1 Up & 6 Downs From WWE SmackDown (11 July - Results & Review)
Jelly Roll saves SmackDown on a night of title changes and other mediocre segments for WWE.
Even Trish Stratus has been joking in the media about WWE's scheduling. The legend knows there hasn't been much gas put into her title bout vs. Tiffany Stratton heading into the all-female Evolution PLE this weekend, so Trish must've been less than Stratus-fied by what creative had planned for them on Friday night. Talk about an afterthought - no Stratus match should feel this overlooked in 2025.
No, this wasn't a banner night for SmackDown's writing team. There was a title change, some Evolution hype, a bit of Saturday Night's Main Event chat and even some SummerSlam start up, but...the energy was lacking. Nashville felt it too. They were quiet for some of the blue brand squad's biggest moments there, and Tennessee only really came alive for Jelly Roll, Randy Orton and a few select others.
Speaking of Jelly Roll, it perhaps says everything that his performance saved the night. No joke. The musician looked comfortable out there. This won't be enough to win over those who simply don't want to see him teaming with Randy against Logan Paul and Drew McIntyre on one of the biggest tentpole events going, but you've got to call 'em how you see 'em. Jelly put a lot of WWE's current roster to shame here.
Incredible.
Unfortunately, the lively atmosphere couldn't sustain once Roll's segment with Logan, Orton and McIntyre ended. SmackDown went right back to mediocrity for the rest of the evening, which sucks to say.
Here's a tiny helping of good and far too much bad from the final stop before SNME-into-Evolution.
Downs…
6. Functional But Bland Opening Segment
This opening segment set the tone for the rest of the night.
LA Knight always gets a pop when his music hits, but he was the only dynamic thing about this bland opening segment. Paul Heyman didn’t say much of anything when threatening Knight to watch his back, Solo Sikoa and Knight resuming old issues is tame after an overload of that over the United States Title, and Nick Aldis announcing a tag bout pitting Knight and Jimmy Uso vs. Solo and JC Mateo didn’t get much of a stir from the live audience. It felt like a so-so main event on paper.
Sikoa and Uso are at loggerheads, but Knight is an odd man out in all of this. He’s supposed to be feuding with Seth Rollins and crew, not Sikoa’s Family Tree, so it's puzzling that Sikoa and buddies took umbrage with anything he and Heyman were saying. Honestly, the lack of true drama here was alarming and must be mentioned.
WWE's TV shows aim to launch hot and get the live crowd onside early. That resonates through the screen and in turn makes programming more enjoyable (if fans in the stands are into it, then that really goes a long way with the viewer back home - look at Backlash 2024 in France), but SmackDown didn't have a whiff of that from the get go.
Functional but bland would just about cover it. Next time, because there will be a next time for these revolving door skits, please make sure everybody has a point to make so nobody rambles on like Sikoa did.
5. Main Event Struggles To Get Going
As aforementioned, Solo Sikoa and JC Mateo vs. LA Knight and Jimmy Uso didn't seem must see going in when Aldis announced it earlier in the night. In execution, it was another fairly nondescript bout for a totally forgettable episode of SmackDown. You've actually got to feel sorry for folks who paid premium ticket prices to attend this one. They weren’t given a lively show at all.
At times, SmackDown was akin to a standard pre-taped effort, and that’s not meant as a compliment.
Yes, we've all seen enough of Knight warring with Solo and pals to last a lifetime. The only thing worth mentioning is the aftermath: Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed attacked Knight to leave him laying, but even that’s a retread for the story Knight has going on with Seth Rollins too. The total lack of Rollins sucked when he's LA's opponent at Saturday Night's Main Event too.
So, to summarise, this tag match wasn't the worst thing on the broadcast by any means, but it can't be considered must-watch fare either. There was a sense that all 4 guys involved in the match were simply killing time out there. Mateo's lack of aura was completely exposed when he was jousting with the much more over Knight as well.
Jimmy rolling up Solo for the win heading into their United States Title showdown at SNME was logical, but it'd be difficult to recommend this one generally. It wasn't a patch on the fab Andrade and Rey Fenix vs. Fraxiom smash hit from last week's episode, put it that way.
4. Wyatts Win Slow Tag Title Match
The Street Profits have now lost the tag straps to Wyatt Sicks members Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis. You'd think a title change would spark some interest and lean towards the 'Ups' section, but something must be said: Uncle Howdy and pals have totally wrecked the momentum others were building for the SmackDown tag ranks. It's a bit crap to say, but they have.
85% of this bout was painfully slow heat stuff from Gacy and Lumis that sucked the life out of the live crowd in Nashville. The entire story framing this (other duos rallying against The Wyatts) has been pretty boring. Now, arguably the most unexciting team in the division are on top of it. The only hope here is that Andrade and Rey Fenix pull a banger out of The Sicks. Maybe Fraxiom too.
It's always confusing when promoters plump for the least-enticing option in the title hot seat(s). That's what Gacy and Lumis are, unfortunately. They're a basic unit who lack the flash of others in the division, and now we're in for endless matches with others chasing them whilst struggling to see eye to eye.
How did we get here when the SmackDown doubles had been a true highlight for ages?!
The initial pop that erupted for a title change fizzled out fast too. Nashville appreciated seeing some gold change hands in their town, but then everyone quickly realised what had happened. The Profits deserved better. This might be the worst match they've worked since becoming champs again on a red hot night in Barcelona this past March.
