5. Carlito
A second generation wrestler, Carlito is one of the members of this list who is probably still remembered briefly by fans, but never really for anything in particular. Popular during his run in the WWE, he held both the WWE United States and Intercontinental Championships and was one of the talents who was heavily involved in storylines with John Cena before he became as popular as he is today. He even beat him for the United States Championship. He's also the guy whose bodyguard "stabbed" Cena in a nightclub. I don't think any wrestling fan is capable of forgetting that absolute piece of wrestlecrap. Carlito was always a talented wrestler, but never really talented enough to break the glass ceiling and become memorable. His tenure in WWE began to take a turn for the worst after he spoke about his dissatisfaction with WWE, and even requested his release. He stuck around for another couple of years, but did nothing except team with his brother in probably the most lacklustre part of his WWE career. Since leaving the WWE, he's had an extensive career in the independent circuit, most likely helped by the fact that his father has always been heavily involved with the running of the promotion.