WWE Backlash 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

From WrestleMania dreams to WWE nightmares at Backlash? Say it ain't so!

WWE Backlash 2024 France Cody Rhodes
WWE

WWE is still in that sugary sweet honeymoon period post-WrestleMania 40. Sure, the 2024 Draft was akin to Triple H coming out on stage and announcing that most of his major players are staying put on shows they're already on, but don't let that dampen spirits. No, let this article do that for you instead.

Clue's in the name, people: "Nightmares"!

This isn't some back-patting, high-fiving, fun-filled ride through the best that'll happen at Backlash over in France. Instead, it's a look at everything that could go pear shaped for WWE during their latest international jaunt, as well as for big time stars like Cody Rhodes, Damian Priest, Jade Cargill, Sami Zayn and even CM Punk.

Will this be a night Cody looks back on and wonders what might've been? Hopefully not, but hope is in short supply within. You know what you're getting in for by now - this is the absolute dirt worst that could happen in WWE circles over in Lyon.

Forced title changes, forced title vacations, and inexperience biting when it matters most? Yikes! All of this is a quite horrendous thought.

10. Inexperience Costs Jade Cargill

WWE Wrestlemania 40 Jade Cargill Dakota Kai
WWE.com

Drive past your local bookies to see a long line of people putting a few quid on Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill winning the Women's Tag-Team Titles. OK, maybe not, but most wrestling fans agree the superhero-like duo will get the job done over in France and supplant division saviours Asuka and Kairi Sane before posing with the belts.

What if WWE sees that outcome as "too obvious"? What if they fancy putting Jade up against it early to see how fans react to her living some adversity? It's certainly not impossible that she slips on the proverbial rookie banana skin in France and ends up costing Bianca the chance to score more gold.

It'd be a bit naff if that happened.

Every worker has to learn to bounce back from defeat at some point, but it feels too soon for Cargill. Besides, her whole thing right now is being a jacked-up force to be reckoned with who barely has any weaknesses. Exposing her inexperience for the sake of a quick split story with Belair would be foolish.


9. Sami Zayn Loses Far Too Soon

Sami Zayn GUNTHER
WWE

Cody Rhodes wasn't the only guy who lived a dream at 'Mania. Sami Zayn did too, and his wonderful Intercontinental Title triumph over record-shattering ex-champ GUNTHER will live long in the memory. The nightmare suggestion here is that winning it was actually the sole peak moment of Sami's latest stint with the famous championship.

He may well be a transitional champion at best.

There will be a few raised eyebrows and tutting responses to that, of course. Nobody wants to think about Zayn dropping the IC belt just yet, but...what if that's the plan? Granted, WWE hasn't officially announced anything for Sami at Backlash either. A three-way vs. Chad Gable and Bronson Reed is incoming though.

At time of writing, Backlash only has five matches scheduled. Trips will presumably add at least one more to the lineup, and either the IC or Women's World Titles are in the frame for that spot. If it's the former, then fingers crossed Zayn doesn't eat a loss.


8. And Not Even To Chad Gable!

Bronson Reed WWE Intercontinental Title
WWE.com

Especially to this dude.

Look, Bronson Reed has skills, and he deserves the chance to develop his 'big mean boy doing big mean things' character on TV for the rest of 2024. That's all true, but Reed isn't on the level of Sami Zayn yet. Hell, he isn't even as interesting a challenger as recent rogue Chad Gable.

People are crying out see Gable go after Sami one-on-one, and it'd be a real pity if WWE didn't book that on PLE at least once. Bronson has been crudely inserted as a third wheel, and yet he could leave France with a surprise Intercontinental Title reign to shout about.

That'd take everyone by surprise, but it's hardly inconceivable. WWE has booked shock title wins before, and Hunter may well view this as Reed's ticket towards the top. That'd totally crush everything Sami and Chad have been working towards, because their rivalry means bugger all without the belt.


7. Naomi Screws Bayley Over

Bayley Naomi Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

Speaking of swerves for the sake of swerves.

Naomi has been Bayley's best buddy since the ex-Damage CTRL leader went good again and vanquished old stablemate IYO SKY at 'Mania. Meanwhile, main roster newbie Tiffany Stratton has acted like the counterpoint to all this merriment. The ambitious former NXT star has zero time for Naomi and Bayley being besties.

It's clear that Naomi is being squeezed out of the title picture after Backlash, so keep a close eye on her behaviour throughout the match. There's every chance the returnee will start acting a wee touch heelish during select spots. Or, WWE will go all in on Naomi turning out to be another snake Bayley can't trust.

Stratton winning the Women's Title feels inevitable, but the build towards that victory is everything. It wouldn't be very satisfying if she grabbed the gold due to Naomi f*cking over Bayley. Similarly, Bayley is only just getting started as champ and deserves better.


6. Solo Sikoa’s Mutiny Is Snuffed Out

Tama Tonga Solo Sikoa Debut
WWE.com

Something brilliant is building on SmackDown involving The Bloodline. You'll have heard that one before, 'cause the faction has been a real linchpin for WWE's product in various forms since 2020-ish. Now, Solo Sikoa is taking the lead and possibly rebelling against directives from absentee leader Roman Reigns.

Please don't snuff that out at Backlash, creative team.

Solo and new recruit Tama Tonga simply have to win against Randy Orton and Kevin Owens. The Bloodline offshoot needs this more than R-KO does, and no-one can convince this writer otherwise. Fail, and they'll only look less like credible mutineers and more like the background joke WWE turned Jimmy Uso into for a while.

