2 Ups & 8 Downs From WWE SmackDown (17 April - Results & Review)

WWE produce a thoroughly miserable 'go home' for WrestleMania 42 on SmackDown.

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

This week's episode of SmackDown easily could've chewed up time on WWE's WrestleMania 42 pre-show. Granted, any 'go home' episode is supposed to be a preview piece, but it's also there to give creative one more chance to add excitement to the PLE and get fans pumped for what they're about to see. Did anything on Friday achieve that?

Advertisement

Not really.

There were a couple of 'Ups' to report on, but SmackDown was a largely negative experience that felt like every issue with current WWE booking in a 3-hour microcosm. WWE Title foes Cody Rhodes and Randy Orton didn't interact at all. Hell, Cody didn't even have much to say about Randy's new "boy" Pat McAfee, but he had a lot of compliments to give CM Punk.

Advertisement

Triple H has clearly given up on a few stories too. The lameness to Rhea Ripley vs. Jade Cargill cannot be ignored, and there are problems elsewhere in the women's division too. You'd be forgiven for thinking Tiffany Stratton was about to skip out of pro wrestling completely, because her character and importance to programming has fallen off a cliff. Not even the usually-switched on women's tag fare could save things on this occasion.

Royce Keys did get a solid win, albeit in a match type that the company badly needs to rethink or retire, and then there was Trick Williams going Vince McMahon comedy on everyone during a nothing skit with Sami Zayn. Maybe Jim Ross was right and Vince is back on creative.

Advertisement

Here's a boatload of bad and not a lot of good to report from the last stop before 'Mania.

Advertisement

Get Surfshark for the bargain price of just $1.78 per month! Valid only until April 19th!

https://get.surfshark.net/aff_c?offer_id=1030&aff_id=1691&url_id=2561

Advertisement

Downs...

8. As Nothing A Nothing Match As You’ll See

WWE.com

R-Truth and Damian Priest defending their tag straps vs. Kofi Kingston and Grayson Waller was flat out dull. What the hell happened to New Day, man? They’ve gone from being one of WWE’s most charming and essential acts to…this. The heel turn has been a bust, and Waller subbing in as a would-be member doesn’t work.

Advertisement

Priest has also cooled off significantly as a star. Personally, this fan still thinks teaming with Truth will be good for him longer term, but it’d be a lie to suggest this was anything above mediocre. At times, it was like a matinee house show match everyone was yawning their way through because they had to hop another flight to New York later for the evening card.

Waller took some lumps from the babyfaces, Kofi felt like he might as well have been a cardboard cutout, and the live crowd struggled to get up for the John Cena tribute from the heroes at the end. SmackDown's doubles division will be better off with an 'odd couple' dynamic from Truth and Priest than it ever was whilst dominated by The Wyatt Sicks or MFTs, but this wasn't exactly living proof of that point.

Advertisement

As the subheading suggests, it was a nothing encounter.

Slap some butter on New Day, because the once-proud group is honestly toast. They have zero menace as bad guys, and the Grayson sub-plot is about as enticing as it sounds. It's like AI booked this then told the writers they were stunning and brave for coming up with it.

Advertisement

7. Ice Cold Booking Gave This No Chance

WWE.com

Watch Tiffany Stratton vs. Jordynne Grace and you'll find out what happens when management conditions fans not to care about certain workers. The match was cold as ice and didn’t have a hope in hell of heating up before the finish. Triple H clearly doesn’t have a clue how to get either of these women over, and the same goes for Giulia. Also, Tiffany is now the top contender for Giulia’s Women’s United States Title, but previously lost a non-title bout to the champ on the 27 March episode.

Advertisement

Did WWE simply forget about that? It feels like they did.

If it wasn’t for the tag side of things, then the women’s division on SmackDown would be unwatchable, and the blue brand didn't even have that to brag about this time! Sure, Tiffany and Jordynne worked hard out there, but they were right up against it and the live crowd didn’t give a toss about what was going on. It certainly didn’t feel like WrestleMania weekend during this scrap, that’s for sure.

