WWE Draft 2016: 5 Things That Will Happen (And 5 That Won't)
So much speculation, but how much of it is true?
On 19 July, SmackDown’s first ever live Tuesday night broadcast will play host to the 2016 WWE Draft. The company will once again create two unique rosters of talent, broadcasters, and authority figures in an attempt to create parity between Raw and SmackDown and revitalise its product in the wake of poor TV ratings and declining fan interest.
The Brand Split may only be a few days away, but concrete details have been thin on the ground so far. We know that Stephanie and Shane McMahon will act as Commissioners for Raw and SmackDown respectively, and each will be responsible for appointing their own General Manager, but not much else.
Everything from SmackDown’s show length to the actual talent rosters themselves remains up in the air. WWE are keeping their cards close to their chest ahead of the big night, and that, of course, has led to rampant speculation across the internet since the split was announced in May.
It’s hard to be optimistic with so many unanswered questions still doing the rounds, but whatever happens, the 2016 Brand Split represents a bold new direction for a company that badly needs it. Fans will continue to speculate until the final draft pick is made, but until then, here are five things that will happen in the 2016 WWE Draft, and five that won't.
10. Roman Reigns WON'T Go 1st Or 2nd
Prior to the Samoan’s 30-day suspension for violating WWE’s wellness policy, it seemed a dead cert that Roman Reigns and John Cena would go their separate ways as Raw and SmackDown’s first picks. Now? Things are much less certain.
For one, Reigns is no longer the WWE Champion. Dean Ambrose took the belt from him (via Seth Rollins) at Money in the Bank, which makes Dean a much likelier pick to occupy a top slot. But even if Stephane or Shane don’t pick their top champion first, Brock Lesnar’s public interest is at an all-time high after his UFC 200 demolition of Mark Hunt. He’s sure to go early in the draft, and as the biggest star in the company, it wouldn’t be a huge surprise to see him go first overall.
Reign’s popularity is at an all-time low, and if WWE are even remotely receptive to their fanbase, they’ll recognise this. Fans will hate the move, the building will fill with boos should he go first or second, and that’ll set the Draft off to a disastrous start right off the bat.
We likely won’t know where Reigns stands in the company until draft night itself, but does Vince McMahon really want to keep promoting a universally-derided failed babyface as his apparent “top guy,” particularly after his wellness violation?
9. The Women WILL Be On The Same Brand
Women’s wrestling hasn’t quite undergone the post-WrestleMania renaissance that many expected. Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch delivered a match-of-the-night performance in Arlington, Texas, but despite a noticeable increase in TV time, erratic storylines and inconsistent face/heel alignments mean the Women’s division is still in a state of flux.
WWE cannot afford to tear its Women’s division in half at this point, and they won’t. The talent pool simply isn’t big enough. 15 women are currently listed on WWE’s female talent roster, four of whom are injured (Emma, Nikkie Bella, Rosa Mendes, and Tamina), one who works solely as a manager (Lana), and another who hasn’t been seen in months (Naomi).
That leaves four active women for each brand, which is nowhere near enough to fill-out a credible title division. As good as the likes of Becky, Sasha, and Paige are, there isn’t enough of them to justify not keeping them together as part of the draft, and while WWE have bumbled their way through the “Divas Revolution,” they do seem genuinely committed to women’s wrestling. If they’re as serious as they claim, they’ll keep this talented-but-sparse group of competitors together.
8. Tag Teams WON'T Be Split-Up
While there are a surprisingly high number of tag teams currently active in WWE, don’t expect the company to split any of them up in this year’s Draft.
The original WWE Draft in 2002 saw a handful of veteran teams like The Dudley Boyz and APA go their separate ways to explore singles options. It didn’t quite work-out for Bubba Ray and Reverend D-Von, but it proved to be the making of John “Bradshaw” Layfield, who’d go on to achieve immense singles success with a 280-day reign as WWE Champion.
Very few of WWE’s current tag team wrestlers have anything like that kind of outlook. There might be long-term potential in a Big E singles run, but The New Day are one of WWE’s most popular acts at the moment, and there’d be no sense in splitting them at this stage. There’s also an outside chance that WWE will split the Dudleyz and let Bubba harness some of the qualities that made him such a great heel as TNA’s Bully Ray, but what would they do with D-Von?
