WWE Royal Rumble 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True

Comebacks falling flat, returning "heroes" being booed and other WWE Royal Rumble nightmares!

The Rock Sami Zayn
WWE

Well, this is it.

Royal Rumble will either be a mighty leap towards potentially one of the most emotional WrestleMania cards ever, or it'll be a humdrum reminder that Vince McMahon is back in town. Look, that's not quite the bash on Vince it may appear; McMahon has produced countless special moments at 'Mania, but him returning could harsh Triple H's creative buzz.

Maybe he'd change some stuff planned for the Rumble too, and favour old favourites over pushing modern heroes. Speaking of which, WWE must be careful not to over-rely on cameos in both titular matches. Although blending retro in does work, it shouldn't be the only trick fans see on Saturday night.

You know the drill by now. There's just no room for positivity here. This aims to look at the worst things that could possibly happen on WWE's next pay-per-view. Unwanted title switches, a gimmicky match that conjures up images of past failures, Rumble winners being booed out of the building - it's all here.

WWE better not turn a blossoming babyface into 2023's biggest afterthought either. He's a 'Mania smash hit waiting to happen!

Tread carefully...

10. “Pitch Black” Is Reminiscent Of Past Failures

Bray Wyatt Fiend Universal Title
WWE.com

No, that image above wasn't picked because Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' is about to make a comeback. It was chosen because of the ruddy red lighting that tortured eyeballs during the character's peak. WWE, playing on the Mountain Dew sponsorship and "Pitch Black" name, may go for something similar in San Antonio.

"Pitch Red" doesn't fit the branding, y'know?

Seriously though, it'd be a nightmare if Bray's bout vs. LA Knight was played through a filter of spooky lighting. Fans who lived through those matches several years ago still have PTSD from them, and it'd outright suck if Wyatt's first in-ring crack since returning was a flop.

Knight deserves better too, because he's been a real credit to this feud and has the chance to spin out of it into something else meaningful on SmackDown. That should be WWE's goal, and they can't afford to let goofy production f*ck everything up.

Of course, Bray vs. LA isn't the only worry there...


9. Supernatural Silliness Restricts Raw’s Women

Uncle Howdy Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

...this one is too.

Alexa Bliss has started creeping back towards her old Wyatt-inspired spookiness lately. The problem? That doesn't really jive with Bianca Belair's non-stop quest to have banger matches on supershows. In short, it'd be a bit naff if WWE double dipped on supernatural silliness in the Raw Women's Title scene too.

The mysterious 'Uncle Howdy' sniffing around in two separate matches on what is currently a five-match card sounds like a recipe for overkill. WWE must be mindful to keep some of that storytelling for TV shows like Raw, because a pay-per-view bout like Bliss vs. Belair should be a winner in-ring.

Basically, beyond Alexa acting like a spooky wee menace, the match doesn't need all the bells and whistles that Bray Wyatt vs. LA Knight will surely get. No, this should be another solid title defence for Bianca against a credible opponent, not a homage to some of the 'Fiend's' worst moments.


8. Retro Surprises Don't Cut It Anymore

Molly Holly Royal Rumble
WWE

The law of diminishing returns is something pro wrestling knows all too well.

Everyone tunes into Royal Rumble expecting to see a smattering of returning favourites from yesteryear. 'Oh look, it's Molly Holly! Wow, it's Diesel!' That sort of thing. This is all well and good, but the gimmick of nostalgic faves coming back for "one last" whirl might be wearing a bit thin, at least for some stars.

Holly, for example, has popped back up in far too many of the women's Rumbles for it to really mean anything nowadays. If she's in the 2023 version, then it'll be sweet Molly's fourth cameo appearance since WWE started running female Rumbles in 2018. That's just one or two too many, eh?

Those backstage must start reaching out to some fresher faces (if possible), because some "surprise" entrants don't really qualify as surprises anymore. A polite pop from the Alamodome masses is all they can expect, and rightly so.


7. Ronda Rousey Wins The Women’s Rumble

Ronda Rousey
WWE

Ronda herself has been chewing the fat with fans via gaming streams and claiming she won't be in the house come the Rumble. Similar reports elsewhere in the media suggest the same sort of thing, but this could easily be a ruse to throw people off the scent.

It better not be.

Rousey won the Rumble last year, and it...didn't get quite the reaction WWE had hoped. People are kinda bored of the 'Baddest' one these days. The bloom is off the rose, so to speak, and the company always has a tough time finding the right opponents for her whether she's heel or baby. So, another Rumble win would be disastrous for the women's division.

This is Rhea Ripley's time, and nothing can change this writer's mind on that. Plus, repeat winners only work when they're wanted (like Shawn Michaels going back-to-back in 1995 and 1996). Ronda becoming a two-time Rumble winner and slipping right back into a feud with Charlotte Flair = hard pass.


6. WWE Does The Unthinkable

Kevin Owens WWE Undisputed Universal Title
WWE

Right, there's no way this happens.

It can't happen, can it? WWE couldn't possibly whip the Undisputed WWE Universal Title(s) off one Roman Reigns before he reaches some sort of final boss scenario at WrestleMania. Could they?! It'd almost feel like putting KO's feet in concrete then pushing him off a pier if creative did that, 'cause fans would not be happy after the initial pop settled down.

