WWE SummerSlam 2025: 12 Nightmares That Could Come True

The 'Final Boss'. The unwanted title twists. The SummerSlam 2025 NIGHTMARES!

WWE SummerSlam 2025 Cody Rhodes The Rock
WWE

SummerSlam has been one of WWE's most important annual events since launching in 1988, but something about 2025's version feels like there's been an in-house mentality shift. Triple H has tacked on another night for this year's summer PLE, and the company as a whole is treating SummerSlam like it's on the same level as WrestleMania. Sorry, Royal Rumble and commiserations Survivor Series, but you're lagging slightly and far behind respectively.

More SummerSlam should mean more shocking moments, killer matches and general WWE goodness, but just take a peek at the title to this piece. See that "nightmares" key word? It doesn't exactly scream positivity. If you're looking for that, then check out everything that must happen in New Jersey across 2-3 August. Once satisfied, come back for some content that'll make you scream and have you checking to see if this is actually Halloween Havoc instead.

John Cena's final SummerSlam appearance is obviously one of the biggest talking points going into the weekend. WWE has pulled out all the stops to make his rematch vs. Cody Rhodes seem must-see. That's understandable yet brave considering what happened the last time this pair shared the ring together at 'Mania 41. Can they improve on that, or will it be more of the same?

Title cash-ins, swerves aplenty, celebs freezing when the pressure's very much on, injuries occurring because somebody has a point to prove and goes too far, returns that ultimately go nowhere after popping interest the night of - there's a lot that could go south at SummerSlam.

Let's dig into the worst that could happen.

Get 76% off, four free months, and a free Amazon gift card when you sign up to NordVPN here: http://go.nordvpn.net/aff_c?offer_id=564&aff_id=3013&url_id=31010&aff_sub1=WhatCulture

12. Charlotte Flair Turns On Alexa Bliss Early

Charlotte Flair Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

This writer is having somewhat of an identity crisis right now. After literally years of bashing WWE's attempts to turn Charlotte Flair babyface, even he has to admit that this tag-team union with Alexa Bliss is working. Honestly, it's practically unbelievable, but Charlotte is finally getting organic babyface cheers from live crowds whilst appearing alongside her spooky doll-loving little friend.

WWE should really ride this, not cut things off just as they've started heating up. At SummerSlam, Charlotte and Alexa must become Women's Tag-Team Champions. Don't shed any tears for Raquel Rodriguez and Roxanne Perez. They're a makeshift team born from Liv Morgan's injury more than a concrete creative plan, and they'll be absolutely fine once they drop the belts.

Besides, this new fangled incarnation of Judgment Day might well be the group's last. They're close to imploding for good, which could benefit 'We're Not Friends'. The sad thought here is that WWE get cold feet on Flair and Bliss as a long-term tag. They were never meant to get this far in the first place - Charlotte was probs going to turn on Alexa and lead to a match between them on PLE.

Instead, the writing team elected to see where the thawing frost between one time NXT hopefuls took them, and SmackDown has been better for that willingness to adapt. SummerSlam is far too early for Flair to revert to her old ways. WWE spent an age trying to beg fans to cheer for her, so they shouldn't toss all of the goodwill these recent weeks have built up away just to be contrary.

Keep this going for as long as possible.


11. TLC Is Blighted By Supernatural Guff

The Wyatt Sicks WWE
WWE.com

The Wyatt Sicks returned to screens in May, caused trouble for a hot SmackDown doubles division, then eventually won the tag straps from The Street Profits on the 11 July episode. They certainly aren’t this fan’s choice to lead the chasing pack, but Triple H clearly sees something in Dexter Lumis and Joe Gacy as champs. Still, ideally they drop the belts on Sunday to Andrade and Rey Fenix or Fraxiom.

Also, no supernatural shenanigans please!

WWE have to just let all 6 squads go hell for leather in New Jersey. If this thrilling TLC occasion is laced with supernatural stuff from Uncle Howdy, Nikki Cross, Erick Rowan and other Sicks members, then it’ll hurt the match. Nobody wants to see that. They want to see the likes of DIY, Motor City Machine Guns, Andrade, Fenix, Nathan Frazer, Axiom and Montez Ford do their thing aerially by hitting sick spots and taking big bumps for 25-30 minutes.

Focusing the fray around Howdy, or dimming the lights Bray Wyatt 'Fiend' style, would be a mistake. That's something Triple H hopefully learned from latter day Vince McMahon. Switching the lights off or coating everything in red might've looked interesting on camera to fans at home here or there, but it didn't exactly do much for Bray's matches.

It'd be a real pity if that sort of presentation snuffed out what's sure to be a TLC rollercoaster. Supernatural stuff can work when used at the right time, but a PLE match like this (one that got a booming reaction when Nick Aldis announced it on TV) is not the "right time".


