WWE: 15 Things That Would Greatly Improve WrestleMania

Vince Mcmahon Wrestlemania How many WrestleMania events have actually been the WWE show of the year? On several occasions, the event just doesn't live up to the hype. We get at least one big main event and usually a classic match, but the show itself is in parts demonstrative of everything that's wrong with pro wrestling. Rushed matches, undeserving stars, terrible segments and for the fans in attendance a terrible view for what is for them a five hour sitting. WWE could improve their WrestleMania concept in several ways. It's high time they did. The event has seen little innovation over the last decade, remaining firm in its nature since the Attitude Era. Sure, its a successful formula, but the event must evolve if it is to go beyond the standard it has set. Right now it succeeds at times in spite of itself, it draws based upon the WrestleMania name and historical connotations as much as it does the actual card of the day. This feature will offer up 15 ideas to strengthen and better WrestleManias in general. The WWE's superbowl of wrestling concept can get even bigger following these proposals. Who knows, we may even see some of these ideas at WrestleMania 30. The build up for the New Orleans show has been mixed to poor, it certainly could have been improved. Will it be a success on the night? If WWE match their product to consumer expectations then yes, hopefully at Mania 30 we remember it as an all time great show. Here are some pointers WWE should take for WrestleMania productions in general ...

15. Lay The Groundwork To Replace The Streak

So much of WrestleMania's success in recent years has hinged on the Undertaker streak being challenged. In many peoples eyes, this is now the real Mania main event, way bigger than the title match or any other contest on the card. How does the WWE go about replacing this big selling point once the 49 year old Mark Calaway retires? They need to create a new annual gimmick. It's something they must endeavour to do, and the groundwork for the replacement concept should start now, Taker has a few years at best left in him. One idea could be to develop out a new streak, the story is a proven draw. One young star who could carry the streak gimmick for the next generation is Roman Reigns. He's young enough to do so and owns his first win from WrestleMania 29. If WWE has any sense he gets his second Mania win at New Orleans. From there he should get his third win at WrestleMania 31, perhaps by winning the WWE Title. From that point he can be drawn out as a Mania streak holder, the man trying to replicate Undertaker's legendary legacy. The company are going to have to get creative, there's no easy solutions, but with the huge absence the streak will leave, it's going to need replacing.

14. Long Term Planning

Something which has really marred the build for WrestleMania 30 has been awful planning. The fact they have been making the story up on a week to week basis is painfully obvious. Daniel Bryan has been the biggest example of WWE's lack of self confidence in their ability to plan right now, they have been chopping and changing his role throughout the last few months. It's crazy to think that they actually had him as part of the Wyatt family just a few months ago. It looks like the company have finally settled on him in the role we all want to see him in, but the inconsistent booking has arguably damaged the Mania 30 perception already. Long term planning should be advised for future WrestleMania feuds. Its no coincidence that WWE has done some of their best business when planning in advance. Steve Austin revealed in his 2003 autobiography that WWE planned every characters story out three years in advance during the Attitude Era. The dividends of this booking strategy where clear for all to see as WWF enjoyed their hottest period. Even just a couple of years ago when WWE booked Cena vs Rock with a three year plan it led to increased PPV buys, "once in a lifetime" was promoted over a year and became the highest grossing WWE PPV ever. Short term storytelling won't cut it, WWE need to think the long game when it comes to WrestleMania.

13. The Two Biggest Stars In The Main Event

It should be common sense really, the WWE main event should be a title face off between the top two biggest stars in the company to see who is greatest. This was the way it happened with Hogan and Andre at Mania 3, Warrior and Hogan at Mania 6 and Rock vs Austin in 1999 and 2001. By this standard, WrestleMania 30 really should have been Cena vs Punk closing the show for the WWE title. It's a legendary feud which always provides an epic match, Cena has been the number 1 guy for years now with Punk the number 2 man since 2011. They really should have faced off at a Mania. Instead, the WWE decided to run with Randy Orton vs Batista this year. It sucked so bad that they've now changed it to involve the popular upriser Daniel Bryan. Meanwhile Punk has left the company he's so miffed, while John Cena must make do with Bray Wyatt in a creatively misjudged feud. For future, WWE should stick with their top two guys for closing Mania. It makes sense, the top two stars in the company combining is the hottest draw ticket you could do at an event.

12. Elevate New Stars

The exception to putting the two biggest stars on last is in the case of a Daniel Bryan, a star who is riding a wave of momentum and is a clearly nailed on bet to become an industry star if given the WrestleMania main event. It was the same case with Brock Lesnar in 2003 and Dave Batista in 2005, the emerging stars who needed the mania win in order to crystallise their status as top guys. Bryan will do that this year at WrestleMania 30, the company will elevate him into being the number 2 biggest star in the company with a win in the main event (Cena will remain the number 1 guy, he's so big he doesn't need the title). The company should continue to elevate new stars with the traditional big win at Mania, it's baffling that they ever even considered doing Orton vs Batista in the main event at New Orleans. The company should in fact elevate new stars across the WrestleMania card. Big wins on the big stage, regardless of card position, will be beneficial to guys like Cesaro, Roman Reigns or even Bray Wyatt. The future should always be in consideration for the WWE.