Advertisement

Obviously, Stratton going after Giulia isn't viewed as important enough to gatecrash the 'Mania party, so why bother booking it at all? At this point, strap a rocket to Kiana James by having her split from Giulia and win the belt herself. Or, just get Chelsea Green back in the mix when she's able. Something needs to change, because Giulia's reign is seriously, seriously dire.

The Women's US Title is about as vital as the old 24/7 one was, which is not a compliment.

Advertisement

6. Another Waste Of TV Time

WWE.com

On paper, Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss vs. Bayley and Lyra Valkyria was a pointless re-run of a match WWE already booked on the 3 April episode of SmackDown. There, it was Flair and Bliss who picked up the win following a spirted showing from all 4, but there was no call for a repeat before WrestleMania. Apparently, creative agreed, then they hit the redo button on something else anyway.

Advertisement

Nia Jax and Lash Legend cut off the planned match pitting Charlotte and Alexa vs. Bayley and Lyra within 30 seconds, then hammered everyone and stood tall. On commentary, Joe Tessitore said: “We’ve seen this before”. Yes, yes we have. Did Triple H and his writers just phone this episode in or what?! They couldn't have given less of a toss had they gone with a 'Best Of 2026 So Far' edition to fill the 3 hours.

It's generally not a great idea to program matches people have already seen then cut it off with a heel beatdown they've already seen. That's so uninspiring, and it's why this road to 'Mania 42 has been cursed. Danhausen's arrival is no coincidence, folks. Just kidding. The ex-AEW man cannot be blamed for some of the nonsense Hunter and gang have been getting up to.

Advertisement

Long story short, the entrances on Friday were longer than the brawl then Jax and Legend standing proudly with their belts. This might not have been so bad had it been something fresh, but it wasn't. It was a retelling of story business from earlier SmackDowns without a new wrinkle.

5. They Need To Retire Andre’s Battle Royal

WWE.com

Andre The Giant's Memorial Battle Royal hasn’t even been on WrestleMania for a while now, and it rarely leads to anything substantial for the winner. There would’ve been better ways to give Royce Keys a big win that this, and it sucked to see the likes of El Grande Americano, Joe Hendry, Aleister Black and Ilja Dragunov in this sort of ‘Mania straggler filled setting.

Advertisement

Keys winning was treated like a big deal by the announcers, but it really isn’t. No, it wasn’t terrible as far as Battle Royals go, but it’s hard to care about this match anymore. It's the same thing over and over and over again every year; WWE gets the commentary team to call it a game-changing moment that'll shake up the product going forwards, then the Andre trophy is carted back to storage until it's needed again.

Nobody even talks about what winning it will do for their career - they just motor forwards or vanish from TV for a while until the next stop-start push begins. So, in other words, what's the point in even bringing the trophy to SmackDown before 'Mania at all? Fans are over seeing wrestlers match Andre's arms crossed pose before cameras quickly pan to something else.

Advertisement

WWE have something good going on with Royce's vignettes about a troubled upbringing. So, focus more on those rather than token wins everyone will forget about by the time WrestleMania's pyro pops off anyway. Either put this on the 'Mania Kickoff or delete it from booking sheets in 2027, please.

4. Trick & Sami Go Over Old Ground

WWE.com

Trick Williams bringing out someone dressed as the Gingerbread Man ("Sami Zayn") was 2019 levels of lame, then Sami Zayn cut a less impressive promo than he did last week. Yep, this was swing and a miss from creative, and they better not try to go the goofy comedy route with Trick once he officially turns babyface. That'll never work.

Advertisement

There wasn’t nearly enough intensity throughout this duelling promo skit. The double turn is coming and should be fun, but even Sami pointed out the flaw in Trick’s plan: He’s running comedy this close to his first ‘Mania but talking about being the future. Are you listening, WWE? Even characters on your own show are tearing into the lack of logic and cohesion you have for some key stars and feuds these days.