10. Talla Tonga Looks Useless

WWE Night Of Champions 2025 Jacob Fatu Hikuleo Talla Tonga
WWE.com

Big Talla has to have his Kane moment here.

To explain, Kane ripped the door off Hell In A Cell back in 1997 and looked like a million dollar machine doing so. Talla Tonga could either do that, or he could just interfere and help Solo Sikoa win generally. It’s very important that he starts looking like the killer cog in Solo’s new faction rather than just another warm body for Jacob Fatu to bounce around in beatdown segments.

If Talla interferes then Jacob wins the United States Title back anyway, then why should fans view Talla as a threat? Be very careful here, writing team. You definitely don't want to squash Tonga's importance to the cause in just one solitary month. The big beast hasn't even worked a televised match yet. Sawing his legs off at the knee and making him look totally ineffectual when defending Sikoa would be daft at this early stage.

Put simply, Talla must be the difference maker (like Fatu was for Solo before they split). That's surely why he was brought in as a bodyguard in the first place?! He'd be clowned overnight if Michael Cole said something like: 'Here comes Talla Tonga. Oh well, so much for that. There goes Talla Tonga!'.

That wouldn't just be unnecessary, it'd be insulting to the story and a real disservice to Sikoa's brand new faction. Sadly, early signs are not good for Tonga. He's been smashing the place up, but arguably nowhere near enough to reflect his size or power. Maintain that menace, please Hunter.


9. AJ Styles Derails ‘Dirty’ Dom’s Momentum

AJ Styles WWE
WWE.com

AJ Styles is an industry treasure, and it sounds so weird to say that him becoming Intercontinental Intercontinental Champion could ever be a bad thing, but Dominik Mysterio deserves to hold that belt for a long time to come. He’s the future, not AJ (as sad as that is to say). Surely WWE heard the pop 'Dirty' Dom got in AAA recently? The guy's a mega-star in the making.

You might've forgotten that Styles previously held the IC Title between June-August 2020, so claims that he 'deserves to win the workhorse title at least once before retiring' are wide of the mark. Those folks need to do their homework on Performance Center and 'ThunderDome' era WWE. AJ didn't get a long or especially fulfilling reign, but at least he's held the IC during his career.

Yeah, keeping the title exactly where it is sounds like the best plan.

Mysterio has issues with Judgment Day pal Finn Bálor that have been simmering away rather nicely for a while now. Once the group goes sour (which seems to be imminent), then Dom vs. Finn can fill the void for creative. Meanwhile, AJ can go off to do something else - he'll never be short of options, because he's so versatile and experienced and is on/off considered one of the best wrestlers in the world.

Derailing Mysterio's momentum wouldn't be a good idea. He's as over as he's ever been in the company, the Intercontinental Title looks fab when he's carrying it around, and it's clear his confidence is going through the roof. Right now, Styles doesn't need the belt as much as Dominik does.

A title change would bring out some 'Latino Heat' from fans, so to speak.


8. WWE Throws Away Becky’s Value

WWE Money In The Bank 2025 Becky Lynch Lyra Valkyria
WWE.com

Everyone gets that WWE want to push Lyra Valkyria to the moon and create a long-term star with her. They can get to that, but Becky Lynch has true value as Women’s Intercontinental Champion for the rest of 2025 and through the first quarter of 2026/WrestleMania 42 season. She should be the veteran people point to in years to come and say: ‘Yep, Becks made that belt what it is today’.

All of the odds being stacked against Valkyria suggest she’ll come away with the title on Sunday, but then what? Her shaky promo on Monday’s Raw didn’t scream confidence. Sure, Lyra deserves the chance to improve on that and get more reps, but do your XP farming away from the title for now until she’s truly ready. There's no need to rush into another title reign for the sake of it.

'Big Time Becks' is the better option as things stand. She's a made woman to WWE's fanbase, and her feuds will always carry some interest because of things she's achieved in the past. Using Lynch's legacy star power to build up as many names as possible in the women's division midcard should be Triple H's goal.

'The Game' also has another option: Running with Bayley as a heart on her sleeve challenger vs. Lynch or turning her heel due to various frustrations. Either choice would work, and recent promos on TV imply that Bayley feels less than huggable in late-July 2025 anyway. She's ripe for a redemption story or a change of pace entirely.

Don't chuck Becky's worth away 'cause of the stip between Lyra and herself. Just don't.


7. Hype Hurts The Women’s Triple Threat

WWE Raw Naomi Rhea Ripley Iyo Sky
WWE

Naomi, Rhea Ripley and IYO SKY have a lot of pressure on their shoulders going into SummerSlam. People are expecting great things from them, and they want a Triple Threat that at least matches what Rhea and IYO did with Bianca Belair at WrestleMania 41. Say your prayers (and take your vitamins) for them before the weekend, peeps.

