WWE Extreme Rules 2016: Every Match Ranked From Worst To Best
The I.C. Title steals the show.
Extreme Rules 2016 was in many ways a typical "B-show" pay-per-view, featuring a couple of bad matches and a couple of good ones, while the bulk was made up of acceptably decent if fairly forgettable bouts.
Yes, Extreme Rules is always handicapped by the WWE's current PG climate, but the best match on the card didn't need any silly gimmicks to succeed, which says it all really.
Still, we got one more title change than you might have expected for a show this inconsequential, while the results mostly made sense even if a few more crowd-pleasers might've compensated for making us put up with the current Roman Reigns title program.
And yet, it's pretty clear that most people won't be talking about the best match of the night or even the main event itself, but rather the return of Seth Rollins at the tail-end of the PPV, nailing Reigns with a Pedigree.
Here is every Extreme Rules 2016 match ranked from worst to best...
8. No DQ: Baron Corbin Vs. Dolph Ziggler
Result: Corbin defeats Ziggler with the End Of Days (7:07).
Rating: It's hard to expect much from this one when the match doesn't even begin until less than 10 minutes before the pre-show concludes, but even so, this was ridiculously low-effort fare.
There was simply nothing particularly interesting to see here: it was an incredibly unremarkable No DQ match that didn't even do much with the stipulation beyond setting up the low-blow finish, and it had a slow pace to match.
To be honest, this was never more entertaining than hearing Mauro Ranallo say "He just pulverised Zigglers plums in his fruit basket" at the finish. 4/10
7. Asylum Match: Chris Jericho Vs. Dean Ambrose
Result: Ambrose drills Jericho with the Dirty Deeds into a pile of thumb tacks (26:21).
Rating: This one was a lot goofier than the creative team were probably expecting, and the constant climbing up to grab weapons and bring them back down made the pacing feel pretty sluggish.
It also went on far longer than it needed to or anyone watching wanted it to, going by the utterly muted crowd response to the match. Plus, 26 minutes? Really? That's even longer than the main event, and it didn't help that it followed the best match on the show.
Still, it had a nice ending sequence full of fun spots, and it was good to see Jericho taking two tack bumps (even though the second was totally off the mark) considering that he has absolutely nothing to prove at this point. And of course, the right guy definitely won. 4/10
6. Women's Title Submission Match: Charlotte (c) Vs. Natalya
Result: Charlotte makes Natalya tap with the Figure 8 (9:30).
Rating: It was great to see these two battling it out with no outside distractions...for about 9 minutes, before Dana Brooke showed up dressed as Ric Flair and ruined it all.
We probably should've seen something like this coming, but banning Ric from ringside really inspired a lot of hope that creative would just let the two put on a wrestling clinic without distractions.
Yes, the heel tactics suit Charlotte's character just fine, but Natalya is in that sweet spot of being strong but also not invincible: a clean win would've been better, because these dirty finishes are boring and more than a little insulting. 5/10
5. Tag Titles: The New Day (c) Vs. The Vaudevillains
Result: Xavier kicks Gotch in the face for the pin (6:20).
Rating: It was certainly nice to see Xavier get some decent ring time early on, while The Vaudevillains came out of it looking strong, and it wouldn't have been too surprising had they actually won the straps (even though Vince apparently hates their gimmick). Still, The New Day are insanely over, so their victory just made sense.
It was a decent bout full of solid spots, but was sadly over in a heartbeat and definitely could've gone longer considering the absurd amount of time allocated to Ambrose vs. Jericho. Perfectly fine, but a few more minutes could've pushed it upwards. 6/10
4. Tornado Tag: The Usos Vs. The Club
Result: The Club destroy Jimmy with the Magic Killer (8:37).
Rating: This was pretty much just a power display by Anderson and Gallows, but the chaos of a Tornado Tag is always pretty fun, as was the crowd being firmly behind The Club and giving The Usos a ton of "X-Pac heat."
It certainly wasn't bad, if not a particularly compelling opener: it served up nothing massively surprising or exciting, and it wasn't a good choice for getting the crowd fired up for the rest of the show. However, it made The Club look incredibly strong, which is really what this one was all about. 6/10
3. U.S. Title: Kalisto (c) Vs. Rusev
Result: Rusev locks Kalisto in the Accolade to win the strap (9:31).
Rating: After having to suffer through several mediocre Kalisto-Ryback matches, it was at least refreshing to see the U.S. champ paired with a big man he has a little more chemistry with. It wasn't anything much memorable overall, but Kalisto kept his botching to a minimum (a problem during his Ryback matches), and the two played off one another well.
Though Kalisto's back getting destroyed by Rusev may not have resulted in the most exciting ending, it helped cement Rusev as a sure-fire threat moving forward, but we just have to hope that this won't result in Kalisto getting de-pushed into obscurity. 6/10
2. WWE World Heavyweight Title: Roman Reigns (c) Vs. AJ Styles
Result: Reigns spears AJ out of the air for the win (22:12).
Rating: It didn't take long for this one to spill to the outside, even if it was a fairly standard brawl, albeit one that made good use of Reigns' strength and AJ's speed. Styles' Backdrop bump into an announce table looked absolutely savage.
The Club and The Usos interfering was fairly boring and predictable, but at least we got an entertaining end sequence as AJ went nuts with the chair and like their Payback match, it felt like it could've gone either way, even if the ending was really just inevitable and Reigns ate way too many big moves.
Naturally, everyone's going to be more interested in Seth Rollins' post-match interference than the match itself, but it was a solid main event all the same. 7/10
1. I.C. Title Fatal 4-Way: The Miz (c) Vs. Kevin Owens Vs. Cesaro Vs. Sami Zayn
Result: Miz pins an unconscious Cesaro to retain the title (18:18).
Rating: Pretty much everyone expected this to be the match of the night and unsurprisingly, it was by a country mile. Zayn got things off to a highly amusing start with his insta-kick to Owens, setting a frantic and unpredictable tone for the rest of the match.
Once it got to all four guys taking each other on in the ring, this was a superbly paced match that never let up. The crowd loved it, and everyone involved, even Miz, came out looking strong.
Sadly the Cesaro fake-out win was super lame, and it made Cesaro look stupid that he celebrated despite not hearing the bell or his music.
This one really made it easy to root for Cesaro: the sheer number of times he kicked out in this match made it feel like he should've won, but at least he came out of it looking like a beast. Probably one of the year's best main roster matches so far. 8/10
What did you think of Extreme Rules 2016? Shout it out in the comments!