At first, your writer thought it might be Lil Yachty as the Gingerbread Man, but he wasn't there for SmackDown. Then, fear kicked in and he figured they were about to do something daft like have Carmelo Hayes join Trick before 'Mania and ruin the double turn fun. Instead, it was just some extra in the costume (as revealed by his neck when Zayn hit his Helluva Kick in the corner and the headpiece nearly popped off).

Advertisement

Overall, Trick and Sami repeated things they'd already been saying during much better segments previously. Doubling down on the Gingerbread Man joke was silly, especially as a parting shot before the United States Title showdown on PLE. That hasn't connected with audiences the way WWE wishes it would.

Next.

Advertisement

3. Randy’s Logic Is Sound, But…

WWE.com

...this whole scenario still feels backwards.

Advertisement

Randy Orton zoomed into the arena with Pat McAfee, Pat signed his contract for the match with Cody Rhodes (they’re just signing it now?!), then Randy cut an impassioned promo about how Cody only takes, takes, takes as a friend. The crowd in Vegas cheered that, and they also booed every mention of Rhodes. This feud is chaos. Sheer chaos.

Cody is going to get verbally mauled at WrestleMania, and there doesn't seem to be anything WWE can do to stop that. In truth, they've made things worse by having guys like Orton and McAfee tell it like it is. It's hard to hate on Randy for multiple reasons, but chief amongst them is that he isn't wrong and the people know it. This was actually a pretty good speech from Orton, but it’s tough to ignore the lame build we’ve been served up for this lay-up of a story between old stablemates.

Advertisement

Lord only knows why the writing staff found this rivalry so difficult to manage. All they had to do was lean into the history between both guys, then go from there. Instead, they've had Pat join Orton like that was necessary, then McAfee ridiculed WWE/TKO for failing to sell more tickets for 'Mania 42.

It was too late in the day to have Mr. RKO outright say he "doesn't need Pat McAfee". They've missed the boat on that bit of storytelling, because the match is literally on Saturday. Again, solid enough speech from Orton, but ultimately a fruitless exercise considering everything else that's been going on.

Advertisement

2. Yet More Women’s Title Pain

WWE.com

Rhea Ripley said she “wanted to come out here before [Jade Cargill] starts wasting everyone’s time”. Then, she proceeded to waste everyone’s time by saying sod all before Jade eventually walked away from the confrontation. This feud has been murder to witness, quite honestly. All they’ve done is say “bitch” a lot, and the build has made both Rhea and Jade feel less-than.

Advertisement

Their title match at ‘Mania better have something to offer that makes this horrendous hype worth sitting through. Hey, who knows? Maybe it'll be a surprise package. Maybe Jade will enter her best performance yet, and 'Mania Mami' will kick in to save the day. That seems like wishful thinking when the pair haven't gelled one bit on the microphone.

It's a true oil and water situation.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, it became clear incredibly quickly that Cargill and Ripley weren't going to click. Then, as if panicking, WWE spliced B-FAB and Michin into the picture alongside Jade for literally no good reason. Now, Rhea is pretending that they're a barrier for her getting to Cargill, but...stood in the ring with Jade and didn't do anything anyway. Huh? Good God, this is one of the worst WrestleMania rivalries of all time for sure.

Things would've been much better had Bianca Belair been able to return and go after Jade. Rhea is someone who either needs a break or something fresh as a character, and Cargill isn't experienced enough to make up for the feud's shortcomings. Fingers and toes crossed for their match. Please be decent, at least.

Advertisement

1. THIS Was The Go-Home For WrestleMania?!

WWE.com

Some believe that Friday's face to face was a teaser for a heel turn and feud between them once either (or both) Cody Rhodes or CM Punk drops their titles at WrestleMania 42. It could be, but let's analyse the segment on its own merits individually first. Spoiler alert: It wasn't good. In fact, it kinda seemed like WWE had spare time left over and just sent these guys out there to fill it.