It’d be awful if they felt the heat and couldn’t live up to the hype. No-one wants to see excellent workers sink at crucial moments, but a bad match is always just around the corner. Naomi, Rhea and IYO certainly wouldn't be the first trio of top names to suck wind and struggle to satisfy. The list of bad WWE matches is almost as long as the greatest in company history.

Fan expectation can weigh things down before a punch or kick is even thrown though. That aforementioned 'Mania 3-way wasn't a scorcher many saw coming - those tuning into April's show knew it'd be a good time, but they didn't think they were in store for one of the best bouts of the entire year until it really got going.

If the wrestling deities are listening, then hear this: Make sure that Naomi vs. Ripley vs. SKY equals Ripley vs. SKY vs. Belair at least. This feels like a pivotal moment in Naomi's young Women's World Title reign, so she needs to knock it out of the park and come away feeling like she could walk on water.

These women deserve the spotlight, and they deserve to feel good about their work. No disasters or off nights wanted.


6. Drew McIntyre’s Replacement Sucks

WWE WrestleMania 39 The Miz Pat McAfee
WWE

Friday's episode of SmackDown will be telling. If Drew McIntyre is in the house for that, then everyone knows he'll be in New Jersey for SummerSlam weekend after all. For context, big Drew has been stranded in the UK after attending a friend's wedding in England, and he's been having some passport woes preventing him from flying back to the United States. Eek!

Recent reports say WWE will put a contingency plan in place should McIntyre miss out on his planned tag-team bout with Logan Paul vs. Randy Orton and Jelly Roll. The Miz has put himself forward on social media as a viable replacement. He wouldn’t be the worst conceivable choice, but it feels like WWE’s hands are tied here should Drew fail to get back to the US in time.

You've got to feel for them, and for him too. What a travel-related nightmare he's been having.

Miz pointed to history with both Orton and Paul as evidence of his viability. Fair enough, but...would anybody fit as snugly into the role of antagonist as Drew? Obviously not due to his key part in the story (including an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live that had mainstream media buzzing). If it's someone other than McIntyre, then Paul will need to do even more of the heavy lifting at SummerSlam.

Fingers crossed that this is one big worry about a whole load of nothing. There's still time for Drew to hop aboard a flight and make his way to SmackDown then WWE's next PLE. If not, then it will probably be Miz who takes his place as a last-minute substitute.


5. Jelly Roll Freezes

Randy Orton Jelly Roll
WWE.com

Drew's absence could, in theory, throw Jelly Roll off his game and knock the musician's confidence in entering a sound performance. After all, WWE will have carefully laid everything out for Jelly with McIntyre and Logan Paul in mind, and Drew has surely given him a mini-pep talk about taking care of business. Take the Scot out of the equation and...well, Mr. Roll's head might be spinning.

Jelly's a seasoned performer who'll know how to handle nerves, but not inside a pro wrestling ring. It’s entirely possible that the guy forgets his spots, misses his cues and generally craps the bed. Hopefully not, but it could happen. Workers as smart as Orton and McIntyre will have kept Jelly's involvement as straightforward as possible. He'll likely only be tasked with running a few spots against Logan, then might be down to eat a Claymore Kick from Drew.

Nobody's expecting Bad Bunny (or Paul himself, ironically) out there, but Jelly has been such a credit to recent WWE television during the build towards SummerSlam that it'd be a crying shame if he made a mess of the actual match. Unfortunately, nothing is guaranteed when it comes to celebrities working between the ropes.

Dude's knees will jelly behind the curtain no matter what, let's be honest!

He's a lifelong wrestling fan, so the singer won't want to screw things up or make the night harder for the pros. If he forgets everything, then Randy, McIntyre and even Paul will take control, but that'd put the old tin hat on Jelly Roll ever wrestling again. His confidence would be shot to bits.


4. CM Punk Ends Up Injured

WWE Raw Gunther CM Punk
WWE

Look, this isn’t meant as a smarky takedown on Gunther as a pro. He’s clearly safe, but the powerhouse does work a rugged, intense and physical style that'd bring tears to the eyes of anybody who eats a few of his chops. During the build, it's become clear that Punk will want to look like a hero against the big Austrian, so he might suggest taking a few too many strikes and other moves during the match.

Watch that through cracks in your fingers.

Punk’s WWE comeback run has already been hit with devastating injuries at key times, and he doesn’t want another slice of that misfortune. He was also getting hurt during his stay in AEW due to a combination of ring rust and age. You've just got to hope they’re smart about this at SummerSlam, and that Punker doesn't encourage Gunther to make his chest into mince meat or hit him with powerbomb after powerbomb just so the veteran looks tough.

That'd be risking injuries, and it's fair to say that Punk has been dinged up in recent years. He'll have physical weaknesses which aren't conducive to wrestling the kind of brutally physical match Gunther likes. Saying that, CM did withstand a Hell In A Cell war with Drew McIntyre last year, so maybe this entry is doing him dirty.