11. A Proper Finish

WrestleMania is certainly not the place to do a screwy finish. The event to be considered special needs to be treated with reverence, the presentation needs to be sophisticated. The ramifications of an unclean finish where most harshly felt at WrestleMania 17, Vince McMahon helped Steve Austin defeat The Rock, effectively killing the Attitude Era in the process. WWE has learned their lesson since that fateful day, we now more often than not get a clean finish to the show, but this should also be the case throughout the card. Mania should about definitive matches with concrete winners and losers. When you look back to shoddy finishes such as WrestleMania 9, it really cheapens the presentation and stature of the brand. Let's hope at WrestleMania 30 WWE gives fans the clean finish we demand. One worry is that with fans locked into the Network, WWE are far more free to present their content in a longer context. Some fans are worrying a final Bryan screwjob will take place at Mania before he wins the belt from Batista at May's Extreme Rules. Let's hope this isn't the case. Bryan's time is now at WrestleMania 30 in a clean and convincing victory.

10. Innovate The Production Techniques

Mania is a pretty slick presentation as it is, a HD broadcast complete with fancy graphics and video packages. For fans in attendance there's also the pyrotechnics and lighting, Kevin Dunn's WWE production team do a great job of polishing up the product. Can they do better? Absolutely. Innovation in the production area hasn't really developed much over the last decade. WWE has been running big arenas and stadiums for years now with the same setup and processes. Compare this to the pre-Austin era and production regularly changed, innovation was clear for all to see every few years. Is the current years old standards because the technology progress has slowed or because the WWE are set in their ways? A bit of both perhaps, but the WWE should certainly think about how they can innovate. Presenting WrestleMania in new and interesting ways, with a new polish, would be a compelling way to make fans feel like we are part of a new and exciting era in pro wrestling.

9. Legitimate A-Star Celebrities

When WWE do celebrities right at WrestleMania, it bears great dividends. When they get it wrong, it plain sucks and takes a spot away from a deserving performer. The case in example of WWE success stories with celebrities has to be Mr T at WrestleMania 1, Donald Trump at Mania 23, and Floyd Mayweather at Mania 24. The utilisation of celebrities at those WrestleManias helped to bring in significant additional interest and buyers. Without Mr T at WrestleMania 1 there may not even have been future WrestleMania events, he helped make the brand. Trump and Mayweather where also hugely beneficial, as key headliners of 23 and 24 respectively they helped to break the box office record for highest grossing WWE PPV at the time. WWE should go down this route a bit more often, they should get a genuinely huge name celebrity in to help sell their product. However, they need to heed caution. When they get it wrong by bringing z-list celebrities in, it often damages the perception of the product. Jersery Shore's Snooki wasn't exactly everyone's cup of tea.

8. Reduce The PPV Price

Sums of money in the region of sixty dollars are way too much to pay for a wrestling show. The WWE are now allowing fans to view events on the WWE Network, so that helps negate the problem of cost to a degree, but it also only highlights just how badly the PPV customers are getting ripped off. The WrestleMania concept is a special commodity, but it would be greatly improved if it was just a little bit cheaper on PPV, it would inevitably convince some on-the-fence fans to purchase the show. While many fans will watch on the Network, a great portion are still going to watch via the traditional pay per view method. Even some Network subscribers are stating they will order the PPV anyway, not wanting to take any chances with the whispered perils of streaming on the night. Will pay per view still be around by the time of WrestleMania 31? I think so. Long term it will be killed off by the Network, but a year from now I still envision WrestleMania being available on pay per view. PPV distributor Dish Network is right, WWE need to bring their PPV price more in line with the Network. It's fair to the fans.

7. Reduce WrestleMania Season

WrestleMania 19 was one of the greatest events ever. It took place in March of 2003, leaving a more traditional gap between pay per view events. For WrestleMania 30 the gap is extended, with a recent trend of April Mania slots. This means we have six weeks of WWE between Elimination Chamber and WrestleMania this year, which is way too over-extending of the natural lifespan of the top feuds. As such WWE has to stretch storylines out, meaning we get repeated angles and over exposed production. The extra week into April is a drain for everyone involved, the audience, the wrestlers, it doesn't help anyone. When you consider that WrestleMania season starts from January's Royal Rumble, it really should be all over by the end of March. Anything further, even a week, is an over-extension. If WWE endeavoured to make their feud timeline more concise, it would avoid feelings of staleness for certain feuds by the time WrestleMania rolls around.

6. Find A Better Way For Fans Attending To View The Ring

Like many sporting events, if you really want to take in the action, you are better off watching from home on TV. Attending WrestleMania can be a horrible experience for wrestling fans, it's all of our dreams, but the practicalities of it can make Mania a real disappointment. The biggest detriment to the WWE live experience at Mania is the size of the arena / stadium. 80,000 people look great on TV, but imagine being one of the thousands of people at the back of the bleachers. Worst still, imagine being sat behind the massive construction which protects the ring in the outdoor locations. Take a look at the photo above. Is that really the best WWE could come up with to guard from the elements ... it's hugely obstructing to the audience's view. For fans attending live, WWE really need to show more consideration in designing the set. For fans in the arena it totals up to being a five hour sitting at WrestleMania, they should at least make it a comfortable and good view.

5. Just One Major Gimmick Match

Less is more in pro wrestling. At WrestleMania, for the sake of impact, only one gimmick match should be booked. WrestleMania 30 this year looks a real clustered mess due to the abundance of undercard gimmicks €” five of the eight matches are multi-person bouts. We have gimmicks such as the Vickie Invitational and the Andre the Giant Battle Royal. It seems a bit kitsch, it would have been far better to book just one properly intense gimmick match. A better formula for success would be to do something similar to WrestleMania 28, have one really big gimmick match which stands alone as something special. At Mania 28 it was Triple H vs Undertaker inside the Hell in a Cell, it was a brilliant contest, the best match of 2012. If WWE applied this 'less is more' formula more often, then it would help the dynamics of the Mania card significantly. Save all the big brutality for one match and it will mean more than spreading it out thinly over multiple gimmicks on the card. One gimmick match per a card should be the rule WWE sticks with.

4. Remove The Filler

While WWE needs rest moments between big matches, the poor standards of filler really hurts WrestleMania. Things would be so much better if the company either removed the filler or at least improved the interest in lower tier matches. WrestleMania 30 in particular is suffering from a terribly filled undercard. Who really wants to see a 14 diva one fall match? It's a horrible match which has no chance of getting over, it's going to be a cluster of bodies and frenzied spots. The company would have been much better off not bothering. It's a lesson to learn for the future of WrestleMania, rather than filling the card with uninteresting contests, just don't bother and instead add another ten minutes on to an exciting match such as Hunter vs Bryan. The paying audience would far prefer that scenario. WWE want to cram as many of their roster on to the high paying Mania card, but with 66 wrestlers on the WrestleMania 30 card, they have definitely gone too far. Talent are being put ahead of the fans interest in this scenario. Much like the last point, less is more. Cut the filler, enhance the main events.

3. A Three Hour Show Time

WrestleMania currently runs for four hours, way too much time for the average fan to remain interested in. By the time co-main events roll around, we have already been sat watching television for two and a half hours. It's too much, the dynamics of viewership would be better served by a three hour show. Losing an hour would be easily implemented, as the last point stated, there's plenty of poor filler WWE could cut from the show. While being sat for four hours at home feels like a long time, spare a thought for the fans attending live. By the time these fans have taken in the hour pre-show and aftermath, they could have been sat in the arena for upwards of five hours. There's also the fact they can be sat outside in the elements, with pre and post show commutes also a consideration. All in all, a three hour run time would make everyone's life easier.

2. Make It About Wrestling

It seems obvious that a wrestling show should be about wrestling. At the risk of sounding like an old time promoter, "Do what it says on the marquee, pro wrestling." It's something WWE doesn't always give the correct consideration toward. If you look up and down previous Mania cards, ask yourself this, how many matches were actually focused on two great wrestlers facing off? All too often we end up with silly matches designed as story pieces as opposed to wrestling contests. This is meant to be WrestleMania, not a B level PPV that's more like Sunday Night Raw. WWE should really focus their efforts on keeping Mania as sacred as possible, a holy ground upon which warriors come to settle their score. The place for storylines and segments is Raw. At WrestleMania we should see the best wrestlers getting a platform to wrestle. It seems obvious, yet all too often it isn't the case.

1. Honour The Royal Rumble

The biggest problem with WrestleMania for me over the years has been the disregard of the Royal Rumble. The perfect story-arc exists for WWE with the Rumble to Mania journey, a heroic underdog overcoming the odds in the Royal Rumble to chase down the treasure and defeat the villain at WrestleMania. It's the story which made a star of Steve Austin in 1998 and Brock Lesnar in 2003. Yet nowadays, the Rumble dynamic into Mania has been bastardised. Perhaps what really killed the meaning was when Sheamus won the Rumble in 2012, only to then wrestle the curtain jerker match of Mania 28 where he won the World Title in 18 seconds. What was the point of investing a Rumble win in someone for that? It was arguably worse this year, Batista won the Rumble with zero momentum and no interest in him main eventing WrestleMania. The perfect story arc WWE possesses from January to April needs reinstating to its former glory. If WWE implements just some of these recommendations, I'm sure they will only strengthen the success story that is WrestleMania.

WWE Writer

Grahame Herbert hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.