Advertisement

It was a conversation that should've taken place behind the scenes, to be blunt.

Cody and Punk gushed with compliments for one another, and warned the other about their opponents at ‘Mania. That was it. Also, Punk practically begged the audience to tune in on Monday for Raw after the PLE. You've got to wonder what WWE is playing at with all these empty segments, the self-hate about ticket sales etc, and the begging from babyfaces. Can anyone else believe this was the last thing WWE thought people should see before WrestleMania 42?!

Advertisement

There was zero heat, zero stakes, zero tension and zero excitement. It was just 2 babyfaces who don't interact a lot on television saying, 'You da best, no you da best' repeatedly until they ran out of time and decided to go celebrate with the crowd before major title matches 24 and 48 hours from that point.

WrestleMania's 'go home' should be impactful and dramatic, not soft-centred and wishy-washy. If this was a preview for a heel turn from Punk or Cody, then it wasn't a very good one.

Advertisement

Ups...

2. Just Be Glad It’s Over

WWE.com

Finally, some good, and it's from a place nobody could've expected.

Advertisement

MFTs vs. The Wyatt Sicks in an 8-man ‘Street Fight’ was nice enough plunder. The rivalry has been horrible and almost killed off the tag division on SmackDown, but at least WWE put some spin off story into this one by booking tension between Solo Sikoa and Tama Tonga near the end. There’s something to work with there, which is why this gets an ‘Up’.

Most watching SmackDown surely think the Sicks are washed though. They’re arguably the most boring act in the company right now, and it’s time to move on from what was a very lovely Bray Wyatt tribute initially. Back on the plus side, going tornado style with the match was smart, because it would’ve been a slog otherwise. It did dip around 3/4s of the way through, but not enough to drag things into ‘Downs’ territory.

Advertisement

Anyone who reads these write-ups regularly will know how brutal this writer has been on the storyline, but it’s important to be fair. Everybody brought plenty of energy with them for this 'Street Fight', and the likes of Talla Tonga, Tama Tonga and even Erick Rowan looked good bell to bell. Now, WWE must draw a line under the issue rather than coming back to it because they're lazy and can't think of something else.

At least there was no humdrum lantern chatter to make everyone snore. Nope, this was rock solid brawling from all 8, and even Nikki Cross got a well-worked dive spot into the bargain. Thumbs up all round.

Advertisement

1. A Nice Preview Of Jacob Fatu’s Future

WWE.com

Assuming he beats Drew McIntyre at ‘Mania, then one Jacob Fatu will be asked to cut more promos like this in the main event scene going forwards. So, Friday’s cop car segment was a preview of things to come from Fatu, and he honestly nailed it. He's managed to strike the perfect balance between shouty intensity and a more measured style on the mic, which is appreciated and will stand him in good stead for the rest of 2026.

Advertisement

Coming out in the cop car to riff on Drew's banter about Fatu being 'nothing more than a criminal who can't run away from his past transgressions' was a neat touch as well. Perhaps the only surprise is that Jacob didn't hit a Samoan Drop on one of those phoney cops atop the vehicle to hammer home his point about leaving the law in his rearview mirror. Perhaps that would've been too literal.

Maybe next time, eh?

Advertisement

All of the big falls, the bloody brawling, McIntyre's promo from a jail cell last week, and now Jacob's cop car hijinks on Friday have built towards their "Unsanctioned Match" nicely. WWE has largely stayed out of its own way and just let these dudes get on with telling their story, and that's made it one of the most pleasing hype jobs on the way to Las Vegas.

This was clearly a test for Fatu, and he passed it with aplomb. Top marks, sir. Top marks indeed. Those promo chops will come in handy following the weekend's PLE once Jacob (theoretically) becomes a bonafide headline player.

Advertisement

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out WWE WrestleMania 42: 20 Things That NEED To Happen and 13 Mind-Blowing WWE WrestleMania 42 Predictions You NEED To Know!