It'd be really depressing if he couldn't keep up with Gunther's rapid fire striking style and took another injury though. Cross those fingers and toes that this is merely one fan worrying about the worst that could happen, and not a sign of things to come. No more muscle tears needed.


3. Seth Rollins Cashes In Whilst Injured

WWE Night Of Champions 2025 Seth Rollins Paul Heyman Bronson Reed Bron Breakker
WWE.com

It's important to say right away that this is highly unlikely, but what if WWE has an injured Seth Rollins cash in Money In The Bank after CM Punk wins the World Title from Gunther? That notion is far-fetched in the extreme, but the company may not be able to resist such a moment. The problem is, they’d be shooting themselves in the foot if Seth is actually injured or going to be out for a while.

You can’t have Raw’s top title on a dude who isn’t going to be around for the rest of the year. It'd be perfectly fine to have Rollins appear to distract Punk and cost him the win, but let’s not have him cash in MITB. The briefcase concept is something that requires either a breather or a bit of patience due to Naomi's cash in on the women's side. In theory, geniuses like Paul Heyman and Seth wouldn't pull the trigger whilst he's hurt.

If he's hurt. No, no he surely is, but it's easy to buy into all the conspiracy theories doing the rounds about this being part of some elaborate, sneaky work. Wrestling has set a precedent for suspiciously timed things like that before, but it does seem like Rollins got injured at Saturday Night's Main Event. If so, then putting the World Title on him wouldn't be the right call.

This wouldn't even fly from a kayfabe perspective anyway. Say Seth cashed in, won the belt, then said he couldn't defend it due to injuries. Raw GM Adam Pearce would have to step in and strip him, whilst pointing out that Rollins did technically wrestling at SummerSlam.

It'd be messy. Fascinating, but messy.


2. Cena & Cody Work Another Stinker

WWE WrestleMania 41 John Cena Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

(OK, perhaps stinker is too harsh, but their WrestleMania 41 main event was hardly high quality. It was slow, boring for the most part, and just didn’t seem to get going. Honestly, it's a nightmare thought for Triple H that booking a rematch and putting it on SummerSlam proves to be a terrible idea.

What if John Cena and Cody Rhodes just don’t have any chemistry? Hey, don't rule it out. Steve Austin and The Undertaker had banging matches against a wide range of workers of all shapes and styles, but they never really meshed when they were put inside the ring together as opponents. It happens. No-one likes that it does, but it happens.

Cena probably needs a top tier match to bring his retirement run up a notch in terms of in-ring quality. Thus far, it's been so-so. At times, JC has slid into a role akin to the WCW main event crew of the late-1990s. In other words, his match has loads of star power but lacks true action and can't hold a candle to what's come earlier on the card. He'd be a fabulous addition to the latter era nWo with this sort of run!

Cody (and Cena too) will be desperate to improve on 'Mania 41. Rhodes had worked 3 singles match classics in a row vs. Seth Rollins and then twice vs. Roman Reigns on the biggest show of the year, so even he must be keenly aware that April's match with Cena sagged. Hopefully, they analyse what happened in Las Vegas and put things right.


1. The Rock Returns Then Vanishes Again

The Rock WWE 2024
WWE.com

A lot of folks still aren’t over how rubbish it was that The Rock played such a massive part in John Cena’s heel turn then vanished after Elimination Chamber. His 'Final Boss' character didn’t play a part in events at WrestleMania 41 either, and that was really rather disappointing. His absence has come back up in the chat since WWE Unreal launched on Netflix, which might prompt the ‘Final Boss’ to interfere in the main event between Cena and Cody at SummerSlam to put things right.

If Rocky does, then he better stick around for a while. It’d be murder for fans if his 'Final Boss' guise returned, did something major, then disappeared all over again after the latest PLE. Pitchforks would be out for WWE's creative team and Triple H if they booked that for Sunday's show without knowing for sure that The Rock could do some follow up dates.

A true nightmare outcome would be Cody turning heel (that isn't the problematic bit) then siding with The Rock by selling his soul to the 'Final Boss'. All sounds pretty funky, right? Yeah, well imagine it without any Rock involvement on episodes of Raw or SmackDown for months afterwards. No context, no explanation, no proper follow through.

Just a one-off angle to pop some interest, do some impressive numbers on socials/YouTube, then...off he goes back to Hollywood yet again. WWE fans deserve better than that, especially if The Rock is part of a second huge heel turn in 2025 without saying his piece on the mic about it.

Those who don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it.

What other nightmares could come true at WWE SummerSlam 2025? For more wrestling, check out 12 Misconceptions About WCW You Probably Believe and WWE SummerSlam 2025: 10 Things That Must Happen! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.