The rest of WWE’s tag teams are either completely dependent on one another (The Usos, Shining Stars, and Lucha Dragons) or too new to split (Enzo & Big Cass, and The Vaudevillains). All in all, there’s nothing to be gained from cannibalising the tag team division at the moment, and that’s why WWE won’t do it.
7. Bayley & Finn Bálor WILL Be Drafted
Finn Bálor’s main roster call-up has been brewing for months. Ever since Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows (his former Bullet Club buddies from Japan) appeared on the scene with AJ Styles, rumours have been rife of Bálor’s imminent appearance on Raw or SmackDown, but it hasn’t materialised yet.
Now is the perfect time to pull the trigger. Bálor’s NXT match with Shinsuke Nakamura has effectively concluded his developmental business and called time on a highly-successful run at Full Sail University. He’s an incredibly polished and refined all-round wrestler with the skills and charisma to make an immediate impact, and there’s absolutely nothing left for him to do in Orlando after his record-breaking title run.
Bayley is in the exact same position. It was vital that she stayed back in NXT when her friends Becky, Sasha, and Charlotte were called-up. Her departure would’ve left the brand’s celebrated women’s division woefully understocked, but Asuka has since succeeded her as the division’s alpha female, and the likes of Alexa Bliss look more than ready to take her place.
There’s no sense in Bayley hanging around Full Sail much longer. She has nothing left to prove in the NXT women’s division, and her arrival will do wonders to freshen-up the WWE Women’s Title scene.
6. NXT WON'T Be Raided
The Brand Split will effectively halve each show’s available talent pool and leave them with a number of empty spaces. It’s been suggested that WWE will look to NXT to fill these spots and restock their roster, and that “up to a dozen” young grapplers could be set for a call-up during next week’s Draft.
Bálor, Bayley, and maybe one or two others will probably go up, but WWE isn’t going to gut its most critically acclaimed brand. For a start, NXT is a genuine touring attraction in its own right. Without the likes of Samoa Joe, Asuka, and The Revival, they’re not going to draw any crowds to their shows, and an already unprofitable brand is going to start hemorrhaging money like nobody’s business.
Secondly, NXT currently produces one of the most widely-lauded weekly wrestling television shows in existence, and the TakeOver live specials are among the year’s most celebrated. Are WWE really going to throw all of this away by taking half the talent and replacing them with underdeveloped trainees who aren’t ready for TV yet?
The answer is no.
5. Multiple Superstars WILL Return
For better or worse, it’s far likelier that WWE will look to unaffiliated former talent to replenish their talent pool rather than tearing NXT apart. With WWE allegedly reaching-out to swathes of veteran workers in the lead-up to Tuesday night’s Draft, look for several former WWE superstars to make their returns as the Draft progresses.
There’s plenty of speculation as to who they’ll turn to, and while we won’t know for sure until Tuesday, there are a few obvious choices. Former United States Champion MVP remains a solid wrestler and is a free agent after his TNA contract expired, Carlito could be tempted to return for an angle with his family members in The Shining Stars, and WWE might be tempted to keep Brian Kendrick around after his Cruiserweight Classic run.
Tommy Dreamer has been rumoured heavily in recent days, and WWE has never been shy to call on ECW originals like him and Rhyno whenever they have a spot to fill. We already know that Tajiri will make a full-time WWE comeback after the Cruiserweight Classic; will more former ECW alumni follow him to Raw and SmackDown?
Whatever the case, look for at least half-a-dozen old faces to re-emerge in the Draft.
4. The Undertaker WON'T Be Drafted
The Undertaker is the heart and soul of WWE. Nobody on the current roster can hold a candle to what he's done for the company since his 1990 debut, and it's not even close. In the current WWE hierarchy, The Undertaker stands alone as a unique attraction whose importance to the company cannot be measured by title reigns and accolades.
