜Narcissist€™ and would stand in front of a full length mirror and flex his bulging muscles before he was ready to compete. The Narcissist did reasonably well as a heel and his biggest feud with the gimmick came against Mr. Perfect, as they battled to determine who was closer to perfection. Fast forward to 2005, Raw introduces the world to Chris Masters A.K.A. The Masterpiece. His titron featured the statue of David wedged in amongst all the slow motion shots of different muscles on Masters€™ body. He would then flex at the crowd, before walking down to the ring with a satisfied grin beaming across his chops. Both wrestlers also had incredibly limited movesets.

3. Dolph Ziggler

Ass Ziggler

Original Gimmick: Billy Gunn Before Dolph Ziggler, Nick Nemeth was given the roles of a golf caddy and a cheerleader; probably two of the least intimidating professions a wrestler could possible mimic. So when offered the role of a PG €˜Mr. Ass€™, Ziggler was probably just grateful that he wasn't being asked to be a ballerina. As it turned out, the gimmick actually really suited €˜the Show Off€™. His new character echoed Billy Gunn€™s look, he had the same wavy bleach blonde hair, white boots and very similar pink trunks. Ziggler also adopting Gunn€™s conceited swagger and would shake his ass at the crowd in a similar way to the Mr. Ass character. Dolph has also incorporated much of Gunn€™s in ring style into his own act; including Billy€™s trademark finisher move, the Fame Asser. Both Gunn and Ziggler are extremely talented wrestlers that have unfortunately been overlooked by the WWE, for some strange reason. The pair have both been used for their exceptional selling ability, spending most of their career going over for other competitors and helping to spiral them into the main event picture. In 2012, Dolph Ziggler labelled Billy Gunn as his choice for the most underrated wrestler of all time on WWE.com.

2. JBL

Ted Jbl

Original Gimmick: Ted DiBiase The rich, arrogant douchebag is a gimmick that the WWE are extremely fond of and has had reasonable success on a frequent basis. Though the first man to really do the role justice was €˜The Million Dollar Man€™ Ted DiBiase; DiBiase cut some of the greatest promos in wrestling history and really sold the character well. Over time, The Million Dollar Man purchased both a suit and a wrestling belt with gold dollar signs pasted all over it, which on hindsight made him look more like a Batman villain than a wrestler. His gimmick consisted of him using his money to humiliate others, including an unknown teenage Rob Van Dam, who kissed Di Biase€™s foot for $100. He probably owed it to his drug dealer. JBL is completely open about incorporating Ted Dibiase€™s gimmick into his own character, in fact earlier this year Layfield tweeted a picture of himself besides Ted DiBiase and Alberto Del Rio, with a description that read €˜three generations of one stolen gimmick€™. Away from wrestling JBL was having great success in the stock market, which the company adopted into his onscreen character. His gimmick included him employing a stable of wrestlers to protect him. Recently Alberto Del Rio also had success with the gimmick, and his entrance included him arriving in a different luxury car each week, as well as having a personal ring announcer introduce his arrival. Again the gimmick enabled Del Rio to triumph in the WWE; he has held both the WWE Championship and the World Heavyweight Title, each on two separate occasions.

1. Ryback

Ryberg

Original Gimmick: Goldberg When your gimmick is such a rip off that you are having a previous wrestler€™s name chanted towards you at each arena you attend, you know subtlety isn't your strongest trait. Ryback is a bit unfortunate in that his appearance resembles Goldberg, but there are ways to edit that. It looks like the €˜feed me more€™ wrestler has rushed into a fancy dress shop and asked for the €˜Bill Goldberg€™ costume, leaving with everything but the black pants; perhaps next time he should come out dressed as Spiderman, at least with a mask it is easier to pretend. Away from his appearance and over to his gimmick; Ryback entered the WWE as an unstoppable one-man wrecking machine, whose character was based around an impressive winning streak; Goldberg started life in WCW with one hundred and seventy three consecutive victories. It can only be assumed that McMahon was so sadden by Goldberg€™s short stay within the company that he thought he should make a clone. The company seemed to hesitate on Ryback€™s big push and his winning streak was eventually broken by CM Punk after just thirty eight matches. Perhaps, Vince was put off by the constant €˜Goldberg€™ chants? Conclusion: if you're going to copy another wrestler€™s gimmick, don't choose the biggest star WCW ever produced because fans will remember. If you enjoyed the list and would like instant updates of future articles follow my Twitter page @Dragonstravel.

Contributor
Contributor

A wrestling enthusiast, currently educating the youth of Taiwan English; there are now a bunch of Asian kids running around with Yorkshire accents. Read about that trip and others at dragonstravel.com.