There's this niggling feeling at the back of yours truly's head that says Sami Zayn might go rogue and cost Roman the belts to prove a point though. It absolutely shouldn't happen, because Zayn himself is a better rival for Reigns down the road that Kevin Owens is here, but it could tempt WWE.

Sami costing Roman the titles would be his ultimate 'f*ck you' to Reigns and Paul Heyman for questioning him. However, it'd also prove them correct and thicken the plot. However, it'd also mean that Reigns isn't top champ anymore, and that's unthinkable heading into 'Mania 39.


5. The Bloodline Splits Early

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

This is a knock-on point to the previous one.

If Sami does cost Roman, then The Bloodline as you know it will be history overnight. Reigns' charges like The Usos and Solo Sikoa would hit the ring to give Zayn a kicking. Or, perhaps WWE would hold off on that until the following night on Raw/the next episode of SmackDown.

There's still so much drama to get through before Sami is on the outs permanently though. Raw Is XXX was a stay of execution, so it'd be hella weird if WWE pulled the trigger on a full-blown split at the Rumble. They don't really need to, and nobody out there actually wants them to.

This Bloodline business was one of 2022's biggest surprise packages, and that success has carried on into the new year. It'd be a real shame if the writers raced through the final lap with a panicky string of booking mistakes they just didn't need to make.


4. Cody Rhodes’ Return Falls Flat

Cody Rhodes
WWE

Man, Cody Rhodes wouldn't deserve this.

He really wouldn't. The dude traded AEW for WWE again in early-2022, and returned amidst much fanfare to produce the goods with Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 38. It was one of the best WWE returns ever, but running that back for a repeat helping is gonna be tough for the 'American Nightmare'.

Fans already know he'll be at the Alamodome, and there's this weird, Triple H in 2001/2002 babyface comeback pressure about the whole thing. What if announcing Cody ahead of time was a mistake and dulls the magic of the moment? Seeing Rhodes emerge with a beaming smile as people look forward to the next Rumble entry already doesn't sound fun.

Trips' aforementioned comeback was one in a million, so WWE shouldn't expect the same thing here. They could, unfortunately, find out that playing the Rhodes card before reaching San Antonio was a huge mistake they'll come to regret.


3. The Rock Gets Booed

The Rock WWE
WWE.com

Dave Meltzer's recent reports say The Rock won't be at the Rumble because he doesn't have time to get ring ready for 'Mania. Think about that: The Rock not being in shape. Sounds impossible - the dude's an absolute tank, but there is a difference between being gym ready and wrestling match ready.

It remains to be seen if people even want Rocky vs. Roman Reigns at this point anyway. 'The Great One' always seemed like he'd be Roman's final boss, but Reigns is more over than ever these days. He even gets cheered during a lot of his appearances, and his "*insert city* Acknowledge Me!" catchphrase is a guaranteed pop.

WWE and Dwayne Johnson could be in for a bit of a nasty surprise then. The Rock might end up getting booed like Reigns was back at the 2015 Rumble if he shows up, and that'd be a real buzzkill for everyone if that's the marquee selling point for this year's WrestleMania.

Wouldn't be the first time WWE fans have turned on The Rock though. Just saying!


2. Sami Zayn = Ultimate Afterthought

The Rock Roman Reigns
WWE

Travesty. Of. Justice.

That's what it'd be if WWE kicked Sami Zayn to the back of the toy cupboard like that little sh*t Andy when Buzz Lightyear replaced Woody (not still bitter about it at all). Honestly, if The Rock comes out and shouts, "To infinity and beyond" as Sami lets everyone know there's a snake in his boots, then this fan will cry.

There's no snake in your boots, sweet Sami. The snakes are backstage, and they've ruined your push! Right, enough of that. In all seriousness, it'd be so rubbish if Zayn's march toward surefire sympathetic babyface status was spoiled just because WWE flashed their knickers at Dwayne Johnson again.

Look, everyone knows how star power works, and nobody's saying Sami is a bigger name than Rocky. However, he does have the best story going on in pro wrestling right now, and him vs. Roman has Daniel Bryan at 'Mania XXX vibes to it.

There are concerns that WWE might get cold feet on Zayn's story and cast him aside.


1. ‘Stone Cold’ Is Just Another Wrestler

WWE WrestleMania 38 Steve Austin
WWE.com

It still feels weird to type things like, 'Steve Austin wrestled Kevin Owens at 'Mania 38'. It happened though, and it was actually very, very fun. Recent reports say WWE offered a bout with Roman Reigns to 'Stone Cold' next, and there are rumours that he'll be one of the 30 in Saturday's Royal Rumble match.

Mr. 3:16 probs ain't winning the thing though, which means he'd become "just another" entrant in the match. Ask yourself this: Does anybody really want to see Austin be "just another" anything, especially after the success of his in-ring return in 2022? He's one of the biggest box office attractions ever.

'Stone Cold' doesn't make up numbers.

This next statement might not go down well with everyone, but here goes. This fan would rather he wasn't in Texas at all if Austin was only getting 10 minutes of cameo ring time before being eliminated. Granted, he didn't feel that way before, but thinking about it has changed minds!

What other nightmares could come true at WWE's 2023 Royal Rumble? For more like this, check out WWE 2K23: 8 New Features You Need To Know About and WWE Royal Rumble 2023: 10 Things That Must Happen!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.