3. Not Sure Where R-Truth Fits Into This Now
What a weird decision to give Truth a 2-minute win over Aleister Black when Black is being built for a feud opposite Damian Priest.
Aleister did get some of his heat back by attacking Priest backstage when Damian encouraged him to “let it go” and move on, but something felt off about this whole deal. Truth, despite the win, still has next to no direction going on other than third wheeling a promising rivalry, and he seems to have all but given up on his relentless pursuit of John Cena.
Also, Truth wandering around oblivious to the fact that Black was about to paste him backstage was like a throwback to his delusional 'where am I this week?' character pre-release. WWE crowds have stopped treating him like a big deal too, but that's only due to Triple H's inconsistent booking. Is he a threat who has changed his mindset, or is he just a veteran who gets lucky from time to time?
Here, it was the latter. There was nothing convincing about Truth springing a surprise on Aleister then wandering around backstage like he'd accidentally walked through the wrong door and got lost. Priest standing up for somebody he viewed as a nuisance in Judgment Day will need some work - that isn't doing Damian any favours either.
All in all, this was a bit of a missed opportunity to have Truth take some of Black's best strikes and still keep coming. They weren't given nearly enough time to produce anything worthwhile, and that's a crying shame.
2. Sloppy & A Bit All Over The Place
We've seen far too many Fatal-4-Ways on WWE TV over the past couple of months. Give that idea a breather, Hunter! All would be forgiven had Alexa Bliss, Kairi Sane, Roxanne Perez and Sol Ruca worked a scorcher on Friday night, but their effort was riddled with miscommunication and far too many one-on-one moments whilst everybody else visibly chilled (literally doing nothing; not selling, just...watching) outside the ring.
Eek.
Ideally, you don't want workers waiting for their next spots to be seen waiting for their next spots. That isn't on WWE's camera crew or production crew through, it's on the wrestlers themselves. They should be smarter than this. You're not working a non-televised house show, guys. Come on now.
There were several clunky moments throughout this match that shattered its promise. Perez and Ruca couldn't get on the same page, Roxanne and Alexa struggled to power through some awkward exchanges, then Sane seemed to forget which bump she was talking for the match-winning DDT from Bliss. This one was all over the place from beginning to end.
Let's just assume the agent responsible won't be proud of it. Nor, mind you, should workers as seasoned as Bliss or Sane. The onus was on them to help guide Perez and Ruca through, but neither veteran could make it happen. So, it's sad to report that you should go out of your way to avoid seeing this unless you've got a sneaky love for spot calling going wrong.
As the subheading says, the bout was a sloppy and uncoordinated preview for another match to come on Evolution's card.
1. Tiffy & Trish Has Been Too Rushed
You can't move for the last-minute vibes going on for the bout between Tiffany Stratton and Trish Stratus at Evolution. This is a topic Trish herself has been bringing up in the media lately, which might not be something Triple H appreciates. The legend has a point though, being fair. WWE left it a little too late to make her comeback title bout special, and they deserve criticism for that.
Friday's in-ring promo segment with Wade Barrett was flagging big time before Naomi interrupted to talk about holding Money In The Bank then Jade Cargill ambushed her from behind. It blows for Trish and Tiffy, but their title match is less interesting than what’s going on between Naomi and Jade. Also, why is Stratton coming across as a stuck up heel despite everyone in WWE telling you she’s some super-likeable babyface?
Her presentation is sketchy, and this just wasn’t good at all.
Stratton's wooden/overly rehearsed-sounding dialogue aside, these women had paper thin material to see them through. Tiffany chose Stratus to prove herself as a worthy champion (erm...didn't beating the likes of Bayley, Charlotte Flair and Nia Jax do that?), and Trish wants to prove she still has something in the tank. Another month or so of build might've helped with that second part.
Neither champ nor challenger came out looking like a priority in this segment, which is a real problem. There really should've been more thought and care put into this, but it played out like somebody filling some spare time when booking in the old EWR sim games.
Bonus points if you remember those classic wrestling video games.
Up…
1. Jelly Roll’s Segment…Rescues The Show?!
Right, so your writer didn't see this one coming whatsoever, but Jelly Roll was excellent in his skit with Logan Paul, Randy Orton and Drew McIntyre. His facial expressions were on point, the way he spoke on the mic was natural and believable, and the live crowd were fired up for the idea of him putting LP in his place. Is Jelly about to become the next celeb sensation in WWE?!
Some will hate the mere thought of that (get him to replace from Def Rebel entrance themes though).
There was a funny moment when Paul called Jelly a celeb outsider who had no place in his industry too. That coaxed some rant out of Randy - he wanted to put Paul in his place for showing such a blatant lack of self-awareness. This distraction left Orton open to a McIntyre Claymore Kick that was revenge for last week’s RKO. The whole thing played out silky smooth.
Yeah, this rescued the episode from oblivion, and who honestly saw that coming when it was revealed that f'n Jelly Roll would probs be involved in a major angle heading into SummerSlam? If this is a sign of things to come with the musician on WWE TV, then we're all in for a treat. Nah, this guy can't believe he's gushing with praise for any of this either. Trust!
Not many could've had, 'Jelly Roll is the only major positive from an episode of SmackDown' on their bingo cards heading into 2025. It just happened, people. We're in the moment living it. Next stop: Roll hitting a 450 splash in MetLife Stadium at SummerSlam. Place your bets now...
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 7 New Directions For WWE After Night Of Champions 2025 and 15 WWE Gimmick Changes That IMMEDIATELY Backfired!