The Undertaker brings a huge spike in interest every time he appears, but he won't be drafted on Tuesday night. As important as he is, 'Taker has been working a limited schedule for years. His appearances come once in a blue moon, and he's not going to commit his ageing body to an increased set of dates just for the sake of filling a draft slot.
There's no sense in forsaking a wrestler like Seth Rollins or Dean Ambrose, who'll appear every week, for The Undertaker, despite his undeniable legacy. Undertaker's calendar will remain as is: one or two matches against big name opposition at the biggest PPVs of the year, sprinkled with a few TV appearances here and there. He doesn't need to be pinned down to a specific brand to justify his annual WrestleMania match, so why bother?
Besides, Undertaker has earned the right to pick and choose. He is the greatest WWE superstar of all-time, and should he return, his destiny should be in his own hands.
The Undertaker's name features on WWE's fantasy draft page, but that's just a red herring. Don't expect The Deadman to feature on Tuesday.
3. There WILL Be A Second World Title
Like it or not, a second World Championship is on the way. It’s been anticipated for months, and WWE should confirm the news next week. Pretty soon, Dean Ambrose won’t be the company’s only “top champion", and Raw and SmackDown will both have their own belt for aspiring title-holders to work towards.
Many fans would prefer for a single World Champion to float between both brands. With two belts, it’s impossible for one not to come-off as more prestigious, and that’s exactly what happened back in 2002. For all intents and purposes, the WWE Title remained the company’s true “top belt,” while the World Heavyweight Championship was considered second best despite WWE’s continued assertions that it was just as worthy a prize.
While creating a second major championship gives talent a chance to become “World Champion” that might not have existed otherwise, it dilutes the belt’s value and creates confusion among fans. There were times during the initial brand split where both belts were treated equally, but those were few and far between. History suggests that one championship will be relegated to B-level status sooner rather than later.
2. Raw WON'T Improve
As romantic as it is to assume that all WWE programming will see a dramatic increase in quality post-Draft, there’s little evidence to suggest that Raw in-particular will improve.
Firstly, the show will still be 3 hours long. WWE already have enough trouble filling a 3-hour broadcast as it is, so consider how thin they’re going to have to spread themselves to keep us entertained with half the available talent.
Secondly, Raw is still going to be written by the same creative team producing the same repetitive stories on a weekly basis. Yes, there’ll be a significant shake-up in the talent pool, but the novelty’s going to wear off after a couple of weeks, and Raw’s writers will revert to type. Without a significant shake-up in creative, it’s hard to imagine anything other than a minor improvement for WWE’s flagship show.
Raw has been struggling for a while. Things aren’t quite as bad as they were at the beginning of the year, but the post-WrestleMania improvements have long since fizzed out, and the show has returned to mediocrity. WWE’s already-talented roster is only going to improve with the Brand Split, but the performers can only do so much without direction. The real issues come from Vince McMahon’s creative team, and without a change at that level, we shouldn’t expect Raw to transform into must-watch television overnight.
1. SmackDown WILL Improve
SmackDown, on the other hand, has quietly improved to become one of the best wrestling shows on television. Bolstered by the promotion of former NXT writer Ryan Ward, the blue brand regularly delivers a high quality night of all-round action that puts the supposed “A-show” to shame on a weekly basis.
It’s not perfect, of course. SmackDown is still very much considered an afterthought among WWE brass and fans alike, and with little-to-no storyline progression taking place, there isn’t much incentive to watch every week. It’s been this way for years, and SmackDown isn’t going to shed its long-held image as a second tier show overnight, but the Draft and Brand Split are about to make it relevant again.
During the original Brand Split, SmackDown became a safe haven away from Raw’s contrived storylines and hackneyed sports entertainment. With a hard-working, highly-motivated roster comprised of WWE’s most spectacular athletes, SmackDown was a wrestling-centric show that promoted workrate and quality match-ups above all else. It had its own unique identity away from the Monday night flagship, and we can expect that to happen again.
SmackDown won’t necessarily become a smark-satisfying paradise of technical wrestling again, but some of the biggest stars in wrestling are about to call it home. The increase in star power coupled with the move away from spoiler-tastic pre-taped results should make SmackDown essential again, and help WWE put its two major shows back on a level footing.