Paul Heyman cannot smugly pick up his phone post-match and call Roman to laugh at the misfortune of soldiers who think they should sit in the big chair. That'd neuter everything that's been happening on TV leading into this PLE. It's pretty vital that WWE protects Sikoa and Tonga.


5. The Atmosphere Isn’t There

WWE France Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Last year, fans in Puerto Rico got loud for Backlash 2023. They roared themselves hoarse for the Bianca Belair vs. IYO SKY opener, and continued passionately putting forth San Juan's case for another PLE all night. By the time Bad Bunny emerged for his 'Street Fight' vs. former friend Damian Priest, the place came unglued.

You've got a lot to live up to, France.

Admittedly, WWE hasn't given Lyon localised scorchers like that Bunny vs. Priest epic. Also, as tantalising a prospect as Cody Rhodes vs. AJ Styles is in-ring, it can't match the storytelling produced for last year's Cody vs. Brock Lesnar headliner. It'd be rotten if French fans sat on their hands instead of going crazy.

Great wrestling crowds should never be taken for granted though. A poor one can spoil what fans see on TV, and that can definitely have an adverse impact on any pay-per-view. This weekend's show must be a celebration of WWE's international appeal, not a yawn-inducing flat, house show-style atmosphere.


4. It Feels More Like A Glorified Raw

CM Punk WWE Raw
WWE.com

Think of this as an extension of the prior point.

It's anyone's guess whether or not injured stars like Drew McIntyre and CM Punk will be in the house to take in Backlash. Neither man has been cleared to wrestle, so the only thing they could do is continue working angles like the one showcased on the Draft special this past Monday.

Lyon would be happy to see Punk or Drew, but WWE has to be careful of one thing: Backlash becoming a glorified episode of Raw or SmackDown. Each PLE should have its own identity that elevates it above the weekly fare, after all. Saturday's card can't turn into a weird mish-mash of house show-esque bouts and segments better suited to Raw.

Balancing everyone's need to see star power in person live and what's best for people watching at home is one of the toughest tasks facing Triple H, not least when booking a feud between two guys who can't work matches. Would McIntyre and Punk repeating their trick from Raw dilute the PLE vibe?


3. Lack Of True Story Bites

Cody Rhodes AJ Styles
WWE.com

This has kinda been explored in earlier entries too, but it's time for a deeper dive.

Yours truly is often outspoken about the lack of meaningful story heading into some AEW pay-per-views. Tony Khan promotes more of an exhibition-style "dream match" factory, and that doesn't always jive with hot storytelling on par with the recent Cody Rhodes vs. Roman Reigns stuff. However, it'd be unfair to pretend that Backlash 2024 is heavy on story.

If anything, Cody working AJ Styles is more in-tune with something Khan would book. That isn't always the worst plan for 'B' tier PLEs, but exactly none of the five announced bouts for France have any long-term story build to speak of. This could have a negative knock-on effect that furthers the 'is this just gonna be a house show?' worry.

Rhodes vs. Styles has been put together quickly, ditto for Damian Priest vs. Jey Uso, and there's nothing else on the card that has the same weight to it as 'Mania tales did. Perhaps that was always going to be the case, but it's worth pointing out anyway.

Story is king, and helps a show stand out from the crowd.


2. WWE Ditches Damian Priest

Jey Uso Damian Priest
WWE

WWE backed themselves into a corner with Damian Priest's Money In The Bank win. Being brutally honest, the promotion should ditch the briefcase gimmick for a few years and let everyone mentally reset on it - they almost let Priest's time with the thing linger too long before his shock cash-in at WrestleMania 40.

Here's another issue: Judgment Day's finest is blatantly a short term fix for the top title spot on Raw. CM Punk or Drew McIntyre will get their mitts on the thing once healthy, which means Priest's Backlash title defence vs. Jey Uso is a little bit of a PLE oddity that was completely unexpected.

WWE might try their luck with Jey Uso in the lead role. Y'know, just to see if he has what it takes to sit atop a division as champ. That'd destroy Damian's credibility into the bargain though, so creative has to be real careful with the outcome on Saturday night in France.

Plan for Priest could be lose the belt > blame his stablemates > watch Judgment Day crumble > feud with Finn Bálor.


1. Cody Rhodes Is Actually Injured

WWE SmackDown Cody Rhodes Carmelo Hayes
WWE

Recent reports say there isn't too much to worry about with Cody Rhodes coming out of his match vs. Carmelo Hayes on SmackDown. That's cool, but Dave Meltzer was playing a guessing game on everything. What if his cries for calm are misplaced and Cody is actually hurting more than WWE wants to let on?

Man, it'd be depressing if Rhodes was the latest champ who had to vacate due to injury.

WWE is still reeling from Rhea Ripley doing the same, and everyone had to deal with CM Punk announcing he was out of the running for WrestleMania during a crunch period before that. Losing Cody would be disastrous for Triple H right now, but injuries don't care about timing. In fact, they regularly strike at the worst possible times.

Rhodes tearfully announcing that he can't work AJ Styles, and thus being replaced by someone like LA Knight, would suck. That isn't meant as disrespect towards LA by any means, but yeah - Cody kissing the WWE Title goodbye so soon after winning it is an awful thought.

What other nightmare scenarios could come true at WWE Backlash 2024? For more wrestling, check out Ranking Every Night Two WWE 2024 Draft Pick From Worst To Best and WWE Backlash 2024: 10 Things That